1 Nicolas Gérard Vaillant

1
!
!"#$%&'()*+&+,(-&"%%&./(
!
"#!$%!&!'()'*+%!,-..!/!0'123456%!7&-!869:!
!!!!;'()%<+!=;>!%6!?('6'13%!
!!!!;3+%()%<+!@%!+%(A%+(A%!@%9!B63C%+93)#9!08)A'$3D<%9!
!!!!;3+%()%<+!@%!?E=F0G!H!?I!.JJK!
!!!!L3(%MN+#93@%6)! C3(%M>%()%<+! 7+%(A%+(A%:! @%! $OB63C%+93)#!
08)A'$3D<%!@%!P3$$%!!
!!!!L3(%M>%()%<+!%6!(A8+5%!@<!9%()%<+!986)#!M!9'(3#)#!
!!!!!!!!!!!!Février!2017!
!
I@+%99%!FGE0!
I@+%99%!Institut!Catholique!de!Lille!
!
Q,R!*'<$%C8+@!L8<*86!
,%+!#)85%!
S-TTT!P3$$%!
KT*39R!+<%!@<!N'+)!7>G:!
0G!JT,T-!
S-T,K!P3$$%!(%@%U!
E%$V!W&&7T:!&XT!,&J!.X-!
Y8UV!W&&7T:!&XT!,&J!T.T!
."#$%&'01&"%%&./23."14#&/5$%"%%607+!
!
!
89:;<;9!(=<(>9!?<;9!:(@?<A=BB=:(
(
CDEFG4( L3(%M>%()%<+!%6!(A8+5%!@<!9%()%<+!986)#!H!9'(3#)#!
CDEHG4( ;3+%()%<+!@%!?E=F0G!H!?I!.JJK!
CDEIG4( ;3+%()%<+!@%!+%(A%+(A%!@%9!B63C%+93)#9!08)A'$3D<%9!!
(;3+%()%<+!@%!$8!Z839'6!@%9!0A%+(A%<+9!@%!$OF69)3)<)!08)A'$3D<%!@%!P3$$%!
(;3+%()%<+!@<!P8*'+8)'3+%!@OI6)A+'2'$'53%!?U2#+31%6)8$%!
CDEJG4!>%92'698*$%! @%! $8! (A83+%! @%! +%(A%+(A%! COMMITMENT! -! COMmunication! CIToyenne,! MEdias,! opiNions! et!
Technologie!7FGE0R!&TT!TTT[:!
CDECG4( L3(%MN+#93@%6)!@%!$OB63C%+93)#!08)A'$3D<%!@%!P3$$%R!%6!(A8+5%!@%!$8!+%(A%+(A%!
(L3(%M!>%()%<+!@%!$OF69)3)<)!08)A'$3D<%!@%!P3$$%R!%6!(A8+5%!@%!$8!+%(A%+(A%!
CDEEG4! ! 0'69%3$$%+!G(3%6)3\3D<%!/!$OF69)3)<)!@%9!G)+8)#53%9!%)!E%(A63D<%9!@%!0'11<63(8)3'6!7FGE0:!
!
89:;<;9!(=<(>9!?<;9!:(@!<=K;=AK=:(
(
CDEJGCDEI!;3+%()%<+!28+!36)#+31!@<!P8*'+8)'3+%!?('$'53%!]!^3'@3C%+93)#!
!>%92'698*$%!@%!$8!(A83+%!@%!+%(A%+(A%!CHREC!H! Capital!Humain,!Responsabilités!et!Economie!Créative!7Y_?GR!
&ST!TTT[:(
CDEE4CDEJ!Z%1*+%!#$<!@<!0'69%3$!@OI@13639)+8)3'6!@<!0'$$45%!@%9!?('6'139)%9!@%!$8!G86)#!
CDED4CDEJ!0'M\'6@8)%<+!%)!;3+%()%<+!@<!0%6)+%!@%!>%(A%+(A%!9<+!$%!0823)8$!=<1836!70>0=:!
!Z%1*+%!@<!('13)#!@%!@3+%()3'6!@%!P3$$%!H!?('6'13%!M!Z8685%1%6)!7BZ>!Q,.-!@<!0">G:!`!>%92'698*$%!@%!$O8U%!
a!18685%1%6)!%)!#('6'13%!@%!$8!986)#!b!
CDDLGCDEC(N+#93@%6)!#$<!@<!0'69%3$!G(3%6)3\3D<%!@%!$OF0P!7<686313)#R!1%1*+%!@%2<39!XTTQ:! !
(Z%1*+%(#$<!@<!0'69%3$!G<2#+3%<+!@%!$OB63C%+93)#!08)A'$3D<%!@%!P3$$%! !
CDDFGCDEI(N+'\%99%<+!@%9!B63C%+93)#9!08)A'$3D<%9!7Y_?GR!B63C%+93)#!08)A'$3D<%!@%!P3$$%:!
CDDHGCDDF!Z8c)+%!@%!0'6\#+%6(%9!@%9!B63C%+93)#9!08)A'$3D<%9!7YPG?_R!B63C%+93)#!08)A'$3D<%!@%!P3$$%:!
CDDIGCDDH!?69%35686)!C8(8)83+%!7"?dZI!7>%319:R!FG_!7N8+39:R!?G0!0'123456%R!0"IZ!7>%319:R!?('$%!Z3$3)83+%!7N8+39::(
CDDMGCDDI!IVEV?V>V!/!$OB63C%+93)#!@%!>%319!0A812856%MI+@%66%!7B>0I:!
CDDDGCDDM! I$$'(8)83+%!@%!+%(A%+(A%9!/!$OB>0I!%)!%69%35686)!C8(8)83+%!7N8+39!FF:!
!
N9O@;!=:(N=(K=?P=K?P=(
!
=#$.$Q"6(,6(%&('&./*(7Risques!psycho-
sociaux,!consommation!à!risque)!
?&R"/&%(53Q&".(7L8$%<+!@%!$8!
C3%!A<1836%R!Entrepreneuriat)!
=#$.$Q"6(,3!,+$"/(70riminalité,!
violence,!2+'9)3)<)3'6:!
=#$.$Q"6(,6(%&!7&Q"%%6(70hoix!du!conjoint)!
!
=#$.$Q"6(,6(%&!R$%"/"S36(7?fficience!
des!députés,!confiance!des!ménages!
!
E0(>$+Q&/"$.(
R0C(
C0(N"+6#/"$.(6/(6TR6+/"'6'(,6(+6#56+#56(
R0C(
M0(N"'/".#/"$.'(6/(R3U%"#&/"$.'(
R0M(
J0(?$%%$S36'(6/(#$.7*+6.#6'(
R0H(
I0(=.'6"V.6Q6./(
R0F(
H0(N"16+'(
R0EE(
! !

