Compte rendu d`entretien - Description de controverses – Mines

!"#$%&'(&)*+'*,&)%(&%-&)'
'
./%&'0'1231435167'
8)%&(9":+%&+('0';(/):<'=/#+>'
?@%-&(A;"):%-")'0'*-(&:%&+('*&'(&:B&(:B&>'/+'!C=DE'!"A*-(&:%&+('*+'?/>%&('=&:B&(:B&'
&)'D:-&):&>'!"F)-%-G&>'HICDE'IJIDDE'K)-G&(>-%@'L/(->A.&>:/(%&>M'
'
Le# contexte# de# cette# rencontre# a# été# un# peu# particulier# puisqu’il# ne# s’agissait# pas#
réellement#d’un#entretien.#Nous#avons#en#effet#rencontré#M.#Franck#RAMUS#le#jeudi#6#mars#
lors#d’une#conférence#sur#la#dyslexie#qu’il#donnait#à#l’école#primaire#de#Miollis,#dans#le#15ème#
arrondissement.#
Ce#que#nous#prenions#tout#d’abord#comme#une#faiblesse#–#une#rencontre#sous#forme#
de#conférence#–#se#révéla#en#fait#comme#un#réel#vivier#d’information#vis#à#vis#des#questions#
que# pouvaient# se# poser# les# parents# et# professeurs# des# écoles# à# propos# de# la# dyslexie.# Le#
public# était# en# effet# composé# d’une# trentaine# de# personnes,# allant# de# la# mère# de# famille#
dyslexique#qui#se#sentait#coupable#d’avoir#transmis#son#trouble#à#son#fils,#à#l’enseignante#
qui#cherchait#à#devenir#une#spécialiste#du#domaine.#
#
La#présentation#s’orienta#autour#de#trois#axes.#Tout#d’abord,#M.#RAMUS#présenta#des#
généralités#sur#les#troubles#«#dys#»,#puis#il#expliqua#en#profondeur#le#problème#de#la#dyslexie#
avant#de#donner#des#conseils#généraux#pour#aider#les#personnes#présentes#à#bien#s’occuper#
des#enfants#dyslexiques#qu’ils#côtoyaient.##
'
8M'N@)@(/9-%@>'>+('9&>'%("+O9&>'>$@:-P-Q+&>'*&>'/$$(&)%->>/F&>E'9&>'%("+O9&>'R'*S>'T'
'
U&>' %("+O9&>' R'*S>'T' >")%' *&>' %("+O9&>' *+' *@G&9"$$&#&)%E' #/->' )&' >")%' $/>' *&>'
%("+O9&>'/:Q+->V'U&>'&)P/)%>'R'*S>'T')&'#")%(&)%'$/>'*&'*@P/-99/):&'-)%&99&:%+&99&E'#/->'
:&99&'*,+)&'P"):%-")':"F)-%-G&E':")%(/-(&#&)%'W'*,/+%(&>'%("+O9&>'%&9>'Q+&'9/'%(->"#-&'56V'
!&>'P"):%-")>'>")%'9-@&>'/+X'>&)>'&%'%"+:B&)%'+)'>&:%&+('$/(%-:+9-&('*+':&(G&/+V'
Y)' Q+/)%-P-&' :&%%&' *@P/-99/):&' F(Z:&' W' 9,@:/(%' Q+,-9' S' /' &)%(&' 9/H9&>M' P"):%-")H>M'
:"F)-%-G&H>M'%"+:B@&H>M'&%':&99&>'Q+-')&'>")%'$/>'/%%&-)%&>V'U/'*S>A#/9/*-&'>&'*@P-)-%'*"):'
