La différence entre catholique et protestant, une

!"#$$%&''((()*+,-.$/*+/)0.1'23*$3.-'4%+.+$3/*+$-'2/$#0*+53-'*/67+88-.-92-6-9$.-62/$#0*+53-6-$6%.0$-4$/9$):#$;*"
<"
La#différence#entre#catholique#et#
protestant,*une*question*de*dogmes!
Publié'le'mardi'9'décembre'2008'à'08:26,'mis'à'jour'le'23'septembre'2009'à'09:32'//'Anonyme'
'
! "#!$%&'()*$*+,#!#&!)#!-.(&#+&%/&*+,#!+(/&!0#12!#/&*&3+!041/#!,5,#!.#)*6*(/!
71*!#+&!)#!$'.*+&*%/*+,#8!9#&&#!$.(:%/$#!#/!1/!,5,#!;*#1!/#!+#!03,(/&.#!-(1.&%/&!
-%+! 0#! )%! ,5,#! ,%/*<.#! #&! +1+$*&#! +(1=#/&! 0#+! 71#+&*(/+! #&! 0#+! 0*+$1++*(/+!
*/$#++%/&#+8! 9(//%>&.#! )%! 0*??3.#/$#! #/&.#! $%&'()*71#! #&! -.(&#+&%/&! -#.,#&! 0#!
,*#12! $#./#.! )#+! $%1+#+! 0#! )%! -#.,%/#/$#! 0#! $#+! 0*=#.6#/$#+! #&! $#! 71*! .#/0!
0*??*$*)#!)4*/+&%))%&*(/!041/!+:+&<,#!04@$1,3/*+,#8!
" =-4" ;0$+84" 7-" 7+>-.1-92-" -9$.-4" 2/$#0*+53-4" -$" %.0$-4$/9$4" 409$" $-**-;-9$"
90;,.-3:"53-"*-4"$#?0*01+-94"*-4"09$"2*/44?4"-9"$.0+4"2*/44-4",/4+53-4"&"*-"%/%-@"*/"4/+9$-"
>+-.1-"-$"*A-32#/.+4$+-)"B-..+C.-"2-4"$.0+4"?*?;-9$4"4-"2/2#-9$"39-"*0913-"43+$-"7A/3$.-4"
?*?;-9$4" 53+" 7+88?.-92+-9$" */" 2092-%$+09" 7-" */" 2098-44+09" 2#.?$+-99-)" D+" /3" 7?%/.$@" */"
9/+44/92-"73"%.0$-4$/9$+4;-"?$/+$"2/34?-"%/."39-"209$-4$/$+09"7-"=3$#-."7-"*/"$#?0.+-"73"
4/*3$"%/."*-4"E3>.-4@"/2$3-**-;-9$@"*-4"%0+9$4"7-"7+>-.1-92-"7->+-99-9$"7-"%*34"-9"%*34"
90;,.-3:" 20;%.-9/9$" *-4" *+-3:" 7-" 23*$-@" *-" 7?.03*-;-9$" 73" 23*$-@" *-" ;+9+4$C.-" 7-4"
8-;;-4)"=/"7+>+4+09">+-97./+$"7A39-"7+88?.-92-"7A+9$-.%.?$/$+09"73";F;-"$-:$-"209$-93"
7/94"*/"G+,*-)"H*"-4$"$03$-80+4"-..09?"7-"2094+7?.-."2-4"7-3:"2098-44+094"20;;-".+>/*-4"
2/."*-"%.-;+-."-94-+19-;-9$"7-"*/"2#.?$+-9$?"2094+4$-"-9"*A/;03."8./$-.9-*)"
"
A1B#+&C$#!71B1/!$%&'()*71#!D!
