Dossier MAS-SACRE plusCOURT

!
!
!"#$%&'(%')"%*&+#,')-#"%."*!-+/0%'1%,%'!*"''
1*"+*')2*"*'3+22*'2#4#56'72'!"#(0)&+#,''
*0&#0"'(0'85*)"%'(0'!"+,&%1!59''
'
!
!
!
'
'
'
'
'
%:');<!=;>?@AB;:'*CD@'2D'&EFGA=D'2DH'&I::D?=H''
72'!=;>?@AB;:6'3BJJI'2;K;H'IHKJ'
"?D'>D'2BHIJI'LL'
MMNO'4=?PDJJDH'
QQQRS@<CBJJIJ;K;HR@;S'

!
!
'
2%'!"#$%&''
'
*T=UH'?:D'TI=D:AEUHD'J?>BV?D'DA'T;FABV?D'ICD@'JI'TBU@D'WD?:D'T?KJB@'!"#$%&'&!"#$%X'
1I=BI')JI=I'3BJJI'2;K;H'=DCBD:AX'T;?='@DAAD'T=DSBU=D'@=FIAB;:'D:'AI:A'V?YI=ABHAD'
=FHB>D:AD'I?'&EFGA=D'2DH'&I::D?=HX'Z'H;:'H?WDA'>D'T=F>BJD@AB;:X'>FWZ'IK;=>F'>I:H'JI'
A=BJ;[BD''()&*+&$#&**+&,&JI'H;@BFAF'>D'@;:H;SSIAB;:'DA'HDH'>F=BCDHR''
%JJD'T=;\BAD'IB:HB'>?'@D:AD:IB=D'>D'JI'T=DSBU=D'>?'-./0$&12&3045#$67%'Z'!I=BHX'D:'
MNM]X'T;?='=DCBHBAD='Z'H;:'A;?='@DAAD'^?C=D'S_AEBV?D'>?'=FTD=A;B=D'S?HB@IJ'DA'
>I:HFR'2I'TBU@D'I'FAF'V?IJB\BFDX'D:'MNM]X''>D'81IHHI@=D'>?'T=B:ADSTH9'TI='JDH'
HTD@AIAD?=H'B:>B[:FH'DA'@E;V?FH'TI='J`ICI:A<[I=>BHSD'>D'JI'@E;=F[=ITEBD'>D',BWB:HaB'
IB:HB'V?D'TI='J`IHTD@A'HI?CI[D'>D'JI'S?HBV?D'>D'5A=ICB:Ha_R'
'
*CD@'8'1IH<5I@=D'9X'1I=BI')JI=I'3BJJI'2;K;H'H;?EIBAD'HD'=F\F=D='Z'@DAAD'TI[D'>D'
J`EBHA;B=D'>`?:D'SI:BU=D'B=;:BV?DX'D:'T=D:I:A'@D'WD?'>D'S;A'JBAAF=IJDSD:AX'\IBHI:A'>?'
SIHHI@=D'V?;AB>BD:'>DH'SBJJBD=H'>`I:BSI?P'IKIAA?H'TI='JYFJDCI[D'B:>?HA=BDJX'JD''
H?WDA'T=B:@BTIJ''>D'@DAAD':;?CDJJD'CD=HB;:'>?'8'5I@=D'9R'
%JJD'H;?EIBAD'IB:HB'\IB=D'>BIJ;[?D='JI'CB;JD:@D'T=FHD:AD'>I:H'JI'TI=ABAB;:'>D'
5A=ICB:Ha_'ICD@'?:'=D[I=>'@=BABV?D'H?='JDH'IK?H'SD:FH'TI='JYB:>?HA=BD'IJBSD:AIB=D'V?B'
A=IBAD:A'JDH'I:BSI?P'>DHAB:FH'Z'JI'@;:H;SSIAB;:'@;SSD'>DH';KWDAHX'T?='DA'
HBSTJDSD:AR'1I:BT?JIAB;:H'DA'JI:@FH'>D'T;?JDAH'\D=;:A'TI=ABD'>`?:D'@;ST;HBAB;:'
@E;=F[=ITEBV?D';b'JDH'>I:HD?=H'B:@I=:D:A'JDH'DSTJ;_FH'Z'JI'@EIc:D'>`?:D'?HB:D'Z'
CBI:>DX'SIBH'I?HHB'JDH'SI@EB:DH'DJJDH<SdSDHX'C;B='JDH'[IJJB:I@FH'V?`BJH'
