Argumentaire SML loi de Santé - Syndicat des Médecins Libéraux

!"#$%&'(%')#*'+,-&.'(%'/,"*+#)'0#1",*-%'
Les$raisons$du$rejet$$
par$les$médecins$libéraux$
2#&"%'+3+&45%'(%'+,-&.'%+&'1-',&#1&'6#1"'-#&"%'6,3+7'0"4+',&&,89.+':')%1"'+3+&45%'(%'+,-&.;'
-#+'8#-8*&#3%-+'+#-&'&"4+'"%8#--,*++,-&+'(%'),'(*+6#-*<*)*&.;'),'8#56.&%-8%'%&')=%>6%"&*+%'(%'
)%1"+'6"#?%++*#--%)+'(%'+,-&.')*<.",1>7!
@4+'),'6".+%-&,&*#-'(1'6"#$%&'(%')#*'%-'A#-+%*)'(%+'5*-*+&"%+;'%-'#8&#<"%'(%"-*%";'8%+',8&%1"+'(%'
6"#>*5*&.;' -=#-&' %1' (%' 8%++%' (%' +#1)*B-%"' C1%' 8%+' 5%+1"%+' -%' 6%"5%&&",*%-&' 6,+' "%)%D%"' )%+'
(.E+' ,1>C1%)+' -#&"%' +3+&45%' (%' +,-&.' %+&' 8#-?"#-&.' F' 8%)1*' (1' D*%*))*++%5%-&' %&' 8%)1*' (%+'
5,),(*%+'89"#-*C1%+;'C1*'&#189%-&',1$#1"(=91*'6"4+'(=1-'G",-H,*+'+1"'C1,&"%'%&'%-B%-("%-&'(%+'
<%+#*-+'-#1D%,1>'(%'8##"(*-,&*#-'(%+'6"#?%++*#--%)+;'-#&,55%-&'(%'6"%5*%"'"%8#1"+7''
2#&"%'+3+&45%'(%'+,-&.'(#*&'89,-B%"'I'8#-H1'6#1"'),'6"*+%'%-'89,"B%'(%+'6,&*%-&+',&&%*-&+'(%'
6,&9#)#B*%+' ,*B1%+;' *)' ?,*&' ,8&1%))%5%-&' ?,8%' :' 1-%' (%5,-(%' (*J."%-&%;' 8%))%' (%+' 6,&*%-&+'
89"#-*C1%+'%&'(1'D*%*))*++%5%-&'(%'),'6#61),&*#-7!
G,8%':'8%'(.E;'),'6"*+%'%-'89,"B%'(%+'6,&*%-&+',66%))%'(%+'<#1)%D%"+%5%-&+'6"#?#-(+'I'6"*+%'%-'
89,"B%' 8##"(#--.%;' <,+.%' +1"' 1-' &",D,*)' %-' ".+%,1' ,1&#1"' (1' 5.(%8*-' &",*&,-&;' *-&.B",-&' ),'
6".D%-&*#-;' )=.(18,&*#-' &9.",6%1&*C1%' 6#1"' ,88#56,B-%"' )%' 6,&*%-&' :' &#1+' )%+' +&,(%+' (%' +,'
5,),(*%7''
!"#5#1D#*"' 1-%' 6"*+%' %-' 89,"B%' 8##"(#--.%' (%+' 6,&*%-&+;' )=#"B,-*+%"' (,-+' ),' (1".%' %&' ),'
8#-&*-1*&.;'%+&')%'(.E':'"%)%D%"7'!1*+C1=*)'+=,B*&'(%'6".D#*"')%+'.&,6%+'(%'),'6"*+%'%-'89,"B%'(1'
6,&*%-&;' (%' 8##"(#--%"' )=,8&*#-' %&' )%' 6,"&,B%' (=*-?#"5,&*#-' %-&"%' &#1+' )%+' 6"#?%++*#--%)+' (%'
+,-&.'*56)*C1.+'(,-+'+,'6"*+%'%-'89,"B%7'K=%-+%5<)%'(%+'%>6%"&+'6),H,*&')%'5.(%8*-'&",*&,-&'%&'
)%+'6"#?%++*#--%)+')*<.",1>',1'8L1"'(%'8%&&%'&",-+?#"5,&*#-7'M)'-=%-'%+&'"*%-7'0#1&',1'8#-&",*"%7''
