La petite fille de la surface comme figure de la

!"#$%!%&'(")"#*#+%,&%#%)#!(-)%#$%#./(!010./(%#*#(11)#232456789#
):#2#;#274<#*#"!(=%#%>#!%#?(+0(+
79
!
La!petite!fille!de!la!surface!comme!figure!de!la!dissolution!du!
soi!
@AB#C')&+#D"+"D"1#
##
#
#
Abstract#
#
>EFG#ABHFIJK#LMJJMNG#HEK#HBAIKG#ML#HEK#!"#$"%&'(("#HEAH#IAO#PK#LMQOR#HEBMQSEMQH#$KJKQTKUG#)*+',%*&%
-"$."V#GM# AG# HM# @AWK# HEK#NAX#LMB# LQBHEKB#BKLJKIHFMO# MO# @MGGFPJK# JFOYG# PKHNKKO# LKZFOFGZ[G\# AOR#
$KJKQTFAO#HEMQSEH:#]X#AOAJXGFOS#HEK#YKX#IMOIK@HG#ML#)*+',%*&%-"$."V#FH#FG#GEMNO#HEAH#$KJKQTK#IMO5
IK@HQAJFTKG#HEK#!"#$"%&'(("#AG#HEK#LFSQBK#ML#HEK#RFGGMJQHFMO#ML#HEK#GKJLV#IABBFKR#MQH#HEBMQSE#A#IJMGK#
BKARFOS# ML# !KFPOFTV# )FKHTGIEK# AOR# @GXIEMAOAJXGFG:# >EK# !"#$"% &'((";HEK# LKZFOFOK# FG# AIIMBRFOSJX#
IMOGHBQKR#AG#AO#AJKAHMBX#@MFOH#AH# HEK# FOHKBGKIHFMO#ML#@MGGFPJK#NMBJR[G\:#>EFG#FO#HQBO#BKGMOAHKG#
NFHE#!QIK#(BFSABAXUG#@BM^KIH#NFHE#BKG@KIH#HM#GK_QAJ#RFLLKBKOIKV#FO#NEFIE#GEK#IAJJG#Q@MO#LKZFOFGHG#
HM#IBKAHK#IMOIK@HFMOG#ML#HEK#LKZFOFOK#AG#@QBK#RFLLKBKOIKV#OMH#IA@HQBKR#PX#HEK#OAZK#ML#HEK#`AHEKB#
MB#HEK#@AHBFABIEAJ#GXZPMJFI#GXGHKZ:#
#
#
#
$AOG#)*+'/#"%0#%."$.V#JA#@KHFHK#LFJJK#KO#HAOH#aQK#@ABARM_KV#@MFOH#AJbAHMFBKV#aQAGF5IAQGK#
c#AGGQBAOH# JA# @JKFOK# AQHMOMZFK# RK# JdKLLKH# e# [$KJKQTK# 48f8#g# 44f\# RbSASK# JdFRKOHFHb# RQ#
ZMORKV#RQ#IMB@G#KH#RQ#GQ^KHV#KH#@ABIMQBH#HMQHKG#JKG#GbBFKGV#KO#HBAWKBGAOH#RKG#ZMORKG#FO5
IMZ@AHFPJKG:#"FOGFV#KO#GAQHAOH#h#JA#GQBLAIKV#KO#GK#IMOGHFHQAOH#RAOG#JA#GQBLAIKV#aQF#KGH#JA#
RFZKOGFMO#@BM@BK#h#Jd"FiOV#KJJK#GK#GFHQK#h#JA#JFZFHK#RK#JA#IMZ@JbZKOHABFHb#RQ#PMO5GKOG#KH#
RQ#GKOG5IMZZQO:#=KHHK#LFSQBK#RKJKQTFKOOK#RK#JA#@KHFHK#LFJJK#GK#IABAIHbBFGK#RdAPMBR#@AB#JK#
LAFH#RUjHBK#."1#2"#KH#RK#BKGHKB#ObAOZMFOG#'$&3$4'("%g#KJJK#BKJkWK#RK#IKHHK#GK_QAJFGAHFMO#FOA5
IEKWbK#aQF#KGH#@BM@BK#h#JdFOGIBF@HFMO#GK_QKJJK#KJJK5ZjZK:#%O#IK#GKOGV#OMQG#@MQBBFMOG#BA@5
@BMIEKB#$KJKQTK#RK#!QIK#(BFSABAXV#aQF#GMQHFKOH#aQdFJ#OdX#A#aQdQO#GKQJ#GK_K#g#JK#LbZFOFO:#1K5
JMO#(BFSABAXV#JA#GK_QAJFGAHFMO#KGH#JdFOGIBF@HFMO#RQ#GK_K#LbZFOFO#KO#HAOH#aQUM@@MGb#RQ#ZAG5
IQJFO#g#JK#GQ^KH#QOFWKBGKJ:#1FZFJAFBKZKOHV#IEKT#JK#$KJKQTK#RK#)*+'/#"%0#%."$.V#JA#GK_QAJFGA5
