Genre et Philosophie

!""#$%&'("&)*$+$"&),-'(.'(*/(0$1)$0(.'(2'0#'(
! "#! $%&$#'(! )#! *#&+#! ,(-&(! +#.-(/0#1#&(! +,$#&(2! %&! &#! '#3(! +#1%&(#+! 4/#&! .%/&!
)-&5!.67/5(%/+#!)#!.-!'7/.%5%'7/#8!9&!'#3(!$#'#&)-&(!+#*+#((#+!.#!$-+-$(:+#!1/5%*;&#!)#!
.-!'7/.%5%'7/#2!)%1/&,#!'-+!.#5!7%11#5!)#'3/5!.6<&(/=3/(,8!>,-&1%/&52!%&!'#3(!'-+(/+!
)#!.6#?'+#55/%&!)#!3)4$0'(.'(5'/-6$)#!)-&5!5%&!%30+-*#!$,.:4+#!)#!@ABA2!.#!Deuxième(
sexe!C! D!On( ne( nait( pas( femme,( on( le( devient!E2! $#! =3/! 5/*&/F/#!=3#! .6%&! &-/(! F#1#..#! 1-/5!
=36%&!)#0/#&(!F#11#!$%11#!$-(,*%+/#!5%$/-.#1#&(!),F/&/#8!
!
789(:'(+';'("#<%=.'(*'(2'0#'(>%$44'(+';'(+$%)/*?(@(:'(+';'(0/1-#'*('1(/01<@+$%)/*(
"#<%=.'(*'(2'0#'(+$%)/*'4'01(%$0+1#-)1(
(
G-&5! .-! F%3.,#! )#! H/1%&#! )#! I#-30%/+2! %&! -! $%&5/),+,! '#&)-&(! .%&*(#1'5! =3#! .#!
J#&+#!,(-/(! .#!5#?#! 5%$/-.2! 5%/(!/553! )63&#! $%&5(+3$(/%&! 5%$/-.#8! K#((#! ),F/&/(/%&! '%5#!
$#'#&)-&(! )#! &%14+#35#5! =3#5(/%&5! '%3+! .#5=3#..#5! .#5! +,'%&5#5! 5%&(! 13.(/'.#5!C! En(
quoi( est7ce( une( construction( sociale!L! Qu’est( ce( qui( est( construit( réellement!L! Si( il( y( a( du(
construit,(y7a7t7il(du(naturel(L!Est7ce(l’obligation(pour(les(hommes(d’être(masculins(et(les(
femmes(féminines!L!Le(fait(qu’il(y(ait(des(hommes(et(des(femmes(et(que(l’on(ne(puisse(pas(
être( l’un( et( l’autre,( ou( ni( l’un,( ni( l’autre(L! 9&! .#! $%1'+#&)! )%&&#+! 3&! 5#&5! ),F/&/(/F! -3!
$%&$#'(!)#!*#&+#!56-0:+#!)/FF/$/.#!0%/+#!/1'%55/4.#8(
"#! *#&+#! $%11#! D!sexe( social!E! $%&$#+&#! .#5! )/FF,+#&$#5! 5%$/-.#5! #&(+#! 7%11#5! #(!
F#11#5! =3/! &#! 5%&(! '-5! )/+#$(#1#&(! ./,#5! M! .-! 4/%.%*/#8! "#! *#&+#! '#+1#((+-/(! )%&$!!
)6-''+,7#&)#+! .-! )/FF,+#&$/-(/%&! )#5! +N.#5! 5#?3,5!$%11#! =3#.=3#! $7%5#)6-3(%&%1#!
$6#5(OMO)/+#! $%11#! /++,)3$(/4.#! M! )#5! .%/5! 4/%.%*/=3#58! "#! 4/%.%*/=3#! #(! .#! 5%$/-.! 5%&(!
)#3?! )%1-/&#5! )/5(/&$(52! #(! .6%&! '#3(! $%&$.3+#! =3#! .#5! /&,*-./(,5! #&(+#! 7%11#5! #(!
