Le dissentiment comme élément structurel de la relation entre

!"#$%&'()"*+$*&
,-"%."%/&01.1*123&45)((67&-"%."%/&8"9&45)((6:&
;&
Le dissentiment comme élément structurel de la relation
entre écoles de droit en Islam
<(66=>$&/$&?%"*5$&,@A1*&BCCD:&
&
&
EF& G& 6"& H1*& /A& II$& +1=56$7& $*& JKKK7& GL"%23"& 4$*7& M%1N& O(#$6& $*& P5(*(L1$7& >%"*/&
1*2$66$52A$6&1*/1$*7&M%(H$++$A%&Q&-"%."%/7&MA#61$&A*&"%2156$&+A%&R0$L(5%"53&"+&"&S*1.$%+"6&
T"6A$UJ&/"*+&6$VA$6&16&5"%"52P%1+$&6"&%$5(**"1++"*5$7&+A%&A*&M6"*&>6(#"67&/$&6"&/PL(5%"21$&
$*&2"*2&VA$&H(%L$&R*(%L"6$U&/$&>(A.$%*$L$*27&5(LL$&6$&M6A+&1LM(%2"*2&P.P*$L$*2&/A&
II$&+1=56$F&E6&.(127&/"*+&6"&.152(1%$&/$+&/PL(5%"21$+&+A%&6$+&/152"2A%$+&$2&6$+&2(2"612"%1+L$+&
M%(/A12+& /"*+& 5$& LWL$& +1=56$7& A*$& /$+& 5(*/121(*+& M(A%& 6"& /1HHA+1(*& /$& 5$22$& *(A.$66$&
*(%L"612P&VA1&%$LM6"5$&6"&VA$+21(*&/$&+".(1%&+1&2$6&(A&2$6&M"3+&$+2&M%W2&M(A%&6"&/PL(5%"21$&
Xfit for democracyY& M"%& 6Z"++$%21(*& VA$& 6$+& M"3+& /(1.$*2& +$& /P.$6(MM$%& >%[5$& Q& 6"&
/PL(5%"21$& Xbecome fit through democracyYF& E6& 5(LL$*2$& 5$& /P.$6(MM$L$*2& M"%& 6"&
M)%"+$\&R])1+&1+&1*/$$/&"&L(L$*2(A+&5)"*>$7&$N2$*/1*>&2)$&M(2$*21"6&%$"5)&(H&/$L(5%"53&
2(&5(.$%&#1661(*+&(H&M$(M6$7&912)&2)$1%&."%31*>&)1+2(%1$+&"*/&5A62A%$+&"*/&/1+M"%"2$&6$.$6+&
(H&"HH6A$*5$UF&&
&
8Z"%2156$&/$&4$*7&%15)$&$*&1/P$+&$2&#"+P&+A%&A*&*(L#%$&/$&%$5)$%5)$+&$LM1%1VA$+7&$++"3$&
/$&5"M2A%$%&A*&/P.$6(MM$L$*2&)1+2(%1VA$&in actuF& E6& /PH1*12& 6"& /PL(5%"21$7& /"*+& 6"& M6A+&
MA%$&2%"/121(*&%PMA#615"1*$7&M"%&/$+&1*+212A21(*+&$2&/$+&M%"21VA$+7&2$66$+&6$+&P6$521(*+&$2&6$&
>(A.$%*$L$*2& M"%& 6"& L"@(%12P7& L"1+& "A++1& $2& +A%2(A2& M"%& 6"& M%(2$521(*& M(6121VA$& VAZ$66$&
/(**$& "AN& 61#$%2P+& $2& Q& 6"& /1+2%1#A21(*& *(*& 5$*+A%P& /$+& *(A.$66$+& $2& /$& 6$A%+&
5(LL$*2"1%$+F&<$+& 61#$%2P+&$2&>"%"*21$+&M$%L$22$*2&/$&>P*P%$%& /$+& ."6$A%+& M(6121VA$+& $2&
