LA FRATERNITE DANS LA TRADITION REPUBLICAINE

LA#FRATERNITE#DANS#LA#TRADITION#REPUBLICAINE#
!
#
#
I# -# Retour# sur# l’histoire#:# la# place# et# le# rôle# de# la# fraternité# dans# la# dynamique#
sociale#et#politique##
#
"#!$%#&'%()&*!+,,-.'!-('!./#,'!,'(&%#/'!0#(1! /#! &%#0)&)+(! %*.-2/),#)('3! 4! .%'-5'6! /#!
0'5)1'! %*.-2/),#)('!7! 8! .%'-5'! #-11)6! 1+(! )(1,%).&)+(! 0#(1! /#! ,+(1&)&-&)+(6! ,'! 9-)! ('! 1'!
%'&%+-5'!.%#&)9-':'(&!(-//'!.#%&!#)//'-%1!7!8!.%'-5'!'($)(6!/'1!0)1,+-%1!'($/#::*1!9-;'//'!#!
1-1,)&*1! 0'.-)1! <=>?6! #5',! @)%#2'#-! .%+,/#:#(&!A! B!C+-1! ,+::'(D+(1! /;E)1&+)%'! 0'1!
E+::'16! /;E)1&+)%'! 0'1! $%F%'1!G6! #5',! H#:)//'! I'1:+-/)(1! )(5)&#(&! 8! B!%'J#%0'%! &+-1! /'1!
E+::'1!'&!&+-1!/'1!.'-./'1!,+::'!0'1!$%F%'1!G3!I'1!&%+)1!5#/'-%1!0'!/#!0'5)1'6!/#!$%#&'%()&*!
'1&!/#!./-1!$%*:)11#(&'3!K//'!1-1,)&'!/;*:+&)+(!$-1)+(('//'!'&!#%%#,E'6!8!/;+,,#1)+(!0'1!/#%:'1!
,+:.#11)+(('//'13!!
!
! @#)1! ,'! 9-)! $#)&! 1#! J%#(0'-%! $#)&! #-11)! 1#! $#)2/'11'3! H#%6! 1+(! ,+(&'(-! 1'! %*5F/'!
):.%*,)16!)(,'%&#)(!'&!.%'19-'!8!.%+.+%&)+(!)(5'%1'!0'!1#!.-)11#(,'!)(,#(&#&+)%'3!"#!/)2'%&*!'&!
/;*J#/)&*!0+(('(&!8!.'(1'%!'(!&'%:'1!0'!.%)(,).'1!'&!0'!0%+)&13!"'1!#../),#&)+(1!'(!1':2/'(&!
.%'19-'!*5)0'(&'1!'&! )::*0)#&'13!"#!$%#&'%()&*6!'//'6! $#)&!5)2%'%!8!%#)1+(! 0'!9-'/9-'!,E+1'!
9-)! %'/F5'! 0'! /;)(&-)&)+(! ./-1! 9-'! 0-! %#)1+((':'(&3! L#,E'%+&! #5#)&! %#)1+(!A! B!"#! /)2'%&*! '&!
/;*J#/)&*! 1+(&! 0'1! .%)(,).'16&#(0)1! 9-'! /#! $%#&'%()&*! (;'1&! 9-;-(! 1'(&):'(&!G3!M+(! %'J)1&%'!
.%+.%'!'1&!/#!:+%#/'6!/'!0'5+)%!./-1!9-'!/'1!0%+)&13!N/!(;O!#!.#1!0'!0%+)&!8!/#!$%#&'%()&*!:P:'!1)!
0'1! 0%+)&1! .'-5'(&! '(! 0*,+-/'%3! H+::'! /'! 0)&! 1)! 2)'(! @+(#! QR+-$6! B!1#! .-)11#(&'! ,E#%J'!
#$$',&)5'6!9-'!1+-/)J('!-('!),+(+J%#.E)'!./')('!0;+)1'#-S6!0'!,T-%16!0'!2#:2)(16!0'!2#)1'%16!
0'!2+-9-'&16!0)1.'(1'!0'!/#!.%*,)1'%!0#5#(&#J'6!':.P,E'!0'!/-)!#&&#,E'%!-('!%'5'(0),#&)+(!
'&!0'!.%*5+)%!-('!1#(,&)+(!#-S!:#(9-':'(&1!9-)!.+-%%#)'(&!/-)!P&%'!$#)&1!<!G3!!
!
U#1!*&+((#(&!9-;'//'!5)'(('!'(!&%+)1)F:'!./#,'!0#(1!/#!0'5)1'6!-('!./#,'!0'!B!.#%'(&'!
.#-5%'!G! V! @+(#! QR+-$! W! )J(+%*'! .#%! /#! I*,/#%#&)+(! 0'1! 0%+)&1! 0'! <=>?6! )(&*J%*'! #5',!