F#11#5!&6%&(!+/#&!)#!&-(3+#..#5!1-/5!5%&(!-+4/(+-/+#5!$-+!5%$/-.#1#&(!$%&5(+3/(#58!!
P.! ;! -3+-/(! )%&$! !)63&! $N(,! .#! 4/%.%*/=3#2! .#! )%&&,2! .#! &-(3+#.! 53+! .#=3#.! 0/#&(! 5#!
53'#+'%5#+! .#! 5%$/-.2! .#! $%&5(+3/(! #(! .#! $3.(3+#.8! "#5! )#3?! )%1-/&#5! 5%&(! )%&$!
-''+,7#&),5!$%11#!/&),'#&)-&(5!.63&!)#!.6-3(+#8!"#!5#?#!4/%.%*/=3#!5#+-/(!3&!/&0-+/-&(2!
.#!*#&+#!%3!5#?#!5%$/-.!5#+-/(!$%&(/&*#&(2!5%/(!1%)/F/-4.#2!(+-&5F%+1-4.#!#(!0-+/-4.#!5#.%&!
.#5!5%$/,(,5!#(!.#5!$3.(3+#58!Q&!(-&(!=3#!$%&5(+3$(/%&!5%$/-.#2!.#!masculin!#(!.#!féminin!&#!
5%&(! '-5! )#5! $-(,*%+/#5! F/*,#52! 5/&*3./:+#5! #(! /113-4.#58! "#! *#&+#! -*/+-/(! )%&$! '.35!
$%11#!-0("#$%'++-+(R!'+%$#5535!=3/!'#+1#(!M!.6/&)/0/)3!)6/&(,+/%+/5#+!.#5!&%+1#5!#(!.#5!
$%)#5!5%$/-3?!+#.-(/F5!-3!masculin!#(!-3!féminin8!!
H6/.! #?/5(#! )#3?! 5#?#5! &-(3+#.5! %3! 4/%.%*/=3#52! /.! #?/5(#! ,*-.#1#&(! )#3?! *#&+#5! 5%$/-3?!
1-5$3./&!#(!F,1/&/&!=3/!0/#&&#&(!56;!53'#+'%5#+8"#!*#&+#!'#+1#(!)%&$!)#!),&-(3+-./5#+!
.#5!+-''%+(5!#&(+#! .#5!5#?#5!#(!#&! F-/+#!.6%4S#(!)63&#!-$(/%&! '%./(/=3#8!K#.-!-!'+%)3/(! 3&!
(#++-/&! F#+(/.#! '%3+! .#! F,1/&/51#! =3/! (#&)! M! 0%/+! )-&5! .#! *#&+#! $%11#! $%&5(+3$(/%&!

5%$/-.#2!3&!/&)/$#!)#!.-!)%1/&-(/%&!1-5$3./&#2!)3!'-(+/-+$-(!#(!)#!.-!7/,+-+$7/5-(/%&!)#5!
5#?#5!=36/.!F-3(!$%14-((+#8!
K#'#&)-&(! .6-&-.;5#! )3( 2'0#'! $%11#! $#! =3/! #5(! +$%)/*'4'01( %$0+1#-)1!)-&5! .#5!
)/FF,+#&$#5! #&(+#! .#5! 5#?#5! '#+1#(! '.35/#3+5! /&(#+'+,(-(/%&5!C! M! (/(+#! )6#?#1'.#2! /.! F-3(!
)/5(/&*3#+! .#! «(rôle( de( genre!E! =3/! ),5/*&#! .#5! $%1'%+(#1#&(5! '34./$5! )63&#! '#+5%&&#!
T3&#! '#+5%&&#! 56/)#&(/F/#! 5%$/-.#1#&(! M! 3&! 7%11#! %3! 3&#! F#11#U! #(! D!l’identité( de(
genre!E!=3/!+#&0%/#!M!.6#?',+/#&$#!'+/0,#!=363&#!'#+5%&&#!M!)6#..#O1V1#!TQ5(O$#!=3#!S#!
1#!),F/&/5!1%/O1V1#!$%11#!7%11#!%3!F#11#U8!
