Argumentaire%
K)($! /(! +*#&'#*! ,#&+$6! 1#$! '(,#*.#(,'4($! *#.'#(-*4(,! $/*! 17#0+%*'#(5#! -#! *#5;#*5;#$! &#(%#$!
-)($! -'.#*$! 5)-*#$! -'$5'+1'()'*#$6! =! +)*,'*! -#! -'<<%*#(,#$! $4/*5#$! #,! #(! -'.#*$! 1'#/09! "4&&#(,!
54&+*#(-*#6! )++*4<4(-'*! #,! *#$,',/#*! 1)! 54(()'$$)(5#! -#$! 51)$$#$! +4+/1)'*#$6! +4/*! 1#$3/#11#$! 1#!
3/)*,'#*! -7;)>',),! @4/#! /(! *L1#! =! 1)! <4'$! #$$#(,'#16! #(! ,#*&#$! -#! *#$$4/*5#$! #,! -#! M! 5)+',)1!
-7)/,45;,4('#! N6! #,! )&>'.)1#(,6! #(! ,#*&#$! -#! -%+#(-)(5#! 145)1#! #,! -#! *)++4*,$! -#! -4&'(),'4(!O!
P4/$!)()12$#*4($!-#$!54(,#0,#$!&)*3/%$!+)*!1#!*#54/*$!=!17'(<4*!.4'*#!=!17'11%8)1',%!A455/+),'4(!
<4(5'Q*#6!)5,'.',%$! %54(4&'3/#$B! 3/'! +#/.#(,! #(,*)'(#*! -#$! (%845'),'4($! ).#5! 1#$! )/,4*',%$! #(!
+1)5#! A'(51/)(,6! +)*! #0#&+1#6! 1#! 51'#(,%1'$&#! %1#5,4*)1B6! &)'$! 3/'! +#/.#(,! )/$$'! #0+4$#*! 1#/*$!
;)>',)(,$!=!-#$!.'41#(5#$!+;2$'3/#!#,!$2&>41'3/#!A*%+*#$$'4(!+41'5'Q*#6!%.'5,'4($B9!!
K)($!/(!$#54(-!,#&+$6!'1!$7)8'*)6!-)($!5#!54(,#0,#!$+%5'<'3/#!-#$!3/)*,'#*$!+4+/1)'*#$6!-#!*%<1%5;'*!
)/0!#(@#/0!-#!17)55Q$!)/0!$4/*5#$!+4/*!1#!5;#*5;#/*!54&&#!+4/*!1#!+;4,48*)+;#6!=!1)!-%<'(','4(!
-#$! ,#**)'($! A1'#/0! #,! '(-'.'-/$! *#(54(,*%$6! '(,#*)5,'4($B6! =! 1)! &'$#! #(! .'$'>'1',%! -#$! $',/),'4($!
%,/-'%#$!+)*!1#!,#0,#!#,!+)*!17'&)8#!#,!=!1)!-'<</$'4(!-#$!*%$/1,),$!-#$!,*).)/09!?#!5*4'$#&#(,!#(,*#!
$5'#(5#$!$45')1#$!#,!+;4,48*)+;'#!(4/$!+)*)R,!=!5#!,',*#!+)*,'5/1'Q*#&#(,!<*/5,/#/0!-)($!1)!&#$/*#!
4S! 1)! 54($,*/5,'4(! -/! 5)-*#! +)*! 1#! +;4,48*)+;#! +#/,! *#(.42#*! &%,)+;4*'3/#&#(,! #,!
54(5*Q,#&#(,!1#!5;#*5;#/*!#(!$5'#(5#$!$45')1#$!=!1)!+*4+*#!54($,*/5,'4(6!+1/$!4/!&4'($!#0+1'5',#6!
-7/(!)/,*#!5)-*#6!,;%4*'3/#!#,!&%,;4-4148'3/#6!-)($!1#3/#1!'1!.)!'($5*'*#!$4(!,*).)'1!-7#(3/T,#!#,!
-7)()12$#6! #(! /(! #$+)5#! #,! #(! /(! ,#&+$! -4((%U9! ?#! +*#&'#*! #(@#/! -#! 5#,,#! @4/*(%#! #$,! -4(5! -#!
54&+*#(-*#!#(!3/4'!#,!-)($!3/#11#!&#$/*#!-#$!#0+%*'#(5#$!+1/*'#11#$!$/*!1#$!3/)*,'#*$!+4+/1)'*#$!
A*#5;#*5;#!#(!$5'#(5#$!$45')1#$!#,!+;4,48*)+;'#B!+#*&#,,#(,!-7)++*4<4(-'*!1)!54&+*%;#($'4(!-#$!