0)1,%*&)+(! #-! 0)1.+1)&)$! ,+(1&)&-&)+(('/! '(! <=?<! '&! %',+((-'! '(! ./*()&-0'! '(! <>X>3! Y('!
%*$*%'(,'!0'!,'!()5'#-!'1&!0;#)//'-%1!B!.%+.%'!8!/#!Z%#(,'!G!V!C+%#!W3!
!Elle#va#pourtant#très#activement#contribuer#à#l’édification#du#droit#social#sur#ses#
deux#versants#:#celui#de#l’assistance,#de#la#protection#sociale#et#celui#du#travail,#en#tant#
que#pensée#de#la#relation,#de#l’«#entre-deux#»#négligé#par#ses#grandes#sœurs.#
!
! Q(!$)()%#6!'(!'$$'&6!#11'R!5)&'!.#%!.%'(0%'!,+(1,)'(,'!0'1!)(1-$$)1#(,'1!0'!/#!/)2'%&*!'&!
0'!/;*J#/)&*!,#(&+((*'1!#-!%'J)1&%'!)(0)5)0-#/)1&'!0'1!0%+)&1!1-2[',&)$13!N/!'1&!5%#)!9-'!/;*J#/)&*!
,%*'! -(! #..'/! 0'! 1+,)#/! '(! &'%:'1! 0'! ,+%%',&)+(\%'0)1&%)2-&)+(6! :#)1! ,;'1&! 1-%! -(! :+0'!
,+:.#%#&)$!'(&%'!0'1!)(0)5)0-1!0':'-%#(&!'S&*%)'-%1!5+)%'!*&%#(J'%1!/'1!-(1!#-S!#-&%'13!Y('!
$+)1! %':./)! 0'! 1'1! 0%+)&16! ,E#,-(! %'(&%'! ,E'R! 1+)3! M'-/'! /#! $%#&'%()&*! .'%:'&! 0'! %'(0%'!
,+:.&'!0'!/#! 0O(#:)9-'!:+%#/'!'&! .+/)&)9-'!0'!/;#&&'(&)+(!8! #-&%-)6!0-!1',+-%1! 9-)!/-)!'1&!
.+%&*!'&!0'!/;#,&)+(!,+::-('!'(!5-'!0;-('!T-5%'!0'![-1&),'3!4O#(&!1+(!1)&'!0#(1!/#!%'/#&)+(6!
'//'!'1&!la#vertu#de#l’entre-deux,#l’âme#du#lien#social!2)'(&]&![-%)0)9-':'(&!0*,/)(*'3!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
1 Dictionnaire de la Révolution française, p. 731.

!
! <^! W! I;#2+%0! 1-%! /'! $%+(&! 0;-%J'(,'! 0'! /;#11)1&#(,'! +%J#()1*'! .+-%! %*.+(0%'! 8! /#!
B!0'&&'! 1#,%*'! 0'! /#! (#&)+(!G! V! "#! _+,E'$+-,#-/&\")#(,+-%&6! H+:)&*! 0'! :'(0),)&*! 1+-1! /#!
H+(5'(&)+(! W! 5)1\8\5)1! 0'1! 5),&):'1! 0-! 1+%&!A! /'1! B!)(':./+O#2/'1!G6! /'1! :#/#0'16! /'1! 5)'-S!
&%#5#)//'-%16! /'1! 5),&):'1! 0'1! ,#&#1&%+.E'1! +-! 0'1! J-'%%'13! "#! $%#&'%()&*! #! 5)1#J'! 0'!
1+//),)&-0'! '&! 0'! ,+:.#11)+(3! K//'! 0+(('! -('! 0):'(1)+(! .+/)&)9-'! 8! /#! 9-'1&)+(! B!`-;#1\&-!
$#)&!0'!&+(!$%F%'!a!G3!K&!,'!(;'1&!.#1!-(!E#1#%0!1)!/#!%*5+/-&)+(!0'!<>X>!1)!.*&%)'!0;)(1.)%#&)+(!
*5#(J*/)9-'! /#! ./#,'! #-! ,T-%! 0'! 1+(! .%+['&! 9-)! '(&'(0! #11-%'%! B!.#%! -('! #11)1&#(,'!
$%#&'%('//'b! /;'S)1&'(,'! 0'1! ,)&+O'(1! (*,'11)&'-S!G3! I;+c! /'! $%*:)11':'(&! 9-)! .#%,+-%&! /'!
0)1,+-%1!.+/)&)9-'!0'!/;*.+9-'3!4)(1)6!d-/'1!I-$#-%'!.+-%!9-)!B!/;#11)1&#(,'!%*1-:'!0*1+%:#)1!
/'!J%#(0!0'5+)%!0'!$%#&'%()&*!9-'!/#!_*.-2/)9-'!#!.+-%!:)11)+(!0;#,,+:./)%3!U+-%!/#!.%':)F%'!
