Les mathématiques à l`école des scribes de Mésopotamie

Les mathématiques à l’école
des scribes de Mésopotamie
Alice Morales(*), Marcel Morales(**)
& Marc Troudet(***)
9H9LH9:5=HGI=H95IL89IL5H9@=9FGEI9BCIG5JCBGDFTG9BHTG5IL89FB=UF9G#CIFBT9G
'5H=CB5@9G
%9DF9A=9F5DCIFGI>9H@9GT7C@9G89G7F=69G9H@9GA5H<TA5H=EI9G8IF5BH@5DTF=C89
D5@TC656M@CB=9BB99BHF9-9H-=@9GHF9@5HT85BG@9GD5F5;F5D<9GP
%9 G97CB8 5H9@=9F DFCDCG9 @fTHI89 8fIB DFC6@UA9 8f5FD9BH5;9 HMD=EI9 89 79HH9
DTF=C89=@9GHFTGIAT85BG@9D5F5;F5D<9
'CIGF9A9F7=CBG<F=GH=B9)FCIGH%56CF5HC=F9+)!*DCIFG9G7CBG9=@G
"(&#)(#"
%5 &TGCDCH5A=9 9GH G=HIT9 85BG @5 FT;=CB C77IDT9 57HI9@@9A9BH D5F @f"F5? 9H
D5FH=9@@9A9BHD5F@f"F5BGCB<=GHC=F9GfTH9B8GIFIB98IFT98f9BJ=FCB5BG%5
7I@HIF9ATGCDCH5A=9BB99GH@9:FI=H89@5F9B7CBHF98989ILD9ID@9Gb@9G+IATF=9BG
5I GI8 9H @9G ??58=9BG 5I BCF8 %5 DTF=C89 @5 D@IG F=7<9 9B 8C7IA9BHG
A5H<TA5H=EI9G7CBBIGP79>CIF9GH@5DTF=C89D5@TC656M@CB=9BB9
%9G HF579G 8fT7F=HIF9 @9G D@IG 5B7=9BB9G 5DD5F5=GG9BH J9FG - GIF 89G H56@9HH9G
8f5F;=@9HFCIJT9GP-FI?=HTOH5H8IGI889@5&TGCDCH5A=99HP+IG9=HTOH5H8I
D5MG 8f@5A =9B EI9 7CBH9GHT9 D5F 79FH5=BG 5GGMF=C@C;I9G @5 H<TCF=9 8CA=B5BH9
9LD@=EI9 @5 B5=GG5B79 89 @fT7F=HIF9 9H 89G A5H<TA5H=EI9G D5F @9G 69GC=BG 89 @5
7CADH56=@=HT85BG79HH9FT;=CB8IACB89T7CBCA=EI9A9BHDFCGDUF9
%9GDF9A=UF9GH9BH5H=J9G897CADH5;95DD5F5=GG9BHGCIG:CFA989>9HCBG89:CFA9G9H
H5=@@9G 8=J9FG9G 5M5BH IB9 G=;B=:=75H=CB IB=EI9A9BH DCIF @9G D9FGCBB9G EI=
=BH9FJ=9BB9BH85BG@5HF5BG57H=CB5BGIBGCI7=8fIB=:=75H=CB89GGMA6C@9G=@GJCBH
VHF9 F9AD@57TG D5F 89G 6I@@9G9BJ9@CDD9G =BGD=FT9G 89G DF5H=EI9G 89G 69F;9FG
7CBH9B5BH89G6CI@9G9H7YB9G8f5F;=@9@9G75@7I@=
)5F@5GI=H9IB;F5D<=GA9T@56CFT5DD5F5WHGIF@9GG795IL7M@=B8F=EI9G*5DD9@CBG
EIfIBG795I7M@=B8F=EI99GHIBD9H=H7M@=B8F9GIF@9EI9@9GH;F5JTIBACH=:5J97IB
7CIFHH9LH9=89BH=:=5BHGCBDCGG9GG9IF%9GD=7HC;F5AA9G9H=8TC;F5AA9G8I8T6IH
G9FCBH9BGI=H9F9AD@57TGD5F@fT7F=HIF97IBT=:CFA9
c79>CIF@9G5F7<TC@C;I9GCBHHFCIJT9BJ=FCBIB89A=A=@@=CB89H56@9HH9G8CBH@5
