L`irresponsabilité politique du Président de la Vème

!"
"
L’irresponsabilité politique du Président de la Vème République
(à la suite des révisions constitutionnelles de 2007 et 2008)
André Moine
!
"#! $%&'()&%(*! +*')+! ,#! -(*.'%(*! /)0&%$+*'%+,,+! $+! $)(%'! +'! .+,,+! +1+).0+! $+! -#%'! /#)! ,+! 2)0&%$+*'! $+! ,#!
30/45,%64+7! ,8(//(&%'%(*9!+*')+! &(*! &'#'4'! $8#)5%')+! +'! &(*! ):,+! $+! .;+-! $+! ,#! <#=()%'07! .(*$4%&+*'7! +*!
,8#5&+*.+! $+! <($%-%.#'%(*! $4! )0>%<+! /(,%'%64+7! ?! $+&! #<0*#>+<+*'&! .(*&'%'4'%(**+,&! %*0@%'#5,+<+*'!
&%5A,,%*&B!"+&!#)'%.,+&!CD!+'!CE!$+!,#!F(*&'%'4'%(*!%&&4&!$+!,#!)0@%&%(*!$+!GHHD!+'!.+)'#%*+&!$+&!<($%-%.#'%(*&!
#$(/'0+&! I! (4! )+=+'0+&! I! +*! =4%,,+'! GHHE! +*! '0<(%>*+*'B! "+&! '%'4,#%)+&! $4! /(4@(%)! .(*&'%'4#*'! $0)%@0!
.(*-)(*'0&!?!4*+!#<5%@#,+*.+!$+!-#%'!$+!,#!-(*.'%(*!$4!2)0&%$+*'!$+!,#!30/45,%64+!(*'!$J!.(</(&+)!+'!(*'!
<#%*'+*4!,+!/)%*.%/+!$84*+!%))+&/(*&#5%,%'0!/(,%'%64+!/)0&%$+*'%+,,+!K!L!"+!/)0&%$+*'!$+!,#!30/45,%64+!*M+&'!
/#&!)+&/(*&#5,+!$+&!#.'+&!#..(</,%&!+*!.+''+!64#,%'0!NOP!QGB!"+!$0$(45,+<+*'!-(*.'%(**+,!$4!2)0&%$+*'!$+!
,#!30/45,%64+7!#464+,!&8#=(4'+!,#!$4#,%'0!+*')+!,#!/+)&(**+!+'!,8()>#*+!648+,,+!%*.#)*+7!.(*$4%'!#%*&%!?!$+&!
<0#*$)+&!=4)%$%64+&!$(*'!.+41!<+*#*'!?!4*+!64#&%!'('#,+!%))+&/(*&#5%,%'0!=4)%$%64+B!2(4)'#*'!0'#'!$+!$)(%'!
+'! )0>%<+! $0<(.)#'%64+! &4//(&+*'! +*! /)%*.%/+! 64+! ,+&! $%)%>+#*'&! /(,%'%64+&! #%+*'! ?! )+*$)+! .(</'+! $+!
,+4)&!#.'+&7!648%,&!&(%+*'!)+&/(*&#5,+&!$+!,+4)&!$0.%&%(*&B!!
"#! )+&/(*&#5%,%'0! /(,%'%64+! $84*!()>#*+!.(*&'%'4'%(**+,! &+! ')#$4%'7!*('#<<+*'R!+'!/)#'%64+<+*'7!$#*&!,#!
/(&&%5%,%'0!/(4)!4*!#4')+!()>#*+!$+!)+<+'')+!+*!.#4&+!&(*!<#*$#'!+*!.#&!$+!$0&#..()$!/(,%'%64+!S!#%*&%!4*!
>(4@+)*+<+*'!<+*#*'!4*+!/(,%'%64+!(//(&0+!?!.+,,+!&(4;#%'0+!/#)!,#!<#=()%'0!$+!,#!.;#<5)+!5#&&+!/+4'!
T')+! )+*@+)&0! /#)! .+,,+U.%B! "+&! 0@+*'4+,&! =4>+<+*'&! $+&! )+&/(*&#5,+&! /(,%'%64+&! /(4)! ,+&! #.'+&!
)0/)0;+*&%5,+&! .(<<%&! $#*&! ,8+1+).%.+! $+! ,+4)! -(*.'%(*! )+,V@+*'! $84*! #4')+! 'A/+! $+! )+&/(*&#5%,%'0B! "+&!
*(4@+#41!#)'%.,+&!CD!+'!CE!$+!,#!F(*&'%'4'%(*!$+!9WXE!*+!)+'%+**+*'!/#&!4*+!$%&'%*.'%(*!.,#%)+!$+&!$+41!
&%'4#'%(*&! /4%&648#/)V&! #@(%)! *+''+<+*'! 0*(*.0! +'! )#//+,0! ,8%))+&/(*&#5%,%'0! $4! 2)0&%$+*'! $+! ,#! YV<+!
30/45,%64+!,8#,%*0#!9!$+!,8#)'%.,+! CD! #=(4'+! L!! &(4&!)0&+)@+! $+&! $%&/(&%'%(*&!$+&! #)'%.,+&! XRUG! +'!CE!QB!Z)!
,8#)'%.,+! XRUG! .(*.+)*+! 4*+! 0@+*'4+,,+! %*-)#.'%(*! /0*#,+7! ,+! .)%<+! .(*')+! ,8;4<#*%'0[7! +'! ,M#)'%.,+! CE! 4*!
0@+*'4+,! #.'+! /(,%'%64+<+*'! )+=+'07! &(%'! $+! ,#! /#)'! $4! 2)0&%$+*'! 4*! L!<#*64+<+*'! ?! &+&! $+@(%)&!
<#*%-+&'+<+*'! %*.(</#'%5,+! #@+.! ,M+1+).%.+! $+! &(*! <#*$#'QB! ! 2(4)'#*'! <+'')+! +*! .#4&+! 4*! ;(<<+!
/(,%'%64+!?!)#%&(*!$8#.'+&!/0*#,+<+*'!)0/)0;+*&%5,+&!(4!?!)#%&(*!$84*!>)#@+!<#*64+<+*'!/(,%'%64+!*8(50%'!
/#&! #41! <T<+&! .(*&%$0)#'%(*&! \&#4-! $80@+*'4+,,+&! L!/#&&+)+,,+&!Q! ,()&64+! ,8#.'+! )0/)0;+*&%5,+! +&'! #4&&%!
/(,%'%64+<+*'!%*#..+/'#5,+]B!!
^4(%!648%,!+*!&(%'!$+!.+''+!$%&'%*.'%(*7!,+!/)%*.%/+!$+!,8%))+&/(*&#5%,%'0!/(,%'%64+!$4!2)0&%$+*'!$+<+4)+!K!,#!
.(*&'%'4'%(*!-)#*_#%&+!)0@%&0+!<0*#>+!I!*(*!&#*&!)#%&(*&X!I!,8#)5%')+!.(*&'%'4'%(**+,7!%>*()#*'!,#!$%&'()&%(*!
%*&'%'4'%(**+,,+!I!#4!<(%*&!#//#)+*'+!I!+*')+!,+&!/(4@(%)&!+1+).0&!$+!-#%'!/#)!,+!2)0&%$+*'!$+!,#!30/45,%64+!