:"##&' +)' (&%/(*' *&' 6[' #"->' &)%(&' 9&>' P"):%-")>' :"F)-%-G&>' -)%/:%&>' &%' 9&>' P"):%-")>'
:"F)-%-G&>'/%%&-)%&>V'U&'(&%/(*'&>%':/9:+9@'W'$/(%-('*&'>%/%->%-Q+&>'@%/O9-&>'>+('9,&)>&#O9&'
*&'9/'$"$+9/%-")'&%'*+'\8'H\+"%-&)%'8)%&99&:%+&9M'*&'9,-)*-G-*+V'
89' &X->%&' /-)>-' *&>' $&(>"))&>' *S>9&X-Q+&>' %(]>' -)%&99-F&)%&>' &%' %(]>' *"+@&>' */)>'
:&(%/-)>' *"#/-)&>E' O-&)' Q+&' F^)@&>' */)>' +)' /+%(&' $/(' 9&+(' %("+O9&V' !,&>%' $"+(Q+"-' 9/'
*S>9&X-&' )&' $&+%' &X$9-Q+&(' W'&99&'>&+9&'9,@:B&:'>:"9/-(&'_' I99&' $&+%' -)*@)-/O9&#&)%' &)'
:")>%-%+&('+)'P/:%&+(E'#/->':&'),&>%'$/>'>+PP->/)%'>-'&99&'),&>%'$/>'/::"#$/F)@&'*,/+%(&>'
P/:%&+(>V'
U/'*-PP-:+9%@E'9"(>Q+&'9,")':B&(:B&'W'@%/O9-('9/':/+>&'*&'9,@:B&:'>:"9/-(&E'G-&)%'*+'P/-%'
Q+&':&'%("+O9&'>$@:-P-Q+&'&>%'>"+G&)%'/>>":-@'W'*,/+%(&>V'R'U/'*S>9&X-&')&'G/::-)&':")%(&'
(-&)' &%' (-&)' )&' G/::-)&' :")%(&' 9/' *S>9&X-&'T' *->/-%' ?V' =`?KDV' D"+PP(-(' *&' $9+>-&+(>'
%("+O9&>' >$@:-P-Q+&>' /$$/(/a%' (@F+9-](&#&)%' &%' &>%' /$$&9@' 9/' :"#"(O-*-%@V' Y)' $&+%'
:+#+9&(' $/(' &X&#$9&'*S>9&X-&E' *S>$(/X-&E' (&%/(*' *+' 9/)F/F&' "(/9' "+' %("+O9&>' *&'
9,/%%&)%-")E':&'Q+-'-)*+-%'*&>'$("P-9>':"F)-%-P>'%(]>':"#$9&X&>V'L/('>+-%&E':&>'%("+O9&>'&)'
&)F&)*(&)%'>"+G&)%'*,/+%(&>E'%&9>'Q+&'9&'#/)Q+&'*&':")P-/):&'&)'>"-E'9&'(&b&%'*&'9,@:"9&'
&%E'*/)>'9&'$-(&'*&>':/>E'9/'*@$(&>>-")V'
U&>'*S>A#/9/*-&>'>")%'*&>'#/9/*-&>'*+(/O9&>'Q+&'9,")'F/(*&'%"+%&'+)&'G-&V'Y)'$&+%'
:&$&)*/)%'&)'/%%@)+&('9&>'&PP&%>'F(Z:&'W'+)'%(/G/-9'-)%&)>-P'&%'(@F+9-&(V'

88M'!/+>&>'*&'9/'*S>9&X-&'
'
U,-99&%%(->#&E':/(/:%@(->@'$/('*&>'*-PP-:+9%@>'W'+%-9->&('9/'9&:%+(&'*/)>'9/'G-&'*&'%"+>'
9&>' b"+(>E' ),&>%' $/>' *&' 9/' *S>9&X-&V' I)' G@(-%@E' 9/' *S>9&X-&' ),&>%' Q+,+)' P/:%&+(' $">>-O9&'
$&(#&%%/)%' *,&X$9-Q+&(' 9,-99&%%(->#&V' Y)' )&' $&+%' *"):' $/>' *-/F)">%-Q+&(' 9/' *S>9&X-&'
+)-Q+&#&)%' W' $/(%-(' *,+)&' 9&:%+(&' B@>-%/)%&V' D-' ")' *@)"#O(&' 6cd' *&' $&(>"))&>'
/%%&-)%&>'*,-99&%%(->#&'/+':"99]F&'&%'66d'W'9,ZF&'/*+9%&E'>&+9'9&'%-&(>'>"+PP(&'(@&99&#&)%'*&'
