Accéder au Média Briefing détaillé

!!Feuille&de&position!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"#$%&'(%!)*+,!
!
La&Commission&prend&le&risque&de&confier&la&transition&énergétique&à&de&
réticents&fournisseurs&d’électricité&&
&&
-%!.*!/#$%&'(%0!12!3#&&4554#/!67(#89%//%!87'14%(2!7/!82:7%;!<%!8(#8#54;4#/5!<%!19=4512;4#/!2>4/!
<?24<%(!1?@6!A!2;;%4/<(%!5%5!#'B%C;4>5!<2/5!1%!C2<(%!<%!1?DCC#(<!<%!E2(45!57(!1%!314&2;F!G%7H!<%!C%5!
8(#8#54;4#/5!<%!19=4512;4#/!I!57(!1%!<9$%1#88%&%/;!<%5!9/%(=4%5!(%/#7$%12'1%5!%;!57(!12!(%<9>4/4;4#/!
<7!&2(CJ9!%7(#89%/!<%!1?91%C;(4C4;9!K!8#7((24%/;!%/!%>>%;!=(2$%&%/;!/74(%!A!12!;(2/54;4#/!9/%(=9;4:7%!
%;!C#/;(24/<(%!1?2C;4#/!<%!1?@6!57(!1%!CJ2/=%&%/;!C14&2;4:7%F!!
!
Winter&(package)&is&coming&&
-%!82:7%;!<?J4$%(!<%!12!3#&&4554#/!2!8#7(!'7;!<%!5#7;%/4(!1%5!%>>#(;5!<%!1?@6!8#7(!14&4;%(!1%!
<9(L=1%&%/;!C14&2;4:7%!A!+FMN30!C#&&%!C#/$%/7!A!12!3OE)+!A!E2(45F!G?4C4!)*.*0!1?@6!5?%5;!%/=2=9%!A!
(9<74(%!5%5!9&4554#/5!<%!C2('#/%!<?27!&#4/5!P*Q0!A!27=&%/;%(!52!82(;!<?9/%(=4%5!(%/#7$%12'1%5!
B75:7?A!27!&#4/5!)RQ!%;!A!2&914#(%(!1?%>>4C2C4;9!9/%(=9;4:7%!<?27!&#4/5!)RQF!3%5!#'B%C;4>5!<%!1?@6!
5#/;!1#4/!<?S;(%!57>>452/;5!%;!1%!82:7%;!<?J4$%(!8#7((24%/;!<?27;2/;!8175!(21%/;4(!1%!8(#=(L5!<%!1?@6!$%(5!
7/!5T5;L&%!<?9/%(=4%!8(#8(%F!U#4C4!C#&&%/;!V!
!
• Les&énergies&polluantes&rétribuées&pour&leur&capacité&de&production&(«&capacity&
payments&»)&–&une&garantie&pour&l’industrie&du&charbon&et&du&nucléaire&
-2!3#&&4554#/!5#7;4%/<(2!8(#'2'1%&%/;!1%!&9C2/45&%!/#C4>!<%5!W!C282C4;T!82T&%/;5!X!8#7(!1%5!
9/%(=4%5!>#5541%5!%;!/7C1924(%50!C?%5;KAK<4(%!1%5!57'$%/;4#/5!8#7(!1%5!>#7(/455%7(5!<?91%C;(4C4;90!2>4/!
:7?415!87455%/;!C#/;4/7%(!A!>24(%!>#/C;4#//%(0!;2/;!'4%/!:7%!&210!1%5!C%/;(21%5!#89(2;4#//%11%5!<%!
CJ2('#/0!<%!/7C1924(%!%;!<%!=2YF!3%5!C%/;(21%5!5#/;!C#/54<9(9%5!C#&&%!<%5!4/5;2112;4#/5!'2CZK78!27H!
(%/#7$%12'1%50!8#7(!1%5!&#&%/;5!#[!C%11%5KC4!5#/;!<2/5!1?4/C282C4;9!<%!8(#<74(%!57>>452&&%/;!