51.1VA$+&5$*+P$+&W2%$&Q&6"&#"+$&/ZA*$&/PL(5%"21$&.1"#6$F&4$*&"22%1#A$&Q&6"&/PL(5%"21$&A*$&
valeur intrinsèque&M"%5$&VA$&6$+&61#$%2P+&VAZ$66$&>"%"*212&+(*27&5(LL$&16&/127&RA*$&M"%21$&/$&
6"& #(**$& .1$& /$+& 1*/1.1/A+& $*& 2"*2& VAZW2%$+& +(51"ANUBF& ^66$& "& "A++1& A*$& valeur
instrumentale importante&M"%5$& VAZ$66$&>"%"*2127&"AN& L$L#%$+& /$& 6"& 512P7& 6Z"22$*21(*&/A&
>(A.$%*$L$*2& Q& 6$A%+& %$.$*/15"21(*+F& ?1*"6$L$*27& 6"& M%"21VA$& /PL(5%"21VA$& $+2& /(2P$&
/ZA*$& >%"*/$& importance constructive:&+$+&/P#"2+&$2&+$+&/1+5A++1(*+& M$%L$22$*2& "AN&
512(3$*+&R/Z"MM%$*/%$&6$+&A*+&/$+&"A2%$+&$2&"1/$,*2:&6"&+(51P2P&Q&H(%L$%&+$+&."6$A%+&$2&+$+&
1
Not for quotation, not for publication

M%1(%12P+& ,_:& 8$+& /%(12+& 51.16+& $2& M(6121VA$+7& $*& M"%215A61$%& 5$AN& VA1& +(*2& %$61P+& "AN&
>"%"*21$+&/$+&/1+5A++1(*+7&/P#"2+7&5%121VA$+&(A&/1++$*21L$*2+&(A.$%2+7&(*2&A*&%`6$&5$*2%"6&
/"*+& 6ZP56(+1(*& /$+& 5)(1N& 1*H(%LP+& $2& %PH6P5)1+F& <$+& M%(5$++A+& +(*2& 5%A51"AN& M(A%& 6"&
H(%L"21(*&/$+&."6$A%+&$2&/$+&M%1(%12P+&$2&*(A+&*$&M(A.(*+&M"+7&$*&>P*P%"67&5(*+1/P%$%&6$+&
M%PHP%$*5$+&5(LL$&1*/PM$*/"*2$+&/$&6"&/1+5A++1(*&MA#61VA$7&5Z$+2aQa/1%$&+"*+&%$>"%/$%&+1&
6ZP5)"*>$&(A.$%2&$2&6$+&/P#"2+&,+A%&6$+&(M21(*+:&+(*2&M$%L1+&(A&*(*UbF&4A%&6"&#"+$&/$+&5$+&
)3M(2)=+$+7& 4$*& +Z"22$*/& Q& 5$& VA$& 6"& /PL(5%"21$& 5(*21*A$&/$&/$.$*1%&A*$&."6$A%&
A*1.$%+$66$7&2$%L$&VA1&*Z1LM61VA$&M"+7&/Z"M%=+&6A17&A*&5(*+$*2$L$*2&A*1.$%+$6&L"1+&M6A2`2&
6Z"22$*2$& VA$& RM"%2(A2& 6$+& >$*+& M$A.$*2& ".(1%& /$+& %"1+(*+& /$& 6"& 5(*+1/P%$%& 5(LL$&
."6"#6$UcF&&
&
EEF&GA@(A%/Z)A17&$*&BCCD7&5$22$&M$%+M$521.$&+$L#6$&L(1*+&56"1%$F&8$&IIE$&+1=56$&$+2&H"5$&Q&
A*$& 5%1+$& /$& 6"& /PL(5%"21$7& *(*& +$A6$L$*2& /"*+& 6$& L(*/$& LA+A6L"*7& L"1+& "A++1& "AN&
^2"2+aS*1+&$2&$*&^A%(M$F&8Z1*."+1(*&/$&6ZE%"V&"&/P2%A12&A*&%P>1L$&2(2"612"1%$7&L"1+&$66$&*Z"&