W&#! )#5! =3#5(/%&5! .-&$/&-&(#5! =3/! -! (+-0#+5,! .-! '7/.%5%'7/#! #5(! )#! 5-0%/+! .%+5=3#! .6%&!
$%1'-+#!5#?#!#(!*#&+#2!#5(O$#!=3#!.6%&!$%1'-+#!)3!&-(3+#.!#(!)3!5%$/-.!L!X#&5#+!.#!*#&+#!
$%11#!.-!'-+(! 5%$/-.#!)3!5#?#!5/*&/F/#! =363&#!F%/5!=3#!.6%&!-!/5%.,!.#!*#&+#! )3!5#?#2!%&!
-((#/&)+-/(! 3&! 0+-/! 5#?#! 4/%.%*/=3#2! '3+#1#&(! &-(3+#.! =3/! 5%/(! '+,O5%$/-.!E! %3! D!&%&O
5%$/-.!E8! 9&! '%5(3.#! )%&$! =36/.! #?/5(#! 3&#! &-(3+#! 5(-4.#! #(! -&(,+/#3+#! -3! *#&+#2! 5%/(! 3&!
5#?#!=36/.!F-3(!$%&5(+3/+#!5%$/-.#1#&(2!=36/.!#?/5(#!3&#!&-(3+#!'+,O$3.(3+#..#!535$#'(/4.#!
)#!5#!'./#+!M!.-!$%&5(+3$(/%&!5%$/-.#8!
!
A89(B#)1),-'(.-(0/1-#'*(C(:'(2'0#'("#<%=.'(*'(+';'(%/#()*(.<1'#4)0'(*'+(+';'+(@(:'(
2'0#'( 0D';"#)4'( "/+( */( "/#1( +$%)/*'( .'( */( .)6)+)$0( .'+( +';'+E( 4/)+( ';"#)4'( */(
.)6)+)$0(.'+(+';'+('**'@4F4'G(
(
9&! '#3(! +#1#((+#! #&! $-35#! $#((#! /),#! =36/.! #?/5(#! 3&#! 4-5#! &-(3+#..#! #(! 4/%.%*/=3#! )#5!
5#?#5!53+!.-=3#..#!.#!*#&+#!0/#&)+-/(!5#!53+-S%3(#+!%3!5#!53'#+'%5#+8!9&!'#3(!$%&$#0%/+!
=3#! .#! *#&+#! T5#?#! 5%$/-.U! &6#5(! '-5! ),(#+1/&,! '-+! .#! 5#?#! #(! .#! 5#?#! &6#5(! '.35! $%&Y3!
$%11#! 3&#! +,-./(,! &-(3+#..#8! "#! *#&+#! &#! 5#+-/(! )%&$! '-5! .#! 5#?#! 5%$/-.8! Q&! +,-./(,! %&!
'#3(!$%&$#0%/+!.#!5#?#!$%11#!5%$/-.!%3!),SM!5%$/-.!C!.#!*#&+#!5#+-/(!)%&$!3&!5;5(:1#!=3/!
#&*#&)+#!.-!)/5(/&$(/%&!#&(+#!.#5!5#?#58!"#!5#?#!#&!.3/O1V1#!&#!5#+-/(!+/#&!C!/.!56-*/(!)63&#!
)/FF,+#&$#!'-+1/!)6-3(+#5!#&(+#!.#5!/&)/0/)35!=3/!(/+#!5-!5/*&/F/$-(/%&!)3!*#&+#8!"#!*#&+#!
5#+-/(! )%&$! 3&! principe( d’organisation( sociale!=3/! $+,#! .-! )/FF,+#&$/-(/%&! )#5! 5#?#5!C! .#!
*#&+#!$%&5(+3/(!.#5!5#?#58!"#!*#&+#!#5(!'#&5,!$%11#!3&!)/0/5#3+2!3&!5;5(:1#!)#!+#.-(/%&5!
5%$/-.#5!'+%)3/5-&(!)#3?!5#?#5!'%5,5!$%11#!-&(-*%&/5(#58!"#!*#&+#!#5(!.#!1-+=3#3+!)#!
