1 Eléments de correction khôlle n°9 Après avoir

1
Eléments de correction khôlle n°9
Après avoir présenté les avantages des régimes de change flottant vous en soulignerez les
inconvénients
!
"#! $#! %#&'#$(! )*(! (+%! ,#(! %#-*%.+#(! /#! 01%-#! /1$2! 34*'! )*%,5! /*$(! ,*! 61%%#62'1$! /#! ,*!
789,,#!$:;<!
!
=,! 0*,,*'2! /*$(! 6#! (+3#2! *&1'%! >! ,4#()%'2! .+4',! #?'(2#! +$! 0,122#-#$2! )+%! #2! +$! 0,122#-#$2!
'-)+%! 6#! .+'! )#%-#22*'2! $12*--#$2! /#! 2%*'2#%! ,*! .+#(2'1$! /#! ,*! 611%/'$*2'1$! /#(!
)1,'2'.+#(!/#!68*$@#!#$2%#!@%*$/#(!$*2'1$(!/#)+'(!ABCD!>!68*.+#!01'(!.+#!(1$2!*))*%+#(!
/#(!6%'(#(!/#!68*$@#!,#(!61$6#%$*$2<!!
=/5#! /4*66%168#!E! 3#! )#$(#! .+4',! #(2! 2%F(! ('-),#! /#! %#)%#$/%#! ,4#?#-),#! 68'$1'(! #$!
61$6,+*$2!6#22#!01'(!$1$!)*(!(+%!,4'$25%G2!.+#!,#(!*+21%'25(!68'$1'(#(!1$2!/#!61$2%9,#%!,#!
%5@'-#!/#!68*$@#!-*'(!),+292!.+#,!'$25%G2!#,,#(!1$2!>!,#!,'H5%*,'(#%<!!
!
I50'$'2'1$!E!+$!%5@'-#!/#!68*$@#!0,122*$2!#(2!+$!%5@'-#!/#!68*$@#!/*$(!,#.+#,!,4*+21%'25!
-1$52*'%#!,*'((#!,#!-*%685!/#(!68*$@#(!0'?#%!,#!61+%(!/#!,*!/#&'(#!#$!01$62'1$!/#!,4100%#!
#2! /#! ,*! /#-*$/#<! J$! &#%%*! *+! 61+%(! /#! ,*! /'((#%2*2'1$! .+#! ,#! 0,122#-#$2! #(2! 2%F(!
%*%#-#$2!)+%!#2!),+(!(1+&#$2!'-)+%<!!
!
Quels&sont&les&avantages&des&changes&flottants&&
L’état&de&la&balance&des&paiements&n’est&plus&une&contrainte&&
K*! )%1H,5-*2'.+#! /#(! 68*$@#(! 0,122*$2(! 5-#%@#! )%1@%#(('&#-#$2! /+%*$2! ,#(! *$$5#(!
ABDL!,1%(.+#!,#!(M(2F-#!/#!N%#221$! O11/(! (#! 8#+%2#! >! /#(! /'00'6+,25(! '$2%'$(F.+#(! .+'!
&1$2!,#!61$/+'%#!>!(1$!56,*2#-#$2!P',!0*+2!6'2#%!#2!#?),'.+#%!'6'!,#!/',#--#!/#!Q%'00'$R<!!
J$! /1'2! *+?! *+2#+%(! -1$52*%'(2#(! (1+(! ,4'-)+,('1$! /#! S',21$! T%'#/-*$! P/16+-#$2! AR!
+$#!/50#$(#!/#(!68*$@#(!0,122*$2(<!U4#(2!/4*',,#+%(!6#!)1'$2!/#!&+#!.+'!(#%*!*/1)25!)*%!,#(!
V2*2(WX$'(! *+! -1-#$2! /#(! *661%/(! /#! ,*! "*-*'.+#<! T*6#! >! /#(! 0%*$Y*'(! /5('%#+?! /#!
