15?%/<,4<*'! -*'! 3%??*'7! ?%,1&4,1!
$*)&! .&5-)$/15! *1! $*)&! -/'6%,/0/$/15! K!
.&%/&*!.*!()B/$'!;*)$*,1!.&%/&*=!!
"!b$! Q! 4! ),*! .%,-/1/%,! 4$4&?4,1*! -*'!
.3%'*'! -4,'! ,%'! 5<$/'*'=! N4! 64&%$*! -)!
S*/<,*)&! -5.$4&*!8! "!w%'! /,/()/15'! %,1!
-51%)&,5! .*'! .3%'*'7! *1! ;%'! 65.35'! %,1!
&*1*,)!n.*'o!0%,,*'!.3%'*'!$%/,!-*!;%)'=!
D4&! /$! '*! 1&%);*! 64&?/! ?%,! 6*)6$*! -*'!
3%??*'!?5.34,1'!A!/$'!'%,1!4)O!4<)*1'7!
.%??*! .*$)/! ()/! ?*1! -*'! L/$*1'! A! /$'!
6%'*,1! ),! 6/@<*7! /$'! 411&46*,1! -*'!
3%??*'t! N*'! 6&%63@1*'! 6&%6351/'*,1!
4;*.!L4)''*157!*1!$*'!6&c1&*'!-/&/<*,1!64&!
$*)&!6%);%/&7!*1!?%,!6*)6$*!4/?*!$B4;%/&!
4/,'/!A!*1!()*!L*&*u+;%)'!-%,.!K!$4!L/,!_H=!
PQ7QM&'!R+*R.*S?!,)+!"!I1!/$'!%,1!64,'5! $4!
6$4/*! -*! $4! L/$$*! -*! ?%,! 6*)6$*! K! $4!
$5<@&*7!-/'4,1!8!24/O7!64/O7!()4,-!/$!,BQ!4!
64'! -*! 64/O!H=! PQ7QM&'! S+)/=! "!I1!
?4/,1*,4,17! 64&.*! ()*! ;%)'! 4;*u! L4/1!
1%)1*'! .*'! 4.1/%,'7! -/1! $*! SIb^MI>Y7! *1!
()*! E*! ;%)'! 4/! 64&$57! ?*! $*;4,1! 1v1! *1!
64&$4,17!?4/'!;%)'!,B4;*u!64'!*,1*,-)!A!
*1! E*! ;%)'! 4/! 466*$5'7! ?4/'! ;%)'! ,B4;*u!
64'! &56%,-)=! DB*'1! 6%)&()%/! E*! L*&4/! K!
.*11*! ?4/'%,7! ()/! *'1! 466*$5*! -*! ?%,!
,%?7! *,! $4()*$$*! ;%)'! ;%)'! L/*u7! *1! K! .*!
$/*)!()*!E*!;%)'!4/!-%,,57!K!;%)'!*1!K!;%'!
6@&*'7! .%??*! EB4/! L4/1! K! S/$%=! I1! E*! ;%)'!
.34''*&4/!-*!-*;4,1!?4!;)*7!.%??*!EB4/!
.34''5!1%)'!;%'!L&@&*'7!*1!?c?*!$B*,1/@&*!
'*?*,.*! -Bl63&4a?=! PQ7QM&'! T+),.)R=!!
U/*)!;4!4'')&5?*,1!4..%?6$/&!S4!64&%$*!
.%,.*&,4,1!.*)O! ()/! ,B5.%)1*&%,1! 64'7!
,*! ;*&&%,1! 64'! *1! &*L)'*,1! $4! $)?/@&*!
()Bb$!$*)&!*,;%/*!H=!))!"U?!*-S+,.*-T+/!
!
N4! -*&,/@&*! <5,5&41/%,! -*! $B#-;*,1/'?*!
*'1!$4!<5,5&41/%,!()/!.3*&.3*!-*'!'/<,*'=!
M%,! 64'! $4! 6&*);*! ()*! D3&/'1! -4,'! S4!
E)'1/.*! 4! 515! 3*)&*)O! -*! -%,,*&7! ?4/'!
.*$$*! ()/! '*! .%,L%&?*! K! '*'! 6&%6&*'!
135%&/*'!*1!/-5*'!*&&%,5*'=!!
!
!
6$!M#3%$!=$!41%(2!