HFMO#HMQH#AQHAOH#aQK#JK#JAOSASK#KGH#QOK#M@bBAHFMOV#QO#KLLKH#RK#GQBLAIK#aQF#ZABaQK#JK#GK_K#
LbZFOFO:#!A#@KHFHK#LFJJK#5"67"6."#aQFV#GQFWAOH#JdAOAJXGK#RK#JA#@KBWKBGFHb#RK#`BKQRV#FORFaQK#
PFKO#bWFRKZZKOH#QOK#GK_QAJFHb#FOLAOHFJK#AO5MKRF@FKOOKV#GKZPJK#RMOI#AWMFB#QOK#LMOIHFMO#
GFZFJAFBK#h#IKJJK#RK#c#JA#LbZFOFHb#e#IEKT#!QIK#(BFSABAXV#aQF#ZKH#KO#^KQ#c#QOK#IMOHBARFIHFMO#
@KBLMBZAHFWK#e#KH#BbWkJK#AWKI#JA#@QFGGAOIK#RK#GA#@KBWKBGFHb#JK#WFRK#AQ#IlQB#RK#IK#ZMORK#
RQ#1Q^KH#QOFWKBGKJ;ZAGIQJFO:#=KHHK#c#IMOHBARFIHFMO#@KBLMBZAHFWK#e#KGH#KO#KLLKH#M@bBbK#@AB#
JK#@ABARM_K#aQdMO#A@@KJJK#JA#@KHFHK#LFJJKV#aQF#^MQK#JK#BiJK#RK#aQAGF5IAQGK#RdQOK#RFG^MOIHFMO#
OMO5K_IJQGFWK#GFSOFLFAOH#JA#@KBHK#RK#JUFRKOHFHb#h#JA#LAWKQB#RdQOK#M@bBAHFMO#h#@ABHFB#RK#JA5

!"#$%!%&'(")"#*#+%,&%#%)#!(-)%#$%#./(!010./(%#*#(11)#232456789#
):#2#;#274<#*#"!(=%#%>#!%#?(+0(+
80
aQKJJK#c#IEAaQK#IEMGK#GdMQWBK#h#JdFOLFOF#RKG#@BbRFIAHG#@AB#JKGaQKJJKG#KJJK#@AGGK#e#[FPFR:#g#
633\:#!A#ZjZK#M@bBAHFMOV#WFGAOH#QOK#MQWKBHQBK#h#JdFOLFOF#RKG#@BbRFIAHGV#KGH#AQ#IlQB#RQ#
@BM^KH#Rd(BFSABAXV#aQF#BKWKORFaQK#c#QOK#GK_QAJFHb#@JQBFKJJK#e#@BM@BK#h#JdFZASFOAFBK#LbZF5
OFOV#RK#ZAOFkBK#h#APMBRKB#QOK#ZQJHF@JFIFHb#RK#GK_KG#AQ#GKFO#RK#JA#LKZZK4:#
=EKT#$KJKQTKV#JK#BbIFH#RK#JA#RFG^MOIHFMO#JFPBK#KGH#bSAJKZKOH#QO#@MFOH#RK#IMZZQOFIAHFMO#
KOHBK#)*+'/#"%0#%."$.%KH#)89$4':;0'5"V#ZjZK#GF#JK#GKIMOR#BMZ@H#AWKI#JdA@@BMIEK#@GXIEA5
OAJXHFaQK# AGGQZbK# @AB# JK# @BKZFKBV# @MQB# KO# @BMRQFBK# QOK# IBFHFaQK# FOHKBOK# KH# BbLJbIEFB#
AWKI#BFSQKQB#GQB#JK#BA@@MBH#KOHBK#ZMRK#RK#@BMRQIHFMO#KH#ZMRK#RK#GQP^KIHFWAHFMO:#+KO5
WKBGAOH#JdAOAJXGK#RK#)*+'/#"%0#%."$.V#RAOG#JAaQKJJK#JK#IMZ@JK_K#RK#IAGHBAHFMO#KGH#IKBOb#
IMZZK#RFG^MOIHFMO#JFPBK#KH#OMO5K_IJQGFWKV#)89$4':;0'5"#BbIQGK#JdKOBKSFGHBKZKOH#lRF@FKO#
@QFGaQK# IKJQF5IF# FOHBMRQFH# c#QO# QGASK# K_IJQGFLV# JFZFHAHFLV# ObSAHFL# RK# JA# GXOHEkGK# RFG^MOI5
HFWK#e#[$KJKQTKV#-QAHHABF#48m2#g#86\:#>AORFG#aQKV#RAOG#)*+'/#"%0#%."$.V#$KJKQTK#GMQJFSOK#
JK#BiJK#RQ#@EAJJQG#KO#HAOH#aQK#c#bJbZKOH#@ABARM_AJ#nop#K_IkG#KH#RbLAQH#h#JA#LMFG#e#[$KJKQTK#
48f8#g#2f<\V#ASKOH#RK#JdbHKBOKJ#BKHMQB#M@bBAOH#QOK#RFG^MOIHFMO#JFPBK#aQF#@BMRQFH#QOK#Bb5
GMOAOIK# KOHBK# JKG# GbBFKG# RFWKBSKOHKG# @MGGFPJKGV# RAOG# )89$4':;0'5"V# $KJKQTK# KH# -QAHHABF#