>F@;=ABV?D:AeREBHA;B=D'>D'=F>?B=D'JDH'\=IBH'>D'T=;>?@AB;:RRR'
f2`I>;=IAB;:'>D'JI'AD==DfX'V?B'@;==DHT;:>'Z'JI'T=DSBU=D'TI=ABD'>D'JI'TI=ABAB;:'>D'
5A=ICB:Ha_X'>DCBD:A'B@B'8'JI'SI=@EI:>BHIAB;:'>D'JI'S;=A'9'g'T;?HHB:H'K=;_FH'Z'JI'
:IBHHI:@DX'T;?JDH'V?B':`;:A'I?@?:'DHTI@D'CBAIJX'T=BCFDH'>D'J?SBU=D'>?'W;?='>UH'JD?='
:IBHHI:@DX'K;?==FDH'>`E;=S;:DH'DA'>`I:ABKB;ABV?DHX':;?==BDH'I?P'\I=B:DH'I:BSIJDH'
T=;CD:I:A'>DH'DP@=FSD:AH'>YI?A=DH'T;?JDHe2DH'\D=SDH'>YFJDCI[D'B:>?HA=BDJH'
=DHHDSKJD:A'I?W;?=>YE?B'Z'>DH'@ISTH'>D'@;:@D:A=IAB;:'T;?='I:BSI?PR'+J':D'HYI[BA'
TJ?H'>YIBJJD?=H'>YFJDCI[D'>YI:BSI?PX'SIBH'>D'T=;>?@AB;:'>D'CBI:>D'I?'TJ?H'KIH'T=BP'
T;HHBKJDR''
'

!
!
'
(I:H'@DAAD'T=DSBU=D'TI=ABDX'JI'[DHA?DJJD'>DH'>I:HD?=H'HD=I'SB:BSIJD'DA'T=F@BHD'DA'
H`B:HTB=D=I'>B=D@ADSD:A'>DH'SI@EB:DH'B:>?HA=BDJJDH'V?B';TU=D:A'A;?AD'JI'@EIc:D'>D'
\IK=B@IAB;:'>`?:'T;?JDA'>D'@;:H;SSIAB;:X'>D'H;:'IKIAAI[D'Z'J`DSKIJJI[DR'+:@I=:FDH'
TI='>DH'f>I:HD?=H<SI@EB:DHfX'@D?P<@B';=@EDHA=D=;:A''?:'[=I:>'KIJJDA'>D'CBI:>DH'
TD:>?DHX'=;?JI:ADH';?'C;JI:ADHR'%\\B@I@BAF'DA'D:>?=I:@D'H;:A'JDH'S;AH'>`;=>=D'>D'@D'
KIJJDAX';b'A;?A'\I?P'TIH'TD?A'SDAA=D'D:'TF=BJ'JD'=DHAD'>?'[=;?TDR''
2I'>D?PBUSD'TI=ABD'>D'JI'TBU@D'@;==DHT;:>'I?'8'5I@=B\B@D'9''>I:H'JI'TI=ABAB;:'>D'
5A=ICB:Ha_'DA'HD'\;@IJBHD=I'H?='8'JYI:BSIJBHIAB;:'9'>D'JI'@EIB='E?SIB:DX'TI='JD'
=ITT=;@EDSD:A'\IBA'D:A=D'J`I:IA;SBD'>`?:'@;=TH'E?SIB:'DA'@DJ?B'>Y?:'I:BSIJX'SIBH'
I?HHB'TI='?:D'[DHA?DJJD'HI?CI[D'DA'@;:C?JHBCDX'T=;@ED'>D'@DJJD'>DH'I:BSI?P'
I[;:BHI:AHR'2I'@EIB='DPT;HFD'>DH'>I:HD?=HX'SB<I:BSI?PX'SB<E?SIB:HX'=D:CD==I'IB:HB'
Z'@DJJD'>DH'SBJJBD=H'>YI:BSI?P'HI@=B\BFH'V?;AB>BD::DSD:A'H?='JYI?ADJ'>?'T=;\BA'DA'>D'JI'
=D:AIKBJBAFR'
2D'HTD@AIAD?='HD=I'TJ;:[F'>I:H'?:'>BHT;HBAB\'IJAD=:I:A'BSI[DH'T=;WDAFDH'DA'
@E;=F[=ITEBDX'T=BCBJF[BI:A'?:D'T=;PBSBAF'ICD@'JDH'B:AD=T=UADHX':YI@@D:A?I:A'TIH'