*S>9&X-&V' !&%' -99&%%(->#&' $&+%' /G"-(' *&' )"#O(&+>&>' :/+>&>' &%' ^%(&' 9-@' W' *&>' $("O9]#&>'
O-"9"F-Q+&>'HG->-")'"+'/+*-%-")'*@P/-99/)%&E'(&%/(*'#&)%/9E'%("+O9&'*+'9/)F/F&E'%("+O9&'*+'
:"#$"(%&#&)%M'"+'&)G-("))&#&)%/+X'H$("O9]#&>'>":-/+XE'P/#-9-/+X'"+'$@*/F"F-Q+&>MV'
D-'/+:+)&'*&':&>':/+>&>'$">>-O9&>')&'$&(#&%'*,&X$9-Q+&('9,-99&%%(->#&'*,+)'-)*-G-*+E'-9'&>%'
Q+/9-P-@'*&'*S>9&X-Q+&V'
!&%%&'*@P-)-%-")'&X$9-Q+&'9,&X->%&):&'*&>')"#O(&+>&>'-*@&>'P/+>>&>':-(:+9/)%'>+('9/'
*S>9&X-&V'`$$/(/->>/)%':"##&'+)'>S#$%e#&'$/('*@P/+%E'-9'@%/-%'P/:-9&'*&'9,+%-9->&('$"+('
&X$9-Q+&('/(O-%(/-(&#&)%'9,/$$/(-%-")'*,+)'%("+O9&V'!&9/'&X$9-Q+&'@F/9&#&)%'$"+(Q+"-'-9'
&>%' $9+>' *-PP-:-9&' *&' >&' P/-(&' (&:"))/a%(&' :"##&' @%/)%' *S>9&X-Q+&' */)>' +)&' f")&'
*,@*+:/%-")' $(-"(-%/-(&' $/(' &X&#$9&V' U&' P/:%&+(' &)G-("))&#&)%/9' >&(/' >"+G&)%' /G/):@'
$"+('#/>Q+&('9/'G@(-%@V'
U/'*S>9&X-&'/$$/(/a%'*"):':"##&'+)'%("+O9&'/S/)%'*&>':/+>&>'$9+>'$("P")*&>'Q+&'
:&99&>' @G"Q+@&>' $(@:@*&##&)%V' !&>' :/+>&>' $&+G&)%' $("G&)-(' *&' *-PP@(&)%>' )-G&/+XE'
>:B@#/%->@>':-A*&>>"+>V'I99&':")>%-%+&'+)'%("+O9&'#+9%-P/:%"(-&9E':,&>%'$"+(Q+"-'*-(&'Q+&'
R':"##&' 9/' *S>9&X-&' /' *&>' :/+>&>' F@)@%-Q+&>E' -9' ),S' (-&)' W' P/-(&' $"+(' 9+%%&(E' (-&)' )&'
$"+G/)%' ^%(&' P/-%' :")%(&' 9&' *@%&(#-)->#&' *&>' F])&>'T' &>%' P/+XE' :/(' *&>' :/+>&>'
&)G-("))&#&)%/9&>' &X->%&)%' @F/9&#&)%V' !&>' :/+>&>' $&(#&%%&)%' *&' :")%(&O/9/):&(' 9&>'
:/+>&>'F@)@%-Q+&>V'
'
'
'
'
'
'
'
'
'
'
'
'
'
'
'
'
'
'
'
#
#
'
'
Environnement*
Niveau*
biologique*
Différence*
génétique*
Dysfonctionnement*
cérébral*
Niveau*
cognitif*
Intelligence*
normale*
Perception*
normale*
Déficit*
cognitif*
Capacités*
*
*
*
******<<*
Niveau*de*
lecture*réel*
Niveau*de*
lecture*
attendu*

U/' *-PP-:+9%@' $("P")*&' (&):")%(@&' $/(' 9&>' *S>9&X-Q+&>' $"(%&' >+(' 9/' :")>:-&):&'
$B")"9"F-Q+&V' 89' P/+%' /G"-(' :")>:-&):&' Q+&' 9&' #"%' >&' *@:"#$">&' &)' $B")]#&>E' Q+-' >&'
*@:"#$">&)%'&+XA#^#&>'&)'>S99/O&>E'Q+-'>&'*@:"#$">&)%'&99&>A#^#&>'&)'9&%%(&>'$"+('
$"+G"-(' O-&)' 9-(&V' 89' &>%' *"):' $">>-O9&' *&' *@$->%&(' 9&>' G(/->' *S>9&X-Q+&>' &)' 9&+('