Ce$projet$désorganise$notre$système$de$santé$et$obère$l’attractivité$de$l’exercice$libéral$de$la$
médecine$en$excluant$95%$des$professionnels$de$santé$libéraux.$$
• Equipes$de$soins$primaires$fermées$
N-'%J%&;'8%'6"#$%&'(%')#*'6"#5%1&'1-'5#(4)%'1-*C1%'C1*'-%'8#-8%"-%'C1%'OP'(%+'6"#?%++*#--%)+'
(%'+,-&.')*<.",1>'I'&",D,*)'%-'.C1*6%+'6)1"*Q6"#?%++*#--%))%+'?%"5.%+'".1-*%+'(,-+'1-%'5,*+#-'
(%'+,-&.'%&'9#-#".%+'(,-+')%'8,("%'(%+'%>6."*5%-&,&*#-+'+#1+'?#"5%'(%'?#"?,*&+7''
2%'6#1""#-&'6,"&*8*6%"',1>'6,"8#1"+'(%'+,-&.'%&',1>'-#1D%,1>'5#(%+'(%'6"*+%'%-'89,"B%'C1%'
)%+' .C1*6%+' (%' +#*-+' 6"*5,*"%+' %&' )%+' 6"#?%++*#--%)+' )*<.",1>' C1*' +%' +%"#-&' #"B,-*+.+' %-'
8#551-,1&.+' 6"#?%++*#--%))%+' &%""*&#"*,)%+' (%' +,-&.' RA!0ST7' N))%+' ,1"#-&' +%1)%+;' ,884+' ,1>'
E-,-8%5%-&+;'+#1+'?#"5%'(%'?#"?,*&+;'6%"5%&&,-&'),'8##"(*-,&*#-'%&')=#"B,-*+,&*#-'(%+'+#*-+7''
K%'5.(%8*-'+%1)'(,-+'+#-'8,<*-%&'C1*'8##"(#--%')%'6,"8#1"+'(%'+,-&.'(%'+%+'6,&*%-&+'&#1&%'),'
$#1"-.%'+%",'%>8)1'(%'8%'E-,-8%5%-&7''
Syndicat$des$médecins$libéraux$
UU'"1%'D,1B%),+'VOWXO'!,"*+'
WX'OY'Z['WX'WW'Q')%+5)\)%+5)7#"B
$sur$1 3

• La$pensée$unique$G$l’histoire$
@,-+')%'8,("%'(1'!,8&%'0%""*&#*"%'S,-&.;')%'B#1D%"-%5%-&','+#1&%-1')%+'*-*&*,&*D%+'(%+',8&%1"+'
(%' &%"",*-' C1*' +#19,*&%-&' (.D%)#66%"' )%' &",D,*)' %-' .C1*6%;' %-' 6,"&*81)*%"' (,-+' )%+' &%""*&#*"%+'
5,"C1.+'6,"'),'(.+%"&*E8,&*#-'5.(*8,)%7'N-'UWXU;'*)'3',D,*&'5#*-+'(%'UWW'5,*+#-+'%&'6])%+'(%'
+,-&.7'M)'3'%-','6)1+'(%'ZWW',1$#1"(=91*7!
@,-+')%'8,("%'(1'!KGSS'UWX^;'(%+'-#1D%,1>'5#(%+'(%'".51-.",&*#-'R?#"?,*&+T'(%+'.C1*6%+'(%'
+#*-+'#-&'.&.'%>6."*5%-&.+'6#1"'6%"5%&&"%',1>'6"#?%++*#--%)+'(%'+,-&.'(%'8#-+,8"%"'6)1+'(%'
&%56+' :' ),' 8#-(1*&%' (=,8&*#-+' (%' 6".D%-&*#-' %&' (%' (.6*+&,B%;' :' ),' 8##"(*-,&*#-' %-&"%'
6"#?%++*#--%)+;' -#&,55%-&' ,1&#1"' (%+' 8,+' 8#56)%>%+;' B"_8%' :' (%+' "%D1%+' (%' 8,+'
+3+&.5,&*C1%+' 6#1"' (%+' 6,&9#)#B*%+' )#1"(%+7' U[W' %>6."*5%-&,&*#-+' #-&' .&.' 5%-.%+7'
K=%>6."*5%-&,&*#-','.&.'B.-.",)*+.%':'YWW',1&"%+7!