JYIHTD@A'[=I:>B;HD'DA'HTD@AI@?JIB=D'>D'@DAAD'^?C=D'SIBH'JYB:CBAI:A'I?'@;:A=IB=D'Z'
;KHD=CD='>DH'[DHADH'\;:@AB;::DJHX'KI:IJDHX'=FTFABAB\H'IB:HB'V?D'>DH'>FAIBJH'g'JI'@EIB='
V?B'=;?JDX'V?B'@;[:DX'V?B'\=FSBA'H;?H'JDH'CBK=IAB;:H'>D'JI'S?HBV?DX'>DH'
SI:BT?JIAB;:HR'2I'@EIB='DHA'>`IBJJD?=H'?:'FJFSD:A'BST;=AI:A'>D'@D'T=;WDAX'V?YDJJD'H;BA'
I:BSIJD';?'E?SIB:DX'@I='DJJD':;?H'@;:\=;:AD'Z':;A=D'SIAF=BIJBAFX':;A=D'\B:BA?>D'DA'
:;?H'=ITT=;@ED'>DH'I:BSI?P'V?D':;?H'@;:H;SS;:H'T?BHV?D':;?H'H;SSDH'A;?H'
\IBAH'>D'@EIB='DA'>Y;HX'>Y?:'@D=CDI?X'>Y?:'@^?=e'
*B:HBX'1IH<5I@=DX'D:A=D'TD=\;=SI:@D'DA'HTD@AI@JD'>D'>I:HDX'DPTJ;=D'DA'HYITT=;T=BD'
JD'[=I:>'@JIHHBV?D'>D'5A=ICB:Ha_'D:'@;:\=;:AI:A'@D'>;:A':;?H'H;SSDH'\IBA'<<':;A=D'
T=;T=D'@EIB=X':;A=D'@;=TH'<<'ICD@'@D'V?B':;?H'\IBA'DA':;?H'D:A;?=D'<<'@D'V?D':;?H'
SI:[D;:HX'@D'V?D':;?H'@;:H;SS;:HR''
'
'

!
!
'
'
'
'
'
'
'
'
'
'
'
'
'
'
'
)#,)205+#,'
'
"DCBHBAD='JD'-./0$&12&7045#$67%&DHA'Z'JI'\;BH'D\\=I_I:A'DA'HABS?JI:A'g'D\\=I_I:A'TI='JD'
T;B>H'>D'HI'T=;T=D'EBHA;B=D'DA'TI='JD':;SK=D'B:@=;_IKJD'>D'CD=HB;:H'DPBHAI:ADHX'
@=FDH':;AISSD:A'TI='>D'[=I:>H'@E;=F[=ITEDH'ADJH'V?D'4FWI=A';?'!B:I'4I?H@ER'
5ABS?JI:A'TI='J`ITTDJ'T=DHV?YB==FHBHABKJD'V?D'JI'S?HBV?D'T;=AD'D:@;=D'I?W;?=>`E?BR''
2YD:WD?'>D'@D'T=;WDA'DHA'>D'T=;T;HD='?:D'JD@A?=D'@;:ADST;=IB:D'DA'8>FHI@=IJBHFD9'
>D'@DAAD'^?C=D'DHHD:ABDJJD'>?'=FTD=A;B=D'>D'JI'>I:HDR')DAAD'>FHI@=IJBHIAB;:'HY;TU=D'
H?=A;?A'TI='JD'KBIBH'>Y?:D'=D<@;:ADPA?IJBHIAB;:'>D'JI'TBU@D';=B[B:IJD'DA'>Y?:D'
ITT=;@ED'B@;:;@JIHAD'>D'JYB>FD'>D'=FTD=A;B=D'DA'>D'=BA?DJR'
2D'T=;WDA'H;?EIBAD'I?HHB'H;?JDCD='JD'>FKIAX'>FWZ'D:AISFD'>I:H'JI'H;@BFAF'>DT?BH'
V?DJV?DH'I::FDHX'I?A;?='>D'JI'T=;>?@AB;:'B:AD:HBCD'DA'JI'@;:H;SSIAB;:'DP@DHHBCD'
>D'CBI:>DX'DA'T;HD='JI'V?DHAB;:'g'JI'CBI:>D'I:BSIJD'DHA<DJJD'C=IBSD:A'?:';KWDA'>D'
@;:H;SSIAB;:'@;SSD'?:'I?A=D'h'
'
'

!
!