*&#/)*/)%'*&'P/-(&'*&>'(-#&>'"+'*&'(@>"+*(&'*&>':")%(&$]%&(-&>'>-#$9&>V'
U/'#@#"-(&'W':"+(%'%&(#&'b"+&'/-)>-'+)'(e9&'&>>&)%-&9'*/)>'9/'G-&'*&>'*S>9&X-Q+&>V'
g%/)%'-):/$/O9&>'*&'*@:B-PP(&(')/%+(&99&#&)%'9&>'#"%>'&%'9&>'@:(-%+(&>'Q+-'9&>':"#$">&)%E'
9&'*S>9&X-Q+&'/'@F/9&#&)%'*+'#/9'W'-#$(-#&('*&')"+G&/+X'#"%>'"+'*&>')+#@(">'*/)>'>/'
#@#"-(&V'89'&>%'*"):'-#$"(%/)%'*&'9+-'P/-(&'P/-(&'*&>'%Z:B&>'*&'#@#"(->/%-")'(/$-*&'&%'*&'
(&)*+'*&'#@#"-(&'(/$-*&V'K)'%&>%':"+(/)%':")>->%&'*"):'$/('&X&#$9&'W'P/-(&' 9-(&'W'+)'
*S>9&X-Q+&'+)'%/O9&/+'*&'6cX6c':/>&>E':B/Q+&':/>&'@%/)%'"::+$@&'$/('9,-99+>%(/%-")'*,+)'
"Ob&%'>-#$9&V'!&'%&>%'$&(#&%'W'9/'P"->'*&'*-/F)">%-Q+&('&%'*,&)%(/-)&('9&'*S>9&X-Q+&E'&)'9+-'
P/->/)%'%(/G/-99&('>/'#@#"-(&V'
U&'(@>+9%/%'*&':&'%&>%'&>%'/>>&f')&%V'I)':"#$/(/)%'9&>'%&#$>'#->'$"+('%&(#-)&('9/'
9&:%+(&'*&'9/'F(-99&E'&%'&)'9&>':"+$9/)%'/G&:':&+X'#->'$"+('+)'/+%(&'%&>%E'-9'/$$/(/-%'Q+&'9&>'
$&(>"))&>'*S>9&X-Q+&>'@$("+G&)%'&)'&PP&%'$9+>'*&'*-PP-:+9%@>'Q+&'9/'#"S&))&'W'*@:B-PP(&('
*&>' #"%>' >-#$9&>' &%' W' 9&>' (@&#$9"S&(' (/$-*&#&)%V' L’exposition# de# ce# fait# souleva# une#
remarque# dans# l’audience.# Une# enseignante# déclara# qu’elle# trouvait# cette# remarque#
intéressante# car# elle# permettait# de# prendre# conscience# du# fait# que# donner# des# exercices#
comportant# des# consignes# trop# longues# pouvait# ajouter# de# la# difficulté# à# un# exercice,#
difficulté#qui#était#rarement#prise#en#compte#lors#de#la#notation.#
U/' #@#"-(&' W' 9")F' %&(#&' /' @F/9&#&)%' +)' (e9&' W' b"+&(' */)>' 9/' *S>9&X-&V' I)' &PP&%E'
$"+('R'9-(&'TE'+)'*S>9&X-Q+&')&'P/->/)%'$/>'*&'(@&9'9-&)'&)%(&'+)'F(/$B]#&'&%'+)'>")E'-9'P/-%'
*&>' /)/9"F-&>' &)%(&' *&>' F(/$B]#&>' &%' *,/+%(&>' #"%>' Q+,-9' /' *@bW' (&):")%(@' &%' Q+,-9'
:"))/a%V'U-(&'9&'#"%'R'O/%&/+'T')@:&>>-%&'*&'>&'(/$$&9&('9&'>")'R'O&'TE'$+->'9&'R'/'TE'*&'9&>'
:"+$9&(' $"+(' P/-(&' R'O/'TE' *&' >%":<&(' 9,-)P"(#/%-")' *&' :&%%&' >S99/O&' &%' *&' *@:B-PP(&(' 9/'
>+-G/)%&E'$+->'*&'(&:"99&('9&>'#"(:&/+XV'U/'#@#"-(&'W'9")F'%&(#&E'Q+-':")>%-%+&'9/'O/>&'
