Enjeux stratégiques

Enjeux straté giques
La tribune fonda - fé vrier 2010 - n°201
PAGE
15
La crise rappelle à l’ordre, sèchement, les entreprises « capita-
listes ». Les entreprises de l’économie sociale faisant partie inté-
grante de l’économie, sont assujetties aux mêmes règles tout en
devant respecter des règles spécifiques sous peine de se trahir.
Cette double contrainte les tient en alerte et stimule leur capacité
à se saisir des opportunités sans perdre le cap.
Ainsi, elles se sont développées considérablement. Cependant ce
développement a un prix. Dès leurs premiers pas au XIX° siècle,
elles ont tissé des rapports privilégiés et ambigus avec la puis-
sance publique. Pour elle, les entreprises de l’économie sociale ont pu remplir des
fonctions différentes : avant-garde, développeur et/ou instrument privilégiés. Puis,
sous l’influence d’une doxa libérale, elles se sont progressivement confrontées aux
logiques de marché.
Ce mouvement a favorisé leur développement tout en suscitant des interroga-
tions fortes sur les contradictions qu’il a fait naître en interne et au quotidien.
##"
:04:7*L.:/1+8+397+57/8+8*+1LB)4342/+84)/'1++3*B5/9*+1+:7*/85+78/438:7
1+89+77/94/7+8+9*+1'*/;+78/9B*+88+)9+:78)4:;+798':8+7;/)+*+85+78433+8
8L',,/72+39)422+:3;+)9+:7B)4342/6:+7+)433:
! #%#
++-+8+3'7B)+22+397+3*:)4259+
K2/11/438*+8'1'7/B87B5'79/8*'38+397+57/8+8-B3B7'39*:
! 
K+11+8439)7BB*+85F1+8*L+<)+11+3)+6:+1L+3;/7433+2+39)43):77+39/+13L+89
5'85'7;+3:@,7'-/1/8+7
1+82:9:+11+8G8'39BH'88:7+39*+8)4:;+79:7+8+3)4251B2+39'/7+
8'39B
1+8('36:+8)445B7'9/;+8*B9/+33+39*+8*B5F98('3)'/7+8
1+82:9:+11+8*L'88:7'3)+8)4:;7+39*+85'798*+2'7).B*L'88:7'3)+
':9424(/1+
1+8)445B7'9/;+8'-7/)41+8*B9/+33+39*+85'798*+2'7).B*:8+)9+:7
'-74'1/2+39'/7+
)+79'/3+8$)45)422+G.C6:+*B0+:3+7H84391+'*+788:71+:72'7).B

La tribune fonda - fé vrier 2010 - n°201
PAGE
16
54:71+:75'791+8'884)/'9/43857+33+39+3).'7-+1'6:'8/949'1/9B*+1L/3
8+79/4384)/'1+*+85+78433+8+3*/,,/):19B84:*+1L')):+/1*+85+78433+8.'3*/
)'5B+8
K'14786:+1+).F2'-++89+3.':88+*+1+8+397+57/8+8*+1LB)4342/+
84)/'1+7+)7:9+397B-:1/C7+2+39397++9+11+8439,'/9574-7+88+71+:7
)'5')/9B*L+2(':).+*+6:'3*)+11+*+8+397+57/8+897'*/9/433+11+889'-3'/9