+'! &(*! #5&+*.+! $+! )+&/(*&#5%,%'0! /(,%'%64+! $+! $)(%'B! "+&! #4'+4)&! $+&! )0@%&%(*&! (*'! #%*&%! #//#)+<<+*'!
.;(%&%&!$+!)+&'+)!L!*+4')+&!Q!+'!$+!>#)$+)7!*(*!&#*&!$84'%,+&!`%,,V)+&7!,+!.#/!$+!,#!.(*&'%'4'%(*!/#),+<+*'#%)+!
%*%'%#,+!K! ,+! 2)0&%$+*'! $+! ,#! YV<+! 30/45,%64+! +&'! 4*! F;+-! $8a'#'! /#),+<+*'#%)+! +'! &(*! %))+&/(*&#5%,%'0!
/(,%'%64+! $(%'!$V&! ,()&! T')+!<#%*'+*4+B! b(4'+-(%&7! ,+!.;(%1!$+! .+''+! %))+&/(*&#5%,%'0! $+! /)%*.%/+7! )+'+*4+!
$#*&! ,+&! )0>%<+&! $+&! cccV<+! +'! cYV<+! 30/45,%64+&7! 0'#%'! #,()&! *('#<<+*'! =4&'%-%0+! /#)! ,#! -#%5,+&&+!
""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""
!"#$%"&'(()*$+,%"-*)%'&$+,%"&$"./"012$"3)456.'75$"%$"%8+,"&',%9"&:5+$"2/+'1*$"85"&:5+$"/5,*$9";"/*6',*$"$,"
*$%48+%/6.$"<"2/'%"./"(8+=,'8+"&:/*6',*$"=8+%,',5,'8++$."$%,"&$"(/',"./*>$2$+,"$+,/2)$"4/*"=$..$"&$"&'*'>$/+,"
48.','75$?"#/"=8+,*/&'=,'8+"$%,"4/,$+,$9".$%"2),/4@8*$%"%48*,'A$%"'+&5',$%"4/*".$",$*2$"&:/*6',*$"$+"
&)=85.$+,",$.";"8+"4$5,""&'(('='.$2$+,""B,*$"&/+%"C./"2B.)$C"$,"/5D&$%%5%"&:$..$"<"E%/5("F"G85$*"/A$=".$"%$+%"&$%"
28,%"$,"F"&'*$"=822$".$"*)41,$+,".$%"=822$+,/,$5*%"/=,5$.%"%5*",$..$"85",$..$"&)='%'8+"+8*2/,'A$"H"
;"".:/*6',*/>$"('+/."*$A'$+&*/"F".:I.J%)$"<K?""
L"IM,*/',"&$".:/*,'=.$"NO"/=,5$."&$"./"P8+%,',5,'8+"&$"!QRS?""
T"#/"*$%48+%/6'.',)"48.','75$"&$%"2$26*$%"&$".:$M)=5,'("4$5,"%$",*/&5'*$"4.5%"./*>$2$+,""4/*".$%"2)=/+'%2$%"
4*)A8J/+,".$%"48%%'6'.',)%"&$"=$+%5*$9"&$"*)A8=/,'8+9"&$"75$%,'8+%9"&$"=8+,*U.$9"&:$+75B,$V"
W"-.5%"4*)='%)2$+,",85,$%".$%"'+=*'2'+/,'8+%9"&8+,".$";"=*'2$"=8+,*$".:@52/+',)"<9"('>5*/+,"&/+%".$"X,/,5,"&$"./"
P85*"4)+/.$"'+,$*+/,'8+/.$"$,"%5%=$4,'6.$%"&:B,*$"485*%5'A'%"4/*"=$..$D='?"
R"-85*"('.$*"./"2),/4@8*$"%48*,'A$"Ecf.$note$1K";"#:/*6',*$"+$"4$5,".8>'75$2$+,"B,*$"*$%48+%/6.$"&$A/+,".$%"
G85$5*%"<?"

L"
"
/(,%'%64+!$4!F;+-!$+!,Ma'#'7!+,,+!/+4'!/#)#d')+!$V&!,()&!%*#$064#'+!&(4&!,#!YV<+!30/45,%64+!$#*&!,#64+,,+!
.+,4%U.%!+1+).+!4*+!-(*.'%(*!$%)%>+#*'+!+--+.'%@+B!!!
"#! .)%'%64+! *0>#'%@+! $+&! $%&/(&%'%(*&! .(*&'%'4'%(**+,,+&! +&'! &(4@+*'! +*! -#%'! .+,,+! $+! ,+4)! #//,%.#'%(*!
.(*'+&'#5,+!(4!$+!,+4)!.(*'(4)*+<+*'!/#)!,+&!#4'()%'0&!/(,%'%64+&B!L!"+!2)0&%$+*'!$+!,#!30/45,%64+7!.;+-!
$8a'#'! $#*&! 4*! )0>%<+! /#),+<+*'#%)+7! +&'! /(,%'%64+<+*'! %))+&/(*&#5,+!Q7! .+''+! #--%)<#'%(*! +&'! +*!
,M(..4))+*.+!%*(//()'4*+!/#).+!64+!,+!2)0&%$+*'!&(4&!,#!YV<+!30/45,%64+!+1+).+!4*!/(4@(%)!$+!$0.%&%(*!
+--+.'%-! *(*! 0*(*.0! $#*&! ,+! '+1'+! .(*&'%'4'%(**+,7! /#).+! 64+! ,+&! #4')+&! ()>#*+&! .(*&'%'4'%(**+,&! *+! ,4%!
.(*'+&'+*'!/#&!.+''+!/(&&%5%,%'0!+'!/#).+!64+!I!<T<+!&%!(*!/+4'!?!'%')+!%*$%@%$4+,7!&(4&!,#!$(45,+!.#&64+''+!
$+!=4)%&'+!+'!$+!.%'(A+*7!,+!)+>)+''+)!I!.+!<(*(/(,+!+&'!#//#)+<<+*'!>0*0)#,+<+*'!#..+/'0!/#)!,#!<#=()%'0!
$+&!<+<5)+&!$+!,#!&(.%0'0!-)#*_#%&+!.(*'+</()#%*+!I!&%!'#*'!+&'!64+!,80@#,4#'%(*!$+!.+!L!&+*'%<+*'!Q!&(%'!
-%#5,+B!!
"8%))+&/(*&#5%,%'0! /(,%'%64+! $+! /)%*.%/+! $4! 2)0&%$+*'! $+! ,#! YV<+! 30/45,%64+! (50%'! ?! 4*+! ,(>%64+!
%*&'%'4'%(**+,,+!\c]!64%!*8+&'!.+/+*$#*'!/#&!+1+</'+!$+!')#@+)&!S!.+41U.%!/+4@+*'!'(4'+-(%&!T')+!+*!/#)'%+!
.(</+*&0&!/#)!$+&!<0.#*%&<+&!%*$%)+.'&!$+!.(*'):,+!\cc]!$+!,8#.'%(*!/)0&%$+*'%+,,+B!!
"
"
"
"
I"#"La"logique"institutionnelle"de"l’irresponsabilité"politique"du"Président"de"la"Vème"République"
!