<?91%C;(4C4;9F!3%8%/<2/;0!%/!(9214;90!1?@6!2!'%27C#78!;(#8!<%!$4%411%5!C%/;(21%5!8#1172/;%5!:74!
%&8SCJ%/;!<%!/#7$%27H!4/$%5;455%&%/;5!<2/5!1%5!(%/#7$%12'1%5F!-%5!W!C282C4;T!82T&%/;5!X!
8%(89;7%(#/;!C%;;%!57(C282C4;9!27!<9;(4&%/;!<%5!4/<4$4<75!%;!<%5!C##89(2;4$%5!5#7J24;2/;!4/$%5;4(!
<2/5!1%5!(%/#7$%12'1%5F!
!
• La&priorité&aux&renouvelables&dans&le&réseau&électrique&risque&d’être&abandonnée&&
-2!3#&&4554#/!$%7;!2'2/<#//%(!7/%!(L=1%!%H45;2/;%!:74!5;4871%!:7%!1%5!(%/#7$%12'1%5!<#4$%/;!S;(%!12!
8(4#(4;9!<2/5!1%!(95%27!91%C;(4:7%!%;!:7%!1?9/%(=4%!<#4;!<?2'#(<!S;(%!8(45%!$42!C%5!5#7(C%5!1A!2$2/;!<%!
<?S;(%!8(45%5!<%5!C%/;(21%5!A!CJ2('#/!%;!/7C1924(%5F!\4!C%;;%!8(4#(4;9!%5;!5788(4&9%0!1%5!9#14%//%5!
8#7((24%/;!>(9:7%&&%/;!S;(%!&45%5!%/!2((S;!8#7(!>24(%!812C%!A!1?9/%(=4%!8(#$%/2/;!<7!CJ2('#/!%;!<7!
/7C1924(%F!6/!%>>%;0!1%5!#89(2;%7(5!<7!(95%27!91%C;(4:7%!<9C4<%/;!:7%11%5!C%/;(21%5!91%C;(4:7%5!<#4$%/;!
S;(%!&45%5!A!1?2((S;!%/!C25!<%!57(8(#<7C;4#/F!E#7(!%7H0!41!%5;!21#(5!8175!>2C41%!<%!54&81%&%/;!&%;;(%!A!
1?2((S;!1%5!(%/#7$%12'1%50!'%27C#78!8175!>1%H4'1%5!:7%!1%5!C%/;(21%5!A!CJ2('#/!%;!/7C1924(%50!:7%!
<?4/$%5;4(!<2/5!1?2&914#(2;4#/!%;!12!>1%H4'41452;4#/!<7!(95%27!91%C;(4:7%F!]S&%!54!1%5!8(#<7C;%7(5!<%5!
(%/#7$%12'1%5!#';4%//%/;!7/%!C#&8%/52;4#/!>4/2/C4L(%!8#7(!1%7(5!C#787(%50!C%;;%!C#&8%/52;4#/!/%!
^2(2!3#//#11T0!CJ2(=9%!<%!32&82=/%!6/%(=4%!A!_(%%/8%2C%!67(#8%2/!@/4;0!2!<9C12(9!V!«"La"
Commission"semble"déterminée"à"mettre"la"transition"énergétique"entre"les"mains"des"mêmes"
fournisseurs"d’électricité"qui"depuis"des"décennies"font"du"lobbying"contre"les"renouvelables."C’est"
scandaleux"de"plafonner"la"taille"des"coopératives"énergétiques"et"de"biaiser"l’accès"au"marché"au"
profit"des"inflexibles"géants"de"l’industrie"fossile.""L’Europe"ne"sera"pas"à"la"hauteur"de"sa"
responsabilité"climatique"tant"qu’elle"ne"permettra"pas"à"ses"citoyens"d’accélérer"la"transition"vers"
du"100%"renouvelables"».""
!

<#4;!825!5%!57'5;4;7%(!A!<2$2/;2=%!<%!(%/#7$%12'1%5!57(!1%!&2(CJ9F!-2!8(#8(%!2/21T5%!<%!12!
3#&&4554#/!&#/;(%!:7%!5788(4&%(!12!<45;(4'7;4#/!8(4#(4;24(%!<%5!(%/#7$%12'1%5!27=&%/;%(2!<%!+*Q!