*&'*"))@&>'W'&X$9"-%&('$"+('(&:B&(:B&(':&>'>")>E'&>%'*"):'@F/9&#&)%'%(]>'>"99-:-%@&'9"(>'
*&'9/'9&:%+(&V'
!&'%(/G/-9'*&'#@#"-(&'@%/)%'&)F/F@')/%+(&99&#&)%'*]>'9/')/->>/):&E'-9'P/+%'^%(&'%"+%'
*&' >+-%&' %(]>' G-F-9/)%' Q+/)%' W' *&' $">>-O9&>' %("+O9&>V' !&$&)*/)%E' /G/)%' *&' (@&99&#&)%'
>,/PP"9&(E'-9'P/+%'/%%&)*(&'Q+&'9,&)P/)%'>"-%'>+PP->/##&)%'*@G&9"$$@E':,&>%'W'*-(&'/%%&)*(&'
&)G-(")'9/'#"-%-@'*&'9,/))@&'*&'!I6V'
'
.&>' :/+>&>' )")' $B")"9"F-Q+&>' $&(#&%%&)%' @F/9&#&)%' *,&X$9-Q+&(' 9/' *S>9&X-&V' K)'
&)P/)%' $&+%' $/(' &X&#$9&' >"+PP(-(' *&' %("+O9&>' G->+"A/%%&)%-"))&9>' Q+-' )&' >")%' $/>'
"$B%/9#"9"F-Q+&>V'K)&'$&(>"))&'*-%&'R')"(#/9&'T'/')"(#/9&#&)%'+)&'P&)^%(&'*/)>'>")'
:B/#$'*&'G->-")'*/)>'9/Q+&99&'%"+%':&'Q+,&99&'G"-%'$&+%'^%(&'$&(h+'/G&:'/%%&)%-")V'!&%%&'
P&)^%(&'$&(#&%' &)'F@)@(/9' *,&)F9"O&('%("->'9&%%(&>V' D-'+)&'$&(>"))&' /'+)&'P&)^%(&' $9+>'
(@*+-%&E'&99&'#&%%(/'$9+>'*&'%&#$>'W'G"-('9&'#"%'&)'&)%-&(E':&'Q+-':")*+-(/'W'+)&'9&:%+(&'
>/::/*@&'&%'*"):'W'+)&':"#$(@B&)>-")'(@*+-%&V'À#cette#remarque,#une#personne#demanda#
si#cette#fenêtre#pouvait#expliquer#qu’un#enfant#inverse#des#syllabes#ou#écrive#des#lettres#à#
l’envers#(le#s# par# exemple).# Selon# M.# RAMUS,# le#premier#problème#est# davantage# d’ordre#
phonologique,#l’enfant#ne#comprenant#pas#ce#qu’il#lit.#Le#second#est#naturel#car#aucun#être#
humain#n’a#la#capacité#naturelle#de#distinguer#un#objet#de#son#image#dans#un#miroir.#Pour#
réussir#à#le#faire,#il#faut#d’abord#l’apprendre#et#différencier#les#formes.#Ainsi,#écrire#un#S#à#
l’envers#n’est#pas#du#tout#alarmant,#il#faut#juste#laisser#le#temps#à#l’enfant#d’apprendre#à#ne#
pas#confondre#les#deux#écritures.#

U&' )-G&/+' O-"9"F-Q+&' $&+%' @F/9&#&)%' -)%&(G&)-(' */)>' 9/' *S>9&X-&V' !&$&)*/)%E' ?V'
=`?KD'),/'$/>'G"+9+'*@%/-99&(':&%%&'$/(%-&E'*&'$&+('*&')"S&('9,/+*-&):&'*/)>'*&>'*@%/-9>'
%&:B)-Q+&>V'C@/)#"-)>E'-9'@G"Q+/'9&'P/-%'Q+,-9'@%/-%'$">>-O9&'*&'%("+G&('*&>'*-PP@(&):&>'
(@:+((&)%&>' */)>' 9/' P"(#&' "+' 9/' *&)>-%@' &)' #/%-](&' F(->&' *&>' :&(G&/+X' *,&)P/)%>'
*S>9&X-Q+&>'&%'*,&)P/)%>')"(#/+XV'
