l/7)/7'B/(!")!3O%#7)#&!
'
Une'comédie'tragique'
M%/(!/&01#-* 2'3$()4.!7B#7!)/!)$Q&#/7%/7!3%!VB&$)! "#!<%#")<'33).!b)!(B#-%'7%'(!)/!"6$B/7)&!3%!$60%/'F#).! N!'/(#VV3)&!3)!7&%R'F#).! QB#&!
&%0B/7)&.!)/7&)!%#7&)(.!3)!Q%&0B#&(!'/'7'%7'F#)!"O#/)!$E&).!a'07B'&)!I%'(B/.!F#'!<)#7!&)7&B#<)&!(B/!V'3(.!Q%&7'!3)!Q3#(!3B'/!QB(('D3)H!;B$$)!
QB'/7!")!"6Q%&7! ")! 3O60&'7#&).! '3! N!%!3O#/'<)&(!")!@)"&B!T3$B"m<%&.!(%!Q&BVB/")#&!)P'(7)/7')33)!)7!(%!3'D)&76!VB&$)33)!7B7%3).! 0B/V'/%/7! %#!
n'7(0-H!o)!<B#3%'(!$)77&)!)/!Q)&(Q)07'<)!")(!p!$N7-B3BR')(!q!7&E(!"'VV6&)/7)(.!3O#/)!QBQ#3%'&)!)7!p!()/(%7'B//)33)!q!)7.!3O%#7&).!3)!<%#"B#.!F#'!
%!%0F#'(!A$%3R&6!3)(!03'0-6(J!()(!3)77&)(!")!/BD3)(()(H!U%"N!M'!)(7!"B/0!$'()!%#!$r$)!Q3%/!F#O#/)!"6)(()!-%s7')//).!B&'R'/%'&).!0B$$)!(B/!
/B$!3O'/"'F#).!"#!M%-B$)NH!U)!7-647&)!Q)#7!r7&)!3)!3')#!")!&%(()$D3)$)/7!")!7B#7!0)!F#'!V%tB//)!/B(!'$%R'/%'&)(.!)7!3O60&'7#&)!"&%$%7'F#)!
0)3#'!")!3O'/7&'0%7'B/!"O636$)/7(!F#'!0B/(7'7#)/7!/B7&)!(B0'676!"%/(!()(!$B")&/'76(.!F#O'3!(O%R'(()!")!3%!$B").!")(!<'"6B_03'Q(.!")(!36R)/")(!
B#!"#!0'/6$%H!UO)(()/7')3!67%/7!")!&)0&6)&!")!3%!@B6(')!u!/&01#-*2'3$()4*Q%&7'0'Q)!")!$B/!)/<')!")!$r3)&!3)!7&%R'F#)!)7!3)!V&'<B3)H!
!
Différences'culturelles'et'intimité'
:'!/&01#-*2'3$()4*Q%&3)!"#!0-B0!")!")#P!$B/")(.!&%0B/7%/7!%#(('.!")!V%tB/!-%33#0'/6).!#/)!Q%&7')!")!3%!R&%/")!k'(7B'&)!A0)33)!")!3%!7&%'7)!)7!
")! 3O)(03%<%R)J.! 3%! Q'E0)! /)! ()! ('7#)! Q%(! $B'/(! Q&BVB/"6$)/7! "%/(! 3O'/7'$)! "O#/)! V%$'33)H! l3! N! )(7! F#)(7'B/! ")! &%QQB&7(! ")! QB#<B'&.! ")!
$%/F#)!"O%$B#&.!")!"6('&(!Q6&'33)#P.!$%'(!%#(('!)7!(#&7B#7!")!(B3'7#")H!o)!7)/%'(!*!Q3B/R)&!3)!(Q)07%7)#&!"%/(!#/!$%)3(7&v$!")!()/7'$)/7(!
)7!")!('7#%7'B/(!Q%&%"BP%3)(!Bh!3OB/!&'7!%#!"6D#7!"O#/)!&6Q3'F#)!QB#&!&)(()/7'&!3O'/(7%/7!"O%Q&E(!3OBD(0#&'76!B#!3%!<'B3)/0).!0B$$)!3O%$)&!F#'!
(#00E")! %#! "B#PHHH! ;)! F#'! )(7! VB/"%$)/7%3! "%/(! 3%! &)/0B/7&)! )/7&)! a'07B'&).! 3%! V)$$)! D3%/0-).! )7! G63'0'76.! 3%! V)$$)! /B'&).! 0O)(7! F#)!