M"+&%PA++1&Q&H(*/$%&A*&+3+2=L$&M(6121VA$&5"M"#6$&/ZP2"#61%&6$+&M%"21VA$+&$2&6$+&.$%2A+&+A%&
6$+VA$66$+& 4$*& #"+$& +(*& "22$*2$F& 8$& LWL$&5(*+2"2&+Z1LM(+$&M(A%&6"& /$+2%A521(*& /$+&
%P>1L$+&"A2(%12"1%$+&/$+&]"61#"*+&$*&GH>)"*1+2"*F&8$+&P6$521(*+&$*&d"6$+21*$&(*2&"MM(%2P&
A*&%P>1L$&L"@(%12"1%$&+"*+&P2"#61%&A*$&M%"21VA$&/PL(5%"21VA$F&8ZP2"2&61#"*"1+&*Z"%%1.$&M"+&
Q&1*2P>%$%&6$&Hizb allah&/"*+&6$&+3+2=L$&6P>"6&61#"*"1+&$2&+$L#6$7&/$&5$&H"127&/A%"#6$L$*2&
"HH"1#61F& 0"*+& 5$+& VA"2%$& 5"+7& 6"& 5(*H%(*2"21(*& L1612"1%$& ".$5& /$+& H(%5$+& L1612"1%$+&
P2%"*>=%$+&+$L#6$&M%(A.$%&VAZ(*&*$&M$A2&>A=%$&1LM(+$%&6"&/PL(5%"21$&M"%&6Z1*."+1(*&(A&
6Z1*2$%.$*21(*&L1612"1%$+F&8"&%P+1+2"*5$&5(*2%$&6Z$**$L1&P2%"*>$%&$+2&2%"12P$7&/"*+&/$+&2$66$+&
51%5(*+2"*5$+7&M"%&5$%2"1*$+&/$+& (%>"*1+"21(*+& L1612"*2$+7&5(LL$&A*$&@A+21H15"21(*&/$& 6"&
6A22$& 5(*2%$& /$+& +3+2=L$+& /PL(5%"21VA$+& VA1& +$%"1$*2& 5"M"#6$+& /Z1*2P>%$%& 2(A2$+& 6$+&
M(+121(*+& M(6121VA$+& /"*+& A*& +$A6& +3+2=L$& 6P>"6F& 0"*+& 6$+& 5"+& 6$+& M6A+& $N2%WL$+7& 6"&
5(*H%(*2"21(*& ".$5& 6Z$**$L1& $N2P%1$A%& $+2& 5(*eA$& 5(LL$& A*$& >A$%%$& /$& %$61>1(*+& VA1&
*P5$++12$&6"&>A$%%$&5(*2%$&6"&/PL(5%"21$F&&
&
8$+& 5(*H612+& L1612"1%$+& *$& +(*2& M"+& 6$+& +$A6+& H"52$A%+& VA1& L$22$*2& $*& 5"A+$& 6Z(%/%$&
/PL(5%"21VA$F&8"&L(*/1"61+"21(*&$+2&A*&"A2%$\&6ZP2"2&*"21(*"6&VA17&M$*/"*2&/$+&+1=56$+7&"&
P2P&6$&5"/%$&/"*+&6$VA$6&6"&/PL(5%"21$&P2"12&5$*+P$&2%(A.$%&+"&M6"5$7&$+2&/$&L(1*+&$*&L(1*+&
2

5"M"#6$& /Z$N$%5$%& 6$+& H(*521(*+& VA1& P2"1$*2& 6$& +1>*$& /$& +"& +(A.$%"1*$2PF& ^+2a16& $*5(%$&
M(++1#6$&/$&/PH1*1%&6"& /PL(5%"21$&"66$L"*/$&(A& H%"*e"1+$&/"*+&6"& 2$%L1*(6(>1$&/$&-"*+&
f$6+$*&/Z"M%=+&6"VA$66$&RGA&+$1*&/ZA*&%P>1L$& /PL(5%"21VA$7& 6"& .(6(*2P& $NM%1LP$& /"*+&
6Z(%/%$&@A%1/1VA$&$+2&1/$*21VA$&Q&6"&.(6(*2P&/$+&+A@$2+F&^*&%$."*5)$7&+Z16+&+(*2&+(AL1+&Q&A*$&