-*'$2#$'%!/#(!)*%'25(! 0'?#(Z! ,#(! *-5%'6*'$(! 1$2Z!*+!61$2%*'%#Z! /50#$/+! ,#! 0,122#-#$2! /#(!
-1$$*'#(<!!
[+#,(!(1$2!,#(!*%@+-#$2(!/#(!-1$52*%'(2#(!\!61--#!,#!%*))#,!I<],'81$!P/16+-#$2!^RZ!,#(!
68*$@#(!0,122*$2(!)#%-#22#$2!>!,*!H*,*$6#!/#(!)*'#-#$2(!/#!(#!%55.+','H%#%!/#!-*$'F%#!
*+21-*2'.+#<!X$!)*M(!#$!('2+*2'1$!/50'6'2*'%#!&1'2!(*!-1$$*'#!(#!/5)%56'#%!6#!.+'!(2'-+,#!
(#(! #?)1%2*2'1$(! #2! %55.+','H%#! (*! H*,*$6#! 61+%*$2#<! K#(! 68*$@#(! 0,122*$2(! )#%-#22#$2!
/1$6! >! 6#! .+#! ,#(! /5(5.+','H%#(! /#(! H*,*$6#(! 61+%*$2#(! P#((#$2'#,,#-#$2! /#(! H*,*$6#(!
61--#%6'*,#(R! (1'#$2! 2#-)1%*'%#(<! =,! $#! )#+2Z! 2851%'.+#-#$2Z! )*(! M! *&1'%! /#! H*,*$6#(!
61+%*$2#(! (2%+62+%#,,#-#$2! /50'6'2*'%#(! P('! 6452*'2! ,#! 6*(Z! #,,#(! (#%*'#$2! /+%*H,#-#$2Z! #2!
$1$!2#-)1%*'%#-#$2Z!/50'6'2*'%#(R<!!
La&politique&monétaire&gagne&en&autonomie&&
K#! (#61$/! *%@+-#$2! -1$52*%'(2#! .+'! /561+,#! /+! )%#-'#%Z! 64#(2! .+#! ,#(! *+21%'25(!
-1$52*'%#(!$41$2!*,1%(!),+(!H#(1'$!/#!(4166+)#%!/#!/50#$/%#!,*!)*%'25!/#!,#+%!-1$$*'#!_!
#$! 68*$@#! 0,122*$2Z! ,#(! *22*.+#(! ()56+,*2'&#(! /'()*%*'((#$2<! J%Z! 6#(! *22*.+#(! 52*'#$2! /#!
),+(!#$!),+(!0%5.+#$2#(!/*$(!,#!(M(2F-#!/#!N%#221$!`11/(!#$2%*a$*$2!,45)+'(#-#$2!/#(!
%5(#%&#(!/#!68*$@#!#2Z!*+!0'$*,Z!/#(!/5&*,+*2'1$(!PT%*$6!ABDB!)*%!#?#-),#R<!!
K#!2%1'('F-#!*%@+-#$2! /561+,#! /+! 2%'*$@,#! /4'$61-)*2'H','25<!IF(! ,1%(! .+#! ,#(! 6*)'2*+?!
6'%6+,#$2! ,'H%#-#$2! #2! .+#! ,*! )+'((*$6#! )+H,'.+#! (1+8*'2#! )1+&1'%! +2','(#%! ,*! )1,'2'.+#!
-1$52*'%#! )1+%! /#(! 1H3#62'0(! '$2#%$#(! P,+22#! 61$2%#! ,#! 689-*@#! )*%! #?#-),#RZ! ',! 0*+2!

2
,*'((#%!0,122#%!,#(!-1$$*'#(<!K#(!0%*$Y*'(!$#!)1((5/*$2!)*(!#$61%#!/#!-*%685(!,'H%#(!/#(!
6*)'2*+?!/*$(!,#(!*$$5#(!ABCL!/50#$/*'#$2!H'#$!(b%!+$!)1'$2!/#!&+#!1))1(5<!!
