(In)esthétique des arts de l`Islam? - E

Université Paris VIII
Vincennes -Saint–Denis
Ecole doctorale: Pratiques et Théories du sens.
Département de Philosophie et d’Esthétique
.
Doctorat de philosophie:
Problématiques de l’image.
(In)esthétique des arts de l’Islam?
Doctorant:
Monsieur: Naceur KHEMIRI.
Thèse dirigée par :
Professeur :
Alain BADIOU .
Soutenue le : 29 Juin 2010.
Jury:
Professeur : René Schérer
Professeur : Jean Marc Lachaud
Professeur : Mohamed Mahjoub
Docteur : Youssef Seddik

2
'pGLFDFH
♣$PHVFKHUVSDUHQWVTXLP·RQWVRXWHQXWRXWDXORQJGHPRQFXUVXVVDQV
YRLUPDUpXVVLWHGHOHXUYLYDQW
♣$PDIHPPHTXLDVXSSRUWpPHVFULVHVG·KXPHXUjFDXVHG·XQOLYUHTXHMH
Q·DLSDVWURXYpRXG·XQHLGpHTXHMHQHSDUYHQDLVSDVjPHQHUjVRQWHUPH
♣ $PRQGLUHFWHXUGHWKqVH$ODLQ%DGLRXTXLP·DVRXWHQXSDWLHPPHQW
ORUVGHVGLIILFXOWpVUHQFRQWUpHVDXFRXUVGHPHVDQQpHVGHUHFKHUFKHHWTXL
P·DSDUDLOOHXUVRXYHUWOHV\HX[VXUODULFKHVVHGHODSKLORVRSKLHIUDQoDLVH
FRQWHPSRUDLQH
♣$WRXV©FHX[TXLVRQWSDUWLVGHFKH]HX[HW TXL RQWOHV ODUPHV DX[
\HX[ª
♣ $©WRXVFHX[TXLDFFXHLOOHQWHWUHVSHFWHQWO· A XWUHª
3DULVOH-XLQ

3
Table des Matières.
,QWURGXFWLRQ3UREOpPDWLTXHGHO·LPDJHSUREOpPDWLTXH"  
35(0,(5(3$57,(3UREOpPDWLTXHVGHO·LPDJH" 
&KDSLWUH,/HVPRQRORJRWKpLVPHVHWODUHSUpVHQWDWLRQ
LFRQRFODVWH
5HOLJLRQVGXOLYUHRXUHOLJLRQGHO·LPDJHGDQVOHVWURLV
PRQRORJRWKpLVPHV  
/·LPDJHLQWHUGLWHGHODUHSUpVHQWDWLRQ  
&KDSLWUH,,/D5pVLVWDQFHKDUPRQLHXVHGHODSRpWLTXHHQ,UDQ 
/DFULWLTXHGHVRULHQWDOLVWHVOLQJXLVWHVGHYDQWODSRpWLTXHSHUVDQH
/·DUFKLWH[WXUHU\WKPLTXHGDQVODSRpVLHSHUVDQH  
'MDOkODG'vQ5Pv3RqPHVG·DPRXUHWGHPRUWP\VWLTXH  
2PDU.KD\\kPOHOLEHUWLQ 
/·DPRXUGHVDPSKLERORJLHVLOWLEkV  
/·DPRXUFRXUWRLVRX/DFRXUG·DPRXU  
&KDSLWUH,,,/HVMDUGLQVRULHQWDX[FRPPHSDUDFKqYHPHQWGHVDUWV
GHO·,VODP 
7UDQVSRVLWLRQGHVMDUGLQVSHUVDQV  
)RQFWLRQGHVMDUGLQVPRJKROV  
'(8;,(0(3$57,(9HUVXQHLQHVWKpWLTXHGHVDUWVLVODPLTXHV"
&KDSLWUH,5HWRXUVVXUO·LPDJLQDWLRQFUpDWULFH 