AC=H=T 5 THT HF58I=H9 )5FA= 79@@9G@P EI9@EI9G  7CADCFH9BH  DFC6@UA9G
A5H<TA5H=EI9G 9H 9BJ=FCB  GCBH 89G H56@9G BIATF=EI9G 9H ATHFC@C;=EI9G %5
D@ID5FH89GH56@9HH9GA5H<TA5H=EI9GCBHTHTDI6@=T9G5I8T6IH8I009G=U7@9D5F(
Pour chercher et approfondir 327
APMEP
no504
7C@@U;99FB5B8%T;9FP+5=BH&5FH=B8f!UF9G
"BGH=HIHCIF=9F-B=J9FG=HT89 F9BC6@9ACF5@9GI>:;F9BC6@9:F
7C@@U;989@f"G@9P.=9BB9
Morales-Texte_Mise en page 1 05/05/13 12:16 Page327

'9I;965I9F 9H  ,<IF95I5B;=B ,CIH9:C=G >IGEIfP BCG >CIFG 89G GDT7=5@=GH9G
7CAA9 # F=69F; # !^MFID  )FCIGH 9H  *C6GCB 7CBH=BI9BH 89 HF58I=F9 9H
8fTHI8=9F8f5IHF9GH56@9HH9G=@GFT=BH9FDFUH9BHT;5@9A9BH@9GH56@9HH9G8T>PTHI8=T9G
'.# ''&'
c @5 :=B 8I 9A=@@TB5=F9 GCIG +5F;CB 8f??58  DI=G D9B85BH @5 9
8MB5GH=98f-FCBC6G9FJ9IB9::CFH89GH5B85F8=G5H=CBEI=DCFH95IGG=6=9BGIF@9G@C=G
9H@5ATHFC@C;=9EI9GIF@9G5IHF9G=BGHFIA9BHG89DCIJC=FT7F=HIF97CADH56=@=HT
75@9B8F=9FG%9FY@989GG7F=69GJ5VHF9:CB85A9BH5@9H@9GT7C@9G89G7F=69GJCBHG9
8TJ9@CDD9F8IF5BH79HH9DTF=C89
c @fCF=;=B9 7<5EI9 7CFDCF5H=CB 5 69GC=B 8fIB 7CBHF9A5WHF9 EI= D@5B=:=9 8=F=;9 @9
HF5J5=@ 9H FT8=;9 @9G 7CBHF5HG 7CIF5BHG %9 7CBHF9A5WHF9 8C=H G5JC=F @=F9 T7F=F9 9H
7CADH9F+CBBCA9GH9B7CF9DFCDF9P7<5EI97CFDCF5H=CB)5F@5GI=H9=@G9GDT7=5@=G9
9H @9 BCA )'& 9B GIATF=9B @=HHTF5@9A9BH 79@I= EI= T7F=H GIF IB9 H56@9HH9
5DD5F5WH,CIH9:C=G79H9FA9F9GH9HFUG;TBTF5@9H=B8=EI989G7CADTH9B79G89B=J95IL
HFUGJ5F=TGb89@5D9FGCBB9_b5@D<56TH=GT9b`75D56@989FT8=;9FIB7CBHF5H7CIF5BHCI
8f58A=B=GHF9F89G6=9BGP@f<CAA989@9HHF9G8TH9BH9IF9HJ97H9IF8fIB9J5GH97I@HIF9
dIJF5BH5IG9FJ=798IFC=CI8fIBH9AD@9%9GG7F=69G:CFA9BHIB97CFDCF5H=CBHFUG
:9FAT9 9H HF5BGA9HH9BH @9IFG 7CBB5=GG5B79G 85BG 89G @=9IL 8T8=TGb  @9G T7C@9G 89G
G7F=69GCI) 9BGIATF=9B98I665A5=GCB89GH56@9HH9G
%9GT7C@9GGIDDCGT9GGCBH89GA5=GCBG85BG@9GEI9@@9G@9G5F7<TC@C;I9GCBHHFCIJT
EI5BH=HT89H56@9HH9GT7F=H9GD5F89GT7C@=9FG9GH56@9HH9GGCBHF9HFCIJT9G9BH5GGT9G
6F=GT9GCI9B7CF9IH=@=GT9GDCIF7CA6@9F89GGC@GCI7CBGHFI=F989GAIFG9GT7C@9G
5DD5F5=GG9BH5I00"9G=U7@95J#%9GD@IG7T@U6F9GD5F@9BCA6F989H56@9HH9G