0-%0#/)!%!Q)&"#!#/!V'3(H!M)!0)!QB'/7!")!<#).!3%!p!<6&'76!Q&BVB/")!q!")!G63'0'76.!0O)(7!")!V%'&)!Q3)#&)&!a'07B'&)HHH!U)!7-647&)!)(7!QB#&!$B'!3)!3')#!
")!3O'&&%7'B//)3.!"#!QB67'F#)H!K7!(O'3!N!%!#/)!Q&6()/0)!"#!QB67'F#)!"%/(!3O#/'<)&(!")!G63'0'76.!0)3#'_0'!/O)(7!Q%(!QB#&!%#7%/7!%D()/7!")!3O#/'<)&(!
")!a'07B'&).!F#'!%!676!%07&'0)H!I%'(!0-)L!)33).!'3!(O)(7!)VV%06H!;O)(7!3O%QQ%&'7'B/!"#!V%/7f$)!")!e)(7.!3)!V'3(!")!G63'0'76.!Q#'(!3O'&&#Q7'B/!")!0)77)!
")&/'E&).!F#'!%$B&0)/7!3%!p!&6<B3#7'B/!q!")!a'07B'&)H!
!!
Parcours'initiatiques'
MO%#7&)(!Q)&(B//%R)(.!"%/(!/&01#-*2'3$()4.!%00B$Q3'(()/7!3)#&!Q%&0B#&(!)7!3)#&!'/'7'%7'B/!*!3O'/(7%&!")!a'07B'&)H!;O)(7!3)!0%(!"#!@E&)!M)/'(.!
F#'!p!/%c7!q!3B&(F#O'3!7B$D)!%$B#&)#P!"#!V%/7f$)!")!e)(7!)7!3B&(F#O'3!Q%&7.!)/(#'7).!*!3%!"60B#<)&7)!")!(B/!Q&BQ&)!0B&Q(!b#(F#O'0'!'/7B#0-6H!
;O)(7!3)!0%(!")!G%/7%.!F#'!<'7!(B/!"#&!F#B7'"')/!"%/(!3%!"67)(7%7'B/!")!()(!p!$%c7&)(!q.!$%'(!%#(('!"%/(!#/!Q&BVB/"!"6/'!"O)33)_$r$)![!)33)!
()&%! p! 0-)<%#0-6)! q! Q%&! 3%! "6)(()! K&L#3'! M%-B$)N! F#'! Q&)/"&%! QB(()(('B/! "O)33)! 0B$$)! #/)! $%3%"')! $)/7%3)H! e)(7.! 7B#7! 0B$$)!
3OT&0-%/R)!"#!V'3$!63"$&7()*")!@%(B3'/'.!)(7!0)3#'!F#'!V%'7!D%(0#3)&!3)(!")(7'/(!")!G%/7%.!"#!@E&)!M)/'(.!")!a'07B'&)!)7!")!G&%/7LH!l3!3)(!&6<E3)!
*!)#P_$r$)(H!:'(('!)(7!3)!()#3!Q)&(B//%R)!")!0)77)!-'(7B'&)!F#'!/)!3#77)!Q%(!0B/7&)!#/)!V%7%3'76!$%'(!F#'!7&%$).!0B/(7&#'7.!B&R%/'()H!T<)0!
G&%/7L.!(B/!V&E&)!b#$)%#.!)33)!(O)(7!&6V#R'6)!"%/(!#/!%#7'($)!'/0)(7#)#P![!3)!Q%((%R)!*!3O%07)!/O%"<')/7.!*!3)#&!0B&Q(!"6V)/"%/7.!F#O*!3%!V'/!")!
3%!Q'E0).! "%/(! #/)! %00636&%7'B/! 7&%R'F#)H!M%/(!0)!0B/7)P7).!3)!$N7-)!")! U%"N! M'! &)Q&6()/7)!#/!Q)#!3)#&!e)&7-)&H!;)!F#'! 7&%<)&()! /&01#-*
2'3$()4.!QB#&!$B'.!0O)(7! 3)!<)&7'R)!Y! 3)(!Q)&(B//%R)(!Q)&")/7! Q')"!0B$$)!('! %#0#/!/O%<%'7!")!7)&&)!=!"%/(!7B#(!3)(!()/(!"#!7)&$)!=!*!