"#!L!/)0&%$+*'%#,%&#'%(*!Q!$4!/(4@(%)!&(4&!,#!YV<+!30/45,%64+!+&'!4*+!)0#,%'0B!"8%))+&/(*&#5%,%'0!/(,%'%64+!
$4!2)0&%$+*'!+&'!.(*&'%'4'%(**+,,+<+*'!/)0@4+B!"#!.(*')#$%.'%(*!$0<(.)#'%64+!+*')+!.+&!$+41!#--%)<#'%(*&!
+&'!/#'+*'+B!"+!'%'4,#%)+!L!)0+,!Q!$4!/(4@(%)!$+!$0.%&%(*!*8#A#*'!/#&!?!)+*$)+!.(</'+!$+&!.;(%1!/(,%'%64+&!
648%,! (/V)+7! .+''+! &%'4#'%(*! #//#)#d'! +*! +--+'! $0<(.)#'%64+<+*'! %))+.+@#5,+B! F+/+*$#*'! $+&! #)>4<+*'&!
.(*&'%'4'%(**+,&!+1/,%64+*'!.+!.;(%1B!"8%*&'%'4'%(**#,%&#'%(*!$84*+!)+&/(*&#5%,%'0!/(,%'%64+!&4//(&+)#%'!+*!
+--+'!$+!$0-%*%)!$+@#*'!64%!,+!2)0&%$+*'!$+!,#!30/45,%64+!&+)#%'!)+&/(*&#5,+!\e]!+'!$+!64(%!%,!#4)#%'!?!)+*$)+!
.(</'+!\f]7!.+!64%!#5(4'%'7!#4!@4!$4!'+1'+!+'!$+!,8064%,%5)+!%*&'%'4'%(**+,!#.'4+,7!?!4*+!%</#&&+B!c,!*8+*!)+&'+!
/#&! <(%*&! 64+! .+)'#%*&! #.'+&! /)0&%$+*'%+,&! 0.;#//+*'! %*(//()'4*0<+*'! ?! '(4'! .(*'):,+! /(,%'%64+!
%*&'%'4'%(**#,%&0!\F]B!
!
!
A)#Le#défaut#d’autorité#politique#susceptible#de#«#désavouer#»#le##Président#de#la#République##
!
"+!2)0&%$+*'!$+!,#!30/45,%64+!+&'!4*!)+/)0&+*'#*'!$4!/+4/,+!0,4!#4!&4--)#>+!4*%@+)&+,!$%)+.'B!c,!*+!/+4'!$+!
.+!-#%'!T')+!)+&/(*&#5,+!/(,%'%64+<+*'!$+@#*'!$8#4')+&!)+/)0&+*'#*'&!$4!/+4/,+!&#*&!,0>%'%<%'0!&4/0)%+4)+B!
"8e&&+<5,0+! *#'%(*#,+7! &+4,! ()>#*+! +*! <+&4)+! $8#&&4)+)! .+! .(*'):,+! 0@+*'4+,! \,+! 2)0&%$+*'! $+! ,#!
30/45,%64+! *+! /(4@#*'7! +*! '(4'+! ,(>%64+! =4)%$%64+! +'! /(,%'%64+7! T')+! )+&/(*&#5,+! $+@#*'! #4.4*+! #4')+!
#4'()%'0!/(,%'%64+!*#'%(*#,+!&#4-!/+4'UT')+!,+!2#),+<+*']7!*+!$%&/(&+!/#&!$+!.+''+!64#,%'0B!e%*&%7!&%!,8#)'%.,+!
9E!$+! ,#! F(*&'%'4'%(*!(--)+! $0&()<#%&! #4! 2)0&%$+*'! $+! ,#! 30/45,%64+! ,#! /(&&%5%,%'0! $+! /)+*$)+! ,#! /#)(,+!
$+@#*'!,+&!/#),+<+*'#%)+&C7!%,!*+!/+)<+'!/#&!64+!.+41U.%!@('+*'!?!,8%&&4!$+!&(*!%*'+)@+*'%(*!*%!<T<+!648%,&!
+*! $05#''+*'! +*! &#! /)0&+*.+B! g*! '+,! &.)4'%*! .(*&'%'4+)#%'! 4*+! -()<+! $80@#,4#'%(*! $+&! .;(%1! /(,%'%64+&!
/)0&%$+*'%+,&D!64%7!+*!.#&!$+!@('+!*0>#'%-7!.(*$4%)#%'!?!4*+!%</#&&+7!#4.4*+!.(*&064+*.+!=4)%$%64+!*80'#*'!
&4&.+/'%5,+!$8T')+!$0$4%'+!$+!.+!$0&#@+4!/(,%'%64+B!!
2,4&!>0*0)#,+<+*'7!'(4'+!,#!,(>%64+!%*&'%'4'%(**+,,+7!$+/4%&!,#!)0@%&%(*!$+!9WCG!+'!#..+*'40+!/#)!.+,,+!$+!
GZZZ7!'+*$!@+)&!4*+!4*%'0!$+!,#!@(,(*'0!/(,%'%64+!(h!&8#&&(.%+*'!,+!2)0&%$+*'!$+!,#!30/45,%64+7!,#!<#=()%'0!
$+!,8e&&+<5,0+!*#'%(*#,+!+'!$(*.!,+!i(4@+)*+<+*'7!*(<<0!/#)!,84*!+'!)+&/(*&#5,+!$+@#*'!,8#4')+B!!j+!.+!
-#%'7!,+&!&+4,&!'%'4,#%)+&!%<#>%*#5,+&!$84*!.(*'):,+!$+!,8#.'%(*!/)0&%$+*'%+,,+!&+)#%+*'!,+&!$0/4'0&!64%7!/#)!,#!
""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""
N"Y."$%,"F"+8,$*"75$"./".85*&$5*"&$"./"4*8=)&5*$"./"*$+&"&:'+,)*B,"48.','75$"$M=$4,'8++$.?"#/"*)A'%'8+"*$,'$+,"
('+/.$2$+,"5+$"4*'%$"&$"4/*8.$"&$A/+,"5+"-/*.$2$+,"*)5+'"$+"P8+>*1%9"&8+="F"0$*%/'..$%9"=$"75'"$%,"
4*86/6.$2$+,".8'+"&$"./"A8.8+,)"Z?"X/*[8\J"75'"%85@/',/',"%/+%"&85,$"'+','/.$2$+,"485A8'*";"F".:8==/%'8+"<"
'+,$*A$+'*";"%'24.$2$+,"<"&$A/+,".$%"&)45,)%"85".$%"%)+/,$5*%?"#$"-*)%'&$+,"4*)(1*$"%/+%"&85,$">)+)*/.$2$+,""
F"=$";"=)*)28+'/."(*/+]/'%"<"*$+=8+,*$*"&$"(/]8+"'+(8*2$..$".$%"4/*.$2$+,/'*$%"&$"%/"2/G8*',)"E.$%"%$5.%"&8+,".$"
&)%/==8*&")A$+,5$."$%,"5+"$+G$5"48.','75$K"85"%:/&*$%%$*"&'*$=,$2$+,"F".:84'+'8+"456.'75$?"