RbIMQ@JKOH#JdbHKBOKJ# BKHMQB#RK#IKH# ASKOH#RK#IAGHBAHFMO# @MQB#aQdFJ# @QFGGK#GdAJJFKB#AWKI# (3%
<3,='$"%0#%02.'6>#$AOG#IKHHK#OMQWKJJK#M@HFaQKV#JA#IAGHBAHFMO#OUAGGQZK#@JQG#JK#BiJK#RK#RFG5
^MOIHFMO#ALLFBZAHFWK#KH#JFPBKV#ZAFG#BKOWMFK#h#JdKOBKSFGHBKZKOH#lRF@FKO#aQF#IBbK#RKG#RFLLb5
BKOHFAHFMOG#GQB#JKG#IiHbG#RK#JA#HBFAOSQJAHFMO#LAZFJFAJK#KH#KGH#BKG@MOGAPJK#RK#JdFOGIBF@HFMO#
PFOAFBK#RK#JA#RFLLbBKOIK#RKG#GK_KG:#!A#RFG^MOIHFMO#JFPBK#ZMPFJFGKBAFHV#AQ#IMOHBAFBKV#JA#LMBIK#
RK#JA#GXOHEkGK#RFG^MOIHFWK#AQ#GKFO#RK#JA#ZAIEFOK#RbGFBAOHKV#KO#ALLFBZAOH#JA#RFGHAOIK#KOHBK#
JKG#HKBZKG#RFWKBSKOHG#KH#KO#RbIJKOIEAOH#JKQBG#RFWFGFMOG#KO#KQ_5ZjZKGV#AQ#JFKQ#RK#JKG#JF5
ZFHKB#PFOAFBKZKOHV#RK#JKG#OFKB#MQ#RK#JKG#K_IJQBK#JdQO#MQ#JdAQHBK:#!dKOBKSFGHBKZKOH#lRF@FKO#
BKOWMFK#RMOI#h#QO#QGASK#FJJbSFHFZK#RK#JA#GXOHEkGK#RFG^MOIHFWKV#JFZFHAOH#O5OMZPBK#RdFRKOHF5
LFIAHFMOG#GK_QKJJKG#WFBHQKJJKG#h#JA#ZAIEFOK#PFOAFBK#RK#JA#GIkOK#RK#ZbOASKV#IMZ@BKOAOH#MQ#
PFKO#RKG#LKZZKG#MQ#PFKO#RKG#EMZZKG:#=UKGH#QO#QGASK#aQF#FORFaQK#AQGGF#c#JUQJHFZK#HKBBFHM5
BFAJFHb#GMQZFGK#KH#@BFWbK#RK#JUEMZZK#KQBM@bKO#e#[$KJKQTKV#-QAHHABF#g#62<562f\:#"FOGFV#JA#
GK_QAJFGAHFMO#KH#JA#BAIFAJFGAHFMO#GUKOHBKIBMFGKOH#g#FJ#GUASFH#RUQOK#M@bBAHFMO#IMJMOFAJK#PFKO#
bHQRFbK#RAOG#JK#IARBK#RQ#LbZFOFGZK#OMFBV#ZAFG#AQGGF#RAOG#JK#IARBK#RKG#AOAJXGKG#IMOIKB5
OAOH# JA# BKJAHFMO# FOHFZK# KOHBK# IA@FHAJFGZK# KH# @AHBFABIEFKV# aQF# GUFOHbBKGGKOH# AQ_# BA@@MBHG#
KOHBK#ZMRK#RK#@BMRQIHFMO#KH#ZMRK#RK#GQP^KIHFWAHFMO:#(
)*+'/#"%0#%."$.V!aQF#GK#@BM@MGK#RK#RbWKJM@@KB#JdFRbK#RdQOK#GQBLAIK#RKG#KLLKHG#FOIMB@M5
BKJG#aQF#BbGQJHKBAFH#RUQOK#@BMLMORKQB#RKG#IAQGKGV#RKG#IMB@G#KH#RK#JKQBG#ZbJAOSKG#HMQH#KO#
OK# IMqOIFRAOH# @AG# IAQGAJKZKOH# AWKI# KJJKV# GdA@@QFK# GQB# JA# OMO5IMZ@AHFPFJFHb# KH# JA# OMO5
IMqOIFRKOIK#RKG#KLLKHG#AWKI#JKQBG#IAQGKGV#RAOG#JK#PQH# RK#BMZ@BK#JA#IEArOK#RK#IAQGAJFHb:#
$KJKQTK#ALLFBZK#FIF#aQdQOK#BKJAHFMO#OK#@KQH#@AG#jHBK#BbRQFHK#h#GKG#HKBZKG#@QFGaQUKJJK#BK5
JkWK# RUQOK# IMZZQOFIAHFMOV# RUQOK# aQAGF5IAQGAJFHb# KOHBK# GKG# KLLKHG:# =KHHK# @MGFHFMO# GKBA#
ARM@HbK#@AB#$KJKQTK#[KH#$KJKQTK#KH#-QAHHABF\#HMQH#AQ#JMOS#RK#GKG#bIBFHG#ZABaQbG#@AB#QO#
IKBHAFO#RQAJFGZK#G@FOMTFGHK:#%O#KLLKHV#IKHHK#ZjZK#JMSFaQK#SMQWKBOKBA#JK#BA@@MBH#KOHBK#JK#