1%5!9&4554#/5!<%!C2('#/%!45575!<%!12!8(#<7C;4#/!9/%(=9;4:7%F!!
!
• Concurrence&déloyale&(appels&d’offres)&
-%5!8(#8#54;4#/5!<%!19=4512;4#/!8(914&4/24(%5!#/;!&#/;(9!:7%!1%5!&9C2/45&%5!<%!5#7;4%/!8#7(!1%5!
9/%(=4%5!(%/#7$%12'1%5!5#/;!575C%8;4'1%5!<?S;(%!&#<4>495!8#7(!52;45>24(%!27H!4/;9(S;5!<%5!=(2/<5!
>#7(/455%7(5!<?91%C;(4C4;9!;#7;!%/!(%/<2/;!8175!<4>>4C41%!8#7(!1%5!8(#B%;5!9/%(=9;4:7%5!<%!8%;4;%!;2411%!
C#&&%!1%5!C##89(2;4$%50!<?#';%/4(!<%5!57'$%/;4#/5F!-2!3#&&4554#/!2!8(#8#59!:7%!8(%5:7%!;#75!1%5!
8(#B%;5!(%/#7$%12'1%5!5#4%/;!%/!C#&89;4;4#/!1%5!7/5!2$%C!1%5!27;(%5!8#7(!(98#/<(%!27H!288%15!
<?#>>(%5!2>4/!<?#';%/4(!1%5!57'$%/;4#/5F!-%!5%71!>2C;%7(!<9;%(&4/2/;!8#7(!#';%/4(!<%5!57'$%/;4#/5!
5%(24;!1%!8(4H!<%!1?91%C;(4C4;9!8(#<74;%!82(!1%!8(#B%;F!G2/5!12!81782(;!<%5!C250!1%5!>#7(/455%7(5!
<?91%C;(4C4;9!8#7((24%/;!>24(%!7/%!&%411%7(%!#>>(%!27!/4$%27!<7!8(4H!:7%!1%5!8(#B%;5!<%!8%;4;%!;2411%F!-%5!
'9/9>4C%5!<4(%C;5!`>4/2/C4%(50!5#C427H!%;!%/$4(#//%&%/;27Ha!<%5!8(#B%;5!1#C27H!%;!<%!8(#H4&4;9!/%!
5%(24%/;!825!8(45!%/!C#&8;%F!-2!$%(54#/!12!8175!(9C%/;%!<%!12!8(#8#54;4#/!8%(&%;!27H!9;2;5!&%&'(%5!
<%!8(%/<(%!%/!C#&8;%!1%5!'%5#4/5!<%5!C##89(2;4$%5!<2/5!12!<9>4/4;4#/!<%5!&9C2/45&%5!<%!5#7;4%/!
&245!/%!>#7(/4;!825!<%!C1275%5!<9;24119%5F!b1!(%$4%/<(24;!21#(5!A!12!G_!<%!12!3#&89;4;4#/!<%!<9C4<%(!82(!
28(L5!<%5!(L=1%5!<9;24119%5F!-%5!288%15!<?#>>(%5!:7%!8(4$419=4%!12!G_!<%!12!3#&89;4;4#/!8#7((24%/;!<%!
>24;!%HC17(%!<%5!&9C2/45&%5!<%!5#7;4%/!1%5!8%;4;5!2C;%7(5!;%15!1%5!C##89(2;4$%50!:7%!12!G_!<%!12!
3#&89;4;4#/!5#75K%5;4&%F!!
!
• Contrôle&maintenu&par&les&grandes&entreprises&sur&le&réseau&électrique&
-2!3#&&4554#/!8(9$#4;!<%!(%/>#(C%(!1%!C#/;(c1%!<%5!>#7(/455%7(5!<?91%C;(4C4;9!57(!1%!(95%27!<%!
<45;(4'7;4#/!<?91%C;(4C4;9!%;!57(!1%5!(L=1%5!:74!1%!=#7$%(/%!%/!C(92/;!7/!/#7$%1!#(=2/%!<%5!%H81#4;2/;5!