O"NB"H"%=*5,'+"75'"&856.$*/',""$+"85,*$"2/.$+=8+,*$5%$2$+,".$"A8,$"%5*".$"4*8>*/22$">85A$*+$2$+,/."4*)%$+,)"
4/*".$"-*$2'$*"2'+'%,*$"$+"A$*,5"&$".^/*,'=.$"WQ"/.'+)/"!?"

T"
"
,(>%64+! %*&'%'4'%(**+,,+! $4! )0>%<+! /#),+<+*'#%)+7! &#4-! ,8+1.+/'%(*! $+! ,#! $%&.()$#*.+! $+&! <#=()%'0&E7!
.(,,#5()+*'!?!,8+1+).%.+!$4!/(4@(%)!#@+.!,+!2)0&%$+*'!64+,!64+!&(%'!,8#&.+*$#*'!$+!.+,4%U.%!$#*&!.+!.(*.(4)&B!!
a*!.+,#!,80@+*'4+,!)+*-().+<+*'!$+&!/)0)(>#'%@+&!$4!2#),+<+*'!,()&!$+!,#!)0@%&%(*!$+!GHHE!*8#5(4'%'!/#&!?!
4*!)0064%,%5)#>+!$+&!/(4@(%)&!/4%&648+*!)+*-()_#*'!$+!-#%'!,#!<#=()%'0!/#),+<+*'#%)+7!64%!+&'!+*!/)%*.%/+!
%$+*'%64+!?!,#!<#=()%'0!/)0&%$+*'%+,,+7!,84*%.%'0!$+!,#!@(,(*'0!/(,%'%64+!$+<+4)+!@(%)+!&8#..)(d'!&(4&!)0&+)@+!
$+! $)(%'&! (--+)'! ?! ,8(//(&%'%(*! 64%! *+! <($%-%+*'! /#&! ,8064%,%5)+! I! (4! /,4&! +1#.'+<+*'! ,+! $0&064%,%5)+! I!
>0*0)#,B!!
2,4&! -(*$#<+*'#,+<+*'7! ,#! )+&/(*&#5%,%'0! $84*! F;+-! $8a'#'! +&'! 4*+! ;A/(';V&+! &#*&! >4V)+! $8%*'0)T'!
%*&'%'4'%(**+,!K! &(%'! ,+! )0>%<+! +&'! /)0&%$+*'%+,! +'! $V&! ,()&! &(*! /)%*.%/+! .(*&'%'4'%-! )0&%$+! $#*&!
,8%*$0/+*$#*.+!$+&!()>#*+&!$+!L!/(4@(%)&!&0/#)0&!Q7!!&(%'!,+!)0>%<+!+&'!/#),+<+*'#%)+!+'7!.(<<+!$#*&!,+!
F(*&'%'4'%(*! $+! 9WXE7! ,+! F;+-! $+! ,Ma'#'! +&'! ,(>%64+<+*'! /(,%'%64+<+*'! %))+&/(*&#5,+! $+@#*'! ,+&! 0,4&! $4!
/+4/,+B! F+''+! ,(>%64+! &+! $(45,+! $84*+! #4')+! .(*&%$0)#'%(*! &8%,! +&'! 0,4! #4! &4--)#>+! 4*%@+)&+,! /4%&648%,!
-#4$)#%'!#,()&!)+.(**#d')+!?!4*!()>#*+!.(*&'%'4'%(**+,!,#!/(&&%5%,%'0!$+!)+<+'')+!+*!.#4&+7!/(4)!$+&!<('%-&!
$+! $%@+)>+*.+! /(,%'%64+7! ,#! @(,(*'0! /(/4,#%)+B! j+! /,4&7! ,8;A/(';V&+! $84*+! )+&/(*&#5%,%'0! /(,%'%64+!
/)0&%$+*'%+,,+!&4//(&+)#%'!$+!$0-%*%)!,+!.(*'+*4!$+!.+!&4)!64(%!,+!2)0&%$+*'!#4)#%'!?!)+*$)+!$+&!.(</'+&B!
!
!
B)#Le#défaut#d’attributions#susceptibles#de#provoquer#la#responsabilité##politique#du#Président#de#la#
République##
!
"+&!#'')%54'%(*&!/)0&%$+*'%+,,+&!*+!=4&'%-%+*'!/#&!+*!+--+'!,8%*&'%'4'%(**#,%&#'%(*!$84*+!/(&&%5,+!<%&+!+*!=+4!
$+!,#!)+&/(*&#5%,%'0!$4!2)0&%$+*'B!c,!*+!/+4'!#@(%)!?!)+*$)+!.(</'+!$4!$0/:'!$84*!/)(=+'!$+!,(%7!.(</0'+*.+!
$4! 2)+<%+)! <%*%&')+7! *%! $+! ,8#$(/'%(*! $4! '+1'+7! .(</0'+*.+! $4! 2#),+<+*'B! k#*&! )+/)+*$)+! '(4'+&! &+&!
#'')%54'%(*&7! &+&! /)0)(>#'%@+&! $%&/+*&0+&! $+! .(*')+&+%*>7! .())+&/(*$#*'! /)%*.%/#,+<+*'! ?! &(*! ):,+!
$8#)5%')+!\#)'%.,+!X]7!.(*&%&'+*'!+&&+*'%+,,+<+*'7!?!,8+1.+/'%(*7!<#)>%*#,+!+'!')V&!+*.#$)0+!/#)!,+!'+1'+7!$+!
.+,,+!$+!,M#)'%.,+!9C7!?!&(,,%.%'+)7!/#)-(%&!&4)!/)(/(&%'%(*7!$8#4')+&!()>#*+&!NF(*&+%,!.(*&'%'4'%(**+,!\#)'%.,+&!
X[!+'!C9]7!/+)&(**+&!#//+,0+&!?!(..4/+)!$+&!-(*.'%(*&! \#)'%.,+&!E!#,97!XC]7!2#),+<+*'!\#)'%.,+!9E]7!.()/&!
0,+.'()#,! \#)'%.,+&! 997! 9G]P! +'! &(*'! $(*.! %*$%)+.'+<+*'! L!.(*'):,0+&!Q! /#)! ,+&! /+)&(**+&! #%*&%! &(,,%.%'0+&B!
l(*!&#*&!%</()'#*.+!5%+*!64+!)#)+<+*'!4'%,%&0+&!/(4)!.+)'#%*+&W7!+,,+&!*+!.(*&'%'4+*'!64+!$+&!$0.%&%(*&!
%*'+)<0$%#%)+&!S! #%*&%! ,+&! 0,+.'+4)&! /+4@+*'7! .(<<+! +*! 9WWD7! *+! /#&! $(**+)! ,#! <#=()%'0! &(4;#%'0+! #4!
2)0&%$+*'!#4'+4)!$+!,#!$%&&(,4'%(*B!"#!)+&/(*&#5%,%'0!/(,%'%64+!$4!2)0&%$+*'!$+!,#!30/45,%64+!*8+&'!$V&!,()&7!
$#*&!.+&!.#&7!/#&!*0.+&&#%)+!+'!>4V)+!#$#/'0+B!Z*!/(4))#%'7!/#)!#%,,+4)&7!+*@%&#>+)!4*+!)+&/(*&#5%,%'0!/(4)!