4#=L:#(BFSABAX#48mm#g#2m:#c#!A#LKZZK#OdA#@AG#QO#GK_K:#%JJK#KO#A#AQ#ZMFOG#RKQ_V#ZAFG#FRKOHFLFAPJKG#KO#QO#e:#

!"#$%!%&'(")"#*#+%,&%#%)#!(-)%#$%#./(!010./(%#*#(11)#232456789#
):#2#;#274<#*#"!(=%#%>#!%#?(+0(+
81
ZMRK# RK# @BMRQIHFMO# KH# JdAOHF5@BMRQIHFMO# [.*,'#.\V# RAOG# )89$4':;0'5"V# AQGGF# PFKO# aQK# JK#
IMOIK@H# RdASKOIKZKOH# @BbGKOHb# RAOG# ?'(("% @(34"3#1V# aQF# HMQBOK# AQHMQB# RdQOK# BKJAHFMO#
GFZFJAFBK#KOHBK#JA#LMBZAJFGAHFMO#RK#JdK_@BKGGFMO#KH#IKJJK#RQ#IMOHKOQ:#
!A#HKOHAHFWK#RdAOAJXGKB#JK#GKOG#KO#HAOH#aQdKLLKH#RK#GQBLAIKV#aQF#OK#GdM@@MGK#@AG#AQ#OMO5
GKOGV#ZAFG#GK#ZAFOHFKOH#RAOG#QO#BA@@MBH#@ABARM_AJ#AWKI#JQFV#BK@MGK#GQB#JA#ObIKGGFHb#RdbWF5
HKB# JA# GQ@@MGbK# IMOHBARFIHFMO# KOHBK# GKOG# KH# OMO5GKOGV# ALFO# RdABBFWKB# h# QOK# HEbMBFK#
GUFOG@FBAOH# RQ# @KBG@KIHFWFGZK# OFKHTGIEbKO# KH# IA@APJK# RdK_@JFaQKB# JA# IMZZQOFIAHFMO#
KOHBK#ZMORKG#FOIMZ@AHFPJKGV#RK@QFG#QO#bJbZKOH#@ABARM_AJ#aQF#bIEA@@KBAFH#h#JA#RFG^MOI5
HFMO#K_IJQGFWK#GUM@bBAOH#AQHMQB#RQ#PMO5GKOG#KH#RQ#GKOG5IMZZQO:#&O#HKJ#@KBG@KIHFWFGZK#A#
@MQB#PQH#RdK_@JFaQKB#JA#SKOkGK#RK#JUFORFWFRQ#KH#RK#JA#@KBGMOOK#h#@ABHFB#RK#JdFRKOHFHb#RQ#
ZMORK#KH#RQ#IMB@GV#AQGGF#PFKO#aQK#GA#RKGHFHQHFMO#h#IEAaQK#FOGHAOH#@AB#JUbHKBOKJ#BKHMQBV#
aQF#LAFH#IFBIQJKB#JK#@MFOH#@ABARM_AJ#RAOG#HMQHKG#JKG#GbBFKG#KH#HMQG#JKG#ZMORKG#@MGGFPJKGV#KO#
JKG#MQWBAOH#AFOGF#h#JA#OMQWKAQHb#RK#IK#aQF#RFLLkBK#RK#GMF5ZjZK#AQ#IlQB#RdQO#ZMORK#LMO5
Rb#GQB#JUFRKOHFHb#RQ#GQ^KH#KH#RK#GMO#IMB@G:#=dKGH#QOK#@KOGbK#BbWbJAOH#JUALLAPQJAHFMO#@BM@BK#
h#QOK#HKJJK#IMOGHFHQHFMO#FRKOHFHAFBK#g#JdFRKOHFHb#RQ#ZMORKV#RQ#GQ^KH#KH#RQ#IMB@GV#HBARFHFMO5
OKJJKZKOH#AGGQZbKV# GUAWkBK#AFOGF# jHBK#QO# RKWKOFB5FRKOHFHAFBK#RK# IK# aQF#RFWKBSK# @AB#OA5
HQBK:#(J#GdASFH#RdQOK#RKG5FRKOHFLFIAHFMO#aQF#IMqOIFRKV#h#IEAaQK#LMFGV#AWKI#JUFRKOHFLFIAHFMO#AQ5
HMQB#RQ#PMO5GKOG#KH#RQ#GKOG5IMZZQO:#
&OK#HKJJK#RKG5FRKOHFLFIAHFMO#FBAFH#RK#@AFB#AWKI#QOK#RbGK_QAJFGAHFMOV#RAOG#JA#ZKGQBK#Ms#
JA#GK_QAJFHb#GKBAFH#QO#KLLKH#RK#GQBLAIK#GK#@BMRQFGAOH#h#@ABHFB#RdQOK#MBSAOFGAHFMO#RKG#KLLKHG#
RK# @BMLMORKQB# KH# RK# EAQHKQB# M@bBbG# @AB# JUbJbZKOH# @ABARM_AJ# RQ# @EAJJQGV# aQFV# KO# HAOH#
aQdASKOH#RK#IAGHBAHFMO#KH#IAGK#WFRKV#ZAOaQKBAFH#RUQOK#FRKOHFHb#@BM@BKV#KH#AIHQAJFGKBAFH#JA#
