O5!&+'!(=,*$'#0'!9&!3*00#/'$&!3&+!+'$&++!#6(*'(N2&+!+2$!5&+!*$@#0(+=&+!(0'&$'(9#2R!,*2$!
+#4*($!9#0+!N2&55&!9S0#=(N2&!*0!+&!'$*24&!&'!,*2$!#(0+(!=(&2R!3*=,#$&$!&'!(9&0'(Z(&$!5&+!
=83#0(+=&+!9&!N2A*0!$&'$*24&!9#0+!5A83*+S+'T=&K
!
! V(((W! "*2$! $8,*09$&! ;! 5#! 9&2R(T=&! N2&+'(*0! 9&! =*0! +'#@&! VN2&55&+! +*0'! 5&+!
9(BB8$&03&+!&0!'&$=&+!9&!6(*9(4&$+('8!&'!9&!+'$23'2$&!&0'$&!5A&+'2#($&!92!C#(0'D%#2$&0'!&'!
5&+! 3P'&+! G'5#0'(N2&+W!\A#(! B#('! 20!83-#0'(55*00#@&!;! b*$! e#S! "$*4(03(#5! "#$f! VH*24&55&D
`3*++&W!+2$!9&2R!+('&+!VHghiYYL!JYjk!D!_jYi!JXL!j]lk!&'!HghiYXmjnlA!D!_jYi!]YLhJjAWK!)AS!
#(! &BB&3'28! 20! (04&0'#($&! 9&+! &+,T3&+! ,$8+&0'&+! 9#0+! 20!]XR]X3=L! &0! ,*2$3&0'#@&! 9&!
$&3*24$&=&0'! ,*2$! 5&+! &+,T3&+! #5@#5&+! &'! 20! 980*=6$&=&0'! ,*2$! 5&+! (04&$'86$8+K! G2!
'*'#5! ]X!N2#9$#'+!VYX!#2!,$&=(&$! +('&!&'!JX!#2!9&2R(T=&W!*0'!8'8!(04&0'*$(8+! ,*2$!9&+!
#0#5S+&+!9A#6*09#03&L!9&!3*=,*+('(*0!&'!9&!$(3-&++&K!<&$'#(0&+!&+,T3&+!8'#0'!(03*002&+L!
0*2+! #4*0+! ,$(+! 9&+! 83-#0'(55*0+! ,*2$! (9&0'(Z(3#'(*0! &0!5#6*$#'*($&! ;!5A#(9&! 9&! @2(9&+!
9A(9&0'(Z(3#'(*03,4K! <&+! (04&0'#($&+! +*0'! 3*=,#$8+! #4&3! ]X! N2#9$#'+! ,$(+! ;! 5#! =U=&!
,8$(*9&!&0!JXYJ!+2$!5&+!3P'&+!+29!9&!5A&+'2#($&!92!C#(0'D%#2$&0'!5*$+!9&!=#!$&3-&$3-&K!
! >&+!*$@#0(+=&+!V9&!J!;!Yh!(09(4(92+W!*0'!8@#5&=&0'!8'8!$83*5'8+!+2$!5&+!+('&+!!9&!
b*$!e#S!3*=,$&0#0'!9&+!&+,T3&+!9&!3-#N2&!@$*2,&!B*03'(*00&5?!9&+!#5@2&+!9&!5#!3#0*,8&!
&'! 9&! 5#! +*2+! 3#0*,8&L! 9&+! (04&$'86$8+! 6$*2'&2$+L! 9&+! Z(5'$&2$+! &'! 9&+! 3#$0(4*$&+K! G2!
=U=&! =*=&0'! 9&+! *$@#0(+=&+! 9&! =U=&+! @$*2,&+! B*03'(*00&5+! B2$&0'! $83*5'8+! +2$! 5&!
+('&!9&!5A&+'2#($&!92!C#(0'D%#2$&0'K! <&+!*$@#0(+=&+!*0'!8'8!+83-8+!V+#0+!5#!3*N2(55&!,*2$!
5&+! @#+'8$*,*9&+!&'! 5&+! Z(5'$&2$+W!&'! +&$*0'! 2'(5(+8+!,*2$!9&+!#0#5S+&+! 9A(+*'*,&+! +'#65&+!
Vo13<!&'!o15HW!#Z(0!9&!98'&$=(0&$!5#!3-#/0&!'$*,-(N2&!9#0+!3-#N2&!$8@(*0K!
! %#! 3*=,#$#(+*0! 9&! 5#! $(3-&++&L! 9&! 5#! 9(4&$+('8! &'! 9&! 5#! +'$23'2$&! &0'$&! 5&+! J!
$8@(*0+L! 5A&+'2#($&! 92! C#(0'D%#2$&0'! &'! 5&+! 3P'&+! G'5#0'(N2&+! 9&! H*24&55&D`3*++&L!
=*0'$&0'!9&+!$8+25'#'+!'$T+!(0'8$&++#0'+!V0*0!,$8+&0'8+!9#0+!3&!$#,,*$'WL!N2(!3*0Z($=&0'!
3&!N2(!#!98\;!8'8!*6+&$48!9#0+!5&!,#++8L!=#(+!=#(0'&0#0'!#4&3!20&!#0#5S+&!3*=,5T'&K!p0!
*6+&$4&!20&! 9(BB8$&03&!+(@0(Z(3#'(4&! &0'$&!5&+! 9&2R! $8@(*0+L! 5&+! 3P'&+! G'5#0'(N2&+! #S#0'!
20&!,52+!@$#09&!$(3-&++&!&'!20&!,52+!@$#09&!9(4&$+('8!&0!@808$#5K!.#(+!+(! *0!$&@#$9&!#2!
0(4! 9&+! @$*2,&+! B*03'(*00&5+L! *0! *6+&$4&! 20&! ,52+! @$#09&! $(3-&++&! &'! 9(4&$+('8!
9A&+,T3&+! =*6(5&+! ,*2$! 5A&+'2#($&! 92! C#(0'D%#2$&0'L! =#(+! 20&! ,52+! B#(65&! $(3-&++&! &'!
9(4&$+('8!&0!&+,T3&+!+&++(5&+K!70&!#2'$&!,265(3#'(*0!+&$#!(++2&!9&!3&+!$8+25'#'+!V#4&3!5&+!
$8+25'#'+!9&+! (+*'*,&+!+'#65&+W!,&$=&''#0'!9&!=(&2R!3*=,$&09$&!5&!B*03'(*00&=&0'!9&!
3&+!J!83*+S+'T=&+K
! C9*+!=.&+%##.-!J,!+)(/.
!<&!+'#@&!B2'!'$T+!3*0+'$23'(B!&'!'$T+!(0'8$&++#0'!;!9(BB8$&0'+!,*(0'+!9&!42&K!)A#(!,2!
983*24$($! 9&! 0*24&55&+! 3-*+&+L! N2&! 3&! +*('! #2! 0(4! 9&+! '&3-0(N2&+! +3(&0'(Z(N2&+! &'!
+'#'(+'(N2&+! *2! #2! 0(4! &04($*00&=&0'#5! #4&3! 5&+! 3P'&+! G'5#0'(N2&+! &'! +*0! -#6('#'!
=#$(0! 9(BB8$&0'+! 9&! 3&! N2&! \&! 3*00#(+! &'! N2&! \A#(! #(=8! 983*24$($K! )A#(! 8@#5&=&0'! ,2!
4