&+&! #4')+&! #'')%54'%(*&! '+,! &#! 2)0&%$+*.+! $4! F(*&+%,! $+&! <%*%&')+&7! &(*! /(4@(%)! )0>,+<+*'#%)+! /#)'%+,7!
,8+1+).%.+!$+!&#!-(*.'%(*!$+!.;+-!$+&!#)<0+&7!&(*!/(4@(%)!$+!*(<%*#'%(*7!&(*!$)(%'!$+!-#%)+!>)m.+O!n#%&!.+&!
.(</0'+*.+&! &(*'! &(4<%&+&! ?! .(*')+&+%*>! +'! $(*.! ,+4)! )+&/(*&#5%,%'0! +&'! +*$(&&0+7! +*! $)(%'7! /#)! 4*!
<+<5)+!$4!i(4@+)*+<+*'9HB!!
!
Remarque!K! b(4'+-(%&7! ,#! $0*#'4)#'%(*! $4! )0>%<+! $+! ,#! YV<+! 30/45,%64+! +&'! %.%! '#*>%5,+B! "80,+.'%(*! #4!
&4--)#>+!4*%@+)&+,!$%)+.'!.(*$4%'!?!.(*-%+)!?!4*!()>#*+!*8+*!#A#*'!/#&!,+&!#'')%54'%(*&!,+!&(%*!$8#//,%64+)!
4*! /)(>)#<<+! 64+! .+,4%! 64%! ,8%*.#)*+! #! /)0&+*'0! #4! &4--)#>+! /#)#,,V,+<+*'! ?! &#! .#*$%$#'4)+B! "#!
.(*')#$%.'%(*!+&'!/#'+*'+!/4%&64+!,+!2)0&%$+*'!$+!,#!30/45,%64+!*8#!*%!,#!.(</0'+*.+!.(*&'%'4'%(**+,,+!$+!
$0'+)<%*+)! ,#! /(,%'%64+! $+! ,#! *#'%(*! *%! .+,,+! $8#$(/'+)! ,+&! ,(%&! .()(,,#%)+&B! F+/+*$#*'! ,+&! .#*$%$#'&! &+!
/)0&+*'+*'! +*! ,8#--%)<#*'! +'! ,8+*&+<5,+! $+&! /+)&(**#,%'0&! /(,%'%64+&7! $+&! <0$%#&! +'! $+! ,#! /(/4,#'%(*7!
&8%*.,%*#*'!$+@#*'!,+&!-#%'&7!+*!+&'!.(*@#%*.4B!!2#)<%!,+&!%*.(*@0*%+*'&!$4!)+.(4)&!#4!)0-0)+*$4<!-%>4)+!,+!
-#%'! 64+! ,+! @('#*'! $(%'! )0/(*$)+! /#)! (4%! (4! /#)! *(*! ,?! (h! .;#.4*! )0/(*$)#%'! L!(4%! <#%&O!Q! (4! L!*(*!
<#%&O!QB! e@+.! ,80,+.'%(*! $84*! %*$%@%$4! +'! $+! &(*! /)(>)#<<+! .(**4! \&8%,! ,8+&']7! ,#! <#=()%'0! $+&! 0,+.'+4)&!
$%&+*'7!(4!$%)#%+*'7!#%*&%!L!(4%!Q!&#*&!L!<#%&!Q!?!$+&!$%o#%*+&!$+!/)(/(&%'%(*&!/,4&!(4!<(%*&!+1/,%.%'+&B!F+'!
0'#'! $+! -#%'! +&'! $0<(.)#'%64+<+*'! #5+))#*'! <T<+! .(</'+! '+*4! $+! ,#! @#,%$#'%(*! /#),+<+*'#%)+! $+&! ,(%&!
%&&4+&!$+!.+!/)(>)#<<+!\cf.#infra#II.A]B!c,!<0/)%&+!#4!<(%*&!4*+!$+&!5#&+&!$+!,#!$0<(.)#'%+!)+/)0&+*'#'%@+!K!
""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""
S"_'%=8*&/+=$"&$%"2/G8*',)%"75$"./"*)(8*2$"&5"75'+75$++/,"$,"%5*,85,".:";"'+A$*%'8+"&$%"=/.$+&*'$*%"<9".:).$=,'8+"
4*)%'&$+,'$..$"4*)=)&/+,".$%").$=,'8+%".)>'%./,'A$%9"8+,",$+,)"&:)A',$*?"
Q"`'+%'9"&/+%"./"4*/,'75$"=8+,$248*/'+$9"+$"%8+,"+8,/22$+,"4/%"5,'.'%)%"4/*".$"-*)%'&$+,"H".:/*,'=.$"N!9".$"
-*)%'&$+,"&$"./"3)456.'75$"+$"%/'%',"4/%".$"P8+%$'."=8+%,',5,'8++$."&$"./"=8+(8*2',)"&:5+$".8'"F"./"P8+%,',5,'8+"
2/.>*)"%8+"*U.$"&$">/*&'$+"&$"=$..$D='9".:/*,'=.$"!!9"F".:$M=$4,'8+"&$"./"*/,'('=/,'8+"&$%",*/',)%"'."+:J"/"4/%"&$"
*)()*$+&52%".)>'%./,'(%"85"$+=8*$".:/*,'=.$"!L9"./"&'%%8.5,'8+"),/+,"&$A$+5$"%/+%"'+,)*B,"&1%".8*%"75$".$"-*)%'&$+,"
&'%48%$"a$priori9"&1%".$".$+&$2/'+"&$"%8+"'+A$%,',5*$"$,"485*"='+7"/+%9"&:5+$"2/G8*',)"&$"&)45,)%".5'"),/+,"
;"/=75'%"<?"
!a"#$"=8+,*$%$'+>"&$%"/=,$%"4*)%'&$+,'$.%"$%,"/448%)"4/*".$"-*$2'$*"Z'+'%,*$"$,"4/*".$"2'+'%,*$"=8+=$*+)?"

W"
"
,#! $0,%50)#'%(*B! "+! .(*'+*4! $4! /)(>)#<<+! /)0&%$+*'%+,! +&'! &4//(&0! $#*&! &(*! +*&+<5,+! L!@(4,4! /#)! ,+!
/+4/,+!Q! /#)! ,+! ')4.;+<+*'! $+! ,80,+.'%(*! $+! .+,4%! 64%! ,8#! /()'0! #@+.! /,4&! (4! <(%*&! $+! /)0.%&%(*&! +'!
$8%*-()<#'%(*&B!"80,+.'%(*!/)0&%$+*'%+,,+!#//#)#d'!+*!64+,64+!&()'+7!#4!@4!$+&!#--%)<#'%(*&7!A!.(</)%&!/(&'!
0,+.'()#,+&7! .(<<+! 4*! )0-0)+*$4<! >0#*'! &4)! ,+&! /)(/(&%'%(*&99!$4! .#*$%$#'! -#%&#*'! -%7! $#*&! ,+! $%&.(4)&!
&%*(*!$#*&!,#!)0#,%'07!$+!,#!-(*.'%(*!/#),+<+*'#%)+!.(*&'%'4'%(**+,,+<+*'!0$%.'0+B!