BbGMOAOIK#KOHBK#RKQ_#GbBFKG#EbHbBMSkOKG#h#HBAWKBG#JK#@BMIKGGQG#RQ#@EAOHAGZK:#!A#IAGHBA5
HFMO#^MQKBAFH#AFOGF#JK#BiJK#RK#(A'$.4'$,4%0"%<*64B%aQF#KGH#IEABSb#*#RK#JA#LMBIK#RK#RKGHFHQHFMO#
RKG# FRKOHFHbG# @BM@BK# h# JUbHKBOKJ# BKHMQBV# IMZZK# JK# BKZABaQAFH# Rb^h# $KJKQTK# RAOG# C'&&2:
6"$,"%"4%D2524'4'*$:#%O#IK#GKOGV#JA#IAGHBAHFMOV#IMOtQK#KO#HKBZKG#RU'$.4'$,4%0"%<*64V#KLLKIHQK#
JA#RFZKOGFMO#GK_QKJJK#KO#ZjZK#HKZ@G#aQdKJJK#RbSASK#QOK#bOKBSFK#RbGK_QAJFGbK:#
!A#@KHFHK#LFJJKV#@KBGMOOFLFbK#RAOG#JA#LFSQBK#Rd"JFIK#RK#!KNFG#=ABBMJJV#GK#GFHQK#RAOG#JA#RF5
ZKOGFMO#RK#JA#GQBLAIK#IMZZK#LFSQBK#RK#JA#RFGGMJQHFMO#RQ#GMFV#GMQZFGK#h#IEAaQK#FOGHAOH#h#
IK# @BMIKGGQG# RUFRKOHFLFIAHFMO# KH# RKG5FRKOHFLFIAHFMOV# GK_QAJFGAHFMO# KH# Rb5GK_QAJFGAHFMOV#
c#GAQHAOH#RdQOK#GQBLAIK#h#JdAQHBK#e#[$KJKQTK#48f8#g#2m9\:#uQMFaQK#IKJA#OK#GMFH#@AG#MQWKB5
HKZKOH#RbLKORQ#@AB#$KJKQTK#RAOG#)*+'/#"%0#%."$.V#FJ#GKBAFH#@KBHFOKOH#RK#GQSSbBKB#aQUFIFV#
HMQH#IMZZK#IEKT#!QIK#(BFSABAX#KH#?MOFaQK#vFHHFSV#FJ#OdX#A#aQdQO#GKQJ#GK_K#g#JK#LbZFOFOV#IAB#
JK#GK_K#ZAGIQJFO#BKOWKBBAFH#AQ#1Q^KH#QOFWKBGKJ#RQ#GKOG5IMZZQO:#%O#ZABaQAOH#JK#HBAIb#RQ#
GK_K#KH#GMQZFGKV#RkG#JMBGV#h#JA#LMBIK#RK#RKGHFHQHFMO#RK#JUbHKBOKJ#BKHMQB#@BM@BK#h#JA#IAGHBA5
HFMOV#JA#@KHFHK#LFJJK#A#JA#IA@AIFHb#RUKLLAIKB#JA#@BbHKORQK#FRKOHFHb#RQ#1Q^KH#QOFWKBGKJ#AWKI#JK#
ZMORK#KH#JK#IMB@G:#%O#@MBHAOH#KO#GMF#JA#HBAIK#RQ#@EAJJQGV#KJJK#BKOR#@MGGFPJK#(3%62.*$3$,"#
KOHBK# JA# GK_QAJFHb# @Bb5SbOFHAJK# KH# JK# c#BAIIMBRKZKOH# @EAJJFaQK# RKG# TMOKG# bBMSkOKG#e#
[FPFR:#g#2f2\V# aQF# RMOOK# JFKQ# h# JUbWbOKZKOH#RAOG# GA# RFLLbBKOIK# AWKI# IKG#RKQ_# GbBFKG:# %O#
HAOH# aQdMP^KH# GK_QKJ# RK# JdABHFGHK# @KBWKBG# [WMFBKV# ?MOFaQK# vFHHFS# aQF# LAFH# HMQHK# GMBHK# RK#

!"#$%!%&'(")"#*#+%,&%#%)#!(-)%#$%#./(!010./(%#*#(11)#232456789#
):#2#;#274<#*#"!(=%#%>#!%#?(+0(+
82
GAQHG#KOHBK#GQBLAIKG#RFLLbBKOHKG\V#JA#LFSQBK#RK#JA#@KHFHK#LFJJK#FORFaQK#aQK#JK#GKQJ#PQH#RQ#GAQH#
h#JA#GQBLAIK#KGH#RUbWMaQKB#IKH#bWbOKZKOH:#
?AFOHKOAOHV#FJ# GUASFBA#RUA@@BMLMORFB#JdAOAJXGK# RKJKQTFKOOK#RK# JA#@BMRQIHFMO# RQ#GKOGV#
RAOG#GMO#BA@@MBH#AQ#OMO5GKOGV#KH#RQ#@BMIKGGQG#RUFORFWFRQAHFMO#h#@ABHFB#RK#JdKLLKIHQAHFMO#
KH#RK#JA#IMOHBK5KLLKIHQAHFMOV#ALFO#RK#ZFKQ_#IMZ@BKORBK#JK#@KBG@KIHFWFGZK#aQF#M@kBK#RAOG#