@,-+')%'8,("%'(1'8,9*%"'(%+'89,"B%+;'61<)*.'%-'?.D"*%"'UWXO;'+1*&%':'),'D,)*(,&*#-'6,"'),'5*-*+&"%;'
)%' "4B)%5%-&' ,"<*&",)' 6"#6#+.' 6,"' `%"&",-(' G",B#-,"(' #1D"%' 8%&&%' %>6."*5%-&,&*#-' (%'
-#1D%))%+' ".51-.",&*#-+' :' (%' -#1D%))%+' +&"18&1"%+' %-' .89,-B%' (=1-%' +."*%' (=%-B,B%5%-&+' I'
"%+6%8&' (1' &",D,*)' %-' .C1*6%' R8#-8%"&,&*#-;' 6"#&#8#)%+;' ?#"5,&*#-T;' (%' )=,884+' ,1>' +#*-+'
R9#",*"%+'.),"B*+;'#1D%"&1"%')%'+,5%(*'5,&*-T;'6,"&,B%'(1'+3+&45%'(=*-?#"5,&*#-77777!
@=*8*' UWXV;' X' WWW' .C1*6%+' (%' +#*-+' (%' 6"#>*5*&.;' +#*&' XW' WWW' 6"#?%++*#--%)+;' <.-.E8*%"#-&' (%'
8%&&%'-#1D%))%'?#"5%'(%'".51-.",&*#-'+166).5%-&,*"%7''
Les$ médecins$ libéraux$ contestent$ un$ modèle$ de$ structuration$ d’équipe$ de$ soins$ fermées$
ignorant$95%$des$libéraux$exerçant$individuellement$tous$en$étant$interconnectés$aux$autres$
professionnels$de$santé$dans$le$cadre$d’une$coopération$de$fait$«$hors$murs$».$$
• L’étatisation$
@,-+')%'8,("%'(%'8%&&%'6#)*&*C1%'61<)*C1%;')%+',B%-8%+'".B*#-,)%+'(%'+,-&.'RabST'*-&%"D*%-("#-&'
6#1"' +&"18&1"%"' 8%+' 6,"8#1"+;' ".+%"D.+' ,1>' .C1*6%+' (%' +#*-+' 6"*5,*"%+' %&' ,1>' 8#551-,1&.+'
6"#?%++*#--%))%+'&%""*&#"*,)%+'(%'+,-&.7''
S%1)%+')%+'.C1*6%+'(%'+#*-+'?#"5,)*+.%+'6#1""#-&'6,"&*8*6%"':'8%+'6#)*&*C1%+'61<)*C1%+'(%'+,-&.7!
c-%' .C1*6%' (%' +#*-+' 6"*5,*"%+;' 8#56#+.%' (=1-' %-+%5<)%' (%' 6"#?%++*#--%)+' (%' +,-&.;'
8#-+&*&1.%' ,1&#1"' (%' 5.(%8*-+' B.-.",)*+&%+' (%' 6"%5*%"' "%8#1"+;' 6#1"",' 8#-&"*<1%"' :' ),'
+&"18&1",&*#-'(%+'6,"8#1"+'(%'+,-&.;'-#-'6,+'(%')%1"'6,&*%-&4)%'5,*+'(%+'1+,B%"+7''
!#1"'".6#-("%':'(%+'<%+#*-+'(%'+,-&.'(*,B-#+&*C1.+;')%+',8&%1"+'(=1-%'#1'(%'6)1+*%1"+'.C1*6%+'
(%' +#*-+' ,*-+*' C1%' (=,8&%1"+' ,++1",-&' (%+' +#*-+' (%' 6"%5*%"' #1' +%8#-(' "%8#1"+' #1' 5.(*8#Q
