©http://agora.qc.ca/Dossiers/Emmanuel_Kant9
Page959sur979
,)(%'+*2+&%'3*)+-*+5(2,*1*2'+$%&'()%<3*+,.2&+-*+'$8()_1*+u.2'%*2+,*+-#%1>8).'%5+
6.'8=()%<3*9+*'+2('.11*2'+,.2&+&*&+%26%,*26*&+&3)+-*&+.6'%/%'8&+<3%+'*2,*2'+7+5.%)*+,*+-.+
,%=2%'8+$31.%2*+32*+)8.-%'8+&.2&+)8&*)/*&9+./*6+>(3)+5%2+-#8'.;-%&&*1*2'+,*+-.+>.%E+
8'*)2*--*@+4.2'+-3%]1F1*+&#*2+*&'+*E>-%<38+6-.%)*1*2'+,.2&+&*&+-*L(2&+,*+>8,.=(=%*@+
"#%1>()'.26*+,*+-.+'$8()%*+,*+-#%1>8).'%5+6.'8=()%<3*+6(11*+;.&*+,*+)85-*E%(2+,.2&+-.+
>)(;-81.'%<3*+.6'3*--*+,*+-.+>.%E+*'+*2+/3*+,#32*+6(*E%&'*26*+>.6%5%<3*+,*+'(3&+-*&+
>*3>-*&+*'+,*+'(3'*&+-*&+63-'3)*&+O&.2&+-*&+6(22('.'%(2&+28=.'%/*&+,*&+>*2&*3)&+
.--*1.2,&U9+,#.3')*&+6$*1%2*1*2'&+-.+5(2'+8=.-*1*2'+.>>.).D')*l+-#%1>8).'%5+6.'8=()%<3*+
&#%1>(&*+'(3G(3)&+,_&+<3#%-+&#.=%'+,*+,85%2%)+32*+2()1*+8'$%<3*+5(2,.1*2'.-*+
,#.>>-%6.'%(2+32%/*)&*--*@+d#*&'+6*+<3#.+;%*2+/3+I@+^%u.'+-()&<3#%-+&#*&'+>)8(663>8+,*+
,85%2%)+-*&+5.6'*3)&+&'.;%-%&.'*3)&+,3+1.)%.=*+,.2&+-*+1(2,*+1(,*)2*@+j*>)*2.2'+-*&+
,%558)*2'&+8-81*2'&+,3+,8;.'+&6%*2'%5%<3*9+%-+).>>*--*+-.+/.-*3)+<3%+5(2,*+*&&*2'%*--*1*2'+
-#8'$%<3*+1(,*)2*+,*+-.+-%;*)'8+*2+)*&>(2&.;%-%'8+l+-.+,%=2%'8+,*+-#F')*+$31.%2+6(11*+
&3G*'+1().-9+6(11*+>*)&(22*9+-.+,%=2%'8+%2'.2=%;-*+,*+6*-3%+<3%9+*2+)8=-.2'+&.+>)(>)*+
6(2,3%'*9+.+-*+>(3/(%)+,#8,%6'*)+-*&+-(%&+,*/.2'+>)8&%,*)+32%/*)&*--*1*2'+7+-.+6(*E%&'*26*+
,#F')*&+$31.%2&+OT\U@+!02+*55*'9+*'+;%*2+<3*+-#$(11*+.=%&&*+6(11*+32+F')*+,*+6$.%)+*'+
,#(&9+%-+2#*&'+>(3)'.2'+>.&+32+%2&')31*2'+,*+-#.);%').%)*+1.%&9+6(25%8+]]+*2+-%;*)'8+*'+*2+
).%&(2+]+7+&.+>)(>)*+)*&>(2&.;%-%'89+%-+*&'+7+-3%]1F1*+&.+>)(>)*+5%2@+!g(3'+F')*+
).%&(22.;-*9+6.>.;-*+,*+,85%2%)+,*&+5%2&9+&*+,%&'%2=3*+,(269+*2+,*)2%*)+)*&&()'9+>.)+&(2+
>)(>)*+6.).6'_)*+,*+5%2+*2+&(%+*'+,*+/(-(2'8+.3'(2(1*9+*'+6#*&'+-7+6*+<3%+6(2&'%'3*+-*+&*2&+
,*+&(2+F')*+1().-N+OTSU@+
+
"#%1>8).'%5+6.'8=()%<3*+*'+-.+)*6(22.%&&.26*+,*+-.+,%=2%'8+,*+-.+>*)&(22*9+<3*-&+<3*+
&(%*2'+-#$(11*+*'+&(2+6$.1>+,#.6'%/%'89+>*3/*2'+F')*+6(2&%,8)8&+6(11*+-*&+,*3E+5.6*&+
