!
SUR$LE$DOUTE$SERIEUX$QUANT$A$LA$LEGALITE$$
DE$LA$DECISION$CONTESTEE$$
!
@'! $(*"/! )*&(! +',! '#A.#/,! '/! +',! .$*+',4'#/,! C.#$"4.)3,! :! _/('! ,4*+.(",3,! '#! )("*("/3! '#! 2"+"'&! ,4*+."('!
*($"#."('! .! 3/3! )*,3! ).(! +'! +3G",+./'&(! $'! +.! +*"! $>*("'#/./"*#! $&! [T! P&"#! QR\X! '#! A.6'&(! $',! )'(,*##',!
C.#$"4.)3',?!!
@.! +*"! #V! WRNW`! $>*("'#/./"*#! ,&(!+>3$&4./"*#! $&! QT! P&"++'/! QRWRB! 4*2)+3/3'! ).(! $"6'(,! /'-/',B! ',/! 6'#&'!
)(34",'(!'/!(3.AA"(2'(!$')&",!4'//'!6*+*#/3!$&!+3G",+./'&(?!!
!
J"#,"B!+.!+*"!$"/'!a=.#$"4.)a!'#!$./'!$&!QQ!A36("'(!STTX!.!('4*##&!+'!$(*"/!:!+>3$&4./"*#!G.(.#/"'!:!4C.4&#!
a*6./)+()3($0(11$();)-E*&'()(/6*/1)'/)+,2("#33(0(/1)+()%*)3($%#//*".1,:)+=,"(2($)%#/)/.2(*')+()6#$0*1.#/)
./.1.*")(1)-#/1./':)+()%=./%,$($)+*/%)"*)2.()%#-.*"()(1)3$#6(%%.#//(""(:)+=(<($-($)%*)-.1#F(//(1,a?!!
!
5'+*#! +7.(/"4+'! @?QQSNQ! $&! I*$'! $'! +73$&4./"*#B! +',! '#A.#/,! '/! .$*+',4'#/,! C.#$"4.)3,! ,*#/! ,*&2",! :!
+7*E+"G./"*#! 3$&4./"6'?! D+,! ,./",A*#/! :! 4'//'! *E+"G./"*#! '#! ('4'6.#/! ,*"/! &#'! 3$&4./"*#! *($"#."('B! ,*"/B! :!
$3A.&/B! &#'! 3$&4./"*#! ,)34".+'B! $3/'(2"#3'! '#! A*#4/"*#! $',! E',*"#,! ).(/"4&+"'(,! $'! 4C.4&#! $7'&-! ).(! +.!
4*22",,"*#! $3).(/'2'#/.+'! $73$&4./"*#! ,)34".+'?! @'! ,'(6"4'! )&E+"4! $'! +73$&4./"*#! .,,&('! $*#4! &#'!
A*(2./"*#!,4*+."('B!)(*A',,"*##'++'!*&!,&)3("'&('!.&-!'#A.#/,!)(3,'#/.#/!&#!C.#$"4.)!*&!&#!/(*&E+'!$'!+.!
,.#/3!"#6.+"$.#/?!!
!
@.!)("*("/3!$*"/!_/('!$'!$*##'(!&#'!,4*+.(",./"*#!'#!2"+"'&!*($"#."('?!
!
J"#,"B!$',!.&-"+"."(',!$'!6"'!,4*+."('!K*&!J44*2).G#.#/,!$',!3+O6',!'#!,"/&./"*#!$'!C.#$"4.)!"#/'(6"'##'#/!
.&)(O,!$>&#!3+O6'!C.#$"4.)3!%&"!#'!$",)*,'!).,!$>&#'!.&/*#*2"'!,&AA",.#/'!)*&(!'AA'4/&'(!+',!.4/',!$'!+.!
6"'!4*&(.#/'!:!+>34*+'?!!
!
@'!E',*"#!$>."$'!',/!.))(34"3!).(!+.!I*22",,"*#!$',!$(*"/,!'/!$>.&/*#*2"'!$',!)'(,*##',!C.#$"4.)3',!K+.!
I?1?J?<?=?L?!!
!
@78/./! ',/! $*#4! /'#&! $7&#'! *E+"G./"*#! $7*AA("(! :! +7'#,'2E+'! $',! '#A.#/,! &#'! )(",'! '#! 4C.(G'! 3$&4./"6'!