+#8*,1>' #1' +#8*,1>;' 6#1""#-&' +%' 8#-+&*&1%"' +#1+' ?#"5%' (%' 8#551-,1&.+' 6"#?%++*#--%))%+'
&%""*&#"*,)%+'(%'+,-&.7''
N-'8,+'(%'8,"%-8%'(=*-*&*,&*D%;')=,B%-8%'".B*#-,)%'(%'+,-&.'RabST'6#1"",'6"%-("%')=*-*&*,&*D%'(%'
8#-+&*&1&*#-'(=1-%'8#551-,1&.',1&#1"'(=1-'5.(%8*-777C1*'6%1&'d&"%'-#-')*<.",)7'!#1"'".6#-("%'
,1>' <%+#*-+' *(%-&*E.+' (,-+' )%' 8,("%' (%+' (*,B-#+&*8+;' )=,B%-8%' 6#1"",' 8#-8)1"%' 1-' 8#-&",&'
&%""*&#"*,)'(%'+,-&.7'e1D",-&':'(%+'+1<D%-&*#-+'61<)*C1%+'%&'(%+'E-,-8%5%-&+'&",-+D%"+,1>'(%'
&36%'GMb;'*)+'6%"5%&&"#-&'(=*56#+%"'1-'6,-*%"'(%'+#*-+'%&'(%+'5#3%-+',++#8*.+7''
!#1"' ),' B%+&*#-' (%+' 8,+' 8#56)%>%+;' )%+' .C1*6%+' (%' +#*-+' 6"*5,*"%+' %&' )%+' 8#551-,1&.+'
6"#?%++*#--%))%+' &%""*&#"*,)%+' (%' +,-&.;' 6#1""#-&' <.-.E8*%"' (1' 8#-8#1"+' (%' 6),&%+' ?#"5%+'
&%""*&#"*,)%+'(=,661*7'N))%+'#-&'6#1"'#<$%8&*?'(%'?,*"%')%')*%-'%-&"%')%'+,-*&,*"%'%&'+#8*,)7'N))%+'?#-&'
%-&"%"'(,-+')%'+89.5,'(%+'6,"8#1"+'(%'+,-&.;')%+',8&%1"+'(1'5.(*8#Q+#8*,)7''
Syndicat$des$médecins$libéraux$
UU'"1%'D,1B%),+'VOWXO'!,"*+'
WX'OY'Z['WX'WW'Q')%+5)\)%+5)7#"B
$sur$2 3

S*' )%' &%>&%' (%' )#*' 6".8*+%' C1%' 8%+' 6),&%+' ?#"5%+' (#-&' )%+' ?#-8&*#-+' +%"#-&' (.D%)#66.%+' %&'
#"B,-*+.%+' 6,"' )%+' ,B%-8%+' ".B*#-,)%+' (%' +,-&.' RabST;' 6#1""#-&' d&"%' (.8)%-89.%+' 6,"' )%'
5.(%8*-'&",*&,-&'#1'1-',1&"%'5.(%8*-'%-')*%-',D%8')1*;'%))%+'+#-&',D,-&'&#1&;'(%+&*-.%+':'d&"%'
*-&.B".%+' :' &%"5%' (,-+' )%+' .C1*6%+' (%' +#*-+' 6"*5,*"%+' %&' )%+' 8#551-,1&.+' 6"#?%++*#--%))%+'
&%""*&#"*,)%+'(%'+,-&.7''
• Disparition$de$la$convention$nationale$$
K=#"*%-&,&*#-' &"4+' ,(5*-*+&".%' %&' .&,&*+&%' (1' 6"#$%&' (%' )#*;' 5,"B*-,)*+%' )=a++1",-8%Q5,),(*%'
1-*C1%5%-&'(,-+'+#-' "])%'(%'6,3%1"'+#1+' ),'(*"%8&*#-'(%')=.&,&' %-'+91-&,-&'+#-'(#5,*-%' (%'
8#56.&%-8%'C1%'+#-&')%+'"%),&*#-+',D%8')%+'6"#?%++*#-+'(%'+,-&.')*<.",)%+7!