"A2(5%"21$7&16+&/$L$A%$*2&$N56A+&/$&6"&5%P"21(*&*(%L"21.$7&6Z)"%L(*1$&$*2%$&6Z(%/%$&$2&6$A%&
.(6(*2P&*Z$+2&M6A+&"++A%P$UgF&41&M6A+&/$&hCi&/$+&*(%L$+&VA1&(*2&H(%5$&(#61>"2(1%$&M(A%&6$&
512(3$*&H%"*e"1+&(A&"66$L"*/&.1$**$*2&/$&!%AN$66$+7&VA$66$&$+2&6"&%$6"21(*&$*2%$&6"&.(6(*2P&
/$+&+A@$2+&$2&6$+&*(%L$+&"ANVA$66$+&16+&/(1.$*2&(#P1++"*5$hj&0$&M6A+7&6$&%`6$&/A&M%1*5$7&
5(LL$&5(*2%`6$A%&/$&6ZP5)"*>$7&/$+&M%1N7&/$+&L(*(M(6$+7&$2&5(LL$&(%>"*1+"2$A%&/$&6"&
51%5A6"21(*& /$+& #1$*+7& #%$H7& 5(LL$& /1%1>$"*2& +(A.$%"1*& /$& 6ZP5(*(L1$7& /(*2& G6"1*&
!(A%$"A&"&2%"5P&6$&/P.$6(MM$L$*2&@A+VAZ"A&IEEE$&+1=56$7&VA1&$*+A12$&$+2&/$.$*A&6Z"M"*">$&
/$+&P2"2+a*"21(*+7&/PM"++$&"52A$66$L$*2&6$+&H(%5$+&/$&6Z(%>"*1+"21(*&M(6121VA$&*"21(*"6$&Q&
5"A+$&/$&6"&L(*/1"61+"21(*&DF&
&
8ZP2"2a*"21(*&/PL(5%"21VA$&*Z$+2&/(*5&M6A+&5"M"#6$&/Z$N$%5$%&+$A6&+"&+(A.$%"1*$2P&+A%&6"&
M%(/A521(*&/$+&*(%L$+&"ANVA$66$+&+$+&512(3$*+&/(1.$*2&(#P1%7&*1&/$&/1%1>$%&(A&5(*2%`6$%&
6$+& M%(5$++A+& P5(*(L1VA$+& +A%& +(*& 2$%%12(1%$F& 4"& +(A.$%"1*$2P& %P/A12$& /1L1*A$7&
*P5$++"1%$L$*27&6$&*(L#%$&/$+& (M21(*+&$2& /$+&5)(1N&VAZ16&M$A2&(HH%1%&Q&+$+&512(3$*+F&^*&
LWL$&2$LM+7&6$+&^2"2+aS*1+7&6$&M6A+&MA1++"*2&P2"2a*"21(*&/PL(5%"21VA$7&$++"3$&/Z$NM(%2$%7&
M"%&6Z1*."+1(*&L1612"1%$7&+(*&L(/=6$&/$&/PL(5%"21$&/"*+&/Z"A2%$+&M"3+&(k&5$22$&2$*2"21.$&
#A2$& 5(*2%$& A*$& %P+1+2"*5$& L1612"1%$& $2& 51.16$F& G& 6"& 5%1+$& +2%A52A%$66$& /$& 6ZP2"2a*"21(*&
+Z"@(A2$& "1*+1& A*$& 5%1+$& 1*2$%*"21(*"6$& /$& 6"& /PL(5%"21$F& lA$6& M$A2& W2%$7& +(A+& 5$+&
5(*/121(*+7&6$&5(*2$*A&/ZA*&5(*5$M2&/$&/PL(5%"21$&$*&2"*2&VA$&."6$A%&A*1.$%+$66$j&&
&
EEEF& <)$%5)"*2& A*$& %PM(*+$& Q& 5$22$& VA$+21(*7& 5$& 5(66(VA$& +A>>=%$& /$& +Z"MMA3$%& +A%& 6$+&
$NMP%1$*5$+&M(6121VA$+7&%$61>1$A+$+&$2&5A62A%$66$+&/$+&+(51P2P+&/A&L(*/$&$*21$%&M(A%&5%P$%&
