Éthique et politique : Castoriadis entre Habermas et Foucault

!
1!
Ethique(–(Politique(:(Castoriadis,(Habermas,(Foucault!"!#$%&'(&)*!+*!,-&./0/,-&*!,/.&1&23*4!
56!(7)&.!5869!"!#/,-&*!:301*;*.+!"!<'&7*)0&1$!+*!=&>?*!
!
Plan(en(bref(:((
@4 A'1)/!B!!
(4 C31!B!0&13*)D!+*!%('&>)*!E)&1&23*D!.(!)$;.*F&/'!+*!G(01/)&(+&0!03)!0/'!)(,,/)1!H!
0*0! E/'1*%,/)(&'0D! 23('1! H! .(! 23*01&/'! +*0! )(,,/)10! *'1)*! 03I*1J$1-&23*! *1!
,/.&1&23*!
K4 L/M*'!B! H,+! +N3'! 1*F1*D! +/'1! I*! 1&)*! .*0! E02! H! 0/'! *F1)O%*D! E/';)/'1*)! 0(!
,*'0$*!(3F!.*E13)*0!23N&.!;(&1!H!.(!;/&0!+NP(K*)%(0!*1!+*!Q/3E(3.1!
E4 G02!B! %/'1)*)! E/%%*'1! /'! ,*31! E/'0&+$)*)! 23*! G(01/! ,/0*! Q/3E(3.1! *1!
P(K*)%(0!E/%%*!+*3F!,/013)*0!,()(+&?%(1&23*0!)(+&E(.*0!+3!,/&'1!+*!73*!
+*! .N()1&E3.(1&/'! ,/.&1&23*R$1-&23*D! 23N&.! )*'7/&*! +/0JHJ+/0!S! %(&0! +/'1! &.! *01!
1)&K31(&)*!+*!%('&>)*!0M%$1)&23*4!L*!,()(T1!+N(31('1!,.30!,*)1&'*'1!23*!.*0!
,()(..>.*0!*'1)*!Q/3E(3.1!*1!P(K*)%(0!/'1!$1$!;(&1!U+&;;$)*%%*'1V!+3!7&7('1!
+*!E*0!+*3F!(31*3)0D!*1!23*!,()!*F4!,.30&*3)0!&'1*)7&*W0!+3!7/.4!AX!+*0!Dits%et%
écrits!+*%('+*'1!H!Q/3E(3.1!+*!0*!,)/'/'E*)!03)!0(!,)/F&%&1$R+&;;$)*'E*!(7*E!
P(K*)%(04!
+4 =&%&1*!B! &%,/00&K&.&1$! +N3'*! %(&1)&0*! (,,)/;/'+&*! ,();(&1*! +*0! Y! (31*3)0!
E/'E*)'$0D! %(&0! IN*0,>)*! .('E*)! 3'! +$K(1! ;*)1&.*! 03)! .*0! .&%&1*0R(,,/)10! +*!
E-(E3'*! +*! E*0! 1)/&0! ,/013)*0! ,/3)! ,*'0*)! .*0! )(,,/)10! +*! .N$1-&23*! *1! +3!
,/.&1&23*!(I+4!Z'!,()1&E3.&*)D!+*!Q/3E(3.1D!73!.*!E(+)*!+*!E*!0$%&'(&)*!
*4 [.('!B! *F,/0$! *'! Y! ,()1&*0!B! 6)*D! $'/'E$! '/'! ,)/K.$%(1&0$! +*! .(! ,/0&1&/'!
*F,.&E&1*! +*! G(01/! 03)! .N$1-&23*!S! 5*! 6)*! ,)/K.$%(1&0(1&/'! U(3! 0*'0! +*! \!1&)*)!
11*0! .*0! E02! +*!]! 0(! %('&>)*! +*! 0&13*)! P(K*)%(0D! %0! 03)1/31! Q/3E(3.1D! ,()!
)(,,/)1!/3!,()!E/'1)(01*!(7*E!0(!,)/,)*!,*'0$*V!S!Y*!,()1&*!B!E/%,.*F&;&E(1&/'!