$+)1!/'!.%*,'.&'!,E%*&)'(!9-)!#!%'(+-5'/*!/#!$#,'!0-!:+(0'!)/!O!#!0)S\E-)&!,'(&1!#(1!0'5)'(&!/#!
2#1'!0'!&+-&!-(!,+0'!#0:)()1&%#&)$!G3!
!
! @#)1!1)!/#!(#&)+(!1'!%',+((#e&!-('!0'&&'!8!/;*J#%0!0'1!B!(*,'11)&'-S!G!,;'1&!.#%,'!9-'!
,'1! 0'%()'%1! +(&! 1#(1! 0+-&'! 9-'/9-'1! 0%+)&1! 8! $#)%'! 5#/+)%! 9-)! 5+(&! 0+(('%! (#)11#(,'! 8! /#!
,#&*J+%)'! 0'1! B!0%+)&1\,%*#(,'1!G6! 0'1! B!0%+)&1! à!G6! -('! (+-5'//'! J*(*%#&)+(! 0'1! 0%+)&1! 0'!
/;E+::'!8!/#!%#,)('!0;-(!0%+)&!1+,)#/!0+(&!/'!.*%):F&%'!('!,'11'%#!0'!1;*/#%J)%3!K(!<>X>!A!/'!
0%+)&!à!/;#11)1&#(,'!'&!/'!0%+)&!au!&%#5#)/!'&!0'!.%+,E'!'(!.%+,E'!/'!0%+)&!à!/;'S)1&'(,'6!/'!0%+)&!
à!/#!.%+&',&)+(6!/'!0%+)&!à!/#!1#(&*6!à!/;*0-,#&)+(!b!";K&#&!.%+5)0'(,'!&%+-5'!/8!1#!:#&%),'3!!
!
! f^! W! I#(1! /'! :P:'! &':.16! /'! :+(0'! 0-! &%#5#)/! 'S.*%):'(&'! /#! .-)11#(,'! 0'! /#!
$%#&'%()&*!.+-%!$#)%'!$#,'!#-S!#/*#1!0'!/;'S)1&'(,'!1-%!-(!:+0'!#-&+(+:'!'&!.+-%!%*1)1&'%!8!
1+(!&%)1&'! 1+%&3!I'!/8!/'1!1)!(+:2%'-1'1!1+,)*&*1! B!$%#&'%('//'1!G!9-)!.%+/+(J'(&!/#!&%#0)&)+(!
0'1! ,+($%*%)'1! '&! 0-! ,+:.#J(+((#J'! '&! +%J#()1'(&! 0'1! 1O1&F:'1! 0'! 1',+-%1! .+-%! /'1!
#11+,)*1!'(!0)$$),-/&*!0-!$#)&!0'!/#!:#/#0)'6!0'!/;gJ'!+-!0'!/;#,,)0'(&!0-!&%#5#)/3!B!h+-1!.+-%!
-(6! -(! .+-%! &+-1!G6! /;-()+(! $#)1#(&! /#! $+%,'6! ,'1! 1+,)*&*1! 0'5)'(('(&! 0'1! 1+,)*&*1! 0'!
%*1)1&#(,'! 9-)! .%*$)J-%'(&! /'1! 1O(0),#&13! "'! 0%+)&! 0-! &%#5#)/! &%+-5'! 0#(1! ,'&&'! E)1&+)%'! /'1!
%'11+%&1! 0'! 1#! 0O(#:)9-'! $+(0*'6! .#%\0'/8! /#! 1-2+%0)(#&)+(! 0-! ,+(&%#)&! 0'! &%#5#)/6! 1-%! /#!
%',E'%,E'!0'!/;*9-)/)2%'!0#(1!/'1!%'/#&)+(1!)(0)5)0-'//'1!'&!,+//',&)5'13!!!
!
! I+(,6!1-%!/'1!0'-S!5'%1#(&16!#&&'1&#&#)%'!'&!,+(&'1&#&#)%'6!0;-()+(!'&!0'!,+:2#&6!0'!
%#..%+,E':'(&!.#%$+)1! ,+::-()'/!:#)1!#-11)!0;'S,/-1)+(!f6!/#!$%#&'%()&*! [+-'!1-%!./-1)'-%1!
%'J)1&%'1!A! ,'/-)! 0'! /;)0'(&)&*! :):*&)9-'6! 2#1'! 0'1! ,+#/)&)+(1! '&! #11+,)#&)+(1! .#%&),-/)F%'1!7!
,'/-)! 0'! /#! ,+:./*:'(&#%)&*! 0'1! 0)$$*%'(,'1! '(&%'! /'1! )(0)5)0-1! '&! /'1! J%+-.'1! 0#(1! -('!
1+,)*&*!:'(#,*'!0'!$%#,&-%'3!
!
! H;'1&! [-1&':'(&! ,'! 1+-,)! 0'! :#()$'1&'%! /#! ,+:./*:'(&#%)&*! '(&%'! 0'1! J%+-.'1!