A*& 5"/%$& M6A+& 6"%>$& VA$& 5$6A1& /A& +$A6& m551/$*2& M(A%& A*$& %PH6$N1(*& +A%& 6$& HA2A%& /$& 6"&
/PL(5%"21$F&8$+&(%>"*1+"2$A%+7&+1&@Z1*2$%M%=2$&#1$*&6$A%&/PL"%5)$7&$++"1$*2&M"%&6ZP2A/$&/$+&
H(%L$+& $2& /$+& 1*+212A21(*+& /$& /P61#P%"21(*7& /$& 6"& %"21(*"612P& VA1& +Z3& L"*1H$+2$7& /$+&
M%(5P/A%$+&VA1&/P51/$*2&/$&5$&VAZ(*&M$A2&/1%$&$2&H"1%$&/"*+&/1HHP%$*2$+&+M)=%$+&/$&6"&.1$&
MA#61VA$&$2&M%1.P$7&/Z(A.%1%&6$&%$>"%/&.$%+&6Z)(%1n(*&M6A+&6"%>$&/$+&$NMP%1$*5$+&+(51"6$+7&
3

M(6121VA$+7& %$61>1$A+$+& $2& 5A62A%$66$+& $*& /$)(%+& /$& 6Zm551/$*2F& <$22$& M$%+M$521.$& $+2&
5(*+212AP$&M"%&6Z1*2P%W2&M(%2P&"AN&/1HHP%$*2$+&L"*1=%$+&/$&61$%&6"&.1$&/$+&1*/1.1/A+&Q&5$66$&
/$+&5(66$521.12P+F&0"*+&6"&M6A+&MA%$&2%"/121(*&H%"*e"1+$&$66$&+$L#6$7&@$&512$&$*5(%$&A*$&H(1+&
G6"1*&!(A%$"A&+A%&0A%o)$1L7&p"%5&!6(5)&$2&0(L1*1VA$&!"%2)$6$L37&&RL$22%$&6$&+$*+&/$&
6Z(%>"*1+"21(*&5(66$521.$&"A&%"*>&/$&H"5A62P&2%"*+5$*/$*2"6$&5)$n&6Z)(LL$&X5$&+"*+&VA(1&6"&
5(*/121(*& )AL"1*$& *$& M$A2& +$& M$*+$%YF& m*& *$& +"A%"12& 1L">1*$%& A*$& .1$& )AL"1*$& +"*+&
M%1*51M$&/$&5(*+2%A521(*&+(51"6$&,_:UqF&&<(LM%$*/%$&5(LL$*2&5$22$&%$6"21(*&$*2%$&6"&.1$&
/$+&1*/1.1/A+&$2&/$&6"&5(66$521.12P&$+2&5(*+2%A12$&$2&%$M%(/A12$&5Z$+2&+"1+1%&6$+&M%(5$++A+&VA1&&
>P*=%$*2& 6$+& ."6$A%+& 1*2%1*+=VA$+7& 1*+2%AL$*2"6$+& $2& 5(*+2%A521.$+& /(*2& 4$*& M"%6$& $2& VA1&
M$%L$22$*2&"AN&L$L#%$+&/ZA*$&+(51P2P&/$&L$*$%&6"&#(**$&.1$7&/$&L"1*2$*1%&6$A%+&/%(12+&$2&
/$&M%(/A1%$&$2&P5)"*>$%&6$+&1*H(%L"21(*+&$2&6$+&%PH6$N1(*+&VA1&6$+&5(*5$%*$*2F&<$&5(66(VA$&
M%PM"%$& Q& A*$& %$5)$%5)$& +A%& 6$+& H(%L$+& $2& 6$+& M%(5P/A%$+& /$& 6"& /P61#P%"21(*& /"*+& 6$A%&
%$6"21(*& "A& %"1+(**$L$*2& VA1& H(*/$& 6$+& *(%L$+& $2& 6$+& 1*+212A21(*+& $27& +A%2(A27& 6"&
M"%2151M"21(*&Q&6$A%&P6"#(%"21(*&$2&6"&@A+21H15"21(*&M"%&5$AN&VA1&+$%(*2&6$A%+&+A@$2+F&
&
S*$& 2$66$& P2A/$& *$& M$A2& >A=%$& +$& 5(*2$*2$%& /ZP2"#61%& A*& 1*.$*2"1%$& (A& A*$& "*"63+$&