0B$$)/0)&!Q%&!3%!7)&&)!/%7%3)![!'3(!(B/7!)P'36(.!%#!()/(!Q&BQ&)!)7!V'R#&6H!;O)(7!#/)!Q'E0)!$#('0%3).!)/!&#Q7#&)(!")!&N7-$)(.!%<)0!()(!<%3()(!
&60#&&)/7)(.! %'R#w(.! ()(! 7B#&D'33B/(! [! )/7&)0B#Q6)! "O%"%R'B(H! M%/(! 3)! RB#VV&).! '3! N! %! 3)(! &)7&B#<%'33)(H! K7! "%/(! 3)(! &)7&B#<%'33)(.! '3! N! %! 3)!
RB#VV&)H!
Jean>René'Lemoine'
Propos'recueillis'par'Laurent'Muhleisen'
'
KP7&%'7!
'
VICTOIRE'>'8$1%'-95*%'9.*#)*(-&$-&5*)##)*':)&;$-<*=).<>*o)!<B#(!%'!<#H!I%'/7)/%/7!<B#(!<)/)L!$)!(#&Q&)/"&)!$r$)!"%/(!$B/!'/7'$'76H!i#)!
<B#3)L_<B#(g!aB#(!<B#3)L!$)!&)R%&")&!<')'33'&!g!aB#(!<B#3)L!<B'&!$)(!()'/(!g!aB#(!<B#3)L!<B'&!3)!"6(%(7&)!")!$)(!()'/(!")!0'/F#%/7)!%/(!g!
aB#(!<B#3)L!<B'&!3)!0-%$Q!")!D%7%'33)g!o)!<B#(!$B/7&)!7B#7H!o)!/O%'!Q3#(!3%!VB&0)!")!3#77)&H!aB#(!<B#3)L!F#)!b)!<B#(!Q%&3)!")!$B/!"6('&!")!
<')'33).!")!$%!(B3'7#")!g!aB#(!<B#3)L!F#)!b)!<B#(!"'()!F#)!3%!/#'7!b)!R6$'(!")!"B#3)#&!")!/Or7&)!b%$%'(!0%&)((6).!F#)!$B/!0B&Q(!(O%3B#&"'7!)7!
(O%/nN3B()! ")! /Or7&)! b%$%'(! 0%&)((6.! F#)! b)! (#'(! "#&)! 0B$$)! #/)! Q')&&)! *! 3O'/76&')#&! )7! $B33)! *! 3%! VB'(! 0B$$)! 3%! R3%'()! g! i#)! b)! (#'(!
)P76/#6)!g!i#)!0)77)!<'33)!$)!7#)!g!i#)!b)!$)!$)#&(!"O)//#'!"%/(!0)77)!<'33)!Bh!b)!(#'(!/6).!Bh!$)(!Q%&)/7(.!$)(!R&%/"(_!Q%&)/7(!(B/7!/6(!
g!i#)!<B#3)L_<B#(!g!;O)(7!")!3O%&R)/7!F#)!<B#(!<B#3)L!g!I)(!6$)&%#")(!g!o)!<B#(!"B//)!7B#7H!@&)/)L.!Q'33)L.!<B3)L.!$%'(!%33)L_<B#(_)/.!%33)L!
"%/()&! %<)0! <B(! b#Q)(! ")! Q%'33)! )7! <B(! 0B3'V'0-)7(.! 7B#&/BN)&! "%/(! 3%! QB#(('E&).! )7! 3%'(()L_$B'! Q3)#&)&! (#&! 3)! 0-%$Q! ")! D%7%'33)! ")! $B/!
Q&BQ&)!0B&Q(H!U%'(()L_!$B'HHH!;O)(7!3)!(B'&!F#)!7B#7!R3'(().!7B#7!0)!F#)!bO%'!%(()$D36!Q6/'D3)$)/7!"%/(!3%!bB#&/6)!()!"6V%'7.!Q%&7!*!3%!")&'<)!
(%/(!F#)!bO%')!%#0#/!0B/7&f3)H!T3B&(!b)!$)!&)R%&")!"%/(!3%!Q(N0-6H!o)!0B$Q7)!0-%F#)!&'").!0-%F#)!DB#&&)3)7H!IB/!$%&'!%!"'(Q%&#!Q&E(!"#!
3%0.!#/)!/#'7.!%Q&E(!(Or7&)!&#'/6!%#!0%('/BH!oO%<%'(!7B#7!(%0&'V'6.!7B#7!%D%/"B//6!QB#&!3#'H!I%'(!'3!)(7!Q%&7'!(%/(!#/!('R/).!Q%(!#/!$B7.!Q%(!#/)!