1+,)#-S! 9-'! /'-%1! )(&*%P&1! 1*.#%'(&! 9-)! ,+(0-)%#! /'1! _*.-2/),#)(1! 8! .%+:+-5+)%! 1+-1! /#!
E+-/'&&'!0'!I-%iE'):!/;)0*'!0'!1+/)0#%)&*!1-%!-('!2#1'!:+)(1!*&E)9-'!9-;':.)%)9-'6!:+)(1!
#$$',&)5'! 9-'! %#&)+(('//'3! "#! $%#&'%()&*! ,+((#e&%#6! 0'! ,'! $#)&6! -(! '$$#,':'(&! 1)(+(! -('!
*,/).1'3!
!
!#Est-ce#à#dire#que#fraternité#a#été#remplacée#par#la#solidarité#?#
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
2 D’où le cri de ralliement de la Révolution française : « la fraternité ou la mort ». Cf. Marcel David, Fraternité et révolution
française, Aubier, 1987 et notre article « Le frère-ennemi ou le tragique de la fraternité », in Les droits de l’homme à l’aube
du XIXe siècle, Bruylant, 1999, p. 1041sqq.

#
#H;'1&!/#%J':'(&!5%#)!1-%!/'!./#(!0-!/#(J#J'!.-)19-'!/;-1#J'!0-!:+&!0*,/)('3!K(!,'/#!
+(! .'-&! .#%/'%! 0'! :)1'! '(! 5')//'-1'3! @#)1! /;)(&-)&)+(! 0+(&! '//'! '1&! .+%&'-1'! 0':'-%'!
1+-&'%%#)(':'(&!#,&)5'3!!
!
! "#!9-'1&)+(!'1&!0'!1#5+)%!.+-%9-+)!/'1!_*.-2/),#)(1!*.%+-5'(&!0#(1!/'1!#((*'1!<>>j!
/'!2'1+)(!0;-(!&'/!0*./#,':'(&!&'%:)(+/+J)9-'3!!
!
! N/! O! #! #-! :+)(1! 0'-S! %#)1+(1! 8! ,'/#!A! 0;#2+%0! /#! $+%&'! ,+((+&#&)+(! %'/)J)'-1'! 0'! /#!
$%#&'%()&*6! 1-%&+-&! #.%F1! <>X>6! )(,+:.#&)2/'! #5',! /;'1.%)&! /#k,)1&'! 0+:)(#(&!7! '(1-)&'6! '&!
1-%&+-&6!,+::'!['!5)'(1!0'!/;)(0)9-'%6!/#!5+/+(&*!0'!$#)%'!0'!/#!1+/)0#%)&*!./-1!9-;-('!5#/'-%6!
-(!$#)&6!-(!0+((*!8!%',+((#e&%'!,+::'!&'/!'&!8!+%J#()1'%3!"'!.#1&'-%)1:'!#!'-!1+(!%]/'!0#(1!
,'&&'!*5+/-&)+(!'(!0*:+(&%#(&!/#!1+/)0#%)&*!(*J#&)5'!8!/#!2#1'!0'!/#!,+(&#:)(#&)+(!.#%!/'1!
:#/#0)'13! @#)1! ,;'1&! 0'! :#()F%'! 0*,)1)5'! K:)/'! I-%iE'):! '&! 1+(! *,+/'! 9-)! 5+(&! &E*+%)1'%!
/;)(&'%0*.'(0#(,'! '(&%'! /'1! )(0)5)0-1! .#%! /'! ['-! 0'! /#! 0)5)1)+(! 0-! &%#5#)/! 1+,)#/6!
)(&'%0*.'(0#(,'! ,+::'! $#)&! 1+,)#/! &%#(1:-*! '(! 5#/'-%! '&! '(! .%)(,).'! 0;+%)'(&#&)+(! 0;-('!
.+/)&)9-'!,'(1*'!*&')(0%'!/#!/-&&'! 0'1!,/#11'1!.#%! /;-()&*!(#&)+(#/'!1+,)#/':'(&! %*#/)1*'3!K&!
$+(0*'!.#%!9-+)!a!KE!2)'(6!.#%!/;#11-%#(,'!9-)!('!5)'(&!.#1!0'!/#!5'%&-!:#)1!0'!/;)(&*%P&!2)'(!
,+:.%)16!/;#5#(&#J'!%'&)%*!.+-5#(&!P&%'!.+-%!,E#,-(!'&!.+-%!/#!1+,)*&*!'//'\:P:'!'(!&'%:'1!
0'!.#,)$),#&)+(6!)($)():'(&!1-.*%)'-%!8!/#!:)1'!)()&)#/'3!@#)1!#/+%1!9-'!/#!$%#&'%()&*![+-'!1-%!/'1!
%'11':2/#(,'16!/'1!1):)/#%)&*1!'(&%'!0'1!B!1':2/#2/'1!G6!/#!1+/)0#%)&*!1;#,,+::+0'!$+%&!2)'(!