)*+'/#"%0#%."$.:#
#
#
Le(cercle(de(proposition(ou(un(Cratyle(dédoublé#
#
$AOG# )*+'/#"% 0#% ."$.V%$KJKQTK# GUFOHbBKGGK#h# JA# aQKGHFMO# GHMqIFKOOK# IMOIKBOAOH#
JUbZKBSKOIK#RQ#GKOG#h#@ABHFB#RdQO#IKBHAFO#BA@@MBHV#MQ#PFKO#RUQOK#IMZZQOFIAHFMOV#KOHBK#
JKG#bWbOKZKOHGV#aQF#GMOH#IMOtQG#IMZZK#RKG#KLLKHG#FOIMB@MBKJG#RbBFWAOH#RK#JKQBG#IAQGKG#
IMB@MBKJJKG:#(IFV#JKG#RKQ_#GbBFKGV#h#GAWMFB#JKG#IMB@G#AWKI#JKQBG#ZbJAOSKG#KH#JKG#KLLKHG#FOIMB5
@MBKJGV#MOH#QO#BA@@MBH#G@bIFLFaQKV#aQK#$KJKQTK#RbLFOFH#IMZZK#c#QO#IJFWASK#HMQH#OMQWKAQ#
RK# JA# BKJAHFMO# IAQGAJK#e# [FPFR:#g# 4<\:# !KG# IMB@GV# h# IiHb# RKG# IAQGKG# KH# RK# JKQBG# KLLKHGV# aQF#
ASFGGKOH#RAOG# HMQHK# AQHBK#GbBFK# KH# HKZ@MBAJFHbV# RMOOKOH#AQ_#1HMqIFKOG# JA# LMBIK# FOHKJJKI5
HQKJJK#RK#@KOGKB#h#JU'$&'$'4'&#RKG#RKWKOFBG#h#JA#GQBLAIKV#RMZAFOK#RKG#aQAGF5IAQGKG#KOHBK#KL5
LKHG#FOIMB@MBKJG:#=KHHK#LMBIK#FOHKJJKIHQKJJK#WFGAOH#IK#aQF#KGH#KO#^KQ#RAOG#JA#@BM@MGFHFMOV#OK#
GK#IMOHKOHK#@AG#RK#IKBOKB#JKG#HBMFG#BA@@MBHG#aQF#FOHKBWFKOOKOH#RAOG#IK#IARBKV#h#GAWMFB#JA#
RbGFSOAHFMO#KO#HAOH#aQK#BA@@MBH#RK#JA#@BM@MGFHFMO#AWKI#JKG#bHAHG#RKG#IEMGKG#[c#JdbJbZKOH#
RK#WBAF#KH#LAQ_#e#FPFR:#g#26\V#JA#ZAOFLKGHAHFMO#KO#HAOH#aQK#BA@@MBH#AWKI#JK#GQ^KH#aQF#@ABJK#
[c#JdbJbZKOH# RK# JA# WbBAIFHb# KH# JA# HBMZ@KBFK#e# FPFR:#g# 23\# KH# JA# GFSOFLFIAHFMO# KO# HAOH# aQK#
c#BA@@MBH#RQ#ZMH#AWKI#RKG#IMOIK@HG#QOFWKBGKJG#KH#SbObBAQ_#e#[FPFR:#g#2<\#[c#JA#IMORFHFMO#
RK#WbBFHb#e#'E'0"<\:#!A#aQKGHFMO#RK#GAWMFB#Ms#BbGFRK#JK#GKOG#OMQG#ZkOK#AQ#IMOHBAFBK#h#JA#
IFBIQJABFHb# @BM@BK# h# JA# @BM@MGFHFMO#g# JKG# HBMFG# bJbZKOHG# BKOWMFKOH# KJJF@HFaQKZKOH# JdQO# h#
JdAQHBK:#!K#GKOG#OK#@KQH#@AG#BbGFRKB#RAOG#JA#RbGFSOAHFMOV#@QFGaQK#JdAGGFSOAHFMO#RQ#WBAF#KH#
RQ#LAQ_#@BbGQ@@MGK#Rb^h#QOK#IMBBKG@MORAOIK#KOHBK#JKG#ZMHG#KH#JKG#IEMGKG#[FPFR:#g#29\V#aQF#
OK#@KQH#jHBK#bHAPJFKV#IMZZK#JK#RFH#1MIBAHK#RAOG#)"%F634G("V#aQK#@AB#JA#SABAOHFK#RQ#RFKQ:#!K#
wK#RK#JA#ZAOFLKGHAHFMO#MQ#RK#JdMBRBK#RK#JA#@ABMJK#OK#@KQH#@AG#OMO#@JQG#jHBK#JK#RMZAFOK#Ms#
BbGFRK#JK#GKOGV#@QFGaQK#JK#wK#@BbGQ@@MGK#Rb^h#c#RKG#GFSOFLFIAHFMOG#aQF#RMFWKOH#jHBK#RbWK5
JM@@bKG#@MQB#KJJKG5ZjZKG#RAOG#JdMBRBK#RK#JA#JAOSQK#e#[FPFR:#g#28\:#!dFRKOHFHb#@KBGMOOKJJK#