@54:71'2D2+5B7/4*+11+87B:3/88+39':04:7*L.:/*+85+78433+8
')9/;+8*B9+397/)+8*L:3+2514/
35'7'11C1+34:8*+;438349+76:L+11+88439*+8+2514=+:78'997')9/,854:71+8
0+:3+8*/51F2B8*LB)41+88:5B7/+:7857+89/-/+:8+888+)11+81+8'99/7+39
5'7*+34:;+11+8,'A438*L+397+57+3*7++93+84395'8+<548B+8':<'1B'8(4:78/+78
'/8:3+1+A43@9/7+7*+1')7/8++896:+1L/25')97B+1*+8+397+57/8+8*+1LB)4
342/+84)/'1+*'38)+)439+<9+*/,,/)/1++9/3)+79'/33+7B8/*+5+:9D97+5'8*'38
1+ 54/*8 6:+)+8 +397+57/8+8 439 ')6:/8':,/1 *+ 1+:757'9/6:+ 2'/8*'381'
*B243897'9/43*:54:;4/7897'9B-/6:+*+1+:78;'1+:78*+7B,B7+3)+8*+1+:747-'
3/8'9/43*B24)7'9/6:++9*+1+:77'5547957/;/1B-/B';+)1'84)/B9B)/;/1+84:7)+
*L/385/7'9/43+9*+1B-/9/2/9B*+1+:75740+9/389/9:9/433+1+9*+1+:782/88/438
L/*+39/9B541/9/6:+*+8+397+57/8+8*+1LB)4342/+84)/'1+8'*/2+38/43897'9B
-/6:+8439*43)@;'147/8+7*L':9'3951:86:+1+:78';'3)B+8B)4342/6:+81+:7
)43,C7+39:3+2+/11+:7+;/8/(/1/9B
! %#
%#
L/3*B5+3*'3)+6:+1+8+397+57/8+8*+1LB)4342/+84)/'1+'94:04:7857B8+7;B5+:
4:574:+:76:'1/9B*L+39/9B541/9/6:+84)/'1+1+8)43*:/9@).+7).+7@)438+7;+7
:3+*/89'3)+';+)1+8*433+:78*L47*7++91+8'1B'8*+1+:757/47/9B32D2+9+258
+11+84398:8+*/,,B7+3)/+7*+8':97+8')9+:78B)4342/6:+8+9B;/9+7'/38/1'5+79+
*+)43,/'3)+6:/1+8',,+)9+':04:7*L.:/&37B)+39843*'-+!/3*/6:+
6:L@1LB).+11++:745B+33+*+85+78433+8/39+774-B+85+38+396:+1+8'884
)/'9/43884391+82/+:<51')B+854:77B543*7+':<'99+39+884)/'1+85'79/):1/C7+2+39
*'381+)'*7+*+88+7;/)+8@1'5+78433+5+38+396:+1'841:9/43*+1')7/8+
;/+3*7'*+1'84)/B9B)/;/1++8+397+57/8+8*+1LB)4342/+84)/'1+8439@)+9/97+
*+847-'3/8'9/43857/;/1B-/B+8)'7+3)'5')/9B*+)43)+;4/7+92+997++3J:;7+:3+
*B24)7'9/+B)4342/6:+3*B5/9*+)+88)47+88/-3/,/)'9/,81+8+397+57/8+8*+
1LB)4342/+84)/'1+84:,,7+39*L:32'36:+*+;/8/(/1/9B*:,'/9*+1+:7*/85+78/43+9
*+1+:78+-2+39'9/43+:7/*+39/,/)'9/43/389/9:9/433+11++89':88//3)+79'/3+ 

Enjeux straté giques
La tribune fonda - fé vrier 2010 - n°201
PAGE
17
')7/8+3+1+8B5'7-3+5'8;7'/2+39+91+884:2+9@*+8'99+39+8+<')+7(B+8
+5+3*'39+11+2+9':88/+3B;/*+3)+1+8)'7')9B7/89/6:+86:/1B-/9/2+391+:7548
9:7+47/-/3'1+;/8@;/8*+1'5:/88'3)+5:(1/6:++9*+82'7).B8+1'8:--C7+
6:+1+24*C1+*L47-'3/8'9/436:L+11+843974*B*+5:/81+:7)7B'9/43+897/).+*L+3
8+/-3+2+398:9/1+854:71L+38+2(1+*+8,'A438*L+397+57+3*7+