2
E0 >$+Q&/"$.(
(
P&U"%"/&/"$.(W(N"+"V6+(,6'(K6#56+#56'(e,XfTKfT.g!Contributions!à!une!économie!de!la!vie!quotidienne!:!Les!êtres!humains!face!au!
crime,! à! leur! santé,! à! la! politique! et! au! choix! de! leur! conjointR! 9'<9!$8! @3+%()3'6!@<! N+V! P'<39! P%ChM_8+*'<8!7B63C%+93)#! N8+39! ,!
N86)A#'6MG'+*'66%:!
N$#/63+( X'( :#"6.#6'( =#$.$Q"S36'!e,.f,XfTJg! 7i<8$3\3#! 0"B! 8<U! \'6()3'69! @%! 18c)+%! @%! ('6\#+%6(%9! %6! XTTS:! Des!
comportements! criminels! et! de! leur! dissuasion!:! Une! analyse! économique! de! la! violence! et! de! la! ruse.! Aspects! théoriques! et!
modélisation!criminométrique!à!partir!de!données!de!panel!françaises!1%6)3'6!E+49!='6'+8*$%!%)!$%9!Y#$3(3)8)3'69!@<!j<+h:R!9'<9!
$8!@3+%()3'6!@<!N+V!j'9#!k'*3%$9l3!7B63C%+93)#!@%!>%319!0A812856%MI+@%66%:!
CDDD!;?I!a!I68$h9%!@%9!18+(A#9!%)!9)+8)#53%9!36@<9)+3%$$%9!b!/!$OB>0IR!1%6)3'6!bien!7major:!
ELLL!Z83)+39%!@O#('6'1#)+3%!/!$OB>0IR!1%6)3'6!assez!bien!
ELLY!P3(%6(%!@O#('6'13%!/!$OB>0I!
ELLF!;?B_!@O#('6'13%!/!$OB>0I!
ELLF!;?B_!@O#('6'13%!/!$OB>0I!
ELLI!^8((8$8<+#8)R!9#+3%!GR!8<!$h(#%!G836)!>#1h!/!G'399'69!
!
C0 N"+6#/"$.(6/(6TR6+/"'6'(,6(+6#56+#56(
!
C0E0 <5X'6'(,6(,$#/$+&/(6/(PNK(
)&+&./(,6(PNK(Z'$3/6.36'[(
P8<+%6)!08+639R!0>,!/!$OFYYGEI>V!=;>!%6!9(3%6(%9!#('6'13D<%9R!9'<)%6<%!$%!XS!m86C3%+!XT,KV!a!Economie!politique!de!la!sécurité!
routière!bV!
N"+6#/"$.(,6(/5X'6'(,6(,$#/$+&/(Z'$3/6.36'[!
j'n$!G86)'9R!Lecturer!/!$O%@A%(!^<936%99!G(A''$V!EA49%!%6!9(3%6(%9!#('6'13D<%9R!9'<)%6<%!$%!T&!9%2)%1*+%!XT,J!8C%(!$8!1%6)3'6!
E+49!='6'+8*$%R!%6!('M)<)%$$%!8C%(!Y8*+3(%!P%!P%(V!a!L’aversion!extrême!aux!risques!majeurs!:!une!approche!économique!basée!
sur!le!modèle!d’utilité!espérée!dépendantes!des!rangs!bV!;<+#%!@%!$8!)A49%!`!M\H(&.'V!
_+#5'3+%!08<(A3%R!Maître!de!conférences!des!Universités!CatholiquesV!EA49%!%6!9(3%6(%9!#('6'13D<%9R!9'<)%6<%!2<*$3D<%1%6)!
$%! TK! \#C+3%+! XT,J!8C%(! $8! 1%6)3'6! E+49! ='6'+8*$%V! a!Talent,! formation! et! expérience!:! le! rôle! du! capital! humain! de!
l’entrepreneur!dans!son!activité!bV!;<+#%!@%!$8!)A49%!`!M\J(&.'V!
_o%6!Z8+D<#R!Directeur!adjoint!de!l’ARS!Nord!Pas!de!Calais.!EA49%!%6!9(3%6(%9!@%!5%9)3'6R!%6!('M)<)%$$%!8C%(!^%6'3)!;%+C8<UR!
9'<)%6<%!2<*$3D<%1%6)!$%!XS!m<36!XT,&!8C%(!$8!1%6)3'6!='6'+8*$%V!a!Développement!d’une!planification!équitable!des!soins!
pour! lutter! contre! les! inégalités! territoriales!:! l’expérience! française!bV!;<+#%! @%! $8! )A49%!`! C( &.'! 7thèse! commencée! avec! un!
autre!directeur:V!
"3('$8h%! P81hR! Responsable! des! Etudes! Economiques! à! EAU! –! Economie! Aménagement! Urbanisme.! EA49%!%6! 9(3%6(%9!
#('6'13D<%9R!9'<)%6<%!2<*$3D<%1%6)!$%!,&!m86C3%+!XTT-!8C%(!$8!1%6)3'6!E+49!='6'+8*$%:R!a!P%!logrolling!('11%!\'6@%1%6)!
@<! 18+(A#! 2'$3)3D<%!`! PO%U%12$%! @<! 28+$%1%6)! %<+'2#%6!bV!;<+#%! @%! $8! )A49%!`! C( &.'(7thèse! commencée! avec! un! autre!
directeur:V!
N"+6#/"$.(,6(/5X'6'(,6(,$#/$+&/(Z6.(#$3+'[!
_8<)3%+!;+<8+)R!enseignant!à!l’ISTC!7XT,TM:!)A49%!%6!9(3%6(%9!@%!5%9)3'6R!%6!('M)<)%$$%!8C%(!Y8*+3(%!P%!P%(R!soutenance!prévue!en!
mars!2016,!a!i<8$3)#!2%+p<%!%)!@392'93)3'6!/!28h%+!2'<+!@%9!2+'@<3)9!2'99#@86)!<6%!(8+8()#+39)3D<%!#)A3D<%!bV!
I6)A'6h!"%A1%AR!enseignant!à!l’Université!ANTONINE,!à!l’Université!Libanaise,!à!Lebanese!International!University!et!à!AUL!-!
Arts! Science! University! in! Lebanon! 718+9! XT,XM:! )A49%! %6! 9(3%6(%9! @%! 5%9)3'6R! %6! ('M)<)%$$%! 8C%(! G%$31! Z%lA@%993R! a!P%!
@#C%$'22%1%6)!@<+8*$%!@%9!NZ?!85+'M8$31%6)83+%9!bV!