^! E*! 23*! G(01/! +&1! +*0! (31*3)0! ,/3)! 1*'1*)! +N&+*'1&;&*)! E*)1(&'0! ,()(..>.*0D!
0&'/'! E*)1(&'*0! \!+*11*0!]! 23N&.! (! 7&0JHJ7&0! +N*3F! *1! *'! 1/30! E(0! E/'1)&K3*)! H!
3'*!%&0*!*'!+&(./?3*!
C4 G(01/)&(+&0!B!=*!E(E-*J%&0>)*!+*!.N$1-&23*!
(4 6)*!73*D!+('0!0/'!_37)*D!\!$1-&23*!]!E/%%*!1*..*!1&*'1!3'*!,.(E*!E/'?)3*!B!5!
1*F1*0!*F,.&E&1*0D!E*.3&J.H!`!3'!*F1)(&1!+*!FFD!)$,/'0*!(3!E/../23*!Autonomie%et%

!
2!
autotransformation%de%la%sociétéD!6aba4!c;;3023$!23N@4!P*..*)!.N(EE30*!+*!'*!
,(0!,)*'+)*!*'!E/%,1*!.(!+&%*'0&/'!$1-&23*!+('0!0(!,-&./0/,-&*4!!
&4 !!)*'7/&1!H!0(!+$;&'&1&/'!+*!praxis!"!!%(F&%*!B!\!+*7&*'1!(31/'/%*!
*1!E/'1)&K3*!(3!+*7*'&)!(31/'/%*!+*0!(31)*0!]!
&&4 [K! +*! .N$1-&23*! 'N*01! ,(0! 0*3.*%*'1! *'I*3! &'1$)&*3)! UE/';.&1! *'1)*!
,(00&/'0! *1! +*7/&)V! "! [.(1/'D! G-)&01&('&0%*D! d('14! L(&0! (300&!
()1&E3.(1&/'!+*0!+&;;$)*'1*0!7&*0D!%3.1&,.&E&1$!+*0!&'+&7&+30!B!!
G&1(1&/'!B!\!=(!7&*!-3%(&'*!+/&1!O1)*!,/0$*!E/%%*!3'!(K0/.3D!,()E*!23*!
.N&'I/'E1&/'!+*!.N(31/'/%&*!*01!E(1$?/)&23*D!*1!23N&.!'NM!(!,(0!+N(31/'/%&*!
0('0! 7&*4! L(&0! .*! ;(&1! *01! 23N&.! M! (! ,.30&*3)0! 7&*0D! 23N*..*0! ,*37*'1!
0N/,,/0*)D! *1! 23*! .N/'! ,*31! O1)*! /K.&?$! +*! E-/&0&)4! e*! 'N(&! 73! (3E3'!
,-&./0/,-*! 0*! ,/0*)! %O%*! 3'! &'01('1! .(! 23*01&/'!B! *01J&.! %/)(.! +*!
+$,*'0*)D!,/3)!3'!0*3.!)*&'!()1&;&E&*.D!+('0!3'!,(M0!)&E-*D!+*!23/&!0(37*)!
+*0!E*'1(&'*0!+N*';('10!+*!.(!;(%&'*!+('0!.*0!,(M0!,(37)*0!f!]!U,4!ggV!!!
03??>)*!+$IH!.(!.&(&0/'!*'1)*!,/.&1&23*!*1!$1-&23*!
&&&4 +$'/'E*!,/00&K&.&1$!23*!.N$1-&23*!%(023*!.(!+&%*'0&/'!\!1)(?&23*!]!+*!
.N*F&01*'E*! -3%(&'*D! EH+! .*! ;(&1! 23*! 1/31*! 0&13(1&/'! &%,/)1('1*! '/30!
%*1!;(E*!H!+*0!E-/&F!/h!&%,/00&K&.&1$!+N3'*!0/.31&/'!\!0('0!E/i1!]!UX#!
C&*'RL(.V! !! \!0/,-)/03'>!]! ,.31j1! 23*! ./?/0! "!!03,,/0*! 23*! .*0!