!
e4=(4)$M;4%7! ,+&! #'')%54'%(*&! /)0&%$+*'%+,,+&! )+&'+*'! $(*.! >0*0)#,+<+*'! +*$(&&0+&! (4! #..+/'0+&! /#)!
$8#4')+&! ()>#*+&7! .+! 64%! *+! =4&'%-%+)#%'! $(*.! /#&! ,#! <%&+! +*! /,#.+! $84*! <0.#*%&<+! $+! )+&/(*&#5%,%'0!
/(,%'%64+!S!.+/+*$#*'!%,!+&'!$+&!#.'+&!$4!2)0&%$+*'!$+!,#!30/45,%64+!64%!&()'+*'!$4!.#$)+!$+!.+!64%!+&'!#%*&%!
=4)%$%64+<+*'!()>#*%&0B!
!
!
C)#Les#actes#présidentiels#souffrant#de#cette#absence#de#responsabilité#politique##
!
e%*&%7!&%!,+!2)0&%$+*'!$+!,#!30/45,%64+!*8#!/#&!$8#'')%54'%(*&!.(*&'%'4'%(**+,,+&!=4&'%-%#*'!a#priori!,#!<%&+!+*!
/,#.+!$84*!<0.#*%&<+!$+!)+&/(*&#5%,%'07!#!4*+!/#)(,+7!!$+&!.(</()'+<+*'&!+'!$+&!@(,(*'0&!$(*'!%,!*8#!/#&!?!
)+*$)+!.(</'+B!!
j#*&!,8+1+).%.+!$+!&#!-(*.'%(*9G7!,+!2)0&%$+*'!$+!,#!30/45,%64+!/+4'!0@+*'4+,,+<+*'!+1/)%<+)!$+&!(/%*%(*&!
(4!#@(%)!$+&!#''%'4$+&!64%!&(*'!&4&.+/'%5,+&!$+!;+4)'+)7!@(%)+!$+!<0.(**#d')+!,#!F(*&'%'4'%(*7!&#*&!6484*+!
64+,.(*64+!)+&/(*&#5%,%'0!/4%&&+!T')+!+*>#>0+B!^4+,64+&!+1+</,+&!)0.+*'&9R!'0<(%>*+*'!$+!.+!)%&64+7!,+!
2)0&%$+*'! #! #%*&%! /47! &#*&! .(*&064+*.+&! =4)%$%64+&7! /)(/(&+)! $+&! $%&'%*.'%(*&! ?! )#%&(*! $+! ,8()%>%*+!
0')#*>V)+!(4!*(*!$+&!*#'%(*#417!+*!(//(&%'%(*!#@+.!,+!/)%*.%/+!.(*&'%'4'%(**+,!$M0>#,%'0!$+@#*'!,#!,(%!$+!
'(4&!,+&!.%'(A+*&!&#*&!$%&'%*.'%(*!$M()%>%*+7!'+*'+)!$+!.(*'(4)*+)!4*+!$0.%&%(*!$4!F(*&+%,!F(*&'%'4'%(**+,!
$(*'!,8#4'()%'0!+&'!#--%)<0+!$#*&!,#!F(*&'%'4'%(*!\#)'%.,+!CG]7!/()'+)!$#*&!&+&!$%&.(4)&!#''+%*'+!#4!/)%*.%/+!
$+!,#p.%'0!-%>4)#*'!?!,M#)'%.,+!9+)!$4!<T<+!'+1'+B!F+&!.(</()'+<+*'&!0'#*'!$(45,+<+*'!+*!.(*')#)%0'0!#@+.!
,#! F(*&'%'4'%(*! /4%&648%,&! *8+*! )+&/+.'+*'! /#&7! a# priori7! '+,! (4! '+,! /)%*.%/+! +'! &+.(*$#%)+<+*'! /#).+! 648%,!
#//#)'%+*'!#4!2)0&%$+*'7!+*!@+)'4!$+!,8#)'%.,+!X7!$+!@+%,,+)!#4!)+&/+.'!$+!,#!F(*&'%'4'%(*B!b#*'!64+!.+&!#.'+&!
*+!&(*'!/#&!.(*&%$0)0&!/#)!,+&!/#),+<+*'#%)+&!.(<<+!4*!<#*64+<+*'!#41!$+@(%)&!/)0&%$+*'%+,&!\cf.#infra#
II.C]7!%,&!&(*'!%*&4&.+/'%5,+&!$8+*')#d*+)!,#!<%&+!+*!=+4!$+!,#!)+&/(*&#5%,%'0!/(,%'%64+!$4!2)0&%$+*'!64#*$!
5%+*! <T<+! %,&! .(*&'%'4+)#%+*'! $+&! #''+%*'+&! >)#@+&! #4! $)(%'7! A! .(</)%&! .(*&'%'4'%(**+,7! +*! @%>4+4)! $#*&!
,8a'#'!/#)!&(*!.;+-B!
b(4'+-(%&!.+&!.(</()'+<+*'&7! a#priori!&#*&! +--+'&!*()<#'%-&!$%)+.'&7!*+!.(*&'%'4+*'!/#&!>0*0)#,+<+*'!.+!
/(4)64(%! L!.+)'#%*&!Q! &(4;#%'+)#%+*'! 64+! ,+! 2)0&%$+*'! &(%'! )+&/(*&#5,+B! a*! +--+'7! .+! &(*'! $#@#*'#>+! ,+&!
.;(%1! /(,%'%64+&! &45&'#*'%+,&! 648%,! +--+.'4+! 64%! &(*'! ,8(5=+'! $+! .+''+! )+@+*$%.#'%(*! ?! )#%&(*! $+&!
.(*&064+*.+&! <#=+4)+&! 648%,&! (*'! &4)! ,#! &%'4#'%(*! &(.%#,+! *#'%(*#,+B! "+! 2)0&%$+*'! $+! ,#! 30/45,%64+!
$0'+)<%*+!+'!.(*$4%'!$+!-#%'!,#!/(,%'%64+!$+!,#!*#'%(*B!Z)!,#!F(*&'%'4'%(*!64%!/)0@(%'!64+!.+''+!/)0)(>#'%@+!
+&'!.+,,+!$4!i(4@+)*+<+*'!.(</,V'+!.+''+!$%&/(&%'%(*7!/)%*.%/+!-(*$#<+*'#,!$4!)0>%<+!/#),+<+*'#%)+7!/#)!
,#!)+&/(*&#5%,%'0!/(,%'%64+!$+!.+,4%!64%!#%*&%!+1+).+!,+!/(4@(%)!$+!$%)+.'%(*!/(,%'%64+B!c,!A!#!$(*.7!(4')+!4*+!
<0.(**#%&&#*.+!$4!'+1'+!.(*&'%'4'%(**+,9[7!!%*.(*'+&'#5,+<+*'!4*!;%#'4&7!&(4@+*'!$0.)%'7!/4%&64+!,8()>#*+!
64%!+&'!)+&/(*&#5,+!$+!$)(%'!*8+&'!/#&!.+,4%!64%!+1+).+!,#!-(*.'%(*!$+!-#%'B!!