HFCIJT9GGCBH79@@9G89'=DDIF-FI?+=DD5F$=G<9H&5F=@@9G85H9BH89@fTDCEI9
D5@TC656M@CB=9BB99BJ=FCB-5BG79GT7C@9G@f9BG9=;B9A9BH9GHCF;5B=GT
9B)+"*)+ 
%f9BG9=;B9A9BH T@TA9BH5=F9 HFUG GHF=7H 8CBB5BH IB9 HFUG ;F5B89 D@579 P
@f5DDF9BH=GG5;9D5F7dIFTJC@I99BGI=H9J9FGIB9BG9=;B9A9BH@5=GG5BH85J5BH5;989
D@579P@f5IHCBCA=95IB=J95I5J5B7T
328 Pour chercher et approfondir APMEP
no504
I"*). .!"(& CB5DDF9B8b
\ 89GGM@@565=F9G
\ 89G@=GH9G 89JC756I@5=F97@5GGTG
G9@CB89G7F=HUF9GDF=B7=D5@9A9BHH<T
A5H=EI9G
\ 89GDFCJ9F69GDF9A=UF9GD<F5G9G9B
GIATF=9B
\ 89GAC8U@9G897CBHF5HG
\ 89GH56@9GATHFC@C;=EI9G75D57=HTG
GIF:579G
\ 89GH56@9GBIATF=EI9GAI@H=D@=75
H=CBG=BJ9FG9G75FFTG7I69G
)"*)*". CB5DDF9B8b
\ 89G7CADCG=H=CBG@=HHTF5=F9G
\ 89G75@7I@GBIATF=EI9G
\ 89G 75@7I@G 89 GIF:579G 9H 89
JC@IA9G
Morales-Texte_Mise en page 1 05/05/13 12:16 Page328

+9@CB)FCIGHb_b%9G7CB79DH=CBGA5H<TA5H=EI9G8965G9HF5BGA=G9GD5F@9GT7C@9G
D5@TC656M@CB=9BB9G7CBGH=HI9BHIB9BG9A6@9<CAC;UB99HIB=:=TA5=GEI=5DIVHF9
9BG9=;BTG9@CB89GATH<C89GDFCDF9GP79FH5=B9GTDCEI9GCI79FH5=B9GFT;=CBGb`
'!(.!(%)'
")!.&(#"1
%9G&TGCDCH5A=9BGIH=@=G9BHIBGMGHUA989BIATF5H=CB
\G9L5;TG=A5@b
\89DCG=H=CBb
\PJ=F;I@9:@CHH5BH9
BT7F=HIF97IBT=:CFA9@9GBCA6F9GGCBHT7F=HGP@f5=8989GMA6C@9G
\@97@CI89J5@9IFGnnŒZ
\@97<9JFCB89J5@9IFG¥nnŒZ
'%)(&#$.&(#"'
"@ Bf9L=GH9 D5G 89 HF579G T7F=H9G 89G ATH<C89G A=G9G 9B dIJF9 DCIF 9::97HI9F 89G
588=H=CBGGCIGHF57H=CBG9HAI@H=D@=75H=CBGBF9J5B7<9=@GI6G=GH9IB;F5B8BCA6F9
89H56@9G89AI@H=D@=75H=CBEI9@9G>9IB9GG7F=69G89J5=9BH5DDF9B8F9D5F7dIF%5
B5HIF9 89G 9FF9IFG 85BG @9G FTGI@H5HG 89 79FH5=B9G AI@H=D@=75H=CBG GI;;UF9 @fIG5;9
8f565EI9G@=HHTF5@9A9BHH56@9G89DCIGG=UF9@CFG89G75@7I@G7CAD@9L9G
%9G&TGCDCH5A=9BG 5J5=9BHIB9 J=G=CB HFUG AC89FB9 89@5 8=J=G=CB DI=GEI9 DCIF
79@5=@GAI@H=D@=5=9BHD5F@f=BJ9FG98I8=J=G9IF)CIF79HH9F5=GCB=@GCBH7CBGHFI=HIB9
H56@9 8f=BJ9FG9G 8CBH CB 5 HFCIJT IB ;F5B8 BCA6F9 8f9L9AD@5=F9G @9G =BJ9FG9G
Bf5DD5FH9B5BH D5G 5IL H56@9G TH5=9BH 75@7I@TG D5F :57HCF=G5H=CB EIf=@G 5DDF9B5=9BH
T;5@9A9BHD5F7dIF