$1-&23*0!1)(+&1&/''*..*0!U)*.&?&*30*0!/3!k('1&*''*0V!7&0*'1!H!/;;)&)!+*0!
)$,/'0*0! H! 1/31*0! 23*01&/'04! G()(E1>)*! &..30/&)*! ,/3)! G(01/D! *1!
*%,OE-*!(,,)/,)&(1&/'!+*!.(!\!0/,-)/03'>!]!
K4 G(E-*J%&0>)*D!6aaY!&'!Montée%de%l’insignifianceB!,.30!+&)*E1*%*'1!*'!+&(./?3*!
(7*E!+N(31)*0!(31*3)0!+*!0/'!1*%,04!!
&4 G&1*! '/%%$%*'1! P(K*)%(0D! LE! A'1M)*D! l(W.0!B! )*,)/E-*! 3'! )*;3?*!
+('0! .(! )$(E1&7(1&/'! \!+N$1-&23*0!1)(+&1&/''*..*0!]! UE/%%3'&E(1&/'D!
'$/J()&01/1*D!'$/Jk('1V!*'!)$(E1&/'!H!.(!\!E)&0*!+*0!#A#!]!/EE&+*'1(.*0!
"!!\!%/'1$*!+*!.N&'0&?'&;&('E*!]!
&&4 A%,.&E&1*%*'1D!%*!0*%K.*!23*!7&0*!Q/3E(3.1!S!
64 l*,)/E-*! (3F! ('?./J0(F/'0! 03&7&1! +N3'! ,()(..>.*! -&01/)&23*!
*'1)*! )*1/3)! +*! .N$1-&23*! E/'1*%,/)(&'D! *1! .&(&0/'! $1-&23*J
,/.&1&23*! H! @1->'*0! +$%/E)(1&23*! ,3&0! \!.*! 1/3)'('1! 7*)0!
.N-/%%*!,)&7$! *1!.(!;./)(&0/'! +*!,-&./0/,-&*0!1/3)'$*0!03)! 0(!
E/'+3&1*!]!U,4!5m6J5m5V!

!
3!
54 n('0! 3'! ./'?! +$7*./,,*%*'1! E)&1&23*! 03)! .*0! \!E/%&1$0!
K&/$1-&23*0!]! U03)! .*! E()(E1>)*! \!(J,/.&1&23*!]V! RR!
()?3%*'1(1&/'!E&1$*! +*! FF%%0! (7*E! .N*F*%,.*!*3)/,$*'!+*!.(!
,)/E)$(1&/'! %$+&E(.*%*'1! (00&01$*,% E/'E.31! \!*01JE*! +*!
K&/$1-&23*! 23*! '/30! (7/'0! K*0/&'D! /3! K&*'! ,.31j1! +N3'*!
biopolitique%f!]! U,4! 5m9V! !! 1)('0;/)%(1&/'! E.(&)*! +3! 0*'0! +*!
\!K&/,/.&1&23*!]!&E&!*'1*'+3!E/%%*!,)&0*!+*!+$E&0&/'!E/..*E1&7*!
+$.&K$)$*!03)!.N(E1&/'!R.*0!,)&/)&1$0!+N(E1&/'!E/'E*)'('1!1/31!.*!
7&7('1!*1!1/30!.*0!-/%%*0R!)$;.*F&/'!E/..*E1&7*!23&!,)*''*'1!*'!
E/%,1*!.*0!+&;;$)*'1*0!)*.(1&/'0!*'1)*!'/0!(E1&/'0!03)!.*!7&7('1!
U$E/./?&*V! *1! .N-3%(&'! U+M'(%&23*! $E/'/%&23*0D! 0/E&(.*0! *1!
,/.&1&23*0!S! '(1&/'(.*! *1! &'1*)'(1&/'(.*0V4! o4! K&/,/.&1&23*!
0/3.&?'$!*'!6aaYD!&%,/00&K.*!23*!E*!'*!0/&1!,(0!3'*!)$;$)*'E*!