)1+2(%1VA$&/$+&/1HHP%$*2+&+3+2=L$+&*(%L"21H+&$2&M"%2151M"21H+F&E6&+Z">127&+1&@Z"1&#1$*&5(LM%1+7&
/ZA*&$N"L$*&/$&6"&L"*1=%$&/(*2&5$+&2%"/121(*+7&M"%&A*$&%P1*2$%M%P2"21(*&/$&6$A%&)1+2(1%$&
%$61>1$A+$7& @A%1/1VA$& (A& +(51"6$7& +(*2& $*&2%"1*&/$&M%(/A1%$&/$&*(A.$66$+&$NMP%1$*5$+&
/PL(5%"21VA$+F&GA2%$L$*2&/127&M(A%&%$M%$*/%$&$2&L(/1H1$%&6Z$NM%$++1(*&/ZGL"%23"&4$*7&/$&
+Z1*2P%$++$%& Q& 6"& L"*1=%$& /(*2& 5$+& +(51P2P+& +$& M%PM"%$*2& Q& H"1%$& H"5$& "AN& /PH1+& M"%& 6"&
L(#161+"21(*&/$&6$A%+&M%(M%$+&%$++(A%5$+&/P61#P%"21.$+&M(A%&H(*/$%&6$A%+&M%(M%$+&M%"21VA$+&
/PL(5%"21VA$+F&
&
ETF&4(A+&5$2&"+M$527&L"&5(*2%1#A21(*&+A%&6Z1+6"L&"A%"12&MA&2%"12$%&/$&+A@$2+&"++$n&/1HHP%$*2+\&
M(A%& 5$& VA1& 5(*5$%*$& 6"& %$6"21(*& $*2%$& %$61>1(*& $2& M(6121VA$& /"*+& 6"& MP%1(/$& 1+6"L1VA$&
56"++1VA$7&$66$&"A%"12&MA&2%"12$%&/A&>$*%$&6122P%"1%$&"NP&+A%&6$+&5(*+$16+&"AN&M%1*5$+7&/$&6"&
/1HHP%$*5$& /$+& H(*521(*+& "22%1#AP$+& Q& /1HHP%$*2$+& MP%1(/$+& "AN& 1*+212A21(*+& M(6121VA$+& $2&
%$61>1$A+$+7& /$+& M%(@$2+& /$& >(A.$%*"*5$& VA17& Q& M"%21%& /A& IET$& +1=56$7& 5)$%5)$*2& 6$&
5(LM%(L1+&$*2%$&6$+&5(*2%"1*2$+&M(6121VA$+&/ZA*$&+(51P2P&1LM"%H"12$&$2&6$+&*(%L$+&/ZA*$&
4

6(1&M"%H"12$7&6Z(%>"*1+"21(*&/$+&5(*H%P%1$+&L3+21VA$+7&/$+&5(%M(%"21(*+&M%(H$++1(**$66$+7&/$&
6"&2%"*+L1++1(*&/A&+".(1%&$2&@Z$*&M"++$F&&
&
^*& 5$& VA1& 5(*5$%*$& 6$& II$& $2& 6$& IIE$& +1=56$7& 6Z1*2$%M%P2"21(*& /$+& 2$N2$+& 56"++1VA$+& /A&
/%(12&$2&/$&6"&%$61>1(*&/$&1+6"L1VA$&$2&6$A%&L1+$a$*a%$6"21(*&".$5&6$&/%(12&M(+121H&M"%&6$+&
5(A%+&$2&6$+&5(*+$16+&5(*+212A21(**$6+&/A&L(*/$&"%"#$&"A%"12&M$%L1+&/$&/PL(*2%$%&6$&M(1/+&
/A&M"++P&/"*+&6"&M$*+P$&5(*+212A21(**$66$&"%"#$7&L"1+&"A++1&6"&L"*1=%$&/(*2&6$+&+2%A52A%$+&
/$+& P2"2+a*"21(*+& "%"#$+& 5(*/121(**$*2& 6Z1*2$%M%P2"21(*& /$&6"&*(%L"21.12P&/$&6Z1+6"L&