89'#")%(/'@F/9&#&)%'9&'(@>+9%/%'*,+)&'@%+*&'Q+,-9'/G/-%'9+-A#^#&'(@/9->@V'K)':"+$9&'
@%/-%' G&)+' 9&' G"-(E' :")>%-%+@' *,+)' #/(-' *S>9&X-Q+&' &%' *,+)&' @$"+>&' )"(#/9&V' !&' :"+$9&'
/G/-%' &+' >&$%' &)P/)%>E' :B/Q+&' &)P/)%' /S/)%' W' >")' %"+(' &)%(&' %("->' &%' :-)Q' &)P/)%>V' U&'
F(/$B-Q+&' #")%(/)%' 9&' (@>+9%/%' *&' 9,@%+*&' @%/-%' />>&f' &X$9-:-%&V' U"(>Q+,+)' *&>' *&+X'
$/(&)%>' @%/-%' *S>9&X-Q+&E' >&>' &)P/)%>' /G/-&)%' +)&' :B/):&' >+(' *&+X' *&' 9,^%(&V' U"(>Q+,/+'
:")%(/-(&' -9' @%/-%' )"(#/9E' >&>' &)P/)%>' 9,@%/-&)%' @F/9&#&)%' %"+>V' !&%%&' @%+*&E' *->/-%' ?V'
=`?KDE' P&(/-%' >/+%&(' +)' F@)@%-:-&)' /+' $9/P")*V' I99&' ),/$$"(%&' $/>' 9/' $(&+G&' Q+&' 9/'
*S>9&X-&'&>%'F@)@%-Q+&E'#/->'$"+>>/-%'W'(&F/(*&('*/)>':&%%&'*-(&:%-")V'89')"+>'/G"+/'Q+&'
:&(%/-)>' *&' >&>' :"99]F+&>' *&' L/>%&+(' $&)>/-&)%' /G"-(' -*&)%-P-@' :&>' F^)&>E' #/->' $"+(' 9&'
#"#&)%E'(-&)'),&>%'>i(V'
U&' P/:%&+(' &)G-("))&#&)%/9' P+%' 9+-' /+>>-' @G"Q+@E' &)' >&' P")*/)%' >+(' +)&'
:"#$/(/->")' W' 9,@:B&99&' &+("$@&))&V' 89' &>%' &)' &PP&%E' *,/$(]>' 9&>' (@>+9%/%>' *,@%+*&>'
&+("$@&))&>E' $9+>' P/:-9&' $"+(' +)' P-))"->' *,/$$(&)*(&' W' 9-(&' Q+,+)' P(/)h/->V' U/' 9/)F+&'
P-))"->&' ),&>%' :")>%-%+@&' Q+&' *&' 56' $B")]#&>' &%' 9,/9$B/O&%' :"#$"(%&' 56' 9&%%(&>E' +)&'
$"+(':B/Q+&'$B")]#&V'./)>'9&':/>'*,+)&'9/)F+&'"j'9&>'>%(+:%+(&>'>&'(@$]%&)%E'%&99&'Q+&'
9,/99&#/)*E'9&>'&)P/)%>'/$$(&))&)%'@F/9&#&)%'W'9-(&'$9+>'G-%&'Q+,&)';(/):&E'#/->'#"-)>'
G-%&' Q+,&)' ;-)9/)*&V' .&' %&99&>' /)/9"F-&>' $&+G&)%' @F/9&#&)%' ^%(&' *(&>>@&>' /G&:' 9&>'
&)G-("))&#&)%>':+9%+(&9>E'$@*/F"F-Q+&>'"+'>":-/+XV'
'
K)' #"S&)' $"+(' 9,&)P/)%' *S>9&X-Q+&' *,@:B/$$&(' W' 9/' G-F-9/):&' *&>' $/(&)%>' &%' *+'
:"($>'&)>&-F)/)%'&>%'*&'>&'P-X&('>&+9'*&>'#@%B"*&>'*,/*/$%/%-")E'F(Z:&'W'*&'%(]>'O"))&>'
P/:+9%@>'-)%&99&:%+&99&>V'Un#parent#demanda#si#bouger#pour#lire#était#un#moyen#d’échapper#
à#la#gêne#causée#par#la#lecture.#Son#fils#ne#pouvait#en#effet#pas#apprendre#une#leçon#sans#
marcher,#se# dandiner# et# la# réciter# à# haute# voix.#M.# RAMUS# répondit# que# bouger# pouvait#