!+72+997+:3+2+/11+:7+7+)433'/88'3)+*+86:'1/9B8*+)+24*C1+8+7;/7'/9@:3+
2+/11+:7+',,/72'9/43*:G57/3)/5+*LB)4342/+51:7/+11+H+5+3*'39)+99+
.=549.C8+7+3;4/+@1')43897:)9/43*L4:9/1885B)/,/6:+8*+-+89/43*+7B-:1'
9/43+9*LB;'1:'9/43,'/8'39:3+51:81'7-+51')+':6:'1/9'9/,+9':9+258)438'
)7B@1L/389':7'9/43*+1/+3884)/':<+99+*B2'7).+'88:7+7'/9':<+397+57/8+8*+
1LB)4342/+84)/'1+:37F1++9:3+47/-/3'1/9B2/+:<7+)433:8
13+,':9*43)5'8)43,43*7+57'9/6:+8+9,/3'1/9B8$/1+:7+,,/)')/9B'5+72/8*+
7B;B1+7*+82'7).B8':,/1*+8')9/438*B;+1455B+8)+3+,:95'81+(:9L+89
'/38/6:L+37=4-:C834:8/3;/9+@*/89/3-:+73435'81+8+397+57/8+8*+1LB)4
342/+84)/'1++397++11+82'/851:9F91+:78B9'5+8*+2'9:7'9/43I)+574548/1
*/89/3-:+1'5.'8+5/433/C7+5479B+5'7)+:<6:/7/86:+39)'7/183L':7'/+397/+3
@5+7*7+*+1'5.'8+-+89/433'/7+*+8.B7/9/+786:/'='3951:8@5+7*7+459+7'/+39
54:71'57:*+3)+'='39+3).'7-+1'57B8+7;'9/43+9
1+*B;+1455+2+39*L:35'97/24/3+84)/'1'*/8
9/3)9/43+397+1+85.'8+8*+)7B'9/43+9*+2'9:7'
9/432+9+3B;/*+3)+6:+)+8+397+57/8+843994:9
*L'(47**+8249/;'9/438541/9/6:+8+945B7'9/43
3+11+8+37B5438+@*+8:7-+3)+884)/'1+8'5.'8+
-+89/433'/7+8:7;/+39+38:/9++3)'8*+8:))C8+9
;/8+ 1' 5B7+33/9B *: 8+7;/)+ $/ )+99+ *+:</C2+
5.'8++89)+11+*+1LB1/2/3'9/43*+87/86:+8+11+3L+3+895'824/385B7/11+:8+
54:71L/*+39/9B*+1L+397+57/8+*+1LB)4342/+84)/'1+3+,,+91+8,/3'1/9B8*+343
574,/9+9*+841/*'7/9B7/86:+39*+8L+,,')+7':574,/9*+1'841/*/9B*+1L'55'7+/1
L+3).'E3+2+39*+85.'8+83+5+72+95'8*+*/7+8/*C81L47/-/3+1L:3+5479+
1L':97++3-+72+37+;'3).+34:854:;438)4389'9+76:L':,/1*:9+2581+8
+397+57/8+8*+1LB)4342+84)/'1+8+,47-+39:3+*4:(1+/*+39/9B541/9/6:++9-+8
9/433'/7+
%4:9+,4/81+82D2+8+30+:<84)/':<+9*B('98541/9/6:+8'='39/385/7B81+85/43
3/+78*+1LB)4342/+84)/'1+249/;+3994:04:781L+3-'-+2+392D2+8/1+8,472+8
+38439*/,,B7+39+8L+891'57+:;+6:+1LB)4342/+84)/'1+34:77/9*+8B).'3-+8
)439/3:8';+)843+3;/7433+2+3984)/4541/9/6:++9B)4342/6:+I )+9/97++11+
8L+895'7,4/8974:;B++3(:99+':<57/47/9B8*+854:;4/785:(1/)8!4:71+:75'79
1+8)411+)9/;/9B89+77/947/'1+88+8439+2(4E9B+8*'381+857'9/6:+8*+1L?9'9+3=
&
%#
#

La tribune fonda - fé vrier 2010 - n°201
PAGE
18
'04:9'39*+8+257:398':<57'9/6:+8*+82'7).B854:757+:;+*+24*+73/82++9
*L+,,/)')/9B+8+397+57/8+8*+1LB)4342/+84)/'1+8+8439'/38/;:+8+<548B+8@