56"++1VA$F&8$&5"+&/$&6"&-"A2$&<(A%&<(*+212A21(**$66$&/Z^>3M2$&"A%"12&P2P&M"%215A61=%$L$*2&
1*2P%$++"*2&M"%5$& VA$&&6$+& "++(51"21(*+&*(*aP2"21VA$+&/$+& /%(12+&/$&6Z)(LL$& +$& +(*27&/$&
M6A+&$*&M6A+&$2&5$&/$MA1+&6$+&"**P$+&VA"2%$a.1*>2a/1N7&".$5&#$"A5(AM&/$&+A55=+7&"MMA3P$+&
+A%& 6"& @A%1+M%A/$*5$& /$& 6"& -"A2$& <(A%&<(*+212A21(**$66$&M(A%&/(**$%&A*$&6P>121L12P&
5(*+212A21(**$66$&Q&6$A%+&%$.$*/15"21(*+F&&
&
TF&'Z"1&$*&$HH$2&2%"."166P&+A%&6$+&/$AN&MP%1(/$+F&'Z"1&2%"12P&6"&@A+215$&5(*+212A21(**$66$&/A&
II$&+1=56$&"A++1&#1$*&VA$&6$&/%(12&$2&6"&.1$&%$61>1$A+$&/$&6"&MP%1(/$&56"++1VA$F&d(A%2"*2&
M(A%&5$&5(66(VA$&@Z"1&5)(1+1&A*&"A2%$&+A@$2\&5$6A1&/$&6Z"%>AL$*2"21(*&5(*2%"/152(1%$7&/$&6"&
6P>121L12P&/A&/1++$*21L$*2&$*&L"21=%$&/$&*(%L"21.12P&%$61>1$A+$&$*&1+6"L&56"++1VA$F&G&A*&
/$>%P& M%$+VA$& 1*5(LM%P)$*+1#6$& M(A%& #$"A5(AM& /$& L$+& P2A/1"*2+7& LA+A6L"*+& (A& *(*a
LA+A6L"*+7&VA1&61+$*2&M(A%&6"&M%$L1=%$&H(1+&A*&2$N2$&56"++1VA$&/A&/%(12&LA+A6L"*7&fiqh,&
5$+&2$N2$+&+(*2&(%>"*1+P+&$*&+A1."*2&6$&M%1*51M$&/$&6"&6P>121L12P&/A&/1++$*21L$*2&$2&/A&61#%$&
5)(1N&$*2%$&(M21(*+&/(52%1*"6$+F&
&
<$22$& 5"%"52P%1+21VA$& /A& fiqh& %$*.(1$& "A& %`6$& M%1L(%/1"6& "22%1#AP7& /"*+& 5$& +3+2=L$&
*(%L"21H7&Q&6"&M$%+(**$&5"M"#6$&/Z$NP5A2$%&/$+&"52$+&@A%1/1VA$+7&5Z$+2aQa/1%$&6"&M$%+(**$&
VA17& M"%& +(*& M%(M%$& %"1+(**$L$*27& +"12& /1+5$%*$%& $*2%$& 6$+& #(**$+& $2& 6$+& L"A."1+$+&
5(*+PVA$*5$+& /$& +$+& "52$+F& 8"& %$6"21(*& $*2%$& 6$+& )(LL$+& $2& 01$A& $+2& #"+P$& +A%& 5$22$&
5"M"512PF&01$A&P2"12&P.1/$LL$*2&5"M"#6$&/Z1LM(+$%&+$+&(%/%$+&Q&6ZW2%$&)AL"1*&$2&Q&6A1&`2$%&
2(A2$&5"M"512P&/$&%P+1+2"*5$7&L"1+&16&*$&6Z"&M"+&H"12F&E6&1LM(%2$&Q&01$A&VA$&6ZW2%$&)AL"1*&
5)(1+1++$7&/$&M"%&+(*&M%(M%$&>%P&$2&/$&M"%&+"&5"M"512P&/$&5%(1%$&(A&/$&*$&M"+&5%(1%$7&/Z(#P1%&
(A&/$&/P+(#P1%&"AN&(%/%$+&%P.P6P+F&<%(1%$&$2&(#P1%&+(*2&/$+&"52$+&VA1&(*2&6$A%&H(*/$L$*2&
5