H!Q/3E(3.14!!
Y4 n0! .(! 03&1*! +*! 0/'! *F,/0$D! )*7&*'1! *4(4! 03)! 3'*! -&01/&)*! +*! .(!
\!+3,.&E&1$!]! +*0! 0/E&$1$0! /EE&+*'1(.*0! U,)&7$R,3K.&E!S!
$1-&23*R,/.&1&23*V!23&!)*,)*'+!H!0/'!E/%,1*D!*'!?)/0D!.N-&01/&)*!
+*! \!.N(0E$1&0%*!]! +7,$*! ,()! Q/3E(3.1! "! (E! 220!
)$&'1*),)$1(1&/'0! U(I/31! ,R! *F! +*! .N/)&?&'*! '/'! +/3K.*! *'!
@1->'*0!+$%/E)(1&23*!*1!&'0&01('E*!+*!.(!)3,13)*!(7*E![.(1/'!S!
+$%/E)(1&*! /h! -&$)()E-&*! E.(&)*! +*0! 7(.*3)0! *1! )(,,/)10! +*!
+/%&'(1&/'! *F,.&E&1*! U70! ,K! +*! .N&+$/./?&*! E/%%*! ;(..(E*!
&'1)/+3&1*! H,+! ()1&E3.(1&/'! 7)(&JK&*'! /,$)$*! ,()! [.(1/'V! V4!
G-()?*!7&)3.*'1*!03)!.*0!01/pE&*'0!
94 6)*!)*%()23*!B! ,)!Q/3E(3.1! \!.*0!q)*E0!]!r!H,+![.(1/'D! 03)1/31!
01/pE&*'0D! EM'&23*0D! $,&E3)&*'0!S! ,)! G(01/)&(+&0!r! X*! 0&>E.*D!
03)1/31!@1->'*0!+$%/E)(1&23*4!
&&&4 Z'I*3!+3!1*F1*!B!;(&)*! 7(./&)! 0(! ,)/,)*! \!('1-)/,/./?&*!]! *1! (,,*.*)!H!
3'*! (31)*! $1-&23*! *1! H! 3'*! (31)*! ,/.&1&23*! U+*! .N(31/'/%&*V4! g!
E/'E*,10!E.$0!E/%%*!.*0!(1/%*0!+3!'/M(3!%/.$E3.(&)*!+*!0(!,*'0$*D!
0*!)$,/'+*'1!*1!0*!)*;.>1*'1!1/30!)$E&,)/23*%*'1!B!

!
4!
64 @31/J&'01&131&/'! +*0! 0/E&$1$0! -3%(&'*0! U220/&1! &%(?&'(&)*!
0/E&(.V!
54 o)(?&23*! +*! .N*F&01*'E*! -3%(&'*! !! ,)*'+)*! +*0! +$E&0&/'0! 1I0!
\!(7*E!E/i10!]!`!,(0!+*!;/'+*%*'1!23&!?()('1&00*!.*!C&*'RL(.!
+N3'*!(E1&/'!S!\!1*))&K&.&1$!]!
Y4 Z1-&23*! E/%%*! \!0/,-)/03'>!]! *F*)E&E*! +*! .(! \!)(&0/'!
,)(1&23*!]! ,)! 1)('E-*)! +('0! .*0! E(0! /h! ,)$E&0$%*'1! )&*'! '*!
?()('1&1!.(!7(.&+&1$!+*!.N(E1&/'!
94 [/.&1&23*!B!.*R.(!B!H!.(!;/&0!,)&0*!+*!+$E&0&/'!03)!.*!E/%%3'D!0/'!
/)?('&0(1&/'! *1! 0*0! K310! U1(! *,-*%&'D! *3s*&'V! *1! )$;.*F&/'D!
)*%&0*!*'!23*01&/'!,*),$1!+*0!+$E&0&/'0!,)&0*0!
m4 G&1/M*'!B!03KI*E1&7&1$!+$.&K$)('1*J)$;.$E-&00('1*!B!&'1*))/?(1&/'!