4
/·H[SpULHQFHP\VWLTXHXQLYHUVHOOH  
D,EQ¶$UDEvÇODPDOPLWKkO
E7KpUqVH'·$YLODO·XQLRQP\VWLTXH 
/H1pR.DQWLVPHHWO·LPDJLQDWLRQ  
D/·LPDJLQDWLRQLQGpSDVVDEOH 
E/HVFDKLHUVGHO·$WKHQDHXPHWODSUREOpPDWLTXHGX5RPDQWLVPH
$OOHPDQG 
%DFKHODUGHWO·LPDJLQDWLRQPDWpULHOOHFRPPHSRVLWLYLWp  
&KDSLWUH,,(VWKpWLTXHVGHO·(WHUQHO5HWRXU2ULHQWDOGkZU 
5HWRXUDX[)RUPHVGHO·,QWHOOHFW$JHQWFKH]3ORWLQ 
/HUHWRXUDX[WUDGLWLRQVSODWRQLFLHQQHVHWQpRSODWRQLFLHQQHVHQ
2ULHQW  
D5HSUpVHQWDWLRQHWLFRQRFODVPHGDQVOHVDUWVHQ,VODP 
E/·DUWGHODILJXUDWLRQILJXUDOH  
(WHUQHOUHWRXUVXU$YLFHQQH,EQ6LQDOH3DVVHXUGHV'HX[ULYHV
D/·LPDJLQDWLRQFRPPHUHSURGXFWLYH 
E/·LPDJLQDWLRQDFWLYHHWFUpDWULFH  
6RKUDZDUGL/·,PDJLQDODJHQWHWPpGLDWHXU  
D+HUPpQHXWLTXH 
E3KpQRPpQRORJLTXH
+DOOkMODOpJHQGHGRUpHGXFDUGHXU 
D/HVDQJHWODOHWWUHG·$OODK
E/DFRQIRUPLWpGH+DOOkMjO·LPDJHFRUDQLTXHGH-pVXV  
F/·pFULWXUHLQILQLHGH'LHX 
0ROOk6DGUk&KLUD]L©SRLQWFRQFOXVLIGHODSKLORVRSKLH
LVODPLTXHª"  
/HVSKLORVRSKHVHQLVODPVHWOHPRQGHLPDJLQDO  
&KDSLWUH,,,/·LPDJLQDOHQpJDWLWp
/DVSHFWUDOLWpGHVGRXEOHV 
)RUPHV6FKqPHV6SHFWUHV  
D/HSODLVLUQpJDWLIRX&RORQQH&RORVVDOH 
E)LJXUDORXGLVFRXUV" 
752,6,(0(3$57,($UWRX(VWKpWLTXH"  

5
&KDSLWUH,1LHW]VFKHFHOXLTXLIDLVDLWEpJD\HUODODQJXH  
&ULWLTXHGHO·pJRFHQWULVPH 
/HVFRUSVH[LVWHQWFRPPHPDFKLQHVGpVLUDQWHV  
&RPPHQWQHSDVSDUOHUGHO·ÈWUH"  
&KDSLWUH,,/HVFDOOLJUDSKLHVDUDEHVFRPPHUDSSRUWVDXFRUSV
RULHQWDO 
/·DUWGHO·pFULWXUHDUDEH 
&DOOLJUDSKLHWDSLVHWVXUIDFHG·LQVFULSWLRQ  
&KDSLWUH,,,+HLGHJJHUHWOHQDWLRQDOHVWKpWLVPH  
/·DUWHQWDQWTXHPLVHHQMHXGHODYpULWp  
/·KDUPRQLHGXSHQVHUSRpWLVHU  
/·LPDJHGHODPDXYDLVHIRL-36DUWUH 
&KDSLWUH,9'LVFRXUVHWLQ(VWKpWLTXH" 
/·$UFKLWH[WXUDO/D3LHUUH1RLUHFRPPHFHQWUHHWRULJLQH 
/·LPDJLQDLUHDUDERLVODPLTXHFRPPHDEVWUDFWLRQSXUH  
&KDSLWUH93RXUVWDWXHUVXUO·LQHVWKpWLTXH  
/HVWDWXWIRUPHOGHO·LQHVWKpWLTXH  
D(VWKpWLTXHRXLQHVWKpWLTXH"  
E(QGpIHQVHGHO·LQHVWKpWLTXH 
0DOODUPpDXWUHPHQWGLUH  
&RQFOXVLRQVRXIRUFOXVLRQSRXUQHSDVFRQFOXUH"  
7DEOHGHV,OOXVWUDWLRQV  