.$.)/3'! :! +'&(,! .)/"/&$',! '/! :! +'&(,! E',*"#,?! D+! ,7.G"/! $7&#'! *E+"G./"*#! $'! (3,&+/./! 4*22'! +'! (.))'++'! +.!
4"(4&+."('!$&!;"#",/O('!$'!+78$&4./"*#!9./"*#.+'!#VSTTRNQ[X!$&!X!*4/*E('!STTR!0!b!+78/./!.B!'#!2./"O('!$'!
(3)*#,'!.&-!E',*"#,!$7.44*2).G#'2'#/!,4*+."('!$',!'#A.#/,!C.#$"4.)3,B!&#'!*E+"G./"*#!$'!(3,&+/./!c?!
!
G("#/)"=*$1.-"()H?IJKLI)+')M#+()+()"=,+'-*1.#/:)"#$%&'()"*)-#00.%%.#/)0(/1.#//,();)"=*$1.-"()H?)KNOLP)+')-#+()
+() "=*-1.#/) %#-.*"() (1) +(%) 6*0.""(%) -#/%1*1() &'() "*) %-#"*$.%*1.#/) +='/) (/6*/1) +*/%) '/() -"*%%() +()
"=(/%(.7/(0(/1)3'9".-)#')+='/),1*9".%%(0(/1)0(/1.#//,);)"=*$1.-"()H?)NNQLK)+')3$,%(/1)-#+()$(&'.($1)'/()*.+()
./+.2.+'(""() +#/1) (""() +,1($0./() "*) &'#1.1,) E#$*.$(:) -(11() *.+() 3('1) /#1*00(/1) 81$() *33#$1,() 3*$) '/)
*%%.%1*/1) +=,+'-*1.#/) $(-$'1,) -#/6#$0,0(/1) *'<) 0#+*".1,%) +,6./.(%) ;) "=*2*/1L+($/.($) *"./,*) +() "=*$1.-"() H?)
PKOLK?)
1'!)+&,B!nom&de&l’enfant!',/!.//'"#/!$7&#!/(*&E+'!$&!,)'4/('!.&/",/"%&'?!](B!,'+*#!+7.(/"4+'!@SZ`NQ!$&!I*$'!$'!
+7J4/"*#!5*4".+'!'/!$',!d.2"++',B!R)1#'1()3($%#//()*11(./1()+')E*/+.-*3)$,%'"1*/1)+')%F/+$#0()*'1.%1.&'()(1)
+(%)1$#'9"(%)&'.)"'.)%#/1)*33*$(/1,%)9,/,6.-.(:)quel$que$soit$son$âge:)+='/()3$.%()(/)-E*$7()3"'$.+.%-.3"./*.$()
&'.)1.(/1)-#031()+()%(%)9(%#./%)(1)+.66.-'"1,%)%3,-.6.&'(%?)
D+*31,();)"=,1*1)(1);)"=S7() +()"*) 3($%#//(:)-(11()3$.%() (/)-E*$7()3('1)81$()+=#$+$()éducatif:)3,+*7#7.&'(:)
1E,$*3('1.&'()(1)%#-.*"?)T!!!:!,&))("2'(!,"!+7'#A.#/!.!&#!.&/('!/e)'!$'!C.#$"4.)?)
D+! (',,*(/! $'! +>'#,'2E+'! $'! 4',! $",)*,"/"*#,! %&'B! $>&#'! ).(/B! +'! $(*"/! :! +>3$&4./"*#! ',/! G.(.#/"! :! 4C.4&#!
%&'++',!%&'!,*"'#/!+',!$"AA3('#4',!$'!,"/&./"*#!'/B!$>.&/('!).(/B!%&'!+>*E+"G./"*#!,4*+."('!,>.))+"%&'!:!/*&,B!+',!
$"AA"4&+/3,!).(/"4&+"O(',!%&'!('#4*#/('#/!$',!'#A.#/,!'#!,"/&./"*#!C.#$"4.)!#'!)'&6'#/!.6*"(!)*&(!'AA'/!#"!$'!
+',!)("6'(!$'!4'!$(*"/!#"!$'!A."('!*E,/.4+'!.&!(',)'4/!$'!4'//'!*E+"G./"*#?!!