G86@+8! >81'9R! assistant! doctorant! à! la! FGES! 79%2)%1*+%! XT,JM:! )A49%! %6! 9(3%6(%9! @%! 5%9)3'6R! %6! ('M)<)%$$%! 8C%(! Y+%@%+3l!
0$8%h#Ra!^<3$@365!A<186!(823)8$!bV!
j'9389!kNdLF?GGFR!assistant!doctorant!à!la!FGES!76'C%1*+%!XT,SM:R!%6!('M)<)%$$%!8C%(!L#+'63D<%!Y$81*8+@R!a!P%9!('12'+)%1%6)9!
@O%\\8(%1%6)!#6%+5#)3D<%!bV!
08)A%+36%!I>0=?Z^IBER!assistant!doctorant!à!YNCREA!76'C%1*+%!XT,SM:R!a!18685%1%6)!@%!$O366'C8)3'6!%)!('@%9356!bV!
I6@+%8! _BF;dR! 89939)86)! @'()'+86)! /! $8! Z839'6! @%9!0A%+(A%<+9! 76'C%1*+%! XT,KM:R! %6! ('M)<)%$$%! 8C%(! _3<9%22%! I))86893R!
a!(oopération et la confiance sur les plateformes de partage en ligne ».
!
8&+/"#"R&/"$.'(W(3.(]3+^(,6(/5X'6(
L8$%+38!I+5<%$$'!089)+'!7)A49%!9'<)%6<%!2<*$3D<%1%6)!$%!XK!'()'*+%!XT,KR!9'<9!$8!@3+%()3'6!@%!ZV!G)%2A%6!P8<68hR!B63C%+93)#!
G'+*'66%!"'<C%$$%!H!N8+39!&:R!+&RR$+/63+R!a!PO369)3)<)3'668$398)3'6!@%9!+%$8)3'69!1<$)3$8)#+8$%9!%6!I1#+3D<%!$8)36%!bV!
=8@h!G%65A'+!7)A49%!9'<)%6<%!2<*$3D<%1%6)!$%!XJ!'()'*+%!XT,KR!9'<9!$8!@3+%()3'6!@<!N+V!Y+86p'39M0A8+$%9!q'$\\R!B63C%+93)#!@%!
"86)%9:R!+&RR$+/63+R!a!PO#@<(8)3'6!%6!I\+3D<%!9<*98A8+3%66%!`!36#58$3)#9!36)+8\813$38$%9!%)!3128()9!9<+!$8!986)#!@%!$O%6\86)!bV!
I*@'<! ;3'2! Y8h%! 7)A49%! 9'<)%6<%! 2<*$3D<%1%6)! $%! ,K! 18+9! XT,X! 8C%(! $8! 1%6)3'6! E+49! ='6'+8*$%R! 9'<9! $8! @3+%()3'6! @<! N+V!
G)#2A86%! 08$$%69R! B63C%+93)#! @OI+)'39:R! R+*'",6./( ,3( ]3+^R! a!I68$h9%! @%9! @#)%+13686)9! @%! $O'\\+%! @%! )+8C83$! @%9! \%11%9! %6!
13$3%<!<+*836!9#6#58$839!bV!

3
N8)+3(%! P%95'<+5<%9! 7)A49%! 9'<)%6<%! 2<*$3D<%1%6)! $%! X-! m<36! XT,T! 8C%(! $8! 1%6)3'6! E+49! ='6'+8*$%R! 9'<9! $8! @3+%()3'6! @<! N+V!
Z3(A%$! ;<2<hR! B63C%+93)#! ^'+@%8<U! FL! M! Z'6)%9D<3%<:R! +&RR$+/63+R! a!Pr#('6'13%! 2'$3)3D<%! @%9! +#531%9! @%! (A865%! `! <6%!
822$3(8)3'6!8<!(89!@%!$8!0A36%!bV!
j<$3%))%!_8@8<@!7)A49%!9'<)%6<%!2<*$3D<%1%6)!$%!,K!@#(%1*+%!XTT-!8C%(!$8!1%6)3'6!E+49!='6'+8*$%!%)!$%9!Y#$3(3)8)3'69!@<!m<+hR!
9'<9!$8!@3+%()3'6!@%! N8)+3(l! N'36)R!B63C%+93)#!^'+@%8<U! FL! H! Z'6)%9D<3%<:R!a!B6%!822+'(A%!#('6'13D<%!@%!$8!+#1<6#+8)3'6!
2'<+!9%+C3(%9!+%6@<9!%6!\'+s)!2+3C#%!`!$%!(89!@%!$O8((<%3$!@<!2<*$3(!bV!
Z8)h!G%6%! 7)A49%! 9'<)%6<%! 2<*$3D<%1%6)! $%! X.! 18+9! XTTQ! 8C%(! $8! 1%6)3'6! E+49! ='6'+8*$%R! 9'<9! $8! @3+%()3'6! @%! Z'63D<%!
P8l+'<1R!B63C%+93)#!@%!>%319!0A812856%MI+@%66%:R!+&RR$+/63+R!a!P8!('11%+(38$398)3'6!@%9!2+'@<3)9!A8$3%<)3D<%9!%)!\$<C38<U!
\+839!%)!9#(A#9!8<!G#6#58$!@%!,-JS!/!XTTS!bV!
!
C0C0 ?$./+&/'(,6(+6#56+#56(
CDDM(P8!(+31368$3)#!@869!$%!@#28+)%1%6)!@%!$8!Z8+6%!`!B6%!868$h9%!#('6'1#)+3D<%R!,XfXTT&R!P8*'+8)'3+%!dZFM?;jR!>%319V(
CDED(P8! C8$%<+! @%9! @'1185%9! ('+2'+%$9!`! B6%! 2%+92%()3C%! #('6'13D<%! @%9! 1#)A'@%9! @O#C8$<8)3'6!%)! @OA8+1'6398)3'6! @%!
$O36@%16398)3'6! @%9! C3()31%9! @O8((3@%6)9! @%! $8! +'<)%R! XTTQMXT,TR! 8C%(! PV! 08+639R! ^V! ;%+C8<UR! LV! =8++86)! %)! GVP%('(DR!
Z3639)4+%! @%! $r?('$'53%R! @%! $O?6%+53%R! @<! ;#C%$'22%1%6)! @<+8*$%! %)! $%! $8! Z%+! M! ;G0>!f! _+'<2%! d+586398)3'66%$! X! @<!
N>?;FE!J!a!Qualité!et!sécurité!des!systèmes!de!transport!»,!0'6C%6)3'6!6t!0L!TTTJKX,V(
!