"=-" 2#.?$+-9" 7-" 2098-44+09" 2/$#0*+53-" -4$" +9+$+?" /3" 2/$?2#+4;-" 7-%3+4" 409" I-39-"
J1-)"H*"4A/1+$"73".-23-+*"7-4"701;-4"53A+*"+9$C1.-./"/3"8+*"7-"4/">+-)"D/"2.0K/92-"-4$"8097?-"
43."*A/22-%$/$+09"7-"$03$-"*/"702$.+9-"53-"*3+"7+2$-9$"4-4"%.?2-%$-3.4)"L9"*A0223..-92-@"+*"
/22-%$-" *A/3$0.+$?" 73" M/%-" -$" *A/22-%$-" 20;;-" D/+9$" MC.-" 7-" *AN1*+4-"-$" 4322-44-3." 7-"
*AO%P$.-"D/+9$"M+-..-"/353-*"*-"Q#.+4$"/"7099?"*-"%03>0+."7-"%.-97.-"40+9"7-"409"N1*+4-)"
B-" 2-$$-" 8/R09@" +*" /22-%$-" $03$-4" *-4" .C1*-4" +;%04?-4" %/." *-" M/%-)" H*" >03-" 39" 23*$-" S" */"
D/+9$-"TC.-"73"D-+19-3.@"*/"U+-.1-"T/.+-"-$"*3+"/$$.+,3-"*-"%03>0+."7-"*-"7?8-97.-"/3%.C4"
7-"B+-3"*-"MC.-)"
"=AN1*+4-"2/$#0*+53-" 2/909+4-" 7-4" %-.4099-4" 53+" 09$" 20993" 39" %/.203.4"
-:-;%*/+.-"-$"*-4"/%%-**-"4/+9$4)"L**-"*-4">?9C.-"-$"%.-97"-:-;%*-"43."-3:@"4AK"8+-"%03."
*-3."%.0$-2$+09)"M03."*-"2/$#0*+53-@"*A-32#/.+4$+-"-4$"2094+7?.?-"20;;-"*A+92/.9/$+09"73"
Q#.+4$"%/." 409"4/91"-$"4/" 2#/+."7/94"*A#04$+-"-$" *-">+9)"H*" 209$.+,3-" 7/94"*-4"E3>.-4" 7-"
*AN1*+4-"%03." /443.-." *-" %/.709" 7-" 4-4" %?2#?4)" =/" 80+" 2/$#0*+53-" +94+4$-" %*34" 43." *-"
2/./2$C.-"4/2.?"7-"B+-3"-$"7-4"D/+9$4@"7-"*/"%.+C.-@"7-"*/";-44-"-$"7-4"/3$.-4"2.0K/92-4)"=/"
;-44-" 2/$#0*+53-" -4$" 2/./2$?.+4?-" %/." */" %.?4-92-" 7-" .+$3-*4" 4/2.?4@" *A34/1-" 7A0,I-$4"
4/2.?4"20;;-"*-4"2+-.1-4"-$"*A-/3",?9+$-@"7-"%.+C.-4"-9"*/913-"*/$+9-"-$"7A39-"#0;?*+-)"

!"#$$%&''((()*+,-.$/*+/)0.1'23*$3.-'4%+.+$3/*+$-'2/$#0*+53-'*/67+88-.-92-6-9$.-62/$#0*+53-6-$6%.0$-4$/9$):#$;*"
V"
A1B#+&C$#!71B1/!-.(&#+&%/&!D!
" W9"%.0$-4$/9$"4-"2094+7C.-"20;;-"/K/9$".-R3"*-"4/*3$"7+>+9"%/."409"39+53-"80+"-$"
.?/*+4-"7-4"E3>.-4"7-",+-98/+4/92-"-9"/220.7"/>-2"2-$$-"80+)"M03."*3+@"*-"4/*3$"/"?$?"7?IS"
8/+$"%/." *-" Q#.+4$" *0.4" 7-" 4/" ;0.$" -$" 7-"4/" .?43..-2$+09" -$" $03$" 2-" 53A+*" /"S" 8/+.-" -4$" 7-"
2.0+.-)"H*"-4$",/%$+4?"7/94"*-4";F;-4"2097+$+094"53-"*-"2/$#0*+53-"-$"+9+$+?"7C4"409"I-39-"
J1-" /3:" %.+92+%-4" 7-" */" 80+)" H*" 9-" >?9C.-" /3239" /3$.-" B+-3" $03$" %3+44/9$" -$" .?83$-" */"
4/+9$-$?"7-4"#0;;-4)"=/"80+"%.0$-4$/9$-"+94+4$-"%*34"43."*-"2/./2$C.-".-*+1+-3:"73"23*$-)"
" O+94+@"*-" 23*$-" %.0$-4$/9$" 4-" 7+4$+913-"%/."39"4-.;09" %*34" /22-44+,*-" -$"*/"G+,*-"
.-4$-"*-"4-3*"/22-440+.-"3$+*+4?"7/94"*-"$-;%*-"/3"203.4"7-"2-*3+62+)"B/94"*/";F;-"+7?-@"*/"
D/+9$-" QC9-" .-;%*/2-" *AL32#/.+4$+-" -$" -**-" -4$" 2094+7?.?-" 39+53-;-9$" 20;;-" 39"
403>-9+."7-"*/";0.$"73"Q#.+4$)"=-">+9"53-"*-4"2.0K/9$4",0+>-9$"9A-4$"53A39"4K;,0*-"73"
4/91">-.4?"43."*/"2.0+:"$/97+4"53-"*-"%/+9"53A+*4"4-"%/.$/1-9$"4K;,0*+4-"*-"20.%4"73"Q#.+4$"
709$"+*4"809$"%/.$+-)"
"
EFGHIJHKLHMJNI!O!9GPFFMIF!;IJ!"I9HIPFJ!