:3+*4:(1+*B5+3*'3)+
K*B5+3*'3)+541/9/6:+;/8@;/8*+8*433+:78*L47*7+
K*B5+3*'3)+-+89/433'/7+;/'*+84:9/187+1+;'39*+1'14-/6:+)'5/9'1/89/6:+
)43):77+39+'/38/*+1L'55+1*L4,,7+
+8*B5+3*'3)+82+3')+391+34=':/*+39/9'/7+541/9/6:++9-+89/433'/7+*+8
+397+57/8+8*+1LB)4342/+84)/'1+
!4:79'391';/9'1/9B*+1LB)4342/+84)/'1++892'3/,+89++34:;+11+854:88+85/43
3/C7+88+2'3/,+89+39).'6:+04:7*B343A'391+8'99+/39+8@1'0:89/)+84)/'1+*'38
1+8*42'/3+8*+1LB*:)'9/43*+1L/39B-7'9/43*:*74/9':14-+2+39*+1L/22/-7'
9/43*+1'5'7/9B+97+;+3*/6:+39:32+/11+:75'79'-+*+8,7:/98*:97';'/1+9*:)'5/
9'1+8+397+57/8+8/389'11B+8,43957+:;+*L:3+/22+38+)'5')/9B*+7B8/89'3)+
+99+7B8/89'3)++9)+99+;/9'1/9B5479+391'2'76:+*L:3+'85/7'9/43*/,,:8+*+1'
84)/B9B)/;/1+@'-/7*/7+)9+2+39+9)43)7C9+2+39',/3*L'2B1/47+784384798'38
'99+3*7+1L/3/9/'9/;+*+8':947/9B8+3).'7-+*+1L/39B7D9-B3B7'1$'386:+)+99+
349/433+84/97+2/8++3)':8+1'84)/B9B)/;/1+)4389'9+':6:49/*/+31'*/;+78/9B
*+8/39B7D986:/1'97';+78++91'7'5/*/9B*+8B;41:9/4386:/1'97'38,472+
+8).B2'6:/B2+7-+'14785+:@5+:8:--C7+6:+).'):38+)438/*C7+)422+
2/+:<51')B6:+6:/)436:+54:7)43)+;4/7+9'-/7':2/+:<*+8+8'99+39+8':
8+/3*L47-'3/8'9/438)411+)9/;+8+9*+574</2/9B+8':947/9B89:9B1'/7+8843954:7
1+:75'79*+51:8+351:8/3;+89/+8+39'396:L/389'3)+87B-:1'97/)+8*+)447*/
3'9/43*LB;'1:'9/43+9*+57485+)9/;+
'84)/B9B)/;/1+8L/389':7+)422+1'2'97/)+*+5740+98*+84)/B9B6:+1+8+397+
57/8+8*+1LB)4342/+84)/'1+8L+2514/+39@97'*:/7++37B5438+845B7'9/433+11+8
+8,/3'1/9B83431:)7'9/;+8+9*+841/*'7/9B84397+)433:+8)422+5+72+99'39
2/+:<*+)43)7B9/8+7)+8'99+39+89'39':51'3541/9/6:+6:L45B7'9/433+1L/*+39/9B
*+8+397+57/8+8*+1LB)4342/+84)/'1+8+974:;+'/38/+351+/3+)43)47*'3)+';+)
1+8'85/7'9/438*+1'84)/B9B)/;/1++9843)425479+2+3911+8)439/3:+39'/38/*+
*B74:1+71+1/+36:/1+8:3/9*+5:/81L47/-/3+
+5+3*'391+8)B3'7/48L+8997'38,472B':,/1*:9+258":'3*+'3':7C88'1:'/9
1LB)4342/+84)/'1+)422+1'57+:;+*+1',B)43*/9B*+857/3)/5+87B5:(1/)'/38
*+1L?9'9':8+7;/)+*:5+:51++11++89':04:7*L.://39+75+11B+*/7+)9+2+395'71'
84)/B9B)/;/1+8+143:324:;+2+3934351:8*+8)+3*'392'/8+37+;'3).+'8)+3
*'39*+1'('8+;+781+854:;4/78541/9/6:+8+9B)4342/6:+8;+781+8/389/9:9/438 

Enjeux straté giques
La tribune fonda - fé vrier 2010 - n°201