K%+' 8#-D%-&*#-+' 5.(*8,)%+' C1*' E>%-&' )%+' &,"*?+;' )%+' #<$%8&*?+' (%' 5,*&"*+%' (%+' (.6%-+%+;'
)=#"B,-*+,&*#-'(%+'6"#?%++*#-+;'),'".B1),&*#-'(.5#B",69*C1%'%&')%+'"4B)%+'(1'6,"8#1"+'(%'+#*-+'
(*+6,",*++%-&'%&'"*+C1%-&'(=d&"%'(.8)*-.%+',1'-*D%,1'".B*#-,)'+#1+'),'8#16%'(%+'abS7''
Le$rejet$unanime$d’une$médecine$réglementée$et$administrée,$ouvrant$la$possibilité$de$filières$
de$soins$privant$le$patient$de$son$libre$choix.$$
S,-+'.&1(%'(=*56,8&'(*B-%'(%'8%'-#5;'+,-+'(.<,&'61<)*8'+1"')%'+1$%&;')%'6"#$%&'(%')#*'#64"%'(%+'
89#*>'+&",&.B*C1%+'C1*'-%'+#-&'6,+'8),*"%5%-&'%>6)*8*&.+7''
K%'S3-(*8,&'(%+'/.(%8*-+'K*<.",1>'RS/KT'+#19,*&%'C1%'),'(*+81++*#-'61<)*C1%'6".8*+%')%'"])%'(%'
89,81-' (%+' ,8&%1"+' D*+.+' 6,"' )=,"&*8)%' *-&"#(18&*?' I' N&,&;' )%+' XY' ?1&1"%+' ,B%-8%+' ".B*#-,)%+' (%'
+,-&.;')=,++1",-8%'5,),(*%;'%&')%'"])%'(.D#)1',1>',++1"%1"+'8#56).5%-&,*"%+7''
fL’unanimité$ contre$ la$ généralisation$ du$ tiersGpayant,$ sans$ garantie$ de$ paiement$ et$ sans$
garantie$de$fonctionnalité$pour$le$médecin$libéral$
K=,--#-8%' (%' ),' B.-.",)*+,&*#-' (1' &*%"+Q6,3,-&' %+&' (=,1&,-&' 6)1+' 6,",(#>,)%;' C1%' )%+'
6"#?%++*#--%)+'(%'+,-&.;'C1*'6",&*C1%-&')%'&*%"+Q6,3,-&'+#8*,);'#-&'6,"&,B.')#"+'(%+'".1-*#-+'(1'
B"#16%' (%' 8#-8%"&,&*#-;' )%+' -#5<"%1+%+' (*g81)&.+' ,1>C1%)+' *)+' .&,*%-&;' (=#"%+Q%&Q(.$:'
8#-?"#-&.+7'e1&"%;'),'".+#)1&*#-'(%+'8,+'(%'(*+8#-&*-1*&.'(%+'("#*&+'(1'?,*&'(%')=#<)*B,&*#-'(%'
5*+%':'$#1"',--1%))%'(%'),'8,"&%'h*&,)%;'(%'-#-Q6#"&,<*)*&.'(%+'*-?#"5,&*#-+'#1'(1'6"#&#8#)%'aK@'
%-'8,+'(%'89,-B%5%-&'*-&%"Q'".B*5%+;777T;'(%'-#5<"%1+%+'".D*+*#-+'".B)%5%-&,*"%+;'(%D"#-&'d&"%'
D,)*(.%+;',D,-&'C1%'),'6",&*C1%'(1'&*%"+Q6,3,-&'+#*&',66)*C1.%',1>'+#*-+'(*+6%-+.+':'1-'6,&*%-&'
.)*B*<)%':')i,*(%'6#1"'1-%'8#56).5%-&,*"%'+,-&.'RaAST;'(4+'$1*))%&'UWXO7''
a1'-*D%,1'(%+'6,&*%-&+;'(%5,-(%'(%'6".)4D%5%-&'(%+'?",-89*+%+'5.(*8,)%+'(*"%8&%5%-&'+1"')%'
8#56&%'<,-8,*"%7''
• Constitution$de$bases$de$données$
A".,&*#-' (=1-' +3+&45%' -,&*#-,)' (%' (#--.%+' 5.(*8#Q,(5*-*+&",&*D%+' ,3,-&' 6#1"' E-,)*&.'
)=*-?#"5,&*#-'(1'61<)*8'+1"'),'+,-&.;'K%+'+#*-+'%&'),'6"*+%'%-'89,"B%'5.(*8#Q+#8*,)%7'A%+'(#--.%+'
:'8,",8&4"%'6%"+#--%)'*++1%+'(1'+3+&45%'-,&*#-,)'6#1""#-&'d&"%'8#-+1)&.%+'6,"')%+'+%"D*8%+'(%'
)=j&,&;')%+'.&,<)*++%5%-&+'61<)*8+'#1'(%+'#"B,-*+5%+'89,"B.+'(=1-%'5*++*#-'(%'+%"D*8%'61<)*C1%7'
e-'6%1&'*5,B*-%"'C1=%))%+'61*++%-&'d&"%'D%-(1%+777''
M)'3','(#-8'B",-('"*+C1%'C1%')%'+%8"%&'6"#?%++*#--%)'%&'),'+.81"*&.'(%+'(#--.%+'6%"+#--%))%+'(%+'
6,&*%-&+'+#*%-&'(.&#1"-.%+7
Syndicat$des$médecins$libéraux$
UU'"1%'D,1B%),+'VOWXO'!,"*+'
WX'OY'Z['WX'WW'Q')%+5)\)%+5)7#"B
$sur$3 3