3)77&)H!TQ&E(!b)!(#'(!&)<)/#)!*!a'33)/)#<).!'3!N!%!)#!F#)3F#)(!%$%/7(.!Q)#!/B$D&)#P.!<B#(!(%<)L.!"%/(!#/)!Q)7'7)!<'33)H!K7!Q#'(!%Q&E(!Q3#(!
&')/H!U%!(B3'7#")H!
!
Jean>René'Lemoine')(7!%#7)#&.!$)77)#&!)/!(0E/)!)7!0B$6"')/H!l3!)(7!/6!)/!k%s7'!)/!1X?X!)7!'/(7%336!*!@%&'(!")Q#'(!1XWXH!I)77)#&!)/!(0E/)!")!?+@%)*A*8B'&#)<<*
$+C'&'*[!/BB34($.)*%#!@)7'7!B"6B/!)7!%#!5-647&)!")!3%!5)$Qr7)![!?)*D$4'E)*F)&.*G&'9%HI-F-7&)*%#!;)/7&)!M&%$%7'F#)!d%7'B/%3!")!:%&7&B#<'33)![!?+J%$&'<-$9*
)(7! 0&66)! %#! 5-647&)! j6&%&"! @-'3'Q)! ")! :%'/7_M)/'(! [! ?'* K)&-.'-)* "OT/7B/! 50-)n-B<! )(7! 3%! Q&)$'E&)! Q'E0)! F#O'3! $)7! )/! (0E/)! "B/7! '3! /)! (B'7! Q%(! 3O%#7)#&!
A5-647&)!j%33'%!")!:%'/7)(.!&)Q&'()!*!3%!I;X8J![!D)&LM*")!j'B<%//'!5)(7B&'!%#!5-647&)!j%&'D%3"'!")!@%3)&$)![!N'B)*A*#'*(7&)**!3%!I;X8H!/&01#-*2'3$()45*%")..)*
%)* #+'($1&* %!676! 0&66)! %#!5-647&)! "#! <')#P!;B3B$D')&!Q%&! 3%! 7&B#Q)!")! 3%! ;B$6"')! G&%/t%'()H!J<#'9<-%)..! 0B$$%/")! QB#&! 3)!Q&Bb)7!C'/f$)!A5-647&)!)7!
(0')/0)(J!%!V%'7!3OBDb)7!"O#/)!3)07#&)!"%/(!3)!0%"&)!"#!G)(7'<%3!"OT<'R/B/!+,18H!:%!$'()!)/!(0E/)!"#!O)1*%)*#+'($1&*)<*%1*3'.'&%*")!I%&'<%#P!%!676!Q&6()/76)!
%#!V)(7'<%3!")(!G&%/0BQ-B/')(!")!U'$BR)(![!P:3-E"9-)*%#!7-647&)!TQB!I'0-%/'(!*!T7-E/)(H!l3!60&'7.!$)7!)/!(0E/)!)7!bB#).!!"%")5*:$7()*)9&'E"**!3%!I;X8.!
Q#'(!%#!5-647&)!j6&%&"!@-'3'Q)H!l3!%!)/()'R/6!3O%&7!"&%$%7'F#)!%#!;B#&(!G3B&)/7![!%!"'&'R6!")(!%7)3')&(!QB#&!0B$6"')/(!%#!5-647&)!")!3%!5)$Qr7)![!*!3%!G6$'(H!
:B/!7&%<%'3!"O60&'7#&)!)7!")!0&6%7'B/!%!BD7)/#!")!/B$D&)#()(!&60B$Q)/()(!Y!3%#&6%7!")!3%!GB/"%7'B/!C)%#$%&0-%'(![!Q&'P!:T;M!_!5-647&)!QB#&!UOB")#&!"#!
dB'&![!?+@%)*A!8B'&#)<<*$+C'&'*BD7')/7!3)!j&%/"!@&'P!")!3%!;&'7'F#)![!3%#&6%7!"#!@&'P!j#6&%/")!QB#&!?+J%$&'<-$9*[!DB#&(')&!")!U%!a'33%!I6"'0'(!QB#&!(B/!Q&Bb)7!
J&B3-F).*%1*81%*[!3%#&6%7!"#!Q&'P!:T;M!QB#&!/&01#-*2'3$()4*[!Q&'P!p!K$'3)!
T#R')&!q!")!3OT0%"6$')!G&%/t%'()!QB#&!P:3-E"9-)*)7!P9*()($&-'(H!
'