!
Les&inconvénients&ou&limites&de&l’utilisation&des&changes&flottants&
c1+(!)1+&1$(!21+2!/4*H1%/!$1+(!/#-*$/#%!('!,4*/1)2'1$!/#(!68*$@#(!0,122*$2(!*!)#%-'(!
*+! (M(2F-#! -1$52*'%#! '$2#%$*2'1$*,! /#! -'#+?! 01$62'1$$#%! #2! ('! ,#(! /'00'6+,25(! #2!
)%1H,F-#(!%#$61$2%5(!(1+(!,#!(M(2F-#!/#!N%#221$!`11/(!1$2!/50'$'2'&#-#$2!/'()*%+<!!!
Les& régimes& de& change& flottants& n’éliminent& pas& les& guerres& des& monnaies& et& la&
spéculation&sur&les&devises&:&les&politiques&monétaires&restent&donc&contraintes&
K#(!%5@'-#(!/#!68*$@#!0'?#!)#%-#22#$2W',(!),+(!/4*+21$1-'#!/#(!)1,'2'.+#(!-1$52*'%#(Z!
61--#!,#!2%'*$@,#!/#(!'$61-)*2'H','25(!#$!0*'2!,48M)128F(#!\!!
K#! 0*'2! .+#! /#(! )*M(! */1)2#$2! /#(! 68*$@#(! 0,122*$2(! $#! ('@$'0'#$2! )*(! ,#(! )1,'2'.+#(! /#!
68*$@#! /'()*%*'((#$2<! J$! 61$(2*2#! *'$('! .+4+$#! )1,'2'.+#! -1$52*'%#! (#! 2%*/+'2! )*%! /#(!
&*%'*2'1$(!/+!2*+?!/#!68*$@#!#2!*!/1$6!+$!'-)*62!(+%!,#!61--#%6#!#?25%'#+%!1+!,#(!0,+?!
/#!6*)'2*+?<!]*%!#?#-),#!#$!^LALZ!,#(!H%5(','#$(!1$2!*66+(5!,#(!*-5%'6*'$(!/4+2','(#%!,#+%!
)1,'2'.+#! -1$52*'%#! *0'$! /#! -*$')+,#%! ,#+%! 2*+?! /#! 68*$@#! )1+%! %#$01%6#%! ,#+%!
61--#%6#!#?25%'#+%!*+!/52%'-#$2!/#!,#+%(!)*%2#$*'%#(!61--#%6'*+?Z!6#!.+'!61%%#()1$/!
>! +$#! ('2+*2'1$! /#! d!@+#%%#! /#(! -1$$*'#(!e<! K#(! *-5%'6*'$(! -#$*'#$2! >! ,45)1.+#! +$#!
)1,'2'.+#!/#! 6%5*2'1$! -1$52*'%#! '$2#$(#! *)%F(!,#! 6816! /#! ^LL;!6#! .+'! *&*'2! 2#$/*$6#! >!
0*'%#!/5)%56'#%!,#!/1,,*%<!U#,*!('@$'0'#!.+#!,#(!)1,'2'.+#(!-1$52*'%#(!/#(!+$(!P,#(!@%*$/(!
)*M(R! 1$2! /#(! '-)*62(! (+%! 6#,,#(! /#(! *+2%#(! P,#(! )#2'2(! )*M(! 1+! ,#(! 5-#%@#$2(R! #2! /1$6!
.+#!,4*+21$1-'#!/#!,*!)1,'2'.+#!-1$52*'%#!P/#(!)#2'2(!)*M(!1+!/#(!5-#%@#$2(R!#(2!%#-'(#!
#$!.+#(2'1$!*,1%(!.+#!$1+(!(1--#(!#$!68*$@#!0'?#<!!
K#(!%5@'-#(!/#!68*$@#!0'?#!)#%-#22#$2W',(!-1'$(!/#!()56+,*2'1$!(+%!,#(!-1$$*'#(!\!!