.-!)/0/5/%&!5%$/-.#!=3/!F-/(!#?/5(#+!7%11#5!#(!F#11#5!$%11#!*+%3'#5!)/5(/&$(5!C!.#!*#&+#!
'+,$:)#! .#! 5#?#! $-+! ! .#! *#&+#! $+,#! .#! 5#?#! -&-(%1/=3#! #&! (+-&5F%+1-&(! #&! )/5(/&$(/%&!
'#+(/&#&(#!'%3+!.-!5%$/,(,!3&#!)/FF,+#&$#!-&-(%1/=3#!),'%3+035!)6/1'./$-(/%&5!5%$/-.#58!
Q&(+%&5! '.35! )-&5! .#! ),(-/.!C! 9&! '#3(! %4S#$(#+! =36-FF/+1#+! =3#! 5/! .#! *#&+#! '+,$:)#! #(!
),(#+1/&#!.#!5#?#2!=36#&!#5(O/.!)3!$%+'5!'7;5/=3#!#(!)#!5-!1-(,+/-./(,!4/%.%*/=3#!L!>%35!
-0%&5!(%35!3&!$%+'52!$#+(#52!/.!56-*/(!)63&#!+,-./(,!/&53+1%&(-4.#8!Z-/5!/)#&(/F/#+!.#!5#?#!
)#!=3#.=363&!&6#5(!'-5!(%3S%3+5!5/!,0/)#&(!!#(!.6%&!'#3(!1V1#!)/+#!=3#!.#5!$+/(:+#5!'%3+!
#?'#+(/5#+[/)#&(/F/#+!.#! 5#?#! 0-+/#! 5#.%&! .#5! $3.(3+#5! #(! .67/5(%/+#! Thormones,( anatomie,(
ADN,( gonades…U8! "-! =3#5(/%&! #5(! '#+(/&#&(#! '%3+! .#5! /&)/0/)35! =3/! 5%&(! 5#?3#..#1#&(!

/&),(#+1/&,5!TintersexesU8!"%+5=363&!1,)#$/&!)%/(!),F/&/+!.#!5#?#!)63&!#&F-&(!/&(#+5#?#!
%3! =36/.! )%/(! '+-(/=3#+! 3&#! %',+-(/%&! $7/+3+*/$-.#2! .#! $7%/?! )3! 5#?#! #5(! 5%30#&(!
),(#+1/&,!'-+!'.35/#3+5!$+/(:+#5!./,5!M!.-!&,$#55/(,!5%$/-.#!)#!)/5(/&*3#+!.#5!7%11#5!#(!
.#5! F#11#58! ! T$-'-$/(,! M! 3+/&#+2! (-/..#5! )#5! %+*-&#5! *,&/(-3?2! $-'-$/(,! M! -0%/+! )#5!
#&F-&(5\U8!9&!'#3(!)%&$!$%&$.3+#!=3#!.#!5#?#2!S35=3#!)-&5!5-!1-(,+/-./(,!#5(! $%&5(+3/(!
'-+!.#!*#&+#8!Q&!#FF#(!.#!5#?#!#5(!3&!#&5#14.#!)#!)%&&,#5!#(!&#!5#!./1/(#!'-5!M!3&!5#3.!
,.,1#&(8! P.! #?/5(#! )%&$! '.35/#3+5! )%&&,#5! )%&(! .-! 1-(,+/-./(,! 4/%.%*/=3#! #5(!
/&$%&(#5(-4.#!1-/5!=3/!&#!53FF/5#&(!'-5!M!),(#+1/&#+!.#!5#?#!#&!(-&(!=3#!(#.8!"#!5#?#!#5(!
)%&$! =3#.=3#! $7%5#! )#! $%1'.#?#! $-+! 5/! .#5! ,.,1#&(5! =3/! .#! $%1'%5#&(! 5%&(! )6%+)+#!