C0M0 O"''"$.'(,_6TR6+/"'6(
CDDL!?U2%+)!I?>?G!`!PF>I?G(H!?I!JJ.T(7B63C%+93)#!N8+39!;%9(8+)%9:!
CDDL!?U2%+)!I?>?G!`!0%+1%9&(H!BZ>!0">G!QX,,!f!B-QQ(7B63C%+93)#!N8+39!;%9(8+)%9:!
CDEJ!?U2%+)!I">E!7X!#C8$<8)3'69!0FY>?:!
!
C0J0 K6%6#/3+6(,_&+/"#%6'(R$3+(,6'(+6136'('#"6./"7"S36'(
>%C3%o!'\!?('6'13(9!'\!)A%!='<9%A'$@9R!I22$3%@!?('6'13(9R!d2%+8)3'6!>%9%8+(A!
P%))%+9R!N9h(A'$'53(8$!>%2'+)9R!I668$9!'\!N<*$3(!86@!0''2%+8)3C%!?('6'13(9R!
j'<+68$!'\!?('6'13(!N9h(A'$'5hR!?('6'13(9!86@!=<186!^3'$'5hR!N<*$3(!0A'3(%R!
"8)3'68$!E8U!j'<+68$R!Z8685%+38$!86@!;%(393'6!?('6'13(9R!
?('6'13%!%)!N+#C393'6R!>%(A%+(A%9!?('6'13D<%9!@%!P'<C836R!P8!>%C<%!
?('6'13D<%R!P%9!08A3%+9!G(3%6)3\3D<%9!@<!E+8692'+)R!?('6'13%!I22$3D<#%R!P8!
>%C<%!Y+86p839%!@O?('6'13%!
!
M0 N"'/".#/"$.'(6/(R3U%"#&/"$.'(
!
M0E0 N"'/".#/"$.'(
"'136#!8<!G)h$'!@O'+!XT,K!7I99'(38)3'6!"8)3'68$%!@%9!;>=R!XX!6'C%1*+%!XT,KR!J!$3C+%9!9#$%()3'66#9:!`!P8!\<$5<+86)%!+%(+#8)3'6!
78C%(!N3%++%!_3'+5363:R!#@V!`!`&^&+,V(
"'136#! 8<! &41%!N+3U! @<! P3C+%! 9<+! $O?('6'13%! G'(38$%! %)! G'$3@83+%! 7XX! 9%2)%1*+%! XT,KR! J! $3C+%9! 9#$%()3'66#9! @869! $8! (8)#5'+3%!
a!?U2%+)9!b:!`!P8!\<$5<+86)%!+%(+#8)3'6!78C%(!N3%++%!_3'+5363:R!#@V!`!`&^&+,V(
N+3U!Z?>F!@O#)A3D<%!`!;%9!A'11%9R!@%9!+%99'<+(%9!+8+%9!%)!@%!$8!)%(A6'$'53%!`!Nihil!novo!sub!sole!78C%(!0A+39)386!^%6!P8lA@8+!%)!
Y8*+3(%!P%!P%(:R!in!a!P8!)+8693)3'6!\<$5<+86)%!bR!9'<9!$8!@3+%()3'6!@%!N3%++%!_3'+5363R!#@V!`!^8h8+@V!
E+'39341%!2+3U!@<!Scientific!Paper!Award!@%!$OEuropean!Monitoring!Centre!for!Drugs!and!Drug!Addiction!7P39*'66%R!N'+)<58$R!XS!
6'C%1*+%! XT,J:! @869! $8! (8)#5'+3%! Policy,! supply! and! crime!`! ^%6! P8lA@8+R! 0VR! P%$%<R! =VR! L83$$86)R! "V! _VR! q'$\\R! YM0V! 7XT,&:!
?\\3(3%6(h!'\!2<+(A89365!86@!9%$$365!85%6)9!36!18+l%)9!o3)A!D<8$3)h!<6(%+)836)h`!EA%!(89%!'\!3$$3(3)!@+<5!)+8698()3'69OR!European!
Journal!of!Operational!ResearchR!XXKR!2VKJKHKS.V!
G%('6@!2+3U!XTTS!@<!1%3$$%<+!8+)3($%!m%<6%!(A%+(A%<+!@%!$OFI>?N!7International!Association!for!Research!in!Economic!Psychology:!
2'<+! $O8+)3($%! a!Human! mate! selection! and! undesirable! characteristics! in! partners!b! 7N+85<%R! >#2<*$3D<%! E(A4D<%R! X,! H! XJ!
9%2)%1*+%!XTTS:V!
!
M0C0 @+/"#%6'(R3U%"*'(,&.'(,6'(+6136'(+*7*+6.#*6'(
CDDJ( aDEb(;39(+31368)3'6!36!18)(A18l365`!?C3@%6(%!\+'1!8!Y+%6(A!18++385%!*<+%8<R!@RR%"6,(=#$.$Q"#'R!XTTJR!C'$V&K7.:R!.X&M
.X-!e?('6'13%!70">G!CR!I?>?GR!qdGMGG0dR!G('2<9:R!G(V!('1V!%)!8@136V!7I?>?G:gV!
aDCb!?9)318)365!)A%! E31%!?$829%@! ^%)o%%6!?6@365! 8! >%$8)3'69A32!86@! j'36365!8! Z8)(A18l365!I5%6(h`!?C3@%6(%!\+'1! 8!
Y+%6(A! Z8++385%! ^<+%8<R! c$3+.&%( $7( =#$.$Q"#( 8'^#5$%$V^R! XTTJR! C'$VXS7K:R! .Q-MQTX!e?('6'13%! 70">G!CR! I?>?GR! qdGM
GG0dR!G('2<9:R!N9h(A'$'53%!%)!9(V!('563)3C%9!7I?>?GR!?>F=R!qdGMGG0dR!G('2<9:R!G(V!('1V!%)!8@136V!7I?>?G:gV!
CDDI( aDMb(Y+'1! P3*%+)36391! )'! Z8+3)8$! 0'113)1%6)! H! EA%! ?('6'13(9! '\! Z8+3)8$! >%9%8+(A! o3)A! =%)%+'5%6%'<9! I5%6)9! 78C%(!
_VP%!_<3++3%(:R!c$3+.&%($7(`"$=#$.$Q"#'R!XTTSR!C'$V.7,:R!QJM-S!e?('6'13%!7G('2<9:R!N9h(A'$'53%!%)!9(V!('563)3C%9!7I?>?G:gV!
aDJb!0'12%698)3'6! 86@! o+'65\<$! $3\%`! I! 2'93)3C%! %('6'13(! 2%+92%()3C%! 78C%(! LV=8++86):R! c$3+.&%( $7( B6V&%( =#$.$Q"#'R!
