Book chapter - Archive ouverte UNIGE

Book Chapter
Reference
Connaître philosophiquement Dieu ? : théologie naturelle et
philosophie de la religion chez Henri Bergson
FENEUIL, Anthony
FENEUIL, Anthony. Connaître philosophiquement Dieu ? : théologie naturelle et philosophie de
la religion chez Henri Bergson. In: C. Riquier. Bergson. Paris : Cerf, 2012. p. 449-467
Available at:
http://archive-ouverte.unige.ch/unige:26323
Disclaimer: layout of this document may differ from the published version.
1 / 1

!
"!
!
!#$%&'$(!)*$*+,-!
!
Connaître philosophiquement Dieu ?
Théologie naturelle et philosophie de la religion chez Henri Bergson
!
!
#.//0!12345067861!9.1!:.0//1!:747;641!<7!:4=6186038!>!?3887;641!:@0<3/3:@09.1A186!
B!<C120/618?1! 16! <7! 876.41! D1! E01.!F"G! ?C1/6!5018! ?1<<1! D1! H14I/38J! -7! ?@3/1! 1/6! DC7.6786!
:<./!/.4:4187861!9.1!<1!:@0<3/3:@1!/C=<30I81!DC1A5<=1!D1!?1!9.0!:3.44706!/1A5<14!<7!K301!
<7!:<./!/L41!:3.4!.81!61<<1!18641:40/1G!<7!K301!D1!<7!6@=3<3I01!876.41<<1G!7.641A186!D06!D1!
<C=<753476038!DC.8!74I.A1867041!/640?61A186!47603881<!/.4!<1!?38?1:6!D1!E01.J!#.!<01.!D1!
?1<7G! 0<! /C3401861! K14/! .81! :@0<3/3:@01! D1! <7! 41<0I038! 16! ?@30/06G! :<.6M6! 9.1! DC=<1K14! /38!
41I74D! K14/! E01.G! D1! <C7570//14!K14/!<1/! @3AA1/! 16! <7!A780N41!D386!0</! /CO! 47::346186J!
P3AA186! :3.44706Q0<! 41/614! >! <7! @7.61.4! D1! /38!35R16!S! P74! >!/.::3/14! 9.C.81!
?38870//78?1!:@0<3/3:@09.1!D1!E01.!TL6!:3//05<1G!<7!?38D06038!/1A5<14706!5018!18!U641!D1!
?3AA18?14! :74! 63.4814! <1! D3/! 7.2! 41<0I038/! 1TT1?60K1/G! >! <1.4! /OA53<0/A1!
786@43:3A34:@09.1! 16! 7.2! ?38618./! =A3603881</! D386! 1<<1/! /1! ?@74I186! :3.4! A01.2!
:=8=6414!<1!A74?@=!63.R3.4/!:<./!?38?.4418601<!D.!/7<.6J!#<34/!/1.<1A186!<1!:@0<3/3:@1G!
7::.O=! /.4! <C12:=4018?1! 16! <1! 470/3881A186G! :3.44706! 1/:=414! D=:7//14! <1/!
41:4=/18676038/! @.A7081/! D1! E01.! 16! 766108D41! /7! ?38870//78?1! K4701J! -1! ?@302!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
"!H14I/38G!&1840G!Les$Deux$Sources$de$la$morale$et$de$la$religion!V"WXYZG![740/G![+)G!Y\\]!^754=I=!E_`G!:J!
YaaJ!
Y!H14I/38G!&1840G!La$Pensée$et$le$mouvant!V"WXbZG![740/G![+)G!Y\\W!^754=I=![c`G!:J!XbJ!

!
Y!
514I/38018!1/6!=80IA7609.1!d!?3AA186!.81!:@0<3/3:@01!D1!<7!41<0I038G!63.48=1!K14/!D1/!
T78670/01/[email protected]/!/0!=<30I8=1/!D1!<C=6@14!D0K08G!:3.44706Q1<<1!/1!/.5/606.14!>!<7!6@=3<3I01!
876.41<<1!?3AA1!A3D1!:40K0<=I0=!D1!<7!?38870//78?1!:@0<3/3:@09.1!D1!E01.!S!!
H14I/38G! :3.4! /7! :746G! 8C.60<0/1! :7/! :<./! <C12:41//038! D1! B!:@0<3/3:@01! D1! <7!