V$!68*$@#!0,122*$2Z!,*!()56+,*2'1$!(+%!,#(!-*%685(!/#(!68*$@#(!(4#(2!2%*$(01%-5#<!f,1%(!
.+4#$!68*$@#!0'?#Z!',!(4*@'((*'2!#((#$2'#,,#-#$2!/#!()56+,#%!(+%!+$#!/5&*,+*2'1$!0+2+%#Z!#$!
68*$@#!0,122*$2Z!,*!()56+,*2'1$!61$('(2#!>!*$2'6')#%!,*!&*,#+%!0+2+%#!/4+$#!/#&'(#!#2!#((*M5!
/4#$! 2'%#%! )%10'2<! J$! %#$2%#! '6'! /*$(! ,#(! #?),'6*2'1$(! /#(! H+,,#(! ()56+,*2'&#(! (+%! ,#(!
-1$$*'#(!Ppartie'du'cours'sur'les'taux'de'change'que'je'n’ai'pas'encore'traitéR<!]1+%!0*'%#!
('-),#Z! ,#(! '$&#(2'((#+%(! '$2#%$*2'1$*+?! 61$('/F%#$2! .+#! ,#(! &*%'*2'1$(! /4+$#! /#&'(#!
'$/'.+#$2! 6#! .+#! ,#! -*%685! )#$(#! /#! ,*! &*,#+%! /#! 6#22#! /#&'(#<! U#,*! '-),'.+#! .+#! ,#(!
'$&#(2'((#+%(!1$2!'$25%G2!>!(+'&%#!,#!-*%685!E!()56+,#%!>!,*!H*'((#!(+%!,#! /1,,*%!.+*$/!',!
-1$2#!#(2!&1+5!>!,4568#6<!]1+%!%#)%5(#$2#%!6#22#!('2+*2'1$Z!1$!/'2!.+#!«'l’on'ne'peut'pas'
battre' le' marché'»Z! 1$! /'2! *+(('! «'qu’il' vaut' mieux' avoir' tord' avec' le' marché' que' raison'
contre'lui'».'V$!61$(5.+#$6#Z!,#(!'$&#(2'((#+%(!*/1)2#$2!/#(!61-)1%2#-#$2(!-'-52'.+#(!
6#! .+'! )%1&1.+#! /#(! #-H*,,#-#$2(! (+%! ,#(! 61+%(<! U#22#! #?),'6*2'1$! *! 525! +2','(5#! )1+%!
#?),'.+#%!,#(!0,+62+*2'1$(!'-)1%2*$2#(!/+!/1,,*%!/+%*$2!,#(!*$$5#(!AB;LZ!-*'(!5@*,#-#$2!
6#,,#!/#!,4#+%1!/+%*$2!,#(!*$$5#(!^LLL<!!
Les& régimes& de& change& flottants& n’éliminent& pas& les& problèmes& de& déséquilibres&
financiers&internationaux&et&leurs&conséquences&&
K#(! %5@'-#(! /#! 68*$@#! 0'?#! )#%-#22#$2W',(! /45,'-'$#%! ,#(! 61$2%*'$2#(! ,'5#(! *+!
/5(5.+','H%#!/#(!H*,*$6#(!61+%*$2#(!\!!
J$! 61$(2*2#! .+#! ,#(! /5(5.+','H%#(! /#(! H*,*$6#(! /#(! )*'#-#$2(! (1$2! $1-H%#+?! #2!
/+%*H,#(<!U#,*!)#+2!(4#?),'.+#%!)*%!,#!/5&#,1))#-#$2!/#(!568*$@#(!/#!6*)'2*+?<!K#(!)*M(!
#$!H#(1'$!/#!0'$*$6#-#$2Z!)1((5/*$2!/1$6!+$#!H*,*$6#!61+%*$2#!/50'6'2*'%#Z!2%1+&#$2!(+%!