XTTSR!C'$V,&7X:R!,M,Qe0">G!MR!?('6'13%!7I?>?G:R!G(V!('1V!%)!8@136V!7I?>?G:gV!
aDIb!EA%! Y+%6(A! +%m%()3'6! '\! )A%! ?<+'2%86! 0'69)3)<)3'6`! 86! %123+3(8$! 868$h939! 78C%(! ^Vj#+u1%:R! =3+$R6&.( c$3+.&%( $7(
8$%"/"#&%( =#$.$Q^R! @#(%1*+%! XTTSR! C'$VX,R! ,TQSM,T-X! ! e?('6'13%! 70">G!CR! I?>?GR! qdGMGG0dR! G('2<9:R! G(V! 2'$3)3D<%!
7qdGMGG0F:R!G(V!('1V!%)!8@136V!7I?>?G:gV!
CDDH( aDHb!?U2%+)! '2363'6! 86@! *+86@! +%2<)8)3'6`! I6! 868$h939! \+'1! 8! Y+%6(A! 0<*86! (358+9! _<3@%*''l! 78C%(! YVP3C8):R! @RR%"6,(
=#$.$Q"#'(B6//6+'R!XTTKR!C'$V,&7X:R!-.M,TT!e?('6'13%!70">G!JR!I?>?GR!qdGMGG0dR!G('2<9:R!G(V!('1V!%)!8@136V!7I?>?G:gV!
aDFb!G%U! @3\\%+%6(%9! 36! 9)32<$8)%@! 2+%\%+%6(%9! 86@! 18)%! 9%8+(A! %\\'+)9! *h! ($3%6)9! '\! 8! Y+%6(A! 18++385%! *<+%8<R!
8'^#5$%$V"#&%(K6R$+/'R!XTTKR!C'$V-QR!XQSMX-T!eN9h(A'$'53%!%)!9(V!('563)3C%9!7I?>?GR!qdGMGG0dR!G('2<9:g.!

4
aDYb!I! _''@9! 0A8+8()%+39)3(9! Z'@%$! '\! )A%! =%@'63(! I5%365! ?D<8)3'6`! ?C3@%6(%! Y+'1! 8! Y+%6(A! Z8++385%! ^<+%8<!
7GV081%+'6:R! `+3''6%'( =#$.$Q"#( K61"6dR! XTTKR! C'$VJQ7J:R! &J,M&SJ!e?('6'13%! 70">G! JR! I?>?G:R! G(V! ('1V! %)! 8@136V!
7I?>?G:gV!
CDDF( aDLb!N'<+D<'3! 7%)! ('1*3%6:!28h%+! 2'<+!+%6('6)+%+! <6! a!*'6!b! ('6m'36)!vR! %&!K6136(=#$.$Q"S36R! XTT.R! C'$VSQR! SQ.MS-.!
e?('6'13%!70">G!CR!I?>?GR!G('2<9:R!G(V!('1V!%)!8@136V!7I?>?G:gV!
CDDY( aEDb!d6! )A%! $3l%$3A''@! '\! \36@365! )A%! +35A)! 28+)6%+! 36! 86! 8++865%@! 18++385%`! ?C3@%6(%! Y+'1! 8! Y+%6(A! Z8++385%! ^<+%8<!
78C%(!LV=8++86):R!c$3+.&%($7(:$#"$4=#$.$Q"#'R!XTTQR!C'$V&.7X:R!KS.MK.,!e?('6'13%!70">G!JR!I?>?GR!qdGMGG0dR!G('2<9:R!
N9h(A'$'53%!%)!9(V!('563)3C%9!7I?>?G:R!G(V!('1V!%)!8@136V!7I?>?G:gV!
aEEb!EA%! <9%! '\! %U2%+)! '2363'6R! D<8$3)h! 86@! +%2<)8)3'6! 36@3(8)'+9! *h! ('69<1%+9`! ?C3@%6(%! \+'1! )A%! Y+%6(A! C8<$)365!
9)8$$3'6!9%1%6!18+l%)!78C%(!NVP%9')R!iV^'668+@!86@!LV=8++86):R!@RR%"6,(=#$.$Q"#'R!Z8+(A!XTTQR!,JKKM,JQ&!e?('6'13%!
70">G!CR!I?>?GR!qdGMGG0dR!G('2<9:R!G(V!('1V!%)!8@136V!7I?>?G:g.!
aECb!L8$%<+! 9<*m%()3C%! @%! $8! C3%! %)! ('w)! @O'22'+)<63)#! /! 683)+%! 8C%(! <6! A86@3(82! 78C%(! LV=8++86)! %)! ^VP%1%663(3%+:R!
c$3+.&%(,_=#$.$Q"6(O*,"#&%6R!XTTQR!C'$VXS7SMK:R!X-SM&TK!e?('6'13%!70">G!JR!I?>?G:R!G(V!('1V!%)!8@136V!7I?>?G:gV!
CDDL(aEMb(I+%!q'1%6!P%99!>39lMP'C%+!)A86!Z%6v!?C3@%6(%!\+'1!IF;G!C3()319!78C%(!LV=8++86):R!=1$%3/"$.(e(P3Q&.(`65&1"$+R!
XTT-R!C'$VX-7K:R!&-KMJT,!e?('6'13%!7I?>?G:R!N9h(A'$'53%!%)!9(V!('563)3C%9!7I?>?GR!?>F=R!qdGMGG0FR!G('2<9:R!G(V!('1V!%)!
8@136V!7I?>?G:R!G'(3'$'53%!7qdGMGG0F:gV!
aEJb( qA8)!18))%+9! 1'+%!36!)A%!>];!86@!(823)8$!%U2%6@3)<+%9!\3686(365!*h!j8286%9%!\3+19`!Z<$)368)3'68$)h!'+!k%3+%)9<!
8\\3$38)3'6v! 78C%(! ZV"%lA3$3! %)! ;V"%lA3$3:R! `&.f6+'\( O&+f6/'( &.,( ;.16'/$+'R! XTT-R! C'$V,TTR! XSM&K!e?('6'13%! 70">G! JR!
I?>?G:R!G(V!('1V!%)!8@136V!7I?>?GgV!
CDED(aEIb!^+'l%6! o36@'o9! )A%'+h! 86@! 18+5368$! @%)%++%6(%`! ;'%9! )A%! 2<639A1%6)! '\! 136'+! 9%U<8$! '\\%6(%9! @%)%+! +82%9v!