,*),$13*..*!+*0!#A#!*1!&'01&131&/'0D!`!+$.&K$)(1&/'!03)!E*!23&!*01!
H!;(&)*!!
g4 A'+&7&+3! (31/'/%*!B! )(,,/)1! )$;.*F&;! *'1)*!
E/'0E&*'1R&'E/'0E&*'1! UX#! 03,)*00&/'! +*! .N&'E/'0E&*'1V! `!
\!,)(F&0!]!E;!03,)(!(31/'/%&*!
G4 #3&7)*!.*!;&.!+*!.(!1)(?$+&*!,/3)!E/%,)*'+)*!/,,/0&1&/'!0M%$1)&23*!*'1)*!P(K*)%(0!
*1!Q/3E(3.14!!
&4 PM,/1->0*! ,)$.&%&'(&)*!B! G(01/)&(+&0! 7/&1! +('0! .(! 1)(?$+&*! U?)*E23*D!
%(&0! (300&! #-(k*0,*()*! ,()! *FV! 3'! ,()(+&?%*! +*! )$;.*F&/'! $1-&23*D!
*F,/0&1&/'! +*! E*11*! &%,/00&K&.&1$! E/'01&131&7*! +*! .NO1)*! -3%(&'D!
+&%*'0&/'!\!1)(?&23*!]!*1D!I*!03??>)*!\!*F*)E&E*!]!+*!0/,-)/03'>t!!!
&'1$)O1!23N&.!M!,/)1*!
&&4 ZF! +*! Antigone% +*! #/,-/E.*D! *'I*3!B! %/'/0! ,-)/'*&'!E;!
\!@'1-)/,/./?&*! E-*u! Z0E-M.*! *1! (31/E)$(1&/'! +*! .N-/%%*! E-*u!
#/,-/E.*!]!U6ab9VD!&'!Figures%du%pensable.!o*F1*!+*!6ab9!/h!/'!,*31!
&+*'1&;&*)! E%1! &.! E/%,)*'+! .N()1&E3.(1&/'! *'1)*! $1-&23*! *1! ,/.&1&23*D!
E/%,)$-*'0&/'D!H!%/'!0*'0!23&!\!03)+$1*)%&'*!]!0(!.*E13)*!+*0!(31)*0!
(31*3)0! 23&! 0*! ,*'E-*'1! 03)! E*11*! 23*01&/'D! E*! 23&! %*! ,*)%*1D! *'!
)*1/3)!+N&'1*))/?*)!0/'!&'1*),)$1(1&/'!+*0!,/0&1&/'0!+NP(K*)%(0!*1!+*!
Q/3E(3.14!

!
5!
64 @'1&?/'*! *1! G)$/'! non% pas% E/%%*! )*,)$0*'1('10! +*!
.N&'E/%,(1&K&.&1$! *'1)*! +*3F! 1M,*0! +*! ./&0! mais!"!-3K)&0!
0M%$1)&23*0! +('0! .(! ,)&0*! *'! E/%,1*! +N3'! 0*3.! 1M,*! +*! ./&!
1)('0;/)%$!*'!(K0/.3!B!
\!=*!03I*1!'N*01!*'!*01!,(0!.(!.311*!+N@'1&?/'*D!7&E1&%*!&''/E*'1*D!E/'1)*!.*!
1M)('! G)$/'D! '&! .(! E/'1)(+&E1&/'! *'1)*! %/)(.*! *1! )(&0/'! +Nv1(1D! '&!
.N/,,/0&1&/'!+*!.N&'+&7&+3!H!.Nv1(1!U&'1*),)$1(1&/'0!%/+*)'*0VD!'&!.*!E/';.&1!
+*!.(!;(%&..*!(7*E!.(!=/&!*1!.*![/.&1&23*!U7*)0&/'!-$?$.&*''*V4!=*!03I*1!+*!.(!
1)(?$+&*!*01D! (3J+*.H!+*! 1/31! E*.(D!.NhubrisD! .N(E1*!E/%%&0!tolmas% kharin4!