OK#@BbIkRK#@AG#JUMBRBK#RK#GFSOFLFIAHFMOV#ZAFG#Rb@KOR#RK#JQF:#%O#BKWAOIEKV#JA#GFSOFLFIAHFMOV#
KO# HAOH# aQK# IMORFHFMO# RK# WbBFHb# KH# LMORKZKOHV# RMFH# AWMFB# QO# BA@@MBH# RFGHFOIH# AWKI# IK#
aQdKJJK#LMORKV#@MQB#bIEA@@KB#AQ#RAOSKB#RK#OUjHBK#aQK#c#JA#GFZ@JK#LMBZK#RK#@MGGFPFJFHb#RK#
JA#@BM@MGFHFMO#ZjZK#e#['E'0"<\:#(J#LAQH#aQdFJ#X#AFH#QOK#RFLLbBKOIK#RK#OAHQBK#KOHBK#JA#IMORF5
HFMO#KH#JK#IMORFHFMOOb:#0O#RKWBAFH#@KQH5jHBK#@BKORBK#@JQG#AQ#GbBFKQ_#JK#ZXHEK#RKG#RKQ_#
=BAHXJK#[WbBFLFKB#GF#=BAHXJK#GUbIBFH#AQ#@JQBFKJ\V#aQF#FZ@JFaQK#QO#RbRMQPJKZKOH#RAOG#JdMP^KH#
RK#JA#RbGFSOAHFMOV#QO#GAQH#WKBG#QOK#GbBFK#aQF#RFLLkBK#@AB#OAHQBK#RK#JA#GbBFK#RKG#IEMGKG#g#QO#
=BAHXJK#h#IMHb#RKG#IEMGKG#KH#QO#AQHBK#h#JA#GQBLAIK#RQ#JAOSASK:#=K#OUKGH#RMOI#@AG#bHMOOAOH#

!"#$%!%&'(")"#*#+%,&%#%)#!(-)%#$%#./(!010./(%#*#(11)#232456789#
):#2#;#274<#*#"!(=%#%>#!%#?(+0(+
83
aQK#1MIBAHK#KO#A@@KJJK#AQ#RFKQ#@MQB#GAQWKB#JUFOHbSBFHb#IMB@MBKJJK#KH#JdFRKOHFHb#@KBGMOOKJJK#
RK#=BAHXJK:#%O#GUA@@QXAOH#GQB#JUAOAJXGK#RK#JUbHKBOKJ#BKHMQB#RK#DJMGGMNGYFV#$KJKQTK#OMQG#
A@@BKOR#aQK#JK#IKBIJK#RK#JA#@BM@MGFHFMO#LAFH#IFBIQJKB#QO#GQ^KH#FRKOHFaQK#h#GMF5ZjZK#h#@AB5
HFB#RdQOK#RFG^MOIHFMO#K_IJQGFWK#RMOH#JK#ZArHBK#KGH#JK#RFKQV#KH#aQK#JdFRKOHFHb#RQ#GQ^KH#WA#RK#
@AFB# AWKI# JdFRKOHFHb# RQ# ZMORK# KH# RQ# IMB@G:# =K@KORAOHV# IKHHK# RFG^MOIHFMO# OK# IMOGHFHQK#
aQdQOK#@KBGMOOK#AOAJXHFaQK#RQ#ZMORK#RQ#GKOG5IMZZQOV#KH#X#FZ@MGK#QOK#JFZFHAHFMO#RK#
@BbRFIAHFMO:#$AOG#JA#RFG^MOIHFMO#JFPBKV#IMZZK#MO#JK#WKBBAV#JKG#@BbRFIAHG#AGGFSOAPJKG#h#QOK#
IEMGK#GKBMOH#OMO5K_IJQGFLG#KH#FOLFOFG:#!A#RFG^MOIHFMO#JFPBK#GUM@kBK#@AB#QO#bJbZKOH#@ABA5
RM_AJV#QO#c#MIIQ@AOH#GAOG#@JAIK#e#[FPFR:#g#<f\#OF#MBFSFOKV#aQF#@ABIMQBH#HMQHKG#JKG#GbBFKG#Eb5
HbBMSkOKG#ALFO#RdKO#LAFBK#QOK#GXOHEkGK#ZQJHF@JK#HMQH#KO#ZKGQBAOH#JKQB#RFGHAOIK2:#
"LFO# RK# BMZ@BK# AWKI# JK# IKBIJK# RK# JA# @BM@MGFHFMOV# FJ# LAQH# IKBOKB# JK# GKOG# IMZZK# QOK#
c#aQAHBFkZK# RFZKOGFMO#e# [FPFR:#g# 2m\V# QO# bWbOKZKOHV# MQ# c#JdK_@BFZb# RK# JA# @BM@MGFHFMO#e#
[FPFR:#g#67\#RAOG#JA#GQBLAIK#FOIMB@MBKJJKV#KH#JK#OMO5GKOG#IMZZK#IKH#bJbZKOH#@ABARM_AJ:#1M5
IBAHK#GQSSbBAFHV#h#BAFGMOV#aQdQOK#WBAFK#IMBBKG@MORAOIK#KOHBK#JKG#ZMHG#KH#JKG#IEMGKG#FZ5
@JFaQK#QO#RbRMQPJKZKOH#g#QO#=BAHXJK#h#IiHb#RKG#IEMGKG#KH#QO#AQHBK#h#IiHb#RKG#OMZG:#xHA5