4/%.%*/=3#2!.#!(+-0-/.!'-+!.#=3#.!$#5!,.,1#&(5!5%&(!+#./,5!#5(!5%$/-.8!"#!5#?#!#5(!)%&$!3&!
#&5#14.#!)#!)%&&,#5!7,(,+%*:&#5!=3/!5%&(!3&/F/,#5!#(!+,)3/(#!!M!3&#!5#3.#!)%&&,#!#..#O
1V1#! (+-&5F%+1,#! #&! +,-./(,! 4/&-/+#! T7%11#OF#11#U8! "#5! )/FF,+#&$#5! -&-(%1/=3#5!
7%11#!]!F#11#!/&),'#&)-&(#5!.63&#!)#!.6-3(+#!5%&(!$%&5(/(3,#!#&!+,-./(,!'#+(/&#&(#!#(!
-''+,7#&)-4.#!'-+!.#!*#&+#8!
"#! *#&+#! )/0/5#! )%&$! .6731-&/(,! #&! )#3?! *+%3'#5! )/5(/&$(5! T7%11#5! #(! F#11#5U! #(.-!
)/FF,+#&$#!)#5!5#?#5!'#3(!-/&5/!V(+#!),F/&/#!$%11#!3&!'7,&%1:&#!D!4/%5%$/-.!E8!!
(
H89(I<%$0+1#-%1)$0(.-(2'0#'(
"#! '+%4.:1#! #5(! =3#! .%+5=3#! .6%&! '-+.#! )#! 5#?#2! %&! &#! 5#! ./1/(#! '-5! M! .-! +,-./(,!
-&-(%1/=3#! 1-/5! &%35! /)#&(/F/%&5!%3! &%35! F-/5%&5! $%++#5'%&)+#!3&! *+%3'#! )#!
'#+5%&&#5!M!.#3+5!-((+/43(5!*,&/(-3?!T*+%3'#!)#5!F#11#5![!*+%3'#5!)#5!7%11#5U8!!
K#!=3/!#5(!5%$/-.#1#&(!$%&5(+3/(2!$6#5(!.6%4./*-(/%&!5%$/-.#!)#!5#!0%/+!-55/*&#+!3&!5#?#!M!.-!
&-/55-&$#8! X%3+! V(+#! $%7,+#&(2! .-! 5%$/,(,! &%35! /1'%5#! )#! '%55,)#+! 3&! 5#?#! 5(-4.#!
#?'+/1,! '-+3&! *#&+#! 5(-4.#8! G#! 1V1#2! $#! =3/! #5(! 5%$/-.#1#&(! $%&5(+3/($6#5(! )#! F-/+#!
$%++#5'%&)+#! 3&! 5#?#! )%&&,! M! )#5! 5(,+,%(;'#5! )#! *#&+#!C! /.! &6;! -! '-5! .M! )#! &,$#55/(,!
4/%.%*/=3#!M!$#((#!$%++#5'%&)-&$#!1-/5!3&#!%4./*-(/%&!5%$/-.#8!H#?#!#(!*#&+#!5%&(!)%&$!
./,5!'-+!3&#!$%&0#&(/%&!5%$/-.#8K6#5(!$#!=36%&!-''#..#!.#!$%&(/&331!'7;5/$%O5%$/-.8!
<''-+(#&/+!M!.6731-&/(,!5/*&/F/#!)%&$!-''-+(#&/+!M!.63&#!)#5!)#3?!$.-55#5!)6V(+#!&-(3+#.5!
=3/!.-!$%1'%5#&(!C!.#5!7%11#5!%3!.#5!F#11#58!>%35!),F/&/+!$%11#!7%11#!%3!F#11#2!
/1'./=3#! )%&$! )#! &%35! $.-55#+! )-&5! .6731-&/(,8! "-! =3#5(/%&! #5(! )#! 5-0%/+! =3#.! #5(! .#!
5(-(3(!)#!(%3(#!3&#! 5,+/#!)6/&)/0/)35!(#.5!les( transsexuels,(les(transgenres,(les(intersexes,(
les(travestis,(les(hommes(efféminés(ou(les(femmes(masculines\%3!(%3(#5!.#5!'#+5%&&#5!#&!