?C3@%6(%!\+'1!Y+%6(A!286%$!@8)8!78C%(!YVM0Vq'$\\:R!=3+$R6&.(c$3+.&%($7(B&d(&.,(=#$.$Q"#'R!XT,TR!C'$V&T7,:R!S-M.,!e;+'3)!
7I?>?GR!qdGMGG0F:R!?('6'13%!70">G!CR!I?>?GR!qdGMGG0FR!G('2<9:R!G(V!('1V!%)!8@136V!7I?>?GR!G('2<9:gV!
aEHb!?)A63(! @3\\%+%6(%9! 36! 9%$\M+%2'+)%@! A%8$)A! 81'65! '$@%+! 135+86)9! $3C365! 36! Y+86(%! 78C%(! YVM0V! q'$\\:R! 83U%"#( P6&%/5R!
XT,TR!C'$V,XJ7X:R!-TM-Q!e?('6'13%! 70">G! MR! I?>?G:R! N9h(A'$'53%! %)!9(V! ('563)3C%9!7I?>?G:R! G(V!2'$3)3D<%! 7qdGMGG0F:R!G(V!
('1V!%)!8@136V!7I?>?G:gV!
CDEE(aEFb!N'93)3C%! 86@! 6%58)3C%! @39(+31368)3'6! 36! A<186! 18)%! 9%$%()3'6! 78C%(! Y+86p'39! 0A8+$%9! q'$\\:R! <56( K61"6d( $7(
=#$.$Q"#'($7(/56(P$3'65$%,R!XT,,R!C'$V-7X:R!X.&MX-,!e?('6'13%!70">G!MR!I?>?GR!G('2<9:R!G(V!('1V!%)!8@136V!7I?>?G:gV!
aEYb!P8! @399<893'6! @%9! A'13(3@%9! C'$'6)83+%9! 78C%(! ^%6'c)! ;%+C8<U:R! %&( K6136( =#$.$Q"S36R! XT,,R! C'$VKXR! X&.MXSJ!
e?('6'13%!70">G!CR!I?>?GR!G('2<9:R!G(V!('1V!%)!8@136V!7I?>?G:gV(
aELb!Y8<)M3$!(A'D<%+!$%9!\<1%<+9!%)!$%9!\<1%<+9!2')%6)3%$9!2'<+!@399<8@%+!$%9!('12'+)%1%6)9!)8*853D<%9!v!78C%(!0V!^%6!
P8lA@8+! %)! YVM0V! q'$\\:R! %&( K6136( ,_=R",*Q"$%$V"6( 6/( ,6( :&./*( 83U%"S36R! XT,,R! C'$VS-7&:R! ,.SM,QK!eN9h(A'$'53%! %)! 9(V!
('563)3C%9!7I?>?G:gV!
aCDb!G)+%99R! 86U3#)#! %)! @#2+%993'6! `! ?U39)%M)M3$! @%9! @3\\#+%6(%9! %6)+%! %6)+%2+39%9! v! 78C%(! YVM0Vq'$\\:R! %&( K6136( >+&.g&"'6(
,_=#$.$Q"6R! XT,,R! C'$VXS7J:R! &-M.J!e?('6'13%! 70">G! MR! I?>?G:R! N9h(A'$'53%! %)! 9(V! @%! $O#@<(8)3'6! 7I?>?G:R! G(V! ('1V! %)!
8@13639)+8)3C%9!7I?>?G:gV!
aCEb!d6! )A%! o8h! '\! E'*8(('! D<3))365!`! I! LI>! 822+'8(A! 78C%(! 0V^%6! P8lA@8+! %)! EVP%*+<6:R! =#$.$Q"#'( `3%%6/".R! XT,,R!
C'$V&,7J:R!&XS&M&XSQ!e?('6'13%!70">G!MR!I?>?GR!G('2<9:R!G(V!('1V!%)!8@13639)+8)3C%9!7I?>?G:gV!
CDEC(aCCb!P%9! @#)%+13686)9! @<! 9)+%99! 2+'\%993'66%$! +%99%6)3!`! <6%! %9)318)3'6! 28+! $8! 1#)A'@%! @%9! #D<8)3'69! @O%9)318)3'6!
5#6#+8$39#%9!78C%(!P398!^%$$365A8<9%6:R!=#$.$Q"6(6/(8+*1"'"$.R!XT,TR! JMSR!6t,-SM,-KR!K.MQX!e?('6'13%!70">G! MR! I?>?GR!
G('2<9:R!G(V!('1V!%)!8@13639)+8)3C%9!7I?>?GR!G('2<9:gV!
aCMb(EA%!C8$<%!'\!*'@3$h!36m<+3%9`!?C3@%6(%!\+'1!('12%698)3'6!8o8+@%@!)'!+'8@!8((3@%6)!C3()319!36!Y+86(%!78C%(!PV08+639!
%)!^V;%+C8<U:R!@RR%"6,(=#$.$Q"#'(B6//6+'R!XT,&R!/!XT7,:R!XQM&&!,TT!e?('6'13%!70">G!JR!I?>?GR!qdGMGG0dR!G('2<9:R!G(V!
('1V!%)!8@136V!7I?>?G:gV!
aCJb!>%)3+%1%6)! 36)%6)3'6! '\! '$@%+! 135+86)! o'+l%+9`! @'%9! A%8$)A! 18))%+v! 78C%(! YVM0Vq'$\\:R! ;./6+.&/"$.&%( c$3+.&%( $7(
O&.R$d6+R! XT,XR! &&7J:R! JJ,MJKT!e?('6'13%! 70">G! MR! I?>?G:R! N9h(A'$'53%! %)! 9(V! ('563)3C%9! 7I?>?G:R! G(V! ('1V! %)!
8@13639)+8)3C%9!7I?>?GR!qdGMGG0FR!G('2<9:R!G'(3'$'53%!7qdGMGG0F:gV!
aCIb!EA%!+'$%!'\!\813$h!36('1%9!36!(358+%))%!91'l365!78C%(! 0A+39)386!^%6! P8lA@8+R!_+#5'3+%!08<(A3%! %)! Y+86p'39M0A8+$%9!
q'$\\:R!:$#"&%(:#"6.#6(&.,(O6,"#".6R!XT,XR!.J7,X:R!,QKJM,Q.&!e?('6'13%!70">G!,R!I?>?G:R!I6)A+'2'$'53%R!%)A6'$'53%!%)!