""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""
!!""P:$%,"/'+%'9"F",',*$"&:$M$24.$"%'>+'('=/,'(9"75$"./"*/,'('=/,'8+"&5"(5,5*"b*/',)"&$"#'%68++$9"4*)A5$"&/+%".$"
4*8>*/22$"&5"=/+&'&/,"X/*[8\J9"/"),)"/(('*2)$"=822$".)>','2$"6'$+"75$"=8+,85*+/+,".$"*$(5%"8448%)"4/*"./"
2/G8*',)"&$%"A8,/+,%".8*%"&5"*)()*$+&52"48*,/+,"%4)='('75$2$+,"%5*".$",$M,$?"c5$."75$"%8',".:'+,)*B,"48.','75$"
85"G5*'&'75$"&$"=$",*/',)9"5+$"&'%48%','8+"&:5+"4*8>*/22$"4*)%'&$+,'$."+$"&$A*/',"4/%9"&/+%"5+$"&)28=*/,'$9"
/A8'*"5+$"/5,8*',)"%54)*'$5*$"F"5+$"&)='%'8+"4845./'*$?"EP$='"$+",$*2$"&$".)>','2',)"&)28=*/,'75$"=/*"
G5*'&'75$2$+,9"./"*/,'('=/,'8+"4/*".$"-/*.$2$+,"/"./"2B2$"A/.$5*9"'='".)>'%./,'A$9"75$"=$..$"$(($=,5)$"4/*"A8'$"
*)()*$+&/'*$K?"
!L"#$"*)>'2$"G5*'&'75$"&$%"/=,$%"&$".:@822$D-*)%'&$+,"$M,)*'$5*%"F"%/"(8+=,'8+"+$"%$*/"4/%",*/',)"'='?""
!T"Y."$+"$%,"&$"4.5%"/+='$+%"+8,/22$+,"=$5M"&/+%".$%75$.%"&$%"-*)%'&$+,%"&$"./"3)456.'75$"8+,"2)=8++5"&$%"
86.'>/,'8+%"=8+%,',5,'8++$..$%",$.".$"-*)%'&$+,"_$"d/5..$"4*848%/+,"F"./"*/,'('=/,'8+"4845./'*$"5+$"*)A'%'8+"
=8+%,',5,'8++$..$"=8+,85*+/+,"/'+%'".^/*,'=.$"SQ"&$"./"P8+%,',5,'8+9".$"-*)%'&$+,"Z',,$**/+&"*$(5%/+,"&$"%'>+$*"
&$%"8*&8++/+=$%"/5"2)4*'%"&$"./".$,,*$"&$".^/*,'=.$"!T"85".$"-*)%'&$+,"P@'*/="/44$./+,"F"+$"4/%"/44.'75$*"5+$".8'"
75:'."A$+/',"&$"4*825.>5$*?"
!W""#/"P8+%,',5,'8+"=8+,$+/+,"./"=/5%$"&$"%/"2)=8++/'%%/+=$"H".^/*,'=.$"La"$%,"'>+8*)"2/'%".^/*,'=.$"N"E*)A'%)"!QNLK"
$+"$%,".$"4*'+='4/."*$%48+%/6.$"?"

R"
"
"+!2)0&%$+*'!k#)q(oA!+'!,+!F(<%'0!f#,,#$4)!#@#%+*'!+*@%&#>07!#-%*!$+!<+'')+!,+!$)(%'!+*!.(*-()<%'0!#@+.!,#!
)0#,%'09X7!$+!<($%-%+)!,M#)'%.,+!X!$+!,#!F(*&'%'4'%(*!+'!$+!-#%)+!$4!2)0&%$+*'!$+!,#!30/45,%64+!,+!'%'4,#%)+!$4!
/(4@(%)! $+! $0'+)<%*#'%(*! +'! $+! .(*$4%'+! $+! ,#! /(,%'%64+! $+! ,#! *#'%(*7! ,+! i(4@+)*+<+*'! ,#! <+''#*'! +*!
`4@)+B!F+''+!/)(/(&%'%(*!#!0'0!#5#*$(**0+B!a,,+!0'#%'!%*&'%'4'%(**+,,+<+*'!%*'+*#5,+!/4%&64+!,M#)'%.,+![W!
*80'#*'!/#&!<($%-%07!,+!)+&/(*&#5,+7!+*!,M(..4))+*.+!,+!i(4@+)*+<+*'7!,8#4)#%'!0'0!$84*+!/(,%'%64+!$(*'!%,!
*8#4)#%'! /#&! +4! +*! $)(%'! ,#! <#d')%&+B! F+)'+&! ,#! )0#,%'0! /(,%'%64+! #.'4+,,+! &4//()'+! .+''+! $%&'()&%(*! <#%&!
,8%*.,4)+! $#*&! 4*! <0.#*%&<+! .(*&'%'4'%(**+,! #4)#%'! 0'0! =4)%$%64+<+*'! %*#//)(/)%0! +'! -m.;+41B! "#!
)+&/(*&#5%,%'0!$4!L!.(,,#5()#'+4)!Q!+'!$+!&(*!064%/+!+&'!$#*&!,#!/)#'%64+!#..+/'#5,+!/#).+!648+,,+!*8+&'!/#&!
<%&+!+*!`4@)+!#@+.!4*+!/)(5#5%,%'0!$+!.+*&4)+9C!!0'#*'!$(**0!,8064%,%5)+!#.'4+,!$+!,#!YV<+!30/45,%64+B!
jV&!,()&7!(*!/+4'!/+*&+)!64+!,80@+*'4+,,+!)+&/(*&#5%,%'0!$4!2)0&%$+*'!*+!=(4+)#%'!/#&!*(*!/,4&!+'!648+,,+!
*8+&'! $(*.! >4V)+! 4'%,+B! F+/+*$#*'7! ,+&! $%--0)+*'&! <0.#*%&<+&! %*&'%'4'%(**+,&7! A! .(</)%&! .+41! 64%! &(*'!
/)0@4&! /(4)! 4*+! &%'4#'%(*! +1.+/'%(**+,,+7! .(*')%54+*'! ?! ,8064%,%5)+! $4! )0>%<+! +'! $(%@+*'! $V&! ,()&! T')+!
.(;0)+*'&B!F+!*8+&'!/#&!,+!.#&!$#*&!,+&!%*&'%'4'%(*&!-)#*_#%&+&!#.'4+,,+&!$4!-#%'!$+!,8%))+&/(*&#5%,%'0!$+!$)(%'!
$+!.+,4%!64%!>(4@+)*+!$+!-#%'B!b(4'+-(%&7!.+''+!%))+&/(*&#5%,%'0!/(,%'%64+!$4!2)0&%$+*'!+&'!#''0*40+!/#)!$+&!
<(A+*&!%*$%)+.'&!$+!.(*'):,+!$+!&+&!$0.%&%(*&!/(,%'%64+&B!
!
!
!
II"#"Les"mécanismes"institutionnels"atténuant"l’irresponsabilité"politique"du"Président"de"la"Vème"
République""
!
F+)'#%*+&! $%&/(&%'%(*&! .(*&'%'4'%(**+,,+&! +'! ,8064%,%5)+! >0*0)#,! $4! )0>%<+! /+4@+*'! #''0*4+)! ,+! $0-#4'! $+!
)+&/(*&#5%,%'0!/(,%'%64+!$4!'%'4,#%)+!$4!/(4@(%)!+--+.'%-!$+!$%)+.'%(*!$+!,#!/(,%'%64+!*#'%(*#,+B!"#!&#*.'%(*!
