Lacan Derrida le malentendu
———— LE TOUR CRITIQUE 3 (2014) ———
Lacan Derrida le malentendu
1. !"!"#$%"#&'(
(#$%"#&) *+"!%" "!%)
,"-%#.*" " !/ ) ((,"-%#
% %/0"%%/#($("( ( "(
&!%",(( 1"!! (/((""(
-%) !!/ ((/((2%("'( !%
%"3#$%"#&) *+"!)
"%,) ("+0- "!"!) /
" (" "!(!" "!%"%%4/
"%/!) " .*" !)
(2( 22) %%(!,(
'3 ( !1! -("/("- ! "+/5"
(!" 6%""/!7889(" "((") "/.
5(%#(""%#6 (%/%"") -(("("
%/+:;
'
3<
) *'" !" !''" 3
E
2. " ) " -= < -> " > !%",(/
"!%",(/("%/(1'%-.(
(%") %%"(,#" "7
(+!(( ?) %&+!((% (
"!!(+"! (( (+"!(%",( +"!"
" '" ""-!"!(// (3
" ) 2("("(!%",(
($!/"!!"" %%"3") (""(
"("%# /% ./!"
"-3(!,(" +")
7Dans son Histoire de la psychanalyse en France. 2 (1925-1985), l’auteur narre les deux temps de
rencontre entre Derrida et Lacan, notamment l’anecdote à caractère familial impliquant Jacques
Derrida, Pierre son fils aîné, et Marguerite son épouse, que le philosophe confie à Lacan lors d’un
dîner chez Jean Piel en 1967, confidence que Lacan reprendra et interprétera assez sauvagement
dans une conférence prononcée à l’Institut français de Naples quelques mois plus tard.
Roudinesco conclut : « Toujours est-il que cette histoire met fin aux rapports entre les deux
hommes. Dommage pour l’historien ! » (419).
— • 49 •
———— LE TOUR CRITIQUE 3 (2014) ———
((> "%%""!!+"! %%"%!) /
'."3
3. @) *'" ," ',* !3
"%!) / "%!) /A +
/ !%" *" /*.((/) 0%%
/B!) ("(" ,(/-!) "C) "(
(- +:) ('%-# *(" !;("
%!) / "%!) /!) ( ( !
) ( .( 3( D '# ( !-
".%) 2 2) 5 2(.6"!!"
) " %( " %( %"/ ! ( 2 % 1 %(
) !%") ( !%") ( %" # %
/%/!# (".( ($ ("%)
" ',(.% %,(" (#""-%# ) ()
(- 2 !% !%"(/ /-(/ "!! %"
+(;5?"/) 2+"("/ "E
( "&!+"("-!%%&3?(' )
" '"//!,((
'
( !" 2
" %( #FA
%
B( " ( !#F
,"%" (%!&+".(/-78GG 2"H"
/"%" (%!&+"2%"/?3963
4. <>("+%%/ (!%",( " /(!
%1#%4"!,,(A"
<%"(
) ( " " (%( !) ,((%( "!
!/B!1!) (/(5/("!" 6
) (+ %%.((/-&"!!!%(%#
A5*!;'"$F'" *") " " "!!
, " %!/!"6B3 %(("
) 5'"( (-!!"("-.(D(6%!%1
#/ // "!!( --// ( !1!"
!"I/#!- #! " () "
((>(%/-(/ "/ ,(4/'
(-03"%" %" "'( %
%# /!JJ/ #%5""(/K6L
%() (D '(%%"!
%,('(!",("/ (2(
"!3
5. "!56%" "!%"%3"!
%"% -0/ . -/"!/ ',( # !" '3 M
#) " ((""!,,((+ " !"
!) "("!% 1("!3"!" '
" '"2/%" '%(%"
9 ?35" (!" 6
/
GN3
,
3GO3
K 5/ ((! !1!- !1!,'" !%!>F>
2%") (-06A
/!JJ
3
"
7B3
— • 50 •
———— LE TOUR CRITIQUE 3 (2014) ———
%( %( +/) !!(D '.! ) ((/%("
(!%%&(!"3?) 2!%(
%" %!%",,(/
!() "*
P"H
"'") ) (
((!(
5 ,'" *() /("+
6A78GOB.5"( 6%%5""
("63) %,"" %" %/(
!("((/) ++""%/!"(
"!/%#$) ) %" ((!("(//"
'4/ "#"-%#"'"((',(3
+'("(!((' "!!!/%#" "# !
5(#"!! !(!(%((!",1%")
,1%".(%"(G63"!+"Q!/%#"
%/"H(; (.() (("!
, "( "!) % # " %( (/
"!) ( %"" #&3
"!!/%" "+"+!,( "3
/-"(""2( %)
" !!"'"($) "0- .(
"%(!("!!) (%%((5("
"%%""(((!-($!,"() R63
!() "*
%"0(!(%" %" /-"
"!) (D '(!((3#%) ?)
( /2%(!A5
M?)
N6B"(5(
!(/%"=6% "!! (D(.(($%
" "- %( %& () "( )
"%%" -0) ('"" "( (!(
/%" #F%5(%/.