,#32*+1F1*+18,.%--*@+"#%1>8).'%5+6.'8=()%<3*+).>>*--*+<3*+-.+,%=2%'8+,*+-.+>*)&(22*+
$31.%2*+*&'+-.+2('%(2+<3%+,(%'+=3%,*)+=828).-*1*2'+-#.6'%(2+$31.%2*@+d#*&'+-.+2('%(2+,*+
-.+!,%=2%'8+5(2,.1*2'.-*+,*+'(3'*&+-*&+,(228*&+2.'3)*--*&+<3%+>()'*2'+*'+*2/%)(22*2'+
-#F')*+$31.%29+6(11*+,*+'(3'*&+-*&+>)(,36'%(2&+2()1.'%/*&+').2&1%&*&+>.)+/(%*+&(6%(]
63-'3)*--*N@+d#*&'+6*+<3%+>*)1*'+7+4.2'+,*+5()13-*)9+,.2&+-.+68-_;)*+&*6(2,*+/*)&%(2+,*+
-#%1>8).'%5+6.'8=()%<3*9+-*+>)%26%>*+5(2,.1*2'.-+,*+-.+6(2,3%'*+,*+-#$(11*9+*2+'.2'+<3*+
>*)&(22*+1().-*9+7+-#8=.),+,*+-3%]1F1*+*'+,*&+.3')*&+$(11*&l+!h=%&+,*+'*--*+&()'*+<3*+
'3+').%'*&+-#$31.2%'8+.3&&%+;%*2+,.2&+'.+>*)&(22*+<3*+,.2&+-.+>*)&(22*+,*+'(3'+.3')*+
'(3G(3)&+*2+1F1*+'*1>&+6(11*+32*+5%2+*'+G.1.%&+&%1>-*1*2'+6(11*+32+1(M*2N+OTmU@+
+
d*''*+%,8*+<3*+'(3'+$(11*+6(2&'%'3*+32*+5%2+*2+&(%9+-%8*+>(3)+2(3&+.3+2(1+,*+4.2'9+)*/F'+
-()&<3#*--*+*&'+&%'38*+>.)+6*)'.%2&+6(11*2'.'*3)&+,.2&+32*+>*)&>*6'%/*+,#./*2%)+O/(%)9+
>.)+*E*1>-*9+j*%2*)+(3+kv)'$-*%2U+32*+=).2,*+%1>()'.26*+>(3)+6*+<3%+6(26*)2*+-.+
&(-%,.)%'8+,*+-.+6(1132.3'8+$31.%2*+OTbU@+0--*+)8>(2,+7+,*&+;*&(%2&+.2'$)(>(-(=%<3*&+
*&&*2'%*-&+*'+(3/)*+-.+/(%*+7+-.+6((>8).'%(2+,*+63-'3)*&+,%558)*2'*&@+!"*+,)(%'+<3*+
)*/*2,%<3*+'(3'+F')*+).%&(22.;-*+6(1>()'*+-.+)*6(22.%&&.26*+,3+1F1*+,)(%'+>(3)+'(3'+
.3')*+F')*+).%&(22.;-*9+&%+-#(2+.,1*'+<3*+'(3&+>3%&&*2'+*E%&'*)+&%13-'.281*2'+*'+6q'*+7+
6q'*+*2+6*''*+<3.-%'8N@+d#*&'+-7+-*+>)%26%>*+,*+)86%>)(6%'8+<3%+*&'+>(&8@+!d*+,*)2%*)+.+,8G79+
&(3&+5()1*+,*+!)_=-*+,#()N9+>)(5(2,81*2'+1.)<389+,*+5.L(2+(3+,#.3')*9+-.+6(2&6%*26*+
1().-*+,*+'(3&+-*&+>*3>-*&N9+*'+%-+&*+')(3/*+5()13-8+*2+'*)1*&+>(&%'%5&+,.2&+-*+f(3/*.3+
g*&'.1*2'l+!h%2&%9+'(3'+6*+<3*+/(3&+,8&%)*H+<3*+-*&+.3')*&+5.&&*2'+>(3)+/(3&9+5.%'*&]-*+
/(3&]1F1*&+>(3)+*3EN+O^.'$%*3+b9+QcU@+
"*+>)86*>'*+,*+>()'8*+32%/*)&*--*+.%2&%+*E>)%18+,.2&+-#(3/).=*+5(2,.1*2'.-+,3+
6$)%&'%.2%&1*9+*2+.66(),+./*6+-*&+.3')*&+=).2,*&+)*-%=%(2&9+>*3'+F')*+5()13-8+7+>*3+>)_&+
6(11*+6*6%+,.2&+-*+-.2=.=*+,*+-.+>$%-(&(>$%*+*3)(>8*22*l+!".+2.'3)*+,*+-#F')*+$31.%29+