%*$%)+.'+! $+! ,#! @(,(*'0! /)0&%$+*'%+,,+! /#)! ,+! 2#),+<+*'! \e]7! ,+! $0&#@+4! /(/4,#%)+! \f]! +'! 4*+! +1.+/'%(*!
.(*&'%'4'%(**+,,+! $+! )+&/(*&#5%,%'0! \F]! &(*'! #%*&%! &4&.+/'%5,+&! $+! .(</+*&+)! (4! $8#''0*4+)!
,8%))+&/(*&#5%,%'0!/(,%'%64+!$4!2)0&%$+*'!#--%)<0+!?!,M#)'%.,+!CD!#,!9!$+!,#!F(*&'%'4'%(*B!
!
!
A)#La#sanction#parlementaire#des#choix#politiques#présidentiels#
!
"+!2)0&%$+*'!$+!,#!30/45,%64+!+&'!%))+&/(*&#5,+!/(,%'%64+<+*'!<#%&!,+!i(4@+)*+<+*'!64%!<+'!+*!`4@)+!
,+&!.;(%1!/(,%'%64+&!$+!.+!.;+-!$+!,8+10.4'%-!,8+&'B!c,!&4--%)#%'!$(*.!#41!$0/4'0&!$+!)+*@+)&+)!,+!>(4@+)*+<+*'!
/(4)!<#*%-+&'+)!4*+!$0&#//)(5#'%(*!?!,80>#)$!$+!,#!/(,%'%64+!/)0&%$+*'%+,,+9DB!
j+!/,4&7!$#*&!,#!/,4/#)'!$+&!$(<#%*+&!/(,%'%64+&!\.-B!*('#<<+*'!,8#)'%.,+!R[!$+!,#!F(*&'%'4'%(*]7!,#!@(,(*'0!
/(,%'%64+!$4!2)0&%$+*'!*0.+&&%'+!4*+!%*'+)@+*'%(*!/#),+<+*'#%)+B!a*!.#&!$+!$0&#..()$!#@+.!,+!2)0&%$+*'7!%,!
&4--%'!(4!%,!&4--%)#%'!$(*.!#41!/#),+<+*'#%)+&!$+!)+-4&+)!'+,!(4!'+,!'+1'+!(4!$+!,8#<+*$+)B!"80'#5,%&&+<+*'!
$84*+!)+&/(*&#5%,%'0!/(,%'%64+!$4!2)0&%$+*'!*8+&'!#%*&%7!$#*&!,+!$(<#%*+!,0>%&,#'%-7!/#&!*0.+&&#%)+B!k(%'!,+&!
/#),+<+*'#%)+&! $+! ,#! <#=()%'0! &(*'! +*! #..()$! #@+.! ,#! @(,(*'0! /)0&%$+*'%+,,+! +'! %,&! *+! <+'')#%+*'! /#&! +*!
.#4&+! #,()&! ,#! )+&/(*&#5%,%'0! /(,%'%64+! $4! 2)0&%$+*'! $+! ,#! 30/45,%64+7! &(%'7! %,&! &(*'! +*! $0&#..()$! +'! %,&!
/+4@+*'!I!&#*&!)0-()<+!I!)+-4&+)!$+!@('+)!,+&!,(%&!/)(/(&0+&!+'!#%*&%!&8(//(&+)!+--%.#.+<+*'!?!,#!@(,(*'0!
/)0&%$+*'%+,,+9EB!b(4'+-(%&7!,#!)0#,%'0!/(,%'%64+!.(*$4%'!?!*4#*.+)!.+''+!-#.4,'0!/4%&64+!$#*&!,#!/)#'%64+!,+&!
/#),+<+*'#%)+&!)0/4>*+*'!?!&8(//(&+)!?!,#!@(,(*'0!$84*!2)0&%$+*'!0,4!#4!&4--)#>+!4*%@+)&+,!$%)+.'!&4)!4*!
/)(>)#<<+!648%,!#7!&+,(*!,+&!#--%)<#'%(*&!.(4)#*'+&!\cf.#supra]7!@(.#'%(*!?!#//,%64+)9W!+'!+*@+)&!64%7!0,4&!
""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""
!R"NB"H"./"&)2/*=@$"$%,"4/*,'=5.'1*$"45'%75:'."%:/>',"/.8*%"+8+"&:/&/4,$*"5+"=8248*,$2$+,"/5"&*8',"2/'%"
&:/G5%,$*".$"&*8',"/5M"=8248*,$2$+,%"75'".5'"%8+,"=8+,*/'*$%?"
!N"X'".:8+"$M=$4,$"./"=$+%5*$"&$"!QNL"e"75'"A'%/',"&:/'..$5*%"5+"=@8'M"4*)%'&$+,'$.""G5*'&'75$2$+,"4*848%)"4/*".$"
-*$2'$*"2'+'%,*$"e""$,".$%"28,'8+%"'%%5$%"&$".:5,'.'%/,'8+"&$".:/*,'=.$"WQ"/."T"4/*"5+">85A$*+$2$+,"+$"&'%48%/+,"
75$"&:5+$"2/G8*',)"*$./,'A$"F".:`%%$26.)$"+/,'8+/.$"E4)*'8&$"!QSSf!QQTK9".$%"2)=/+'%2$%"&$".:/*,'=.$"WQ9"%:'.%"
8+,".$5*%"*U.$%"&/+%".:)75'.'6*$"&5"*)>'2$9"+$"=8+&5'%$+,"4/%"$(($=,'A$2$+,"F"./"&)2'%%'8+"&5"d85A$*+$2$+,?"
Egh"H"$+"!QNL9".$"-*$2'$*"2'+'%,*$"&8+,".$"d85A$*+$2$+,"/A/',"),)"=$+%5*)"/"),)"*$=8+&5',"F"=$,,$"(8+=,'8+"4/*"
.$"-*)%'&$+,"_$"d/5..$"F"./"%5',$"&$%").$=,'8+%"'%%5$%"&$"%/"&)='%'8+"&$"&'%%8.5,'8+K""
!O"#/"&'%%8.5,'8+"485A/+,"/.8*%9"=822$"$+"!QNL9"4$*2$,,*$"/5"4$54.$9"$+"(/',"/5"=8*4%").$=,8*/."4/*,'='4/+,"/5"
%=*5,'+9"&:/*6',*$*".$"=8+(.',"48.','75$?""
!S"P(?"F"=$"%5G$,"./"*)(.$M'8+"&$"X,)4@/+$"-Ygig9";"Une$Ve$République$toujours$plus$"parlementaireC"<9"3$=5$'."
_/..8\9"LaaS9"4?"TaQN"
!Q"X'".$";"(/',"2/G8*',/'*$"<"4$5,"G85$*"&/+%".$%";"/5,*$%"<"*)>'2$%"4/*.$2$+,/'*$%9"%'".$"P@$("&5">85A$*+$2$+,"
4$5,"J"/A8'*"5+$"/%%'%$")75'A/.$+,$"F"=$..$"&5"=@$("&$".:$M)=5,'("(*/+]/'%9".:).$=,'8+"&5"-*)%'&$+,"/5"%5((*/>$"