=3#5(/%&&#1#&(! '-+! +-''%+(! M! .#3+! 5#?#! %3! .#3+! 5#?3-./(,8! ^-3(O/.! .#5! #?$.3+#! )#!
.6731-&/(,! ,(-&(! )%&&,! =36/.5! &6#&(+#&(! '-5! )-&5! .#5$-(,*%+/#5! )#! 5#?#5! 5%$/-.#1#&(!
),F/&/#5!L! T#?8! )#5! (+-&55#?3#.5! &,5! )-&5! 3&! D!1-30-/5! $%+'5!E! #(! '%3+! .#5=3#.5! %&! F-/(!
(%3(!'%3+!.#5!+#&)+#!&%+1-3?!5%/(!F-/+#!$%++#5'%&)+#!0/-!3&#!%',+-(/%&!$7/+3+*/$-.#!.#3+!
5#?#!4/%.%*/=3#!M!.#3+!*#&+#U8_3#!F-/+#!)%&$!)#!(%35!.#5!/&)/0/)35!=3/!&#!+,'%&)#&(!'-5!
-3?!&%+1#5!)#!*#&+#!L!

K#+(-/&5!1%30#1#&(5!%&(!-/&5/!(#&(,!)#!+#1#((+#!#&!$-35#!.6/),#!)63&#!+#.-(/%&!&-(3+#..#!
#&(+#! 5#?#! #(! *#&+#8! P.5! 0/5#&(! M! (+-0-/..#+! .6/)#&(/(,! 5#?3#..#! #(! M! (+%34.#+! .#5!
+#'+,5#&(-(/%&5!5%$/-.#5!#&!+%1'-&(!.-!4/O$-(,*%+/5-(/%&!=3/!&#!(%.:+#!=3#!)#3?!5#?#5!#(!
+%1'(!.-!&,$#55/(,!5%$/-.#!#&(+#!5#?#!#(!*#&+#2!.#!$%&(/&331!'7;5/$%O5%$/-.!#&(+#+!5#?#!#(!
*#&+#8! "6%4S#$(/F! #5(! )#! &#! '-5! #&F#+1#+! )#5! 1/&%+/(,5! )-&5! )#5! $-(,*%+/5-(/%&5!
),F/&/(/0#5! %3! )#5! #55#&$#5! =3/! .#5! %''+/1#&(8! "6%4S#$(/F! #5(! )%&$! )#! ),$%&5(+3/+#! .-!
&%(/%&!)#!*#&+#!'%3+!5340#+(/+!.#5!&%+1#5!5%$/-.#5!=3/!56;!-((-$7#&(8!
9./0/#+! `-&)#+7-#*#&! T^%&$(/%&&-/+#! )#! X+,0#&(/%&! M! W$$.#! #(! 1-a(+#O-55/5(-&(! #&!
7/5(%/+#!#(!'7/.%5%'7/#!M!.-!b-3(#!Q$%.#!X-3.Ob#&+/!H'--cU!
!
5)J*)$2#/"&)'(
X%3+!.-!+,-./5-(/%&!)#!$#!+,531,2!.#5!%30+-*#5!53/0-&(5!%&(!,(,!3(/./5,5!C!!
- P5-4#..#!K"<Pd2!Sociologie(du(Genre2!X-+/52!ef@e!
- Q8! >Q`QW! #(! K8! JWP9>Qg2! Féminin/Masculin,( Sociologie( du( Genre2! X-+/52! effA!
Te#1#!,)U!
- h8! IWg"Qd2! Trouble( dans( le( genre2! X-+/52! effi! Tg+-)! )#! .6-1,+/$-/&! J#&)#+!
g+%34.#U!
- H8! Kb<W`P>2! <8! h<W><dg2! <8! dQ`P""<dG2! Introduction( au( Gender( Studies2!
I+3?#..#52!effj!T@#+#!,)8U!
- Q8!G9d"P>2(Sexe,(genre(et(sexualités2!X-+/52!effj!
!