1#C27H!<7!(95%27!91%C;(4:7%F!d%27C#78!<%!C%5!%H81#4;2/;5!5#/;!<9;%/75!82(!<%5!>#7(/455%7(5!
<?91%C;(4C4;9F!-?#(=2/%!%/!:7%5;4#/!27(2!1%!8#7$#4(!<%!812/4>4C2;4#/!<7!(95%27!91%C;(4:7%!%;!<?9C(4;7(%!
<%!C%!:7?#/!288%11%!1%5!W!C#<%5!<7!(95%27!XF!!3%8%/<2/;0!12!3#&&4554#/!/?2!825!%H4=9!:7%!C%5!
>#7(/455%7(5!<?91%C;(4C4;9!$%/<%/;!1%7(!82(;!<%5!(95%27H!<%!<45;(4'7;4#/F!3%C4!C(9%!7/!C#/>14;!<?4/;9(S;!
%;!(%&%;!%/!:7%5;4#/!1?4/<98%/<2/C%!%;!12!/%7;(214;9!<%!12!=%5;4#/!1#C21%!<%5!(95%27H!91%C;(4:7%5F!
!
• La&Commission&européenne&met&des&barrières&au&«&people&power&»&&
-%!82:7%;!<?J4$%(!<%$(24;!27554!4/C17(%!:7%1:7%5!919&%/;5!8#54;4>50!4/C172/;!1%!<(#4;!<#//9!27H!
C4;#T%/5!<%!8(#<74(%0!<%!C#/5#&&%(!%;!<%!5;#CZ%(!1%7(!8(#8(%!9/%(=4%0!&245!27554!<%!12!$%/<(%!27!
(95%27!91%C;(4:7%F!3%C4!#7$(4(24;!12!8#(;%!A!<%5!&4114#/5!<%!8%(5#//%5!:74!8#7((24%/;!<%$%/4(!2C;4>5!57(!
1%!&2(CJ9!<2/5!<%5!82T5!C#&&%!1?6582=/%!:740!8#7(!1?4/5;2/;0!(%5;(%4/;!1?27;#8(#<7C;4#/F!3%12!
%/C#7(2=%(24;!12!82(;4C482;4#/!<%5!W!C4;#T%/5K9/%(=4%!X!A!12!;(2/54;4#/!9/%(=9;4:7%F!3%8%/<2/;0!12!
3#&&4554#/!$%7;!14&4;%(!1%!8#;%/;4%1!<%5!C##89(2;4$%5!9/%(=9;4:7%5!%/!812>#//2/;!1%7(5!8(#B%;5!A!7/%!
&#T%//%!<%!+e]f!82(!2/F!!3%C4!8#7((24;!59(4%75%&%/;!8#(;%(!8(9B7<4C%!27!8#;%/;4%1!<%5!
C##89(2;4$%5!9/%(=9;4:7%5!<%!<%$%/4(!<%5!2C;%7(5!&2B%7(5!<7!&2(CJ9!<%!1?9/%(=4%!<%!1?67(#8%F!!
!
«&CitoyensIEnergie&»&
G#//%(!1%!8#7$#4(!27H!>2&411%5!%;!27H!C#&&7/27;95!<%!8(#<74(%!1%7(!8(#8(%!9/%(=4%!(%/#7$%12'1%!
>%(24;!82(;4C48%(!<%5!&4114#/5!<%!8%(5#//%5!<2/5!12!17;;%!C#/;(%!1%!CJ2/=%&%/;!C14&2;4:7%F!-%5!=%/5!5%!
5%/;4(24%/;!8175!4&814:795!<2/5!1?27;#8(#<7C;4#/!<%!1?9/%(=4%!C%!:74!(%/<(24;!1%!&2(CJ9!8175!
<9&#C(2;4:7%F!@/%!8175!=(2/<%!82(;4C482;4#/!<7!87'14C!A!12!;(2/54;4#/!9/%(=9;4:7%!(%/>#(C%(24;!1%!
5#7;4%/!8#7(!1%5!(%/#7$%12'1%5!%;!1?2C;4#/!C14&2;4:7%F!3%12!<9'1#:7%(24;!<%5!&41142(<5!<?%7(#5!