41<0I038!F! 9.1! ?1<<1!D1! B!6@=3<3I01! 876.41<<1!FJ! $=78A308/G! <C3::3/06038! 0440I.1!
08?3861/675<1A186! /7! D1480N41! e.K41J! f.1! ?1<7! :.0//1! 7::747;641! 7.//0! ?<7041A186!
6=A30I81! /78/! D3.61! D1! <7! T=?38D06=! D.! 514I/380/A1! :3.4! <7! ?3A:4=@18/038! 16!
<C=K7<.76038!D1/!:435<=A7609.1/!?3861A:347081/!d!<1/!4183.K17.2G!D78/!<7!/:@N41!78I<3Q
/723881G! D1! <7! 6@=3<3I01! 876.41<<1G! <1.4/! 47::346/! 7K1?! <1/! /?018?1/! D1/! 41<0I038/!
7.[email protected]! 5018! =675<01/! A70/! 63.R3.4/! 18! 9.U61! DC.81! 4=T<12038! =:0/6=A3<3I09.1!
?38/=9.1861G! =I7<1A186! <7! D0TT0?.<6=! 6@=3<3I09.1! D1K786! ?1/! D1.2! 6186760K1/!D1! <7!
6@=3<3I01!876.41<<1!16!D1!<7!:@0<3/3:@01!D1!<7!41<0I038G!>!643.K14!/7!K301!:43:41J!
!
Théologie naturelle et philosophie de la religion : Dieu ou Non-Dieu ?
1. Théologie$naturelle$
f.C1/6Q?1!9.1!<7!6@=3<3I01!876.41<<1!S![7/!9.1/6038!0?0!D1!41K1804!/.4!<1/!D0TT=41861/!
=<753476038/! D386! <C12:41//038! 7! :.! T7041! @0/63409.1A186! <C35R16J! %1838/Q83./! 18! >! .8!
6O:1!d!<7! 6@=3<3I01! 876.41<<1! ?3AA1! 6186760K1! DC7::43?@1!D1! E01.! >! :74604! D1/! A3O18/!
876.41</!D1!?38870//78?1G!>!/7K304!<C0861<<0I18?1!16!<7!/18/050<06=J!,<!1/6!=K0D186!9.1G!D78/!
?1!?3.:<1G!?C1/6!<C0861<<0I18?1!9.0!60186!<7!:41A0N41!:<7?1!d!<1/!D388=1/!/18/05<1/!8C386!D1!
:1460818?1! 9.C>! :3.K304! U641! 086=I4=1/! D78/! .81! 74I.A18676038! 47603881<<1! K0/786! >!
D=A386414! /306! <C120/618?1! D1! E01.G! /306! ?1467081/! D1! /1/! :43:40=6=/J! ,<! /1A5<1! D38?!
470/38875<1!DC7DA16641!.81!D=T0806038!D1!<7!6@=3<3I01!876.41<<1!?3AA1!.81!6186760K1!D1!
?38870//78?1!intellectuelle!D1!E01.J!

!
X!
g1/61! >! D=T0804! <C0861<<0I18?1J! $3./! 7K38/! :3/=! 9.C0<! /C7I0//706! DC.8! A3O18! D1!
?38870//78?1! naturel! >! <C@3AA1J! [418D41! ?1661! 876.47<06=! 7.! /=401.2G! ?C1/6! DC1A5<=1!
08/?4041!<C0861<<0I18?1!D78/!<7!vieG!16!<7!D=614A0814!?3AA1!?747?6=40/609.1!spécifique$D1!
?1661!T34A1!D1!K01!9.C1/6!<C@3AA1J!f.C1/6Q?1!>!D041!S!*//18601<<1A186!9.C0<!T7.6!:418D41!
<C0861<<0I18?1!61<<1!9.C1<<1!/1!D3881G!08/64.A186!K067<!:<.6M6!9.1!A3O18!D1!?38870//78?1!
D=/086=41//=1!d! B!7K786! D1! /:=?.<14G! 7TT04A1! H14I/38G! 0<! T7.6! K0K41!FY!J! h6.D014G! D38?G!
<C0861<<0I18?1!18!614A1/!D1!503<3I01J!-7!K01!D386!0<!/C7I06G!8=78A308/G!8C1/6!:7/!<0A06=1!>!