PJFB#QOK#RFLLbBKOIK#RK#OAHQBK#KOHBK#JA#GbBFK#RKG#IEMGKG#KH#JA#GbBFK#RKG#OMZG#@BMRQFH#QOK#
bHBAOSK# IMBBKG@MORAOIK# KOHBK# KJJKGV# aQF# LMOIHFMOOK# IMZZK# OMO5IMBBKG@MORAOIK# @Bb5
GQ@@MGAOH# QO# RbRMQPJKZKOH# RQ# GQ^KH:# !KG# RKQ_# GbBFKG# EbHbBMSkOKG# GK# IMBBKG@MORKOH#
AFOGF#JUQOK#JUAQHBK#RAOG#JA#ZKGQBK#Ms#JKG#KLLKHG#FOIMB@MBKJG#RbBFWKOH#RKG#IMB@G#KH#RK#JKQBG#
ZbJAOSKGV#ZAFG#KO#ZjZK#HKZ@G#KJJKG#OK#GK#IMBBKG@MORKOH#@AG#RAOG#JA#ZKGQBK#Ms#JKG#KL5
LKHG#OK#@KQWKOH#@AG#jHBK#BbRQFHG#h#JKQBG#IAQGKG:#,MFIF#JK#RQAJFGZK#BARFIAJ#RKG#1HMqIFKOG#*#
ZFKQ_# RbLFOF# IMZZK# QOK# LBMOHFkBK6#*#aQF# BKOWMFK# AQ# IMOIK@H# RK# c#RFGHAOIK#e# IEKT#
)FKHTGIEK#g#JKG#IEMGKG#h#IiHb#RKG#IEMGKG#KH#JKG#KLLKHG#FOIMB@MBKJG#h#IiHb#RK#IKH#bWbOKZKOH#
QOFaQK#aQdMO#A@@KJJK#JK#GKOG:#
#
#
L'effectuation(:(la(constitution(de(l'individu(et(de(la(personne#
#
&O#HKJ#BA@@MBH#KOHBK#JKG#IEMGKG#KH#JKG#ZMHG#BKOR#@MGGFPJK#QOK#RFGHBFPQHFMO#OMZARFaQK#
RKG#AHHBFPQHG#RKG#IEMGKGV#RAOG#JA#ZKGQBK#Ms#FJ#JFPkBK#RKG#GFOSQJABFHbG#FOHKOGFWKG#RK#JKQB#
IBFGHAJJFGAHFMO#RAOG#JdMBRBK#RQ#PMO5GKOG# KH#RQ#GKOG5IMZZQO:# $AOG#C'&&26"$,"% "4% D2524':
4'*$V#$KJKQTK#ALLFBZK#AWKI#WFSQKQB#aQK#JdFRKOHFHb#OdKGH#aQdQO#@BFOIF@K#GKIMORAFBKV#QO#RK5
WKOFB5FRKOHFHAFBK# RK# RFLLbBKOIK:# =MOLMBZbZKOH# h# IKHHK# FRbKV# RAOG# )*+'/#"% 0#% ."$.B#$K5
JKQTK#RbLFOFH#JK#PMO5GKOG#IMZZK#JUMBRBK#RK#JA#RFGHBFPQHFMO#LF_K#KH#GbRKOHAFBK3#aQF#MBSAOFGK#
JA#RFWKBGFHb#AQHMQB#RdQOK#GKQJK#RFBKIHFMOV#KH#JK#GKOG5IMZZQO#IMZZK#JUMBSAOK#BA@@MBHAOH#
2#=L:#FPFR:#g#96#g#c#nop#IKH#bJbZKOH#@ABARM_AJV#5"65"4##<%<*E'(KV#KHI:#g#FJ#A#@MQB#LMOIHFMO#RK#@ABIMQBFB#JKG#
GbBFKG#EbHbBMSkOKGV#KH#RdQOK#@ABH#RK#JKG#IMMBRMOOKBV#RK#JKG#LAFBK#BbGMOOKB#KH#IMOWKBSKBV#RdAQHBK#@ABH#RK#
JKG#BAZFLFKBV#RdFOHBMRQFBK#KO#IEAIQOK#RdKJJKG#RKG#RFG^MOIHFMOG#ZQJHF@JKG#e:#
6#=L:# FPFR:# g# 6m#g# c#!KG# IEMGKG# KH# JKG# @BM@MGFHFMOG# GMOH# ZMFOG# RAOG# QOK# RQAJFHb# BARFIAJK# aQK# RK# @ABH# KH#
RdAQHBK#RdQOK#LBMOHFkBK#BK@BbGKOHbK#@AB#JK#GKOG#e:#
3#=L:#FPFR:#g#86#g#c#0B#JK#PMO#GKOG#GK#RFH#RdQOK#RFBKIHFMO#g#FJ#KGH#GKOG#QOFaQKV#FJ#K_@BFZK#JdK_FSKOIK#RdQO#MBRBK#
RUA@BkG#JKaQKJ#FJ#LAQH#IEMFGFB#QOK#RFBKIHFMO#KH#GdKO#HKOFB#h#KJJK#e:#