être#le#moyen#trouvé#par#l’enfant#pour#outrepasser#la#gêne,#mais#pouvait#également#être#
une#habitude#plutôt#qu’une#réelle#aide.#
'
'
888M'!"##&)%'P/-(&'$"+('/-*&('9,&)P/)%'k'
'
K)' $("P&>>&+(' &>%' :/$/O9&' *&' (&$@(&(' +)' &)P/)%' *S>9&X-Q+&E' *&' 9+-' $("$">&(' +)&'
/-*&' &%' *&' 9+-' /#@)/F&(' +)' $/(:"+(>V' 89' 9+-' &>%' :&$&)*/)%' -#$">>-O9&' *&' $">&(' +)'
*-/F)">%-:E'*&'*@$->%&('"+'*&'(@@*+Q+&('9,&)P/)%V'L("$">&('+)&'#@%B"*&'-)%&)>-G&'$&+%'
P"):%-"))&(V'!&$&)*/)%E'-)%&)>-G&'>-F)-P-&'/+'#"-)>'+)&'B&+(&'$/('b"+(E'&%')")'+)&'B&+(&'
$/(' >&#/-)&E' :"##&' :,&>%' /:%+&99&#&)%' $("$">@' $/(' 9&>' $("P&>>-"))&9>' *&' 9/' >/)%@V'
?/9B&+(&+>&#&)%E'#^#&'>-'$9+>'*&'%&#$>'@%/-%'$("$">@'/+X'P/#-99&>E'&99&>'>&(/-&)%'G-%&'
:")P(")%@&>' /+X' $("O9]#&>' 9-@>' /+' %(/)>$"(%E' W' 9/' 9"F->%-Q+&' &%' /+' :"i%' *,+)&' %&99&'
(@F+9/(-%@V'
.]>' 9/' #/%&()&99&E' 9,-)%&(G&)%-")' &>%' $">>-O9&V' U&>' :"#$@%&):&>' "(/9&>' @%/)%'
-)*->$&)>/O9&>' W' 9/'9&:%+(&E'P/-(&'%(/G/-99&('9,&)P/)%'*]>'9&'$9+>'b&+)&'ZF&'>+('>")'
G":/O+9/-(&E' >+(' 9&>' :"):&$%>' $B")"9"F-Q+&>' &%' >+(' 9,/$$(&)%->>/F&' *&>' 9&%%(&>' &>%'
-)*->$&)>/O9&V'Un#parent#demanda#alors#si#l’apprentissage#des#lettres#n’était#pas#un#frein#à#
la#lecture,#le#nom#pouvant#entrer#en#interférence#avec#le#son.#M.#RAMUS#rétorqua#que,#de#
toute#façon,#il#était#impensable#de#ne#pas#connaître#les#lettres#de#l’alphabet#dans#la#vie#de#

tous#les#jours.#De#plus,#la#plupart#du#temps,#les#noms#des#lettres#ont,#à#de#rares#exceptions#
près,#un#lien#direct#avec#la#sonorité.#Pour#lui,#apprendre#l’alphabet#tôt#est#une#bonne#chose.'
Cela#permet#de#planter#la#graine#du#langage#tôt#chez#l’enfant,#lui#permettant#ainsi#de#se#
développer#plus#rapidement.#
!&%%&'Q+&>%-")'>"+9&G/'+)&'-)%&(("F/%-")'9@F-%-#&V'g%/)%'*"))@'Q+,-9'P/+%'B/O-%+&('
9,&)P/)%'%e%'/+'9/)F/F&E'$"+(Q+"-'/%%&)*(&'>&$%'/)>'&%'*&#-'/G/)%'*&'>&'*&#/)*&('>,-9'&>%'
*S>9&X-Q+&'k' I)' G@(-%@E' *&>' P/:%&+(>' $(@*-:%-P>' &X->%&)%E' #/->' -9>' ),")%' /+:+)&' G/9&+('
*@%&(#-)->%&V'
.,/$(]>' +)&' @%+*&' *&' 9,8CDI=?E' :-)Q' &)P/)%>' >+(' >-X' >+-G/)%' +)' /$$(&)%->>/F&'