!
X?/2$+09"S"*/"*-2$3.-"7-"*/"%/1-"73"4+$-"&"
=/"7+88?.-92-"-9$.-"2/$#0*+53-"-$"%.0$-4$/9$@"39-"53-4$+09"7-"701;-4"
"
M3,*+?"*-";/.7+"Y"7?2-;,.-"VZZ["S"Z[&V\@";+4"S"I03."*-"V]"4-%$-;,.-"VZZY"S"ZY&]V"''"O909K;-"
"
F3%$&*(/!0#!6+QRSTTU6,%*)8$(,!V=-"<]"02$0,.-"VZ<]"S"<<&]Y"
=A?1*+4-" 2/$#0*+53-" .0;/+9-" -:+4$-" 7-%3+4" %*34" 7-" V@ZZZ" /94" -$" 20;%$-" %*34" 7-" V@V"
;+**+/.74"7-"8+7C*-4"^"_"]Z`"7-"%.0$-4$/9$4"-$"<V`"7a0.$#070:-4)b"
c"-**-" -4$" */" .-*+1+09" 7-4" /7-%$-4" 7-" d?4346Q#.+4$)" 6" H*" 4A/1+$" 7A39-" .-*+1+09" ;090$#?+4$-@"
./%%0.$?-"%/." *-4" /%P$.-4@"-$"7-4"%.-;+-.4" 7+42+%*-4"7-"d?434)"6" =-" 2#.+4$+/9+4;-"-4$"*/"
.-*+1+09" */" %*34" .?%/973-" 7/94" *-" ;097-" -$" /" %.08097?;-9$" ;/.53?" 7+88?.-9$-4"
2+>+*+4/$+094"/3"203.4"7-"*A#+4$0+.-"/*0.4"53A-**-"?$/+$"+9+$+/*-;-9$"2094+7?.?-"20;;-"39-"
4-2$-"I3+>-"%/.;+"7A/3$.-4)"6"
'ec"H*" -:+4$-" $.0+4" 1./974" 1.03%-4" 7AN1*+4-4"&" *-4" 2/$#0*+53-4@" *-4" 0.$#070:-4" -$" *-4"
%.0$-4$/9$-4)6"
'ec"L9"2-"53+"2092-.9-"*-4"702$.+9-4"73"4/*3$@"*/"%*3%/.$"7-4"%.0$-4$/9$+4;-"2094+7C.-9$"
53-" 4-3*" B+-3" 7?2+7-" 53+" -4$" 4/3>?" 03" %/4)" D+" =3$#-." -$" Q/*>+9" ?$/+-9$" %-44+;+4$-4" -$"
%-94/+-9$" S" 39-" %.?7-4$+9/$+09" /3" ;/*@" 7092" S" *a-98-.@" *-4" %.0$-4$/9$4" 209$-;%0./+94"
409$"7->-934"0%$+;+4$-4@"2094+7?./9$"53-"*/".?7-;%$+09"-4$"%03."$034"*-4"#0;;-4)"
'ec"=/"80+"53+"4/3>-"-4$"39-"80+">+>/9$-@"39-"80+"53+"/;C9-"39"2#/91-;-9$"7/94"*/">+-"-$"*-"
7?4+."7-"43+>.-"d?434)"
W9-"80+"$#?0.+53-"9-"4-.$"7-".+-9@"2-"9A-4$"%/4"*/"80+)6=/"_>./+b"80+"/;C9-"80.2?;-9$"7-4"
f0-3>.-4f@"%/.2-"53A-**-"-4$">./+"-$"%.08097-@"09"9A/1+$"%*34"%/.-+*"/3"530$+7+-9"53/97"09"
43+$"-$"/+;-"d?434)"

!"#$$%&''((()*+,-.$/*+/)0.1'23*$3.-'4%+.+$3/*+$-'2/$#0*+53-'*/67+88-.-92-6-9$.-62/$#0*+53-6-$6%.0$-4$/9$):#$;*"
]"
Q-%-97/9$"2-"409$"7-4"0-3>.-4"909"209$./+9$-4@"9+"80.2?-4"7/94"*-",3$"7-"%*/+.-"S"B+-3@"