\'$l$'+%!7I?>?G:R!;#1'5+82A3%!7I?>?G:R!N9h(A'$'53%!%)!9(V!('563)3C%9!7I?>?GR!?>F=:R!G(V!('1V!%)!8@13639)+8)3C%9!7I?>?GR!
qdGMGG0F:R!G'(3'$'53%!7I?>?GR!qdGMGG0FR!G('2<9:gV!
aCHb!;'!('69<1%+9!$%8+6!\+'1!)89)365!9('+%9!9%)!*h!%U2%+)9!v!78C%(! YVM0Vq'$\\:R!=#$.$Q"#'(`3%%6/".R!XT,XR!&X7X:R!,&.QM
,&QJ!e?('6'13%!70">G!MR!I?>?GR!G('2<9:R!G(V!('1V!%)!8@13639)+8)3C%9!7I?>?G:gV!
aCFb( Z%9<+%+! $O%\\3(8(3)#! @%9! @#2<)#9! 8<! 9%36! @<! N8+$%1%6)! \+86p839`! $O822'+)! @%9! )%(A63D<%9! @%! \+'6)34+%9! 6'6M
28+81#)+3D<%9! 78C%(! j<$3%6! "8C8++'! %)! Y+86p'39M0A8+$%9! q'$\\:R! K6136( >+&.g&"'6( ,6( :#"6.#6(8$%"/"S36R! KX7J:R! K,,MK&K!!
e;#1'5+82A3%! 7I?>?G:R! ;+'3)! 7I?>?G:R! >%$8)3'69! 36)%+68)3'68$9! 7G('2<9:R! G(3%6(%! 2'$3)3D<%! 7I?>?GR! G('2<9:R! G'(3'$'53%!
7I?>?GR!G('2<9:gV!
CDEM( aCYb!B6@%+9)86@365! A'o! %U2%+)9! +8)%! (358+9`! 86! A8C86'1%)+3(! 868$h939! 78C%(! YVM0V! q'$\\:R! @RR%"6,( =#$.$Q"#'R! XT,&R!
C'$VJS7,:R!--M,T-!e?('6'13%!70">G!CR!I?>?GR!qdGMGG0FR!G('2<9:R!G(V!('1V!%)!8@13639)+8)3C%9!7I?>?G:gV!
aCLb!P%9!<985%9!@%!a!legal!highs!b!9'6)M3$9!98)39\83)9!v!78C%(!0A+39)'2A%MI$836!^+<6%%$!%)!0A+39)386!^%6!P8lA@8+:R!%&(K6136(
,_=R",*Q"$%$V"6(6/(,6(:&./*(83U%"S36R!K,7GJ:R!GX,X!eN9h(A'$'53%!%)!9(V!('563)3C%9!7I?>?G:gV!

5
aMDb( i<8$3)h! <6(%+)836)h! 86@! %\\3(3%6)! )+8698()3'69! '6! 3$$3(3)! @+<59! 18+l%)! 78C%(! 0A+39)386! ^%6! P8lA@8+R! =%+C#! P%$%<! %)!
Y+86p'39M0A8+$%9!q'$\\:R!=3+$R6&.( c$3+.&%( $7( 9R6+&/"$.&%(K6'6&+#5R! XXKR! KJKMKS.!e?('6'13%! 70">G! ER! I?>?GR! G('2<9:R!
G(V!('1V!%)!8@13639)+8)3C%9!7I?>?G:gV!
CDEJ(aMEb!I+%! $%58$! A35A9O! <9%+9! 98)39\3%@v! ?C3@%6(%! \+'1! '6$36%! (<9)'1%+! ('11%6)9! 78C%(! 0A+39)'2A%MI$836! ^+<6%%$! %)!
0A+39)386!^%6!P8lA@8+:R!:3U'/&.#6(A'6(&.,(O"'3'6R!J-7J:R!&K&M&.&!eN9h(A'$'53%!%)!9(V!('563)3C%9!7I?>?GR!?>F=R!qdGMGG0FR!
G('2<9:R!G(3%6(%!2'$3)3D<%!7qdGMGG0FR!G('2<9:R!G'(3'$'53%!7qdGMGG0FR!G('2<9:gV!
aMCb!0'69<1%+!9%6)31%6)!86@!5'C%+61%6)!('6\3@%6(%`!F9!)A%+%!8!9)8*$%!(8<98$!+%$8)3'69A32v!78C%(!L#+'63D<%!Y$81*8+@:R!
>+6.#5(8$%"/"#'R!,X7J:R!&,TM&&T!e>%$8)3'69!36)%+68)3'68$9!7G('2<9:R!G(3%6(%!2'$3)3D<%!7I?>?GR!G('2<9:R!G'(3'$'53%!7G('2<9:gV!
CDEI( aMMb!?('6'13(! ('6@3)3'69! 86@! ('6\3@%6(%!`! ;'%9! (A865%! 36! )A%! ('69<12)3'6! $%C%$! 8\\%()! )A%! @h6813(9! '\! ('6\3@%6(%v!
78C%(! L#+'63D<%! Y$81*8+@:R! =#$.$Q"#'( `3%%6/".R! &J7J:R! IXXT!e?('6'13%! 70">G! MR! I?>?GR! G('2<9:R! G(V! ('1V! %)!
8@13639)+8)3C%9!7I?>?G:gV!
aMJb!;'%9! 91'l%! (+'99! )A%! *'+@%+9v!0358+%))%!)8U!8C'3@86(%!36!Y+86(%! 78C%(! 0A+39)386! ^%6! P8lA@8+! %)!Y+86p'39M0A8+$%9!
q'$\\:R!=3+$R6&.(c$3+.&%($7(P6&%/5(=#$.$Q"#'R!à!paraitre!7;dF!,TV,TT.f9,T,-QMT,SMT.JKM,:!e?('6'13%!70">G!CR!I?>?GR!
qdGMGG0FR!G('2<9:R!N9h(A'$'53%!%)!9(V!('563)3C%9!7I?>?G:R!G(3%6(%!2'$3)3D<%!7qdGMGG0F:R!G(3%6(%9!('1V!%)!8@13639)+8)3C%9!
7I?>?G:gV!
CDEH!aMIb!"%o! \3+1! 9<+C3C8$`! EA%! l%h! \8()'+9! '\! \'<6@%+9! A<186! (823)8$! \'+! $'65%C3)h! 78C%(! _+#5'3+%! 08<(A3%:R! c$3+.&%( $7(
P3Q&.(?&R"/&%R!,T7X:R!,QKMX,,!e?('6'13%!70">G!CR!I?>?GR!qdGMGG0FR!G('2<9:R!G(3%6(%9!('1V!%)!8@13639)+8)3C%9!7I?>?G:gV!
aMHb!N+3(%! %$89)3(3)h! 86@! %6@'5%6'<9! 2')%6(h! '\! (8668*39`! ?C3@%6(%! \+'1! Y+86(%! 78C%(! 0A+39)386! ^%6! P8lA@8+! %)! YVM
0Vq'$\\:R!@,,"#/"$.(K6'6&+#5(&.,(<56$+^R!à!paraître!eN9h(A'$'53%!%)!9(V!('563)3C%9!7I?>?GR!?>F=:R!G(3%6(%!2'$3)3D<%!7qdGM
GG0F:R!G'(3'$'53%!7qdGMGG0F:gV!