<?4/$%5;455%&%/;!A!;(2$%(5!1?67(#8%0!82(;4C714L(%&%/;!<2/5!1%5!9C#/#&4%5!1#C21%50!(%/<(24;!1%5!=%/5!
&#4/5!<98%/<2/;5!<%5!>#7(/455%7(5!<?91%C;(4C4;9!%;!(9<74(24;!1%7(5!>2C;7(%5!<?91%C;(4C4;9F!!
!

3#/;(4'7;4#/!<%5!W!C4;#T%/5K9/%(=4%!X!A!1?#'B%C;4>!)*.*!<%!1?@6!
)gQ!
.,Q!
P.Q!
M*Q!
MQ!
+*Q! +PQ!
+gQ!
*Q!
+*Q!
)*Q!
.*Q!
P*Q!
M*Q!
,*Q!
)*+M! )*)*! )*)M! )*.*!
E(#B%Ch#/!<%!12!82(;!<%!1?91%C;(4C4;9!8(#$%/2/;!<%5!(%/#7$%12'1%5!<2/5!
1%!C2<(%!<%!1?#'B%Ch>!(%/#7$%12'1%5!)*.*!
E(#B%Ch#/!<%!1?91%C;(4C4;9!8(#$%/2/;!<%5!W!C4;#T%/5K9/%(=4%!X!
3J2:7%!W!C4;#T%/K9/%(=4%!X!8#7((24;!C#/;(4'7%(!
/%!5%(24;KC%!:7%!8%70!&245!;#75!%/5%&'1%!
8%7$%/;!B#7%(!7/!=(2/<!(c1%!<2/5!12!;(2/54;4#/!
$%(5!1?9/%(=4%!8(#8(%F!@/!(9C%/;!(288#(;!<%!36!
G%1>;!2!&#/;(9!:7%!8175!<%!++)!&4114#/5!<%!
W!C4;#T%/5K9/%(=4%!X!8#7((24%/;!52;45>24(%!+gQ!
<%!12!<%&2/<%!<?91%C;(4C4;9!%/!67(#8%!<?4C4!
)*.*F!G?4C4!)*M*0!8175!<%!),P!&4114#/5!<%!
C4;#T%/5!%7(#89%/50!5#4;!12!&#4;49!<%5!C4;#T%/5!
<%!1?@/4#/!67(#89%//%0!8#7((24%/;!52;45>24(%!
PMQ!<%!12!<%&2/<%!<?91%C;(4C4;9!<%!1?67(#8%F!
-?@6!%;!1%5!19=4512;%7(5!/2;4#/27H!<#4$%/;!
>#7(/4(!1%5!'#//%5!(L=1%5!%;!4/C4;2;4#/5!8#7(!>24(%!<%!C%;!4&&%/5%!8#;%/;4%1!7/%!(9214;9F!
!
Contact&Greenpeace:&!
Tara&Connolly&3J2(=9%!<%!32&82=/%!6/%(=4%0!_(%%/8%2C%!67(#8%2/!@/4;0!i.)!`*aPRR!Rg!*P!+,!
;2(2FC#//#11Tj=(%%/8%2C%F#(=!!!
Sebastian&Mang&D5545;2/;!3J2(=9%!<%!32&82=/%!6/%(=4%0!_(%%/8%2C%!67(#8%2/!@/4;0!i.)!`*a))R!
P+!g*M!5%'25;42/F&2/=j=(%%/8%2C%F#(=!!
Greenpeace&European&Unit,&bureau&de&presse&i.)!`*a)!)RP!+g++!8(%55<%5ZF%7j=(%%/8%2C%F#(=!!!
3%;;%!>%7411%!<%!8#54;4#/!%5;!27554!<458#/4'1%!57(V!kkkF=(%%/8%2C%F%7!!!!
E#7(!1%5!2C;7214;95!%;!C#&&%/;24(%5!57(!1%5!2>>24(%5!<%!1?@6V!kkkF;k4;;%(FC#&l_(%%/8%2C%6@!!
!