DB*'1! K! $4! -*&,/@&*! <5,5&41/%,! -*!
$B#-;*,1/'?*! ()*! D3&/'1! 4-&*''*! .*'!
64&%$*'!8! "!t! 94/'! 4).),! '/<,*! ,*! $)/!
'*&4! -%,,57! '/! .*! ,B*'1! $*! '/<,*! -)!
6&%63@1*! C%,4'!H=! 94113/*)! Wj=kp=! #!
$B56%()*! -*! D3&/'1! .*'! 64&%$*'! L4/'4/*,1!
4$$)'/%,!K!S4!?%&1!!*1!K!S4!&5')&&*.1/%,7!
-*! ,%'! E%)&'7! ()*! .%??),/()*,1+*$$*'!
4)! 6*)6$*! -*! U/*)!_! C%,4'! 514/1! -4,'! $*!
;*,1&*! -)! <&4,-! 6%/''%,! -)&4,1! 1&%/'!
E%)&'! *1! 1&%/'! ,)/1'! ()/! *'1! ),! 1Q6*! -)!
?*''4<*! -*'! 1&%/'! 4,<*'! ()/! *'1! ;5&/15!
6&5'*,1*! 6%)&! ,%)'! 4)E%)&-B3)/=! N*'!
?*''4<*'!-*'!1&%/'!4,<*'!'%,1!$*'!;5&/15'!
()/!'*!1&%);*,1!')&!$*'!.4&1*'!-*!Wq[k!*1!
WqZX=! VZ\! N*'! ?*''4<*'! ')&! .*'! .4&1*'!
'%,1!$*'!L%,-*?*,1'!-*!$B#-;*,1/'?*=!b$'!
'%,1!4)''/!.%?64&5'!4)!Y%.3*&!-*'!#<*'!
Vs\=! N4! .%?6&53*,'/%,! -)! ?*''4<*! -*'!
1&%/'! 4,<*'! 4! 515! %0'.)&./*! 64&!
$B4..*6141/%,! -*'! L4)''*'! 135%&/*'! *1!
?513%-*'! -B/,1*&6&5141/%,! 0/0$/()*=!
94/'!.*'!L%,-*?*,1'7!()/!'%,1!4)''/!"!$*'!
4,./*,'!'*,1/*&'!H!')&!$*'()*$'!$*!6*)6$*!
-*! U/*)! *'1! 466*$5! K! &*1%)&,*&7! '%,1!
?4/,1*,4,1! *,! 1&4/,! -Bc1&*! &*'14)&5'=!
VC5&5?/*! s=Ws\=! I1! *,! &5')$141! -*! $*)&!
&*'14)&41/%,7! $*'! ?*''4<*'! -*'! 1&%/'!
4,<*'! '%,1! .%?6&/'! *1! 6&%.$4?5'! -*!
,%);*4)=!!
!
N).! WW=kX! -5.$4&*! ()*! C%,4'! $)/+?c?*!
514/1!),!'/<,*!6%)&!$*'!M/,/;/1*'=!!
!
"!I1! ()4,-! $*! 6*)6$*! 'B4?4''47! /$!
.%??*,J4!K! -/&*!8! DB*'1!),*! <5,5&41/%,!
6*&;*&'*7!*$$*!-*?4,-*!),!'/<,*7!*1!/$!,*!
$)/! '*&4! 64'! -%,,5! -*! '/<,*7! '/,%,! $*!
'/<,*!-*! C%,4'! $*! 6&%63@1*=! D4&! .%??*!
C%,4'! L)1! ),! '/<,*! 6%)&! $*'! M/,/;/1*'7!
4/,'/! '*&4! 4)''/! $*! F/$'! -B3%??*! 6%)&!
.*11*!<5,5&41/%,!H=!N).!WW=jp+kX!
!
N4! '/<,/L/.41/%,! -)! ,%?! C%,4'! *'1!
"!.%$%?0*!H=! #! $B56%()*! -*! D3&/'17! $*!
S4/,1+I'6&/1! -*'.*,-/1! '%)'! $4! L%&?*!
-B),*!.%$%?0*!K!S%,!0461c?*=!DB514/1!),!
'/<,*! 6%)&! C*4,+]461/'1*! *1! 6%)&! $4!
,41/%,!E)/;*!()*!D3&/'1!514/1!$*!9*''/*=!!
!