!
M0M0 @+/"#%6'(R3U%"*'(,&.'(,6'(+6136'(.$.(+*7*+6.#*6'(
CDDJ( aMFb!PO#('6'1#)+3%!@<! (+31%!`! <6!369)+<1%6)! 8<! 9%+C3(%! @%!$8! 2+'92%()3C%R!%&(K6136(,6( %&()6.,&+Q6+"6( !&/"$.&%6R! m<36!
XTTJR!6tX,,R!2V!,XXM,XQV!
CDDI( aMYb!;'!$%58$!986()3'69!+%36\'+(%!9'(38$!986()3'69v!I6!%('6'13(!868$h939!'\!36\86)3(3@%R!P$Q$(96#$.$Q"#3'R!6'C%1*+%!
XTTSR!C'$VXX7&:R!&&&M&JKV(
CDDY( aMLb!qA'!C')%9!\'+!%('$'539)! 28+)3%9v! P%99'69! \+'1! G<*<+*86! Y+86(%! 78C%(! xV?58$R! >VY+86(lR! "V_%+)(A%CR! ^Vj#+u1%! 86@!
^VP%1%663(3%+:R!P$Q$(96#$.$Q"#3'\!XTTQR!XS!7,:R!,M,KV(
CDEE( aJDb!PO#C893'6!\39(8$%!+%$8)3C%!8<U!8(A8)9!)+869\+'6)8$3%+9!@%!(358+%))%9!78C%(!0V^%6!P8lA@8+:R!<6.,&.#6'R!XT,,R!.SR!2V!,MKV(
CDEC( aJEb!d6! )A%! +%$38*3$3)h! '\! 9%$\M+%2'+)%@! A%8$)A`! ?C3@%6(%! <9365! $'653)<@368$! I$*86386! @8)8! 78C%(! Y+86p'39M0A8+$%9! q'$\\:R!
c$3+.&%($7(=R",6Q"$%$V^(&.,()%$U&%(P6&%/5R!XT,XR!X7X:R!-&M-QV(
CDEM(aJCb!G%$$365!2+3(%!'\!@381'6@9!86@!o%35A)`!F6935A)9!\+'1!D<86)3$%!A%@'63(!2+3(%!\<6()3'69!78C%(!Y+86p'39M0A8+$%9!q'$\\:R!
@'"&.(=#$.$Q"#(&.,(>".&.#"&%(K61"6dR!&7,,:R!,SJTM,SK,V(
!
M0J0 ?5&R"/+6'(,&.'(,6'($31+&V6'(
CDEE( aJMb!P%9! 822'+)9! @%! $O#('6'13%! @%! $8! 986)#! /! $O868$h9%! @%9! %6m%<U! @%! $8! 9#(<+3)#! +'<)34+%! 78C%(! ^%6'c)! ;%+C8<U! %)!
G)#2A863%!P%('(D:R!in! a!N'<+! <6%! #('6'13%!@%! $8! 9#(<+3)#!+'<)34+%!bR!9'<9!$8! @3+%()3'6!@%!P8<+%6)!08+639!%)! ;'1363D<%!
Z356')R!#@V!`!=#$.$Q"#&R!6'C%1*+%!XT,,:V!
aJJb!;8)365!89!$%39<+%!78C%(!L#+'63D<%!Y$81*8+@!%)!Y+86p'39M0A8+$%9!q'$\\:R!in!a!=86@*''l!'6!)A%!%('6'13(9!'\!$%39<+%!bR!
9'<9!$8!@3+%()3'6!@%!G81<%$!081%+'6R!#@V!`!=,d&+,(=%V&+R!XT,,R!(A823)+%!-:V(
CDEJ( aJIb(?@<(8)3'6!86@!?('6'13(!_+'o)A!78C%(!;%639!0A%%l!%)!j'%$!G86)'9:R!XT,JR!36!International!Encyclopedia!of!Social!and!
Behavioral!SciencesR!X6@!%@VR!=%'61"6+V!
aJHb!;%9!A'11%9R!@%9!+%99'<+(%9!+8+%9!%)!@%!$8!)%(A6'$'53%!`!Nihil!novo!sub!sole!78C%(!0A+39)386!^%6!P8lA@8+!%)!Y8*+3(%!P%!
P%(:R!in!a!P8!)+8693)3'6!\<$5<+86)%!bR!9'<9!$8!@3+%()3'6!@%!N3%++%!_3'+5363R!#@V!`!`&^&+,V(
CDEH( aJFb(P8!2%36%!`!$%!2+3U!@<!(+31%!v!78C%(!^$86@36%!Z8$$%C8%h!%)!><9)81!>'1863<(:R!36!Le!sens!de!la!peineR!#@V(B_5&+Q&//&.R!
à!paraitreV!
(
M0I0 931+&V6'(
CDEH( aJYb!P8!\<$5<+86)%!+%(+#8)3'6!78C%(!N3%++%!_3'+5363:R!#@V!`!`&^&+,V(
(
M0H0 @+/"#%6'(6.(+*1"'"$.(,&.'(,6'(+6136'('#"6./"7"S36'(W(#$Q"/*(,6(%6#/3+6(
!
M0F0 N$#3Q6./'(,6(/+&1&"%('$3Q"'(R$3+(R3U%"#&/"$.(,&.'(,6'(+6136'('#"6./"7"S36'(W(#$Q"/*(,6(%6#/3+6(
e!!g!=<186! (823)8$! '\! %6)+%2+%6%<+9! 86@! m'*! (+%8)3'6`! ?C3@%6(%! \+'1! Y+%6(A! 13(+'@8)8!78C%(! _+#5'3+%! 08<(A3%R! 9'<139! /!
Applied!Economics:V!
e!!g! _%6@%+!@3\\%+%6(%9!36!9)+%99!81'65!%12$'h%%9`!d((<28)3'68$!9)+%99!39!6')!8$$y!78C%(!YVM0Vq'$\\R!9'<139!/!Public!Health:V!
!
M0Y0 @+/"#%6'(,6(13%V&+"'&/"$.(
(
CDDJ( P%9! A'13(3@%9! C'$'6)83+%9! %6! Y+86(%!`! B6%! #)<@%! #('6'1#)+3D<%! %U2$'+8)'3+%R! la# Tribune# du# Commissaire# de# PoliceR!
@#(%1*+%!XTTJV(