-**-4"7?203*-9$"I34$-"7-"90$.-"903>-**-">+4+09"7-"*/">+-"-9"Q#.+4$)6M03."*-4"2/$#0*+53-4@"*/"
80+"d3+>-"-$"*/"80+";343*;/9-"MXNMOXL"*-"4/*3$"53+"4-./"7099?"MOX"=L"QgXHDh"_7/94"*/"
>+-"7-"*/"Q#/.+$?b)"
'ec"%03."-9$.-."/3"%/./7+4@"7/94"*/">+4+09"7-" B+-3@"+*"9A4$"%/4"4388+4/9$"7A/+;-."B+-3)6H*"
8/3$"-9"%*34"/>0+."39"20-3."$0$/*-;-9$"#3;,*-"0i"%*3$P$"39"20-3."f,.+4?f@"4/94"+**34+09"
43."40+@"2-*3+"7A39"%/3>.-"4/3>?"%/.";+./2*-)"
T/+4"+*"9-"8/3$"%/4"$0;,-."7/94"*-4"-:$.F;-4)"=/"4-3*-"2#04-"53+"+;%0.$-"/"B+-3"2A-4$"53-"
9034">+>094"7/94"*/"2#/.+$?"-$"*A/;03."7-4"394"7-4"/3$.-4)"
"
F3%$&*(/!0#!)&.(W%&!V=-"<j"7?2-;,.-"VZ<]"S"VV&ZV"
h.C4",099-"4K9$#C4-@"S"*/"80+4"2092+4-"-$"-:/2$-)"
d-" %.?2+4-./+4" 53A-9" 2-" 53+" 2092-.9-" *-" ,/%$F;-@" */" .C1*-" 7/94" *-" 2/$#0*+2+4;-" -4$" 7-"
,/%$+4-."*-4"-98/9$4"*-"%*34"$P$"%044+,*-@"-$"403>-9$"903>-/3:69?4"_/>-2"7-4"-:2-%$+094"
%03."*-4"209>-.$+4"9A/K/9$"%/4"?$?",/%$+4?4@"03"*-4"/70*-42-9$4"903>-**-;-9$"2/$?2#+4?4b)"
B/94" *-" %.0$-4$/9$+4;-@" +*" 8/3$" 7+4$+913-." *-" 2/4" 7-4" ?1*+4-4" *3$#?.06.?80.;?-4" 0i" *-"
,/%$F;-"%-3$"F$.-"%./$+53?"S"7+88?.-9$4"J1-4"7-"*/">+-"_9/+44/92-@"-9"203.4"7-"2/$?2#C4-"
03"S"*/"8+9"7-"2-**-62+b@"-$"*-4"?1*+4-4"?>/91?*+53-4"_,/%$+4$-4@"%-9$-2P$+4$-4@"-$2)))b"53+"9-"
,/%$+4-9$"53-"*-4"/73*$-4"/3"$-.;-"7-"*-3."80.;/$+09".-*+1+-34-)"
B-"%*34@"%03.".?%097.-"/3"20;;-9$/+.-"%.?2?7-9$@"+*"-4$">./+"53-"Q/*>+9"2.0K/+$"-9"*/"
703,*-"%.?7-4$+9/$+09"_/3"4/*3$"?$-.9-*"%03."*-4"394@"S"*/".?%.0,/$+09"?$-.9-**-"%03."*-4"
/3$.-4b)"Q-*/"7+$@"-**-"?$/+$"*/"2092*34+09"7A39"53-4$+099-;-9$"53A+*"4-"%04/+$"S"%.0%04"7-"
*/" 80+" ;/+4" 9A/" I/;/+4" ?$?" *-" %0+9$" 2-9$./*" 7-" 4/" $#?0*01+-)" B3" .-4$-" 2-$$-" 53-4$+09"
-;,/../44/+$"*-4"%/4$-3.4"73">+>/9$";F;-"7-"Q/*>+9"-$"/"?$?"/,/97099?-"7-%3+4",-**-"
*3.-$$-"%/."*A?1*+4-".?80.;?-)))"
"