,#(! -*%685(! -1$/'*+?! /#(! 6*)'2*+?! ,#! 0'$*$6#-#$2! .+'! ,#+%! )#%-#22#$2! /#! )1+&1'%!
61$(1--#%!),+(! .+4',(! $#! )%1/+'(#$2<! U4#(2! #00#62'&#-#$2! ,#! 6*(! /#(! V2*2(WX$'(! /1$2! ,*!
61$2%#)*%2'#!/+!/5(5.+','H%#!61+%*$2!#2!,4#$2%5#!/#!6*)'2*+?!&#$+(!/+!-1$/#!#$2'#%<!K#!
%'(.+#!/#!6#22#!('2+*2'1$!#(2!*,1%(!/#!&1'%!,#(!6*)'2*+?!%#0,+#%!#2!(1%2'%!(1+/*'$#-#$2!/+!

3
)*M(!Psudden'stopR!)%1&1.+*$2!+$#!/5)%56'*2'1$!(1+/*'$#!/#!,*!-1$$*'#!#2!*((568*$2!,#!
6%5/'2!/*$(!,#!)*M(!Pattention,'il'existe'aussi'des'sudden'stop'avec'des'pays'pratiquants'des'
changes' fixes,' comme' les' pays' d’Asie' en' 1997R<! =,! #(2! *+(('! )1(('H,#! /4G2%#! /*$(! +$#!
('2+*2'1$! '$&#%(#! 1g! 64#(2! ,#! 2%1)! ),#'$! /#! ,'.+'/'25! .+'! )#+2! )%1&1.+#%! +$#! 6%'(#!E! ,*!
)5%'1/#!/+!/5H+2!/#(!*$$5#(!^LLL!*+?! V2*2(WX$'(! 61%%#()1$/! >! +$#! )5%'1/#!/4#$2%5#(!
2%F(!'-)1%2*$2#!/#!6*)'2*+?!.+'!&1$2!(2'-+,#%!#2!)%1&1.+#%!+$!6M6,#!/#!6%5/'2!*+?!V2*2(W
X$'(!.+'!(#!2#%-'$#%*!*&#6!,*!6%'(#!/#(!(+H)%'-#(<!J$!61$(2*2#!/1$6!.+4*&#6!,41+&#%2+%#!
/#(!-*%685(! /#(! 6*)'2*+?Z! ,#(!568*$@#(! '$2#%$*2'1$*+?! $#! 01$62'1$$#$2! ),+(! 61--#! ,#!
/56%'&*'#$2! ,#(! -1$52*%'(2#(! /*$(! ,#(! *$$5#(! ABDL<! K4#((#$2'#,! /#(! 568*$@#(! #(2!
*+31+%/48+'!61$6#$2%5!(+%!,#(!0,+?!/#!6*)'2*+?!#2!$1$!)*(!(+%!,#(!0,+?!61--#%6'*+?<!K#(!
0,+?! /#! 6*)'2*+?! )#%-#22#$2! *+?! /5(5.+','H%#(! /#(! H*,*$6#(! /#(! )*'#-#$2(! /#! (#!
-*'$2#$'%!/+%*H,#-#$2!P6#!.+'!)#%-#2!>!,4561$1-'#!/#!)1+&1'%!(456*%2#%!/#!,*!61$2%*'$2#!
'-)1(5#! )*%! +$#! 561$1-'#! 0#%-5#RZ! -*'(! ',(! )#+&#$2! *+(('! *&1'%! /#+?! #00#2(! $50*(2#(!E!
/4+$#!)*%2Z!,#(!#$2%5#(!#2!(1%2'#(!/#!6*)'2*+?!)#+&#$2!)%1&1.+#%!/#(!6%'(#(!0'$*$6'F%#(Z!#2!
/4*+2%#!)*%2Z!,#(!0,+?!/#!6*)'2*+?!1$2!+$#!/'-#$('1$!/#!61+%2!2#%-#!P/#!2%F(!61+%2!2#%-#R!