++
.
4
86;
) *'$/!"(( A%" ) "($("-
!%*' , /("%.( -0B(
( %%")
'.
4
A" *" %/,
B ) . (!%! " " %) !( %+"
(("%2!%((/% ( ( ((2%/(
.(((4!(7O3
6. + " ((%/
(((%/) " /" ((3
(+) ( ( !/%#" (
") ((" '"'") /.(,%"
1! 2(/- /(-(!/%#$) " !
%"&) %" 1%* %!" !%(,(3
" ) "'"/( .>%(=) "!/2!(
P ?3
!() "*
7G7873
G
,3
7GP3
R
,3
7N93
N
,3
7G
8
,3
7GP3
7O
,3
7NP3
— • 51 •
———— LE TOUR CRITIQUE 3 (2014) ———
- ! ,) (!&'(1,&'!
%%(/3
CONTRE LACAN
7. 5" (!" 6(%#(""%#2%"!/#")
!"!!(('/*.+("
""
)
"%%" !/(! 2(! ( %$#($ ( . (
/" "3<.(0- #!!% /./@*") (
" ;
('(!') !"!"H%#(""%#&!
!* " "! "-/ ) * %"%" "!!.
!"!(.%#""!S" %#(("-"!%%( ) "
!"%" +'5/" 6A) "!) ,/'
!!%/0"/.(+"%#(""%#) 2) 2
%%%" %#(""%#) "!!(".%(%#(""%#)
% ( ) %" '%( 1!%(!%#(""%#) "%#
(""%#) " #"(%#(""%#B.!1!!"!2!
!1!!"!"%" '. ( #/") " (
) +( -(%( +"% !!% (" (!"+.
!$ 2/" ,(" /" ";) /"("
!"%( -') (-" (! %( /" ,((
%#(""%#A(%#""!(("-"!(%#(("!(%"(
%("!!'//((! -0(" (
(/%%"%"'(%( %"% ( %"% 2,""
!) 3 !!(/+/%#(""%#) "(+"!
!"/(!(( ((%) %#") (%"-
!) *$' B" (!" %( /"
,(!!1!) '/,"(%#(""%#" (""#/"
("-A*' 2(" #--B!%/*.T(!"
.78GPT%%(."" ) "/" 3</+/
(""(" '%%(/+:"+/) /'"0%+"
".(%"(#- ("-"%//%U--.(
'// (( "!!/) ") "!!'"(!S/'"(!773
8. " (%$#($(" %%/" %(
/" " %!#+3?) 1%2%(
) (""52%("6'(D '/(
;
<) (!"/" !,(" Q
!>I">) ((!"() "(%#("
"%#(" (%$#($) (( ) "
/"!A"!.!CB(#"(%#(""%#
((%$#($.'"(/"!) *"!!/%#(
("-"!. !"!(" /!"#"
) %/"'"((0( "($) &-(
(!793
77 J. Derrida, Résistances, 73.
79
,
3NN3
— • 52 •
———— LE TOUR CRITIQUE 3 (2014) ———
9. >!1!"+/(5# !"+76) "
>) &-(%% %%"//-(#/"(
(() ((2%"(/! (>'"(/%() (
" '(
3#+ ") " '
""
A78R9B
<%"(
A5 ('//678NOB"
%>2%("'3"%" /"(!"(/
) !% () (%$#($(3'
,(!/-&(!"+(" (3
!) -(%!!>(
,( /" () ((?) &-("!% '
(%") '"-!!) !
() ((( "C
+"
(!.%"%) %#"
"!(3 !%"((" ' +((
(%"+) 5"!%(/!/%#$) 7K6) /'")
(%/+.5 (&(/ 6;5<%#""
!2%(!+"%( !1!"!!
/"!!(('" *" //A+ / (%&
" %B78R978R"%V'W!V%&W" -!!"("-*
(!" B7P36) " %#""!(
%"!!"5!'6 ,(
3#&" ) (%#"/!!! /-%#/!
!!) /%>! #X'(%/(,(
2#&-!!"("-) +"/ ("-"!)
'//%"+";
" " *" &,(T) (( %"#=T.
" ( !" '! ( & #/") / % /*
+"!1!%+""(2"!"*'%(3
(/ %/(" %&GN* ) .'&5-!
!"("-) !6(/"/) */" .(# (/ 5%#"/
!) !1! " *" %#"/) 6 % ) ( / ( /!
";
5@(-0% +:"(! %%"
%#"/!) 7G63
10. <) %%((5- , "(/ .(
%"( " 78RO6!/) ("$>.
" %//( (.'"// 2&-!!"("
-) 3 (% "!")
!%(/5" (.%"(%/ "!!-7R63<>%"%"
") "%%((,"!!>/ %-(
) /'&%"/" " +)
%! .'"" /) #/") " (4
Y!
!"("-
3) "("("!) ") ("!
% ((/" ,(!/"$!) =
7
,
3RN3
7K ?3
(
4/
98K3
7P ?3
/
RR3
7G
,
3R8NO3
7R
,
3NO3
— • 53 •
6
7
8
9
1
/
9
100%