%/0+!%'*"&+5&+/0%'!%,(*,&'2*')"%*&+#,'g'
'
%JJD'HD=I'@;ST;HFD'>Y'M'@E;=F[=ITEDX'i'>I:HD?=HX'M'CB>FIHAD'X'M'AD@E:B@BD:'
J?SBU=DH6H;:6'CB>F;X'M'S?HB@BD:'jT;?='JYI:IJ_HD'S?HB@IJDkR''
'
%/0+!%'%,'&#0",%%'g'
'
i'>I:HD?=HX'M'@E;=F[=ITEDX'M'AD@E:B@BD:'
jT=BP'>D'@DHHB;:'H?='>DSI:>DX'>BCD=H'\;=S?JDH'T;HHBKJDH'HDJ;:'JD':;SK=D'>D'
=DT=FHD:AIAB;:HkR'
'
!;=AD?HD' >?' T=;WDA' g' 1*"+*' )2*"*' 3+22*' 2#4#5' 6' )#1!*.,+%' 72'
!"#(0)&+#,'
'
1I=BI' )JI=I' 3BJJI' 2;K;H' j1)32k' DHA' :FD' Z' 4=IHBJBI' D:'
MNlLR' *T=UH' HDH' FA?>DH' D:' >I:HD' Z' 4D=JB:' DA' Z'
!R*R"R&R5' Z' 4=?PDJJDHX' DJJD' A=ICIBJJD' ICD@' >B\\F=D:AH'
@E;=F[=ITEDH' ADJH' V?D' "?B' -;=AIX' (ICB>' -D=:I:>DmX'
nBJJB'(;=:D=X')E=BHAB:D'(D'5SD>A'DA'2DH'4IJJDAH')R'>D'JI'
4RX'5IHEI'nIJAm'DA'&E;SIH'2DESD:'ICI:A'>D'HD'JI:@D='
>I:H'HI'T=;T=D'@=FIAB;:'@E;=F[=ITEBV?DR''
(UH'MNNoX'DJJD'@=FD'>D'@;?=ADH'\;=SDH'ADJJDH'V?D'896$&%:$$#&;96$&DA'!049R'
%:'LOOO'1)32' \;:>D'HI'@;STI[:BDX'72' !=;>?@AB;:X' DA' HD' JI:@D' >I:H' ?:D' HF=BD' >D'
HTD@AI@JDH'V?B';:A'T;?='AEFSIABV?D'JI'H;@BFAF'>D'@;:H;SSIAB;:'DA'HDH'>F=BCDHR'%JJD'
@=FD' >B\\F=D:ADH' TBU@DH' @E;=F[=ITEBV?DH' DA' AEFGA=IJDH' >;:A' *+)& <$/.2%$& %4=$& 19$%&
6.##$0& jLOOOk'@=FFD' >I:H' JD' @I>=D' >D' 4=?PDJJDH' LOOOX' *-& jLOOLk'D:' @;JJIK;=IAB;:'
ICD@'JI'SIBH;:'>D'T=;>?@AB;:'I:CD=H;BHD'3BJJI:DJJIX'()&25$&74>/$&69?$55$&jLOO]kX'
**+& jLOOikX' -27$0& @& jLOOlk' D:' @;<T=;>?@AB;:' ICD@' )EI=JD=;B<>I:HDHR'(DT?BH' LOOO'
F[IJDSD:AX' DJJD' @;JJIK;=D' =F[?JBU=DSD:A' ICD@' JD' 8'4IJ' 1;>D=:D'9R'
%:' LOONX' DJJD' @=FD' JD' H;J;' 8$.1& A5& V?B' B:HTB=D=I' TI=' JI' H?BAD' !"#$%& '& !"#$%X' >?;'
@E;=F[=ITEBV?D' T;?=' D:\I:AH' Z' TI=AB=' >D' ]' I:H' T=FHD:AF' I?P' "D:@;:A=DH' >D' -?_'
LOMMR'(DT?BH'HDTADSK=D'LOML'DA'T;?=']'I:HX'DJJD'DHA'I=ABHAD'D:'=FHB>D:@D'I?'&EFGA=D'
2DH'&I::D?=H'j4=?PDJJDH'6'4DJ[BV?DkR'(I:H'@D'@I>=D'DJJD'T=FHD:AD'>D?P'H?@@UH'>D'JI'
@;STI[:BD' *+)& <$/.2%$& %4=$& 19$%& 6.##$0& DA' ()& 25$& 74>/$& 69?$55$& DA' @=FD=I' HI'
:;?CDJJD'@=FIAB;:X'(.%B-./0$X'I?A;?='>?'-./0$&12&3045#$67%&D:'\FC=BD='LOMpR''