0-!['-!0'1!0)$$*%'(,'13!K&!D;'1&!,'/#!/'!,+-.!0'!J*()'!9-)!.'%:'&&%#!0#(1!-(!.%':)'%!&':.1!
0;+%J#()1'%!-('!./-1![-1&'!)(0':()1#&)+(!0'1!#,,)0'(&1!0-!&%#5#)/!V!/+)!0;#5%)/!<>?>!W!#5#(&!0'!
1;*&'(0%'!8!/;'(1':2/'!0'!/;#,&)5)&*!1+,)#/'!O!,+:.%)16!&%F1!&]&6!/'1!#,,)0'(&1!0'!,)%,-/#&)+(6!
.-)1! /#! :#/#0)'! '(! <?lj! .+-%! ,-/:)('%! 0#(1! /'! 1O1&F:'! 0'! 1*,-%)&*! 1+,)#/'! 0'! <?Xm\<?Xn3!
U#&%+(16! +-5%)'%16! ':./+O*1!A! &+-1! 0#(1! /#! :P:'! ,#)11'!o! K(! &'%:'1! 0;):#J)(#)%'! 1+,)#/!
-()$),#&'-%6!/;'$$'&!'1&!*(+%:'!'&!/;+(! :'1-%'! %*&%+1.',&)5':'(&! 8! 9-'/! .+)(&!/#!1+,)+/+J)'!
(#)11#(&'! $-&! -('! 1+,)+/+J)'! .+/)&)9-'3! H'! 0+(&! ('! 1'! ,#,E#)'(&! 0;#)//'-%1! ()! I-%iE'):!
+21*0*! .#%! /#! E#(&)1'! 0'! /#! %*5+/-&)+(6! ()! #! $+%&)+%)! 0'1! J'(1! ,+::'! "3! p+-%J'+)1! +-! 43!
Z+-)//*'!9-)!/#(,'%+(&!/;)0*+/+J)'!+%J#()9-'!0'!/#!NNN'!_*.-2/)9-'!A!/'!solidarisme3!!!
!
! @#)1!)/!$#-&! 0)%'!9-'!:P:'! 8!,'&&'!*.+9-'6!/#! $%#&'%()&*!(;'1&!.#1! &+&#/':'(&!:)1'!
1+-1! ,/+,E'3! K//'! ,+(&)(-'! 0;#..#%#e&%'! 0#(1! /'! 0)1,+-%1! 0'! ,'%&#)(1! #-&'-%1! '&! (+(! 0'1!
:+)(0%'13!@),E'/'&6!.#%!'S':./'!.+-%!9-)!B!/#!$%#&'%()&*6!,;'1&!/'!0%+)&!.#%!0'11-1!/'!0%+)&!G3!
K&! /'! J%#(0! [-%)1&'! @#-%),'! q#-%)+-6! ,#&E+/)9-'! )/! '1&! 5%#)6! 9-)! $#)&! 0'! /#! $%#&'%()&*! -(!
1O(+(O:'!0'!/#!1+,)#2)/)&*3!!H+::'!-(!B!*/#(!5)&#/!G!2'%J1+()'(6!-('!*&+)/'!&)%#(&!/#!,E#%%-'!
0'!/#!1+/)0#%)&*!./-1!)::*0)#&':'(&!.%+,E'!0-!&'%%#)(3!!
!
! Q(! %*#/)1'6! #-! $+(06! 9-'! /#! 1+/)0#%)&*! 5#! :+)(1! .%+$+(0! 9-'! /#! $%#&'%()&*3! U+-%!
%'.%'(0%'!/;)0*'!1)!,EF%'!8!q#-%)+-!0;)(1&)&-&)+(!0+(&!)/!$-&!/'!J%#(0!&E*+%),)'(6!/#!$%#&'%()&*!1'!
%*5F/'!./-1!)(1&)&-#(&'!9-'!/#!1+/)0#%)&*3!K//'!'1&!)($%#\)(1&)&-#(&'3!K&!/;#5'()%!5#!/'!,+($)%:'%#3!!
!
#
#
#
#

II#-#Son#retour#comme#principe#d’orientation#en#situation#de#crise#
##
Aujourd’hui,# alternative# crédible#dans# les# pratiques# et# modes# d'organisation#
socio-économiques#?##
!
! d'! /'! .'(1'! '(! '$$'&! '&! ['! %'[+)(1! 1-%! ,'! .+)(&6! ,+::'! 1-%! 0;#-&%'16! :+(! ,+//FJ-'!
@),E'/! p+%J'&&+! 9-)! 0*$'(0! /;)0*'! 0;-(! réenchantement# de# la# fraternité!0'.-)1! -('!
5)(J&#)('! 0;#((*'1! l3! N/! 5#! :P:'! [-19-;8! ,+(1)0*%'%! 9-'! /#! $%#&'%()&*! '1&! %'0'5'(-'! /#!