.+'!#?),'.+#$2!)1+%.+1'!,#(!2*+?!/#!68*$@#!(1$2!2%F(!&1,*2',#(<!!!
h*%'*2'1$(! #%%*2'.+#(! /#(! -1$$*'#(Z! -1+&#-#$2(! H%+(.+#(! /#! 6*)'2*+?! #2! ()56+,*2'1$!
(+%! ,#(! -1$$*'#(! )1(#$2! /1$6! +$! )%1H,F-#! *+?! V2*2(!E! ,1%(.+#! ,#(! 61+%(! (1$2! 2%1)!
&1,*2',(!6#,*!8*$/'6*)#!,#(!568*$@#(!'$2#%$*2'1$*+?<!J$!)#+2!/1$6!61-)%#$/%#!)1+%.+1'Z!
61--#!,#!%*))#,,#!i2'@,'2j!/*$(!,#!/16+-#$2!kZ!6#%2*'$(!)*M(!*/1)2#$2!/#(!(2%*25@'#(!/#!
611)5%*2'1$! )1+%! (2*H','(#%! ,#(! 2*+?! /#! 68*$@#! P60! '$2#%&#$2'1$! AB;k! #2! AB;;C! )1+%!
(2*H','(#%! ,#! /1,,*%! 1+! ^LLLW^LL^! )1+%! (2*H','(#%! ,4#+%1R<! J$! 61-)%#$/! *+(('! )1+%.+1'!
6#%2*'$(! )*M(! 681'('((#$2! /#! (456*%2#%! /#(! %5@'-#(! /#! 68*$@#! 0,122*$2!E! 1$! M! 2%1+&#!
H#*+61+)!/#!)*M(!#$!/5&#,1))#-#$2!.+'!)%50F%#$2!*$6%#%!,#+%(!-1$$*'#(!P#2!,'-'2#%!,*!
,'H#%25! /#! 6'%6+,*2'1$! /#(! 6*)'2*+?R! 1+! H'#$! )%*2'.+#%! /#(! 68*$@#(! 0'?#(! ),+(! /+%(!
P/16+-#$2! CR<! =,! #?'(2#%*'2! *'$('! «'une' peur' du' flottement'»!PU*,&1! #2! l#'$8*%2R! .+'!
3+(2'0'#%*'2!,456*%2! #$2%#! ,#! $1-H%#! /#! )*M(! )%16,*-*$2! de' jure! +$! %5@'-#! 0,122*$2! -*'(!
)%*2'.+*$2!de'facto!+$!%5@'-#!0'?#<!!
i'!,#(!68*$@#(!0,122*$2(!61$6#%$#$2!/#!),+(!#$!),+(!/#!)*M(Z!6#!2M)#!/#!%5@'-#!/#!68*$@#!
(1+,F&#! *+(('! +$! 6#%2*'$! $1-H%#! /#! %5(#%&#(<! =,! #?'(2#! /1$6! /#(! 61$2%*'$2#(! .+'!
2#-)F%#$2! ,4'$25%G2! )1+%! 6#! 2M)#! /#! %5@'-#! /#! 68*$@#<! U#(! 61$2%*'$2#(! )1%2#$2! (+%! ,*!
)#%2#!/4*+21$1-'#!/#!,*!)1,'2'.+#!-1$52*'%#!#2!(+%!,#(!%'(.+#(!/#!&1'%!(#!/5&#,1))#%!,#(!
)%*2'.+#(! ()56+,*2'&#(! (+%! ,#(! -*%685(! /#(! 68*$@#(<! U1--#! ,4*00'%-#! /1$6! T%*$7#,!
PABBBRZ! ',! $4#?'(2#! )*(! +$! %5@'-#! /#! 68*$@#! .+'! 61$&'#$$#! >! 21+(! ,#(! )*M(! #$! 21+2#(!
6'%61$(2*$6#(<!!
!
mmmmmmmmmmmmm!
!