/1/!A780T1/676038/!34I7809.1/!d!1<<1!/C18618D!:<./!<74I1A186!?3AA1!D=:<301A186!DC.81!
7?60K06=J! PC1/6! :3.49.30G! /0! <C0861<<0I18?1! D306! U641! D=T0801! 18! 614A1/! 503<3I09.1/XG! ?C1/6!
/1.<1A186!7.!/18/!3i!0<!T7.6!<7!?3A:418D41!>!:74604!D1!/38!4M<1!D78/!<C34I780/76038!D1!
<C7?60K06=!@.A7081G! D1! /7! T38?6038bG!D1!?1661!T38?6038!9.0!/:=?0T01! <C7?60K06=! DC.8! ?146708!
K0K786! 18! 7?60K06=! humaineJ! $38! :7/! 9.1! <1/! @3AA1/! /30186! 8=?1//7041A186! <1/! /1.</!
U641/!K0K786/!D36=/!DC0861<<0I18?1!d!<C@O:36@N/1!/14706!?3L61./1G!16!H14I/38!DC70<<1.4/!81!
801!:7/!9.C0<!/1!643.K1!DC7.641/!K146=54=/!0861<<0I186/J![3.4!<.0G!<C7?60K06=!@.A7081!8C1/6!
:7/! /:=?0T09.1! :74?1! 9.C1<<1! 1/6! 0861<<0I1861G! A70/! :74?1! 9.C1<<1! 1/6! plus$ 0861<<0I1861!
quC08/608?60K1aJ! -C0861<<0I18?1! 7! :40/! <1! :7/! /.4! .8! 08/608?6! 9.0! 81! D0/:747;6! :7/! :3.4!
7.6786G! A70/! :14D! /38! 4M<1! :40A34D07<! D78/! <C7?60K06=! 834A7<1J! ,<! :3.447! 41/614G!
=K186.1<<1A186G! .8! ?38641:30D/! >! <C0861<<0I18?1! D1/608=! >! =9.0<05414! <C7?60K06=!D78/! /38!
18/1A5<1!j!0<!81!/147!:<./!<1!:408?0:1!D1!?1661!7?60K06=J!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Y!H14I/38G!&1840G!La$Pensée$et$le$mouvant!V"WXbZG![740/G![+)G!Y\\W!^754=I=![c`G!:J!XbJ!
X!E_G!:J!"\b!d!B!E38838/!D38?!7.!A36!503<3I01!<1!/18/!64N/!?3A:4=@18/0T!9.C0<!D1K4706!7K304G!9.C0<!:418D47!
:1.6QU641!.8!R3.4!FJ!,<!/C7I06! DC.81!=6.D1!D1!<7! K01!?3AA1!7?60K06=!16!838!/1.<1A186!?3AA1!:@=83AN81!
34I7809.1J!
b!_0I87<38/! 9.1! <C7TT04A76038! /1<38! <79.1<<1! <C0861<<0I18?1! 41A:<06! .81! T38?6038! K067<1! D0TTN41! D1! ?1<<1G!
T087<0/61G!/1<38!<79.1<<1!<C0861<<0I18?1!7!=6=!?4==1!:3.4!41A:<04!/7!T38?6038J!H14I/38!/C7??34D1!7K1?!E74k08!
:3.4!41R1614!.8!61<!T087<0/A1!d!?1!8C1/6!:7/!:74?1!9.1!<C0861<<0I18?1!possède$.81!T38?6038!9.C1<<1!7!=6=!créée$
pour$?1661!T38?6038J!
a!l304!H14I/38G!&1840G!L’Évolution$créatrice!V"W\mZG![740/G![+)G!Y\\m!^754=I=!*P`!:J!"bXQ"bbJ!

!
b!
P3AA186! /1! D0TT=418?01! <C7?60K06=! 0861<<0I1861! DC.81! 7?60K06=! 08/608?60K1!S! *8!
:41A0N41! 787<O/1G! :74! /7! non$ immédiateténJ! -C7?60K06=! 0861<<0I1861G! >! <7! D0TT=418?1! D1!
<C7?60K06=! 08/608?60K1! 9.0! 7661086! /38! 5.6! D041?61A186G! :43?ND1! :74! 7DR38?6038! D1!
A=D076038/!R./9.C7.! 4=/.<676J! ,<! 1/6! =K0D186! 9.1! <Ce/641! D.! ?@1K7<! 81! sait$ :7/G! <34/9.C0<!