,#&*J+%)'! :#&%),)'//'! 0+(&! /#! 1+/)0#%)&*! (;'1&! 9-;-('! 0'1! 'S.%'11)+(13! H'! 9-)! ,+($)%:'! 1#!
$+(,&)+(!)(1&)&-#(&'3!
!
! I'-S!%#)1+(1!8!,'/#3!
!
! I;#2+%06! /'! %'$%+)0)11':'(&! 0'1! 1O1&F:'1! 0'! 1+/)0#%)&*! 0-! $#)&! 9-'! /'1! :*,#()1:'1!
:)1!'(!T-5%'!('!1+(&!./-1!%#..+%&*1!8!,'!9-)!/'1!#!$#)&!(#e&%'3!_'J#%0'R!/#!B!M*,-!G!#11):)/*'!
0#(1!/;'1.%)&!0'!2'#-,+-.!8!-(!J%#(0!1'%5),'!.-2/),!0;K&#&3!`-)!%*#/)1'!'(,+%'!9-;)/!1;#J)&!0'!
/#! :)1'! '(! $+%:'! 0'! /#! 1+/)0#%)&*! '(&%'! 0'1! #11-%*1! 9-)! 1+(&6! '(! %*#/)&*6! 0'1! #11+,)*1!
%'.%*1'(&*1!,+::'!&'/1!0#(1!/'1!+%J#('1!0'!J'1&)+(!a!N/!:;#%%)5'!0'!0)%'!8!:'1!*&-0)#(&1!A!
B!@'%,)!0'!:'!.%'(0%'!'(!,E#%J'!/+%19-'!['!1-)1!:#/#0'!'&!%*,).%+9-':'(&!G3!K&!['!/'-%!.+1'!
/#! 9-'1&)+(!7! 9-;'1&\,'! 9-)! .'%:'&! ,'/#!a! KE! 2)'(! /#! %*.+(1'! ('! 5)'(&! .#1! ,+::'! -('!
*5)0'(,'!o!!
!
! U)%'! 9-'! ,'/#6! (+(! 1'-/':'(&! /#! 1+/)0#%)&*! )(1&)&-*'! 1;'1&! 0*&#,E*'! 0'! /#! 1+/)0#%)&*!
)(1&)&-#(&'! :#)1! '//'! 1;'1&! :)1'! 8! $+(,&)+(('%! ,+(&%'! '//'! ,+::'! 0#(1! /'1! :#/#0)'1! #-&+\
)::-('13!d'!:;'S./)9-'3!L+)/8!5+&%'!5+)1)(!0'!.#/)'%!9-)!&+:2'!:#/#0'!'&!5+-1!/'!$#)&!1#5+)%3!
"#! &'(&#&)+(! 1'%#! $+%&'! 0'! 5+-1! 0)%'!A! B!`-;)/! #..'//'! 1+(! :*0',)(! '&! /;#:2-/#(,'! 1)!
(*,'11#)%'!o! 4.%F1! &+-&6! )/! #! /#! M*,-3! `-;)/! 1'! 0*2%+-)//'!o!G3! !K(! 1+%&'! 9-;-(! :*,#()1:'! 0'!
1+/)0#%)&*! $)()&! .#%! 1'! %'&+-%('%! '(! 1+(! ,+(&%#)%'! '&! .%+0-)%'! 0'! /;)(0)5)0-#/)1:'!o! Y(! 2'/!
'S':./'! 0;)(5'%1)+(! 0'! J%#(0'1! )(1&)&-&)+(1! 9-)! 0+(('! %#)1+(! 8! N5#(! N//),E! $-1&)J'#(&! /#!
,+(&%'\.%+0-,&)5)&*!0'1!B!J%#(01!+-&)/1!G3!
!
! @#)1!5+-1!.+-5'R!#-11)!5+-1!.+%&'%!8!1+(!,E'5'&!.+-%!/'!%*,+($+%&'%6!/;#%%#,E'%!8!1#!
1+/)&-0'6! &*:+)J('%! 0'! 5+&%'! E-:#()&*! 1+-1! -('! $+%:'! 9-)! '1&! .%*,)1*:'(&! ,'//'! 0'! /#!
$%#&'%()&*3! C)! /'! 0%+)&6! ()! /#! :+%#/'! (;O! +2/)J'(&! 1#-$! ,#1! 0'! B!.'%1+(('! '(! 0#(J'%!G3!
";*&E)9-'6!'//'6!.%+.-/1'!#-\0'/8!.#%,'!9-;'//'!'1&6!,+::'!O!#!1+-5'(&!)(1)1&*!U#-/!_),T-%6!
0'!/;+%0%'!0'!/;'S,F1!'&!0'!/#!1-%#2+(0#(,'3!!
!
! U'%1+(('//':'(&6! ['! 0)1&)(J-'! 0'-S! $+%:'1! 0'! 1+/)0#%)&*6! chaude!'&! froide6!