#$+)5#$!%,/-'%$!54&&#!1)!*%<1#0'4(!$/*!1)!-%&)*5;#!-#!*#5;#*5;#9!
V/!$#'(!-#$!$5'#(5#$!;/&)'(#$!#,!$45')1#$6!#(!+)*,'5/1'#*!-#!17)(,;*4+4148'#!+/'$!-#!1)!$45'4148'#6!
-#$! ,*).)/0! 4(,! #/! =! 5W/*! -#! -'$5/,#*! -#! 1)! &%,;4-4148'#! -#! 1)! *#5;#*5;#9! K#+/'$! 17X541#! -#!
";'5)84! #,! 1)! +*),'3/#! -#! M!17#(3/T,#! $45')1#!N! A"#<)Y! #,! )19! Z[U\B6! #,! @/$3/7=! )/@4/*-7;/'6! #(! 1'#(!
).#5! 1#$! 54(,#0,#$! $45'4]%54(4&'3/#$! -)($! 1#$3/#1$! +*#((#(,! 54*+$! &)'(,$! 4>$#*.),'4($! #,!
#(,*#,'#($!&#(%$!AE)$$'(!#,!^#($)6!Z[[_B6!-#!(4&>*#/$#$!%,/-#$!4(,!+4/*!)(5*)8#!1#$!3/)*,'#*$!
+4+/1)'*#$6!,4/5;)(,!)/0!,;%&),'3/#$!-#!1)!+)/.*#,%6!-#!1)!.'41#(5#6!-#!17'11%8)1',%!#,!-#!1)!-%.')(5#!
A`;2,#6! UaabcUadef6! !^4/*84'$6! Z[[U! C!D)/.)-#,6! Z[[b! +4/*! (g#(! 5',#*! 3/#! 3/#13/#$! /($B9!X11#$!
(4/$! $#&>1#(,! +4$#*! -#! &)('Q*#! +1/$! )'8/#! -#$! 3/#$,'4($! ,4/5;)(,! )/! -%*4/1#&#(,! -#! 1)!
*#5;#*5;#! #,! -#! 17%.#(,/#11#! #0+4$','4(! -/! 5;#*5;#/*! =! -'.#*$! *'$3/#$! +;2$'3/#$! #,! %&4,'4($!
AV8'#*6!UaahB9!X11#$!$4/1'8(#(,!17'&+4*,)(5#!-#!+*#(-*#!#(!54&+,#!1#$!#<<#,$!-#!17#(3/T,#!+4/*!1#$!
+4+/1),'4($9! X(<'(6! #11#$! -'$5/,#(,! -#! 1)! +4*,%#! -#$! $5'#(5#$! $45')1#$6! #(! +)*,'5/1'#*! 14*$! -#! 1)!
*#$,',/,'4(!-#$!,*).)/09!"4&&#(,!&)'(,#('*!/(!M!#(8)8#&#(,!-'$,)(5'%!N!A"#<)Y!#,!V&'*)/06!Z[[ZB!
i!54&&#(,!(#!+)$!,*);'*6!(#!+)$!T,*#!'($,*/&#(,)1'$%!&)'$!)/$$'!*#.#(-'3/#*6!%.#(,/#11#&#(,6!/(#!
<4*&#!-7#(8)8#&#(,!)/0!5L,%$!-#$!+4+/1),'4($!*#(54(,*%#$!AD5;#+#*]I/8/#$!UaaZB6!*#54(()R,*#!
17#(8)8#&#(,!-#!5#$!-#*('Q*#$!-)($!1#!+*45#$$/$!-#!*#5;#*5;#!#,!<)'*#!-#!1)!*#5;#*5;#!/(!4/,'1!)/!
$#*.'5#! -7/(! -'$54/*$! &'1',)(,! Aj1-<'#1-! Z[U\B!O! "#$! 3/#$,'4((#&#(,$! $#! $4(,! &/1,'+1'%$6! )/,4/*!
-#$! #0+*#$$'4($! -#! M!,#**)'($! &'(%$!N! A!"#$%&%'()* +,-$.-(/)6! Z[[UB!4/! #(54*#! M!$#($'>1#$!N!
A^4/'114(! #,! )196! Z[[\B6! +4'(,)(,! 17'(54(<4*,! -/! 5;#*5;#/*! -)($! 17#0#*5'5#! -74>@#5,'.),'4(! #,! -#!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
U!P4(!$)($!-%>),!)/!$#'(!-#$!5;)&+$!)5)-%&'3/#$!i!$/*!1)!(4,'4(!-70$1),2&-//6!1#!,#*&#!-#!8;#,,4!4/!#(54*#!17#<<#,!
3/)*,'#*k!