B:=BIB;F5B8BCA6F989H56@9G8975FFTG7I69G9HF57=B9G75FFT9GBT79GG5=F9G85BG
@9G75@7I@G89GGIF:579G9H89JC@IA9GCBHTHTF9HFCIJT9G
.#!.(&
%9 JC756I@5=F9 ;TCATHF=EI9 9GH 7CBGH=HIT 89G ACHG GI=J5BHGb  HF=5B;@9 75FFT
F97H5B;@99HHF5DUN9BCAATb:FCBH896dI:79F7@9DF=GA98FC=H6F=EI9CIH5G89
6F=EI9GHFCB789DF=GA97M@=B8F9@CB;I9IF@5F;9IFa"@Bf9L=GH9D5G89ACHDCIF
8TG=;B9F@5D9FD9B8=7I@5=F9)CIF79@5=@GIH=@=G9BH@9H9FA98989G79B85BH985BG@9
G9BG8I:=@PD@CA6
9AVA9@9H9FA989D5F5@@U@9B9G9F9B7CBHF9D5GA5=GCBD5F@989@5HF5BGJ9FG5@9
9BH5BHEIfC6>9H;TCATHF=EI9D5F5@@U@95IL65G9G8fIBHF5DUN9EI=@9D5FH5;99B89IL
HF5DUN9G89 AVA9 5=F9 %9G 7YHTG 89G EI58F=@5HUF9G GCBH BCAATG :FCBHG 9H :@5B7G
H9FA9G 9ADFIBHTG 5I ACB89 5B=A5@ +I=H9 P IB9 FCH5H=CB 89 @fT7F=HIF9 89 [ 5I
00."""9G=U7@95J#@9G:=;IF9GCBHHCIFBTA5=G@9JC756I@5=F99GHF9GHT
9 BCA6F9IL DFC6@UA9G DCFH5BH GIF 89G 75@7I@G 8f5=F9G 9H 89 JC@IA9G D5F:C=G
=BGD=FTG89GDFC6@UA9G DF5H=EI9G A5=GD5GHCI>CIFG ACBHF9BH IB9;F5B89<56=@=HT
85BG@5FTGC@IH=CBEI=:5=G5=H<CBB9IF5ILG7F=69G
Les mathématiques des scribes 329
APMEP
no504
Morales-Texte_Mise en page 1 05/05/13 12:16 Page329

"%)&.'# )(#"'$&# /!')'#"&.
%5H56@9HH9 & 85HT98f9BJ=FCB -9GH 7CBG=8TFT9D5F @9G GDT7=5@=GH9G
7CAA9@9A5BI9@ 8I G97CB889;FT @@9 7CBH=9BH DFC6@UA9G CF;5B=GTG8I D@IG
G=AD@95ID@IG7CAD@=EIT%9GG9DHDF9A=9FGGCBH8T8=TGP@5FTGC@IH=CB89GTEI5H=CBG
8IG97CB889;FT8IHMD9ax+bx =c@9GGI=J5BHGDCFH9BHGIF89GGMGHUA9G89CI
TEI5H=CBG8IG97CB889;FTPCI=B7CBBI9G
)9B85BH@f5H9@=9F@9GD5FH=7=D5BHGCBHHF5J5=@@TGIF@9DFC6@UA9BC89@5H56@9HH9&
8IDC=BH89JI95@;T6F=EI99H;TCATHF=EI9JC=F5BB9L9
%fTHI8985BG@9IF9BG9A6@989GDFC6@UA9GTBCB7TGGIF79GH56@9HH9G8fIBDC=BH89
JI9 5@;T6F=EI9 9H ;TCATHF=EI9 89A5B89 8f56CF8 89 GIFACBH9F @9G 8=::=7I@HTG 8I
JC756I@5=F9 9H 89 @5 D9BGT9 A5H<TA5H=EI9 656M@CB=9BB9 @@9 A9H 9B @IA=UF9 @9G
5GHI79G8CBH:5=G5=9BHDF9IJ9@9GG7F=69G9D9B85BH=@B9:5IHD5GD9F8F989JI9EI9
@f=BH9FDFTH5H=CB8979GH9LH9G5B7=9BG9B@f56G9B7989@9IFG5IH9IFG9GHIBDFC6@UA9
FT7IFF9BH 9B @f<=GHC=F9 89G A5H<TA5H=EI9G B D5FH=7I@=9F =@ :5IH TJ=H9F HCIH