*&%+)&':'(&!):2%)9-*'1!'&!,+:./*:'(&#)%'13!!
!
"#! 1+/)0#%)&*! chaude! &%+-5'! 1+(! 1)&'! 0#(1! 0'1! %'/#&)+(1! 0'! .%+S):)&*! $#:)/)#/'6!
#:),#/'6! #11+,)#&)5'3! K//'! '1&! $#)&'! 0'! (+(\)(0)$$*%'(,'6! 0;#&&'(&)+(6! 0'! 1+//),)&-0'6! 0'!
,+:.#11)+(! :#)1! #-11)! 0;)(&*%P&! 2)'(! ,+:.%)1! '&! $+%&! /*J)&):'! /+%19-'! /'1! )()&)#&)5'1! 1'!
[+)J('(&! 0#(1! -('! T-5%'! ,+::-('! '(%),E)11#(&! /;'S)1&'(,'! 0'! ,E#,-(3! "#! 1+/)0#%)&*!
$#:)/)#/'!%'1&'!0*&'%:)(#(&'!A!nmr!0'1!J#%D+(1!0'!fX!#(1!.'-!0)./]:*1!5)5'(&!'(,+%'!,E'R!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
3 Voir La notion de fraternité en droit public français, LGDJ, 1993.

/'-%1!.#%'(&1!'&!Xlr!0-!2-0J'&!0'1!*&-0)#(&1!'1&!0;+%)J)('!$#:)/)#/'3!I#(1!/'!:P:'!&':.16!
/#! 1+/)0#%)&*! #11+,)#&)5'! 1'! 0*5'/+..'! 1.*,)#/':'(&! 0#(1! -('! .'%1.',&)5'! 0;#)0'! #-S! ./-1!
0*:-()1!'&!#-S!.'%1+(('1!8!.%+2/F:'1!0#(1!/;'1.#,'!(#&)+(#/!'&!)(&'%(#&)+(#/3!N/!('!1'!.#11'!
.#1!0'![+-%!9-'!('! (#)11'! -('! (+-5'//'!#11+,)#&)+(!.+-%!,+(&%)2-'%!8!/;#/.E#2*&)1#&)+(6!#-!
,+(1')/! 0'1! 1#(1\':./+)16! #-S! *,E#(J'1! /+,#-S! V! MK"! W6! #-! 1+-&)'(! 0'1! )::)J%*1! +-! 0'!
$%#,&)+(1!0'!.+.-/#&)+(!'(!J%#(0'!1+/)&-0'3!!
!
I#(1!&+-1!,'1!,#16!/#!1+/)0#%)&*!'1&!B!,E#-0'!G!0-!$#)&!0'!/#!.%+S):)&*!'(&%'!/'!.%+['&!
$+(0#&'-%! '&! /'1! 0'1&)(#&#)%'1! 0'! /;#,&)+(3! K//'! 1'! [+-'6! 1-%! -(! :+0'! $%#&'%()&#)%'6! 0#(1! -(!
%#..+%&!0'!5)1#J'!8!5)1#J'6!0'!.#%+/'!8!.#%+/'6!#11-%#(&!-('!)::*0)#&'&*!#-11)!'$$),#,'!9-'!
J%#&)$)#(&'3! B!Q(! 1#)&! .+-%9-+)! +(! '1&! /8! '&! +(! 5+)&! /'1! %*1-/&#&1! 0'! (+&%'! #,&)+(!G3! 45',6!
,'.'(0#(&6! -('! 0+-2/'! /):)&'!A! 0;#2+%06! /;):.+11)2)/)&*! 0'! %*0-)%'! /#! 5)'! 1+,)#/'! 8! 0'1!
%'/#&)+(1! '(&%'! 0'1! B!d'!G! '&! 0'1! B!h-!G! 0#(1! /;+-2/)! 0'! B!N/1!G! +-! B!K//'1!G! '(! #&&'(&'! 0'!
1+-&)'(!7!'(1-)&'6!/#!1-2+%0)(#&)+(!0'!,'1!,+(&%)2-&)+(1!8!0'1!,E+)S!.'%1+(('/1!.#%!0*$)()&)+(!
%*5+,#2/'1!#-!J%*!0'1!B!)(&'%:)&&'(,'1!0-!,T-%!G3!K&!,;'1&!'(!,'!.+)(&!9-'!/#!1+/)0#%)&*!$%+)0'!
%'&%+-5'!&+-&'!1#!%#)1+(!0;P&%'3!
!!!
U#%/'%!0'!1+/)0#%)&*!froide!(;':.+%&'!#-,-(![-J':'(&!0'!5#/'-%!.*[+%#&)$3!N/!('!1;#J)&!
.#1! 0'! /#)11'%! 1+-1\'(&'(0%'! 9-;'//'! 1'%#)&! 0*1E-:#()1*'3! "'! 9-#/)$),#&)$! 1+-/)J('!