PAGE
19
+91+847-'3/8'9/43837B5438+@)+8/3043)9/438+11+8843957/B+8*+G8+7+974:8
8+71+82'3).+8H+9*+04:+71+:75'79/++394:9+*B24)7'9/+84:81+)4397F1+*+
1'84)/B9B)/;/1+2/8++3'1+79+5'71+82B*/'8
+99+ B;41:9/43 4,,7+ *+ 7B+11+8 455479:3/9B8 ':< +397+57/8+8 *+ 1LB)4342/+
84)/'1+!4:79'39)+99+574</2/9B+9/22+78/43':)J:7*+1'84)/B9B8+2(1+
+3)47+,'/(1+2+39/3;+89/++99+1+39+:75+:9D97+:3++77+:7897'9B-/6:++8
)43):77+398*+8+397+57/8+8*+1LB)4342/+84)/'1+8439B-'1+2+398+38/(1+8':<
'99+39+884)/'1+8+98';+398+)43,472+7':<'99+39+8*+1'84)/B9B)/;/1++39+72+8
*+7B5438+8841/*'/7+8+9B)414-/6:+8
C814781+8+397+57/8+8*+1LB)4342/+84)/'1+8L';C7+39D97+':,/1*:9+258
24/38:3+'19+73'9/;+B)4342/6:+6:L:34(8+7;'94/7++9*+81'(47'94/7+8)'5'
(1+8*+*B;+1455+7*+85740+98*+541/9/6:+84)/'1+*'381+)'*7+*L:324*C1+
B574:;B*+*B24)7'9/+B)4342/6:+ 35+:97+-7+99+76:+1L/25')9*+)+99+
*B243897'9/4384/9B24:88B5'71'*/85+78/43+91'2=45/+*+8+397+57/8+8*+
1LB)4342/+84)/'1+
#
1+89'99+3*:6:+1+8+397+57/8+8*+1LB)4342/+84)/'1+9B24/-3+39+3*/7+)9
57+:;+@1L'55:/*+1L+,,/)')/9B*:5740+9*B24)7'9/6:++9*+841/*'7/9B6:/1+8
,43*++91+8'3/2+*'381+*4:(1+*42'/3+541/9/6:++945B7'9/433+1%4:9+*B,'/1
1'3)++3)+*42'/3++895+7A:+343)422+:32'36:+2+392'/8)422+:3+97'
./843L+89*/7+6:+1'84)/B9B)/;/1+'5'7,'/9+2+39/39B-7B1'*4:(1+/*+39/9B*+
1LB)4342/+84)/'1+541/9/6:++9-+89/433'/7+'/38/6:+1+*B24397+1+897';':<*+
+'34:/8';/11+
'6:+89/43+89'1478*+8';4/78/+11+8+3439:3+)438)/+3)+':88/;/;+$4:2/8+8
@:3+/39+38+8B7/+*+)4397'/39+87B-1+2+39'/7+8+91B-/81'9/;+8*'381',4:1B+*+
1LB*/)9/43*+8*/7+)9/;+8+:745B+33+8)43,7439B+8@:3+)43):77+3)++<')+7(B+
+11+84398:,'/7+,')++324(/1/8'39+357/47/9B94:9+1+:7B3+7-/++91+:78';4/7
,'/7+8:71+7+-/897+-+89/433'/7++84(8+7;'9+:785+:;+39'1478)4389'9+7:3*B8
B6:/1/(7++397+1+8;+78'398541/9/6:++9-+89/433'/7+*+1+:7/*+39/9B'('11++89
*'381+)'25*+8+397+57/8+8*+1LB)4342/+84)/'1+I +11+8*+7BB6:/1/(7+71+8
5F1+8/*+39/9'/7+8541/9/6:++9-+89/433'/7++9*+7+88+77+7+3)47+51:81+81/+38*+
7B)/574)/9B+3/39+73++9';+)1'84)/B9B)/;/1+8+1431+87+)422'3*'9/438*+
'*/3+#/).+>'99+89/+,'/91+8)43):77+3984395+:9D97+7+3*:':<+397+
57/8+8*+1LB)4342/+84)/'1+1+-7'3*8+7;/)+*+1+:784:,,1+71+:747/+39'9/43897'
9B-/6:+5'71'*B343)/'9/43*+8*B7/;+8*+)+79'/3+8+397+57/8+8