C&*'!0i)D!@'1&?/'*!*1!G)$/'!)*,)$0*'1*'1!+*3F!(31/)&1$0!*'!E/';.&14!L(&0!
E*0! (31/)&1$0! ,/3)1('1! [t]! .*! ,/>1*! '*! .*0! E/'0&+>)*! ,(0! E/%%*!
(K0/.3%*'1! &'E/%,(1&K.*0D! ,3&023*! .N-/%%*! ,*31! +*7*'&)! hupsipolis!*'!
.*0! 1&00('1! *'0*%K.*!]! U,4! YYV! -3,0&,/.&0!B!\!?)('+! +('0! 0(! E&1$! ! %(&0!
03)1/31! ?)('+! U03K.&%*tV! *'! 1('1! 23*! %*%K)*! +*! 0(! E&1$D! +N3'*!
E/%%3'(31$!,/.&1&23*!]!!!/,,/0&1&/'!-3K)&01>0R(,/.&0!!
(4 @'1&?/'*!B!,)&0*!*'!E/%,1*!3'&7/23*!+*!.(!\!I301&E*!+*0!
+&*3F!?()('1&*!,()!.*0!0*)%*'10!]!
K4 G)$/'!B!,)&0*!*'!E/%,1*!3'&7/23*!+*0!./&0!+*!.(!G&1$!
54 !!,)/,)*!+*!.N-/%%*!,/3)!#/,-/E.*!URR!G(01/)&(+&0V!B!E(,(E&1$!
H! tisser% ensemble!E*0! 5! \!)$?&%*0! +*! 7$)&1$!]4! o&00(?*!
&'+&0,*'0(K.*!H!.(!7&*!+*!.(!E&1$!URR!E/'1*%,/)(&'!$1-&23*R./&0V!
\!Antigone!'/30!,*)%*1!(3!%/&'0!+N(;;&)%*)!3'*!E-/0*!0('0!-$0&1(1&/'!B!
.(!I301&E*!+*0! +&*3F!'*! 03;;&1!,(0D!,(0!,.30!23*!'*!03;;&0*'1!.*0!./&0!+*!.(!
1*))*4!Z'!/K$&00('1!H!E*0!./&0D!.N-/%%*!+/&1!0(7/&)!23N*..*0!'*!+$;&'&00*'1!
,(0!*FE.30&7*%*'1!E*!23&!*01!,*)%&0!*1!23N*..*0!'N$,3&0*'1!,(0!'/'!,.30!E*!
23&!*01!+$;*'+34!A.!+/&1!*F&01*)!H!Ej1$!+*!.(!./&!E-(23*!;/&0!&'01&13$*!"!./&!
,/0&1&7*! *1! ;/)E$%*'1! .&%&1$*! ,()! +*0! ;(E1*3)0! 0,(1&/J1*%,/)*.0D! +/'E!
)*.(1&7*!"!3'!(31)*!$.$%*'1!23&D!0('0!.N(''3.*)!'&!.3&!+&E1*)!0*0!E/'1*'30D!
'$E*00&1*!+NO1)*!1&00$!(7*E!*..*4!G*1! $.$%*'1D!.*!,/>1*D!(7*E!.(!.('?3*!*1!
.*0!)*,)$0*'1(1&/'0!+*!0/'!$,/23*!*1!+*!0(!E&1$D!.N(,,*..*D!1-*j'!*'/)k/'!
+&k('!]!U,4!96V!!
!! -M,/1->0*!B! G(01/)&(+&0! )*,)*'+! E*.(! H! 0/'! E/%,1*D! %(&0! ;(&1! I/3*)!
./&R$1-&23*!(I+!,.31j1!23*!./&R%/)(.*!)*.&?&*30*!
Y4 L/'/0!,-)/'*&'!B!H!.(!;/&0!,)&0*!*'!E/%,1*!3'&7/23*!+N3'*!+*0!
+*3F! '/)%(1&7&1$0! R! ,)&0*! +*! +$E&0&/'0! &0/.$*0! ^! .(!
E/%%3'(31$!