>$@:-P-Q+&' -)%&)>-P' &)' (&%-(&)%' +)&' /#@9-"(/%-")' W' 9/' P"->' )&%%&' &%' *+(/O9&V' ./)>' 9&+('
@%+*&E' :&%' /$$(&)%->>/F&' >,@%/9/-%' >+(' %("->' #"->E' &%' @%/-%' >+-G-' *&' %&>%>' *&' :"#$@%&):&'
(@F+9-&(>'$&)*/)%'*&+X'/)>V'
'
D-' 9/' $(->&' &)' :B/(F&' @%/-%' -)>+PP->/)%&E' 9&' #@*&:-)' "+' 9&' $>S:B"9"F+&' >:"9/-(&'
$"+G/-%'-)%&(G&)-(V'U&'*-/F)">%-:'@%/-%'*,/+%/)%'$9+>'(-:B&'Q+&'9&>'$&(>"))&>'$">/)%'*&>'
*-/F)">%-:>' @%/-&)%' *&' *->:-$9-)&>' *-PP@(&)%&>V' U/' *-PP-:+9%@' @%/-%' /9"(>' *&' %("+G&(' +)&'
$&(>"))&' :/$/O9&' *&' P/-(&' *&>' 9-&)>' &)%(&' %"+>' :&>' *-/F)">%-:>V' I)' "+%(&E' P/-(&' *&>'
*-/F)">%-:>'/G/)%'*&+X'/)>'*,&)>&-F)&#&)%'*&'9/'9&:%+(&'&>%'+)&'&((&+(E'9/'>%/O-9-%@'*+'
*-/F)">%-:'$"+G/)%'^%(&'(&#->'&)':/+>&V'
K)'$("O9]#&'/+b"+(*,B+-'&>%'9&'%("$'P(@Q+&)%'*-/F)">%-:'>"9-%/-(&V'!&'*-/F)">%-:')&'
$&(#&%'$/>'*,@%/O9-('+)'$("P-9':"F)-%-P'*&'9,&)P/)%E'&%'/-)>-'&#$^:B&'*&'9+-'/$$"(%&('+)&'
(@$")>&'(@&99&#&)%'/*/$%@&V'
'
U&>'/#@)/F&#&)%>'$("$">@>'$/(' 9&>' $("P&>>&+(>' >")%' @F/9&#&)%' %(]>' -#$"(%/)%>'
*/)>'9&':"#O/%':")%(&'9/'*S>9&X-&V'I)':/>'*&'O9":/F&'/+')-G&/+'*&'9/'9/)F+&E':&'),&>%'$9+>'
(@&99&#&)%'9/'#/%-](&'&)>&-F)@&'Q+-'&>%'@G/9+@&V'g%/)%'*"))@'Q+&'h/'),&>%'$/>')")'$9+>'
9,"(%B"F(/$B&E'(-&)')&'(&>>"(%'(@&99&#&)%V'?V'=`?KD'*@:9/(/'Q+,-9'@%/-%':")%(&'9&'P/-%'*&'
)"%&(' 9,"(%B"F(/$B&' */)>' +)&' -)%&(("F/%-")' *,B->%"-(&E' :/(' 9,&)P/)%' $"+G/-%' /9"(>' ^%(&'
*@:"+(/F@' $/(' 9,B->%"-(&E' >/)>' (@&99&#&)%' ^%(&' )"%@' */)>' :&%%&' #/%-](&V' K)&' #@%B"*&'
@F/9&#&)%'&PP-:/:&'$"+('/-*&('9&>'&)P/)%>'*S>9&X-Q+&>'&%')&'$/>'9&>'$(@:-$-%&('&)'@:B&:'
>:"9/-(&' @%/-%' *&' 9&+(' *"))&(' *+' %&#$>' &)' $9+>' $"+(' P/-(&' 9&>' *&G"-(>' H9&' P/#&+X' %-&(>'
%&#$>'*+'O(&G&%'"+'*+'O/:MV'.-#-)+&('9/':B/(F&'@:(-%&'&%'+%-9->&('*&>'"+%-9>'-)P"(#/%-Q+&>'
:")>%-%+&)%' @F/9&#&)%' >&9")' 9+-' *&>' O")>' #"S&)>' *&' :")%"+()&(' 9&>' $("O9]#&>' >"+>A
b/:&)%>'&%'/-)>-'*&'>&'P":/9->&('>+('9&'P")*V'
L"+('$9+>'*,-)P"(#/%-")>E'9&>'$/(&)%>'&%'&)>&-F)/)%>'@%/-&)%'-)G-%@>'W':")>+9%&('9/'
P"(#/%-")'>+('9/'*S>9&X-&'$("$">@&'$/('9,8)>$&:%-")'`:/*@#-Q+&'*+'=Be)&V'
*