1):./':'(&! /'! $#)&! 9-'! 1#! :)1'! '(! T-5%'! 1;+.F%'! 1'/+(! 0'1! :*,#()1:'1! 0;#//-%'!
%*J/':'(&#)%'!'&!0-!:P:'!,+-.!):.'%1+(('//'3!`-;)/!1;#J)11'!0'1!)(0':()&*1!0;#11-%#(,'\
:#/#0)'! +-! %'&%#)&'6! 0'1! #//+,#&)+(1\,E]:#J'6! 0-! _'5'(-! 0'! 1+/)0#%)&*! #,&)5'! +-! 0'!
/;4//+,#&)+(! 0;#0-/&'! E#(0),#.*b/;#&&%)2-&)+(! 1;'$$',&-'! '(! $+(,&)+(! 0'! 1)&-#&)+(1! &%F1!
.%*,)1*:'(&!'(,#0%*'1!.#%!/'!0%+)&3!"'!:#19-'![-%)0)9-'!.%*5#-&!,'&&'!$+)1!1-%!/'!5)1#J'3!`-)!
1;'(!./#)(0%#)&!a!C*1!0'!/#!.%+&'1&#&)+(!1+-5'(&!)(,#(0'1,'(&'!,+(&%'!/;)([-1&),'!0'!/#!/+&'%)'!
0'! /;'S)1&'(,'6! ,'1! 0)1.+1)&)$1! 0'! .%+&',&)+(! '&! 0'! %'0)1&%)2-&)+(! .+%&'(&! /#! :#%9-'! 0'! /#!
%#)1+(! .+/)&)9-'! 9-)! /'-%! #! 0+((*! /'! [+-%3! I'! /8! -('! $%+)0'-%! [-1&)$)#(&! 0#(1! -('! B!1+,)*&*!
0*,'(&'!G6! .+-%! %'.%'(0%'! /;'S.%'11)+(! 0'! @#%J#/)&! 45)1,E#)6! 0'1! )(1&)&-&)+(1! #11'R!
):.'%1+(('//'1! .+-%! P&%'! (+(! 1&)J:#&)1#(&'1! '&! *5)&'%! /'1! &%#5'%1! 0;-('! ,'%&#)('! ,E#%)&*!
,+(0'1,'(0#(&'!0;#-&%'$+)13!K&!,;'1&!'(!,'!.+)(&!9-'!/#!1+/)0#%)&*!,E#-0'!%'&%+-5'!&+-&'!1+(!
):.+%&#(,'3!
!
!#Cette# «#solidarité# chaude#»# n’est-elle# pas# l’autre# nom# de# la# fraternité# qui#
pourrait#constituer#en#contexte#individualiste#une#forme#de#contre-culture#?#
#
#Q(! .'-&! /'! 1+-&'()%! 8! ,+(0)&)+(! 0'! ('! .#1! (*J/)J'%! .+-%! #-&#(&! /;#-&%'! 5+/'&! 9-)! O!
,+(&%)2-'!*J#/':'(&3!@#)1! )/!'1&!5%#)6!9-'! /'!B!5*,-!G!0'!,'&&'! 1+/)0#%)&*!,E#-0'!'1&!:)'-S!
#,,+%0*!8!/;)0*'!9-'!/;+(!1'!$#)&!0'!/#!$%#&'%()&*6!,'//'!0-!M#:#%)&#)(!1-%!/'!,E':)(!0'!d*%),E+3!
N/!.#)'!0'!1#!.'%1+(('!.+-%!&*:+)J('%!0'!/;E-:#()&*!'(!/-)!'&!'(5'%1!/;#-&%'3!
!
! @#)16!)/!$#-&! 2)'(!5+)%!#-11)!9-'! ,'&&'!%*1-%J'(,'!0'!/#! $%#&'%()&*!.'-&!0*./+O'%!1'1!
'$$'&1! 0#(1! /'! 0%+)&! /-)\:P:'! .#%! -('! #-&%'! :#()F%'! 0'! .'(1'%! /'1! 0)1.+1)&)$1! '&! 0'! /'1!
#:*(#J'%!'(!5-'!0'!%*.+(0%'!8!0'-S!#&&'(&'13!H;'1&!/;#-&%'!%#)1+(!#((+(,*'!&+-&!8!/;E'-%'3!
!
! "#! .%':)F%'! '1&! 0'! &%#)&':'(&! 1*%)'-S! '&! [-1&'! 0-! .%+2/F:'! 0'! ,'! 9-;)/! $#-&! 2)'(!
(+::'%!/#!.#-5%'&*!9-)!,+(,'%('!#-[+-%0;E-)!0'!<f!8!<m!:)//)+(1!0'!.'%1+(('1!'(!Z%#(,'3!
";'S)J'(,'!'1&!0'!%*&#2/)11':'(&!0'!/;*J#/)&*!+-&%#J*'!:#)1!.#%!.%)1'!'(!,+:.&'!0-!.%+$)/!0'!