B!D=:3/1! /1/! e.T/! /.4! <1/! R7A51/! 3.! <1/! =:7.<1/! D1! <C780A7<G! ^o`! 9.1! /7! <74K1! D306! /1!
D=K1<3::14! D78/! <C1/63A7?! D.! ?@1K7<G! 16! 9.1! <1! ?@1K7<G! 18! /1! <=?@786G! 6478/:346147! <7!
<74K1!870//7861!D78/!/38!6.51!D0I1/60TJ!Fm!%3.61/!?1/!=67:1/!8C120/6186!:7/!:3.4!<C08/608?6J!
*8! 41K78?@1G! 0<!1/6! 63.6! >! T706! /0I80T0?760T! 9.1! 83./G! U641/! 0861<<0I186/G! 81! :.0//038/!
7::4=@18D14! ?1! :43?1//./! 7.641A186! 9.1! ?3AA1! .81! /.??1//038! DC=67:1/!
?3441/:38D786!>!7.6786!D1!41:4=/18676038/J!E1!<>G!0<!8C1/6!:7/!0<<=I060A1!D1!T7041!.8!:7/!D1!
:<./!16!D1!D=T0804!<7!T38?6038!D1!<C0861<<0I18?1!:74!<7!T7540?76038!D1/!3.60</G!16!AUA1!D1/!
B!3.60</!>!T7041!D1/!3.60</!F]G!:3.4!A01.2!12:40A14!?1!T706!9.1!<C0861<<0I18?1!8C1864160186!
:7/! D1! 47::346! D041?6! >! <C35R16J! #.//0! <C7?60K06=! 0861<<0I1861! 1/6Q1<<1G! D78/! .8! AUA1!
A3.K1A186G! 4.:6.41! D1! <C0AA=D07616=! 08/608?60K1! 16! 6186760K1! D1! ?3A5<14! <7! T70<<1! :74!
<C08K186038!DC.81!08T0806=!D1!A=D076038/WJ!P1<7!8C1/6!:7/!/78/!?38/=9.18?1!/.4!<1!47::346!
7.!A38D1!D.!K0K786!?38?148=J![<./!127?61A186G!7K1?!<7!4.:6.41!D1!<C0AA=D07616=G!7K1?!
<C08643D.?6038!DC.81!T70<<1!18641!<1!D=5.6!D1!<C7?6038!16!/7!T08G!?C1/6!<7!:3//050<06=!AUA1!D1!
9.1<9.1!?@3/1!?3AA1!.8!47::346!7.!A38D1!9.0!=A14I1G!:74?1!9.C=A14I1!<7!:3//050<06=!
DC.81!D0/608?6038!18641!/.R16!16!A38D1G!16!AUA1!18641!/.R16!7?60T!16!A38D1!:7//0T!?C1/6Q>Q
D041G! 7.! 53.6! D.! ?3A:61G! A76=401<"\J! P74! /0! <C0861<<0I18?1! 1/6! <7! T7?.<6=! DC08K18614! D1/!
3.60</G!0<!<.0!T7.6!?1661!A760N41!9.C1<<1!:.0//1!.60<0/14!>!/38!I4=J!*6!?C1/6!>!<7!<.A0N41!D1!?1!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
n!*PG!:J!"bYQ"bXJ!
m!*PG!:J!"bnQ"bm!
]!*PG!:J!"b\!d!B!*8!D=T08060K1G!l’intelligence,$envisagée$dans$ce$qui$paraît$en$être$la$démarche$originelle,$est$la$
faculté$de$fabriquer$des$objets$artificiels,$en$particulier$des$outils$à$faire$des$outils,$et$d’en$varier$indéfiniment$
la$fabricationJ!F!
W!*PG!:J!"bYQ"bXJ!
"\!E1!<>!<C0D=1!514I/3801881!/1<38!<79.1<<1!<C0861<<0I18?1!418D!<1!A38D1!B!T430D!?3AA1!<7!A346!F!V[cG!:J!
"bYZG!?74!7K1?!<C0861<<0I18?1!83./!81!83/!/18638/!:<./!0AA=D0761A186!:40/!D78/!<1!A3.K1A186!D.!A38D1G!
A70/!<1!A38D1!83./!D1K0186!.8!35R16!126=401.4J!