5B57<FCB=GA9%9G5JC=F:5=F9ATGCDCH5A=9B5HF5J9FGT@9GQ;9G7CAA9@f5HH9GH9BH
@9GT7F=HG5B7=9BG;F97GJC=F@fdIJF98f!TFCB8f@9L5B8F=9CI5F569GJC=F@f56FT;T
8f5@;U6F98f@$<KRF=NA=5I"09G=U7@99H"6B768gB5I09G=U7@9
%9G57H=J=HTG9H9L9F7=79G7CBSIG9H9LDTF=A9BHTG9B7@5GG9D5F@9;FCID9!=GHC=F989G
&5H<G89@f"*&89 F9BC6@9GCBH7CBGI@H56@9G5IDCFH5=@89@f"*&
"+!$ .#!.(&1 2"(.#&(##" )'&*
2&$"()&
#!!"($&(&)"(&$/,")+$&('!0!&1
9DFC6@UA98f5FD9BH5;9HMD=EI95DD5F5WH6=9B5J5BH@5DTF=C89D5@TC656M@CB=9BB9
%5H56@9HH9"&85H5BH8I"""9A=@@TB5=F95J#DFTG9BH98T>PIBHF5DUN95=BG=
D5FH5;T+IF79HH9H56@9HH9@9G7F=695BCHTIB=EI9A9BH@9G@CB;I9IFG89G7YHTG89@5
:=;IF9(BHFCIJ99BD5FH=7I@=9F7CAA9@CB;I9IFG89G89IL65G9G7CI8T9G9HD9IH
VHF9b7CI8T9G9BGMGHUA9G9L5;TG=A5@2@5J5@9IF7CI8T9G;=7CI8T9GBf9GH
D5G79FH5=B975F@5H56@9HH99GH9B8CAA5;T93
9G89ILJ5@9IFGBCIG=BH9FD9@@9BHB9::9H@9GATGCDCH5A=9BG7CBB5=GG5=9BH89G
HF=D@9HG89BCA6F9GBCAATG_bHF5DTNCX85ILb`DFC7<9G89GHF=D@9HGDMH<5;CF=7=9BG
H9@GEI9bbCZ9GH@5@CB;I9IF8IG9;A9BHEI=D5FH5;9IBH9@HF5DUN99B
89IL:=;IF9G89AVA95=F9
330 Pour chercher et approfondir APMEP
no504
Morales-Texte_Mise en page 1 05/05/13 12:16 Page330

%9G H56@9HH9G EI9 BCIG 5JCBG THI8=T9G IH=@=G9BH @5 :CFAI@9 CZ t9GH @5
@CB;I9IF89@5HF5BGJ9FG5@99H%9Hl79@@9G89G89IL65G9G
f9GH@975GGIF@5H56@9HH91CZIB98TACBGHF5H=CB9GH8CBBT97=89GGCIG
85BG @9 758F9 89 @f9L9AD@9 HF5=HT 'CHCBG HCIH9:C=G EI9 79HH9 89FB=UF9 D9IH VHF9
HF5BGDCGT985BG8f5IHF9GG=HI5H=CBG79EI=@I=7CB:UF9IB75F57HUF9;TBTF5@B:5=H
@58TA5F7<97CBG=GH5BHP9LDCG9FIB9ATH<C89PD5FH=F8fIB9L9AD@9DFT7=G5D9F8IFT
D9B85BH89GA=@@TB5=F9G9H79>IGEIfP@f=BHFC8I7H=CB8IGMA6C@=GA95@;T6F=EI95IL
9BJ=FCBG8I0."9G=U7@9
.C=7=8CB7@5DF9IJ98f5DFUG@5ATH<C8989@5H56@9HH91
HD5F588=H=CBb
)5F5::=B=HTCFH<C;CB5@979HH9:CFAI@9F9GH9JF5=9b
#) &)( '.
%9GH56@9HH9GEI9BCIGTHI8=CBGDCFH9BHHCIH9GGIF@9D5FH5;98fIBHF5DUN9_b:FCBH89
6dI:b`
=+ tlL
2
2
2 2
= −tL 2 A.
2 2
= +t l 2 A.
2 2
= +t l2 L .
2 2 2
Les mathématiques des scribes 331
APMEP
no504
Morales-Texte_Mise en page 1 05/05/13 12:16 Page331