Comprendre Marx et Le Capital

Web
Bombix
4 décembre 2011
Agitateur.org
!
Comprendre)Marx)et)Le)Capital)
)
dimanche)4)décembre)2011)à)15:19,)par)bombix)
!
"#$$%!&'()*+,-+.!/%0+1!"#&&+0!2-01!&'30!2%!1%1!-3.*%1!&+,*%1!4!5!Si)
le)critère)de)la)science)est)la)vérification)expérimentale)des)
prédictions)déduites)de)la)théorie,)Marx)passe)le)test)haut)la)
main!6!789:!;-*<=!>3'#0!)*#?-+.!$#*.!%.!%0.%**(=!-3*-+.!%0)#*%!
>3%&>3%!)@#1%!A!0#31!2+*%!B!C#3*!D-*.*%!-311+=!&%!$-*<+1$%!(.-+.!
5!&'@3$31!2%!.#3.%!E%01(%!E-*.+)3&+F*%!%.!&'@#*+G#0!2%!.#3.%!
)3&.3*%!6!7H9:!C#3*.-0.!)%!$-*<+1$%I&A=!-,%)!1%1!)#0)%E.1!$-11+J1!
)#$$%!&%!5!$-.(*+-&+1$%!2+-&%).+>3%!6=!1%1!-*.+)&%1!2%!J#+!%.!1-!
E@+&#1#E@+%!2%!&'@+1.#+*%!1'%1.!%JJ#02*(!%0!8KLK!-,%)!&%!$3*!2%!
M%*&+0:!N%1!E-*.+1!)#$$30+1.%1!%3*#E(%01!#0.!2+1E-*3!#3!1#0.!
%0!,#+%!2'%<.+0).+#0:!N-!5!J+0!2%!&'@+1.#+*%!6!%.!&%!.*+#$E@%!2%!&-!
5!2($#)*-.+%!&+O(*-&%!6!%0!1-!,%*1+#0!-$(*+)-+0%!7P9!1#0.I+&1!
-&#*1!*%2%,%031!0#.*%!1%3&!@#*+G#0!B!;#+01!>3%!Q-$-+1:!N%!
)-E+.-&+1$%!%1.!%0!)*+1%=!)#$$%!)@-)30!&%!1-+.=!$-+1!E#3*13+.!1-!
1+0+1.*%!)-**+F*%:!N%!)-E+.-&+1$%!B!C&3.R.!&%!Capital!)#$$%!
E*#)%1131=!&%!mode)de)production)capitaliste=!-,%)!%0!1#0!)S3*!)%!
1#&%+&!0#+*!4!&-!$-*)@-02+1%!%.!&'-*T%0.!)#$$%!(>3+,-&%0.!
T(0(*-&:!
!
C#3*!)#$E*%02*%!0#.*%!.%$E1=!*+%0!2%!E&31!3*T%0.!2#0)!>3%!2%!J-+*%!*%.#3*!A!;-*<:!U0!
E@+&#1#E@%!J*-0V-+1!)@*(.+%0=!;+)@%&!W%0*?!7X9=!-,-+.!.*-)(!&-!,#+%:!"'%1.!13*!1%1!E-1!>3%!)@%$+0%!
/%0+1!"#&&+0:!Y0&-11-O&%$%0.=!+&!E#3*13+.!1#0!.*-,-+&!E(2-T#T+>3%!%.!J-+.!S3,*%!2'%<E&+)+.-.+#0:!
/%E3+1!1#0!E*%$+%*!&+,*%!4!5!La)théorie)de)la)connaissance)chez)Marx!6=!Q31>3'A!1#0!2%*0+%*!#E31!
5!)Comprendre)Marx)et)le)Capital)!6:!;-+1!+&!0%!1'-T+.!E-1!1%3&%$%0.!2%!)#$E*%02*%!%.!2%!E*#23+*%!
2%1!.@(#*+%1:!Y&!1'-T+.!-311+=!+&!1'-T+.!13*.#3.!2%!1'#*T-0+1%*!E#3*!-T+*:!Y&!%1.!2#0)!J#02-$%0.-&!2%!
)#0,-+0)*%!%.!2'%<E&+>3%*:!Y&!%1.!3*T%0.!2%!1'-2*%11%*!A!)%3<!2#0.!&-!J#*$-.+#0!#3!&%1!-).+,+.(1!
E*#J%11+#00%&&%1!0%!&-+11%0.!E-1!&%!&#+1+*!2%!&+*%!%.!2%!2+T(*%*!&'+$$%01%!)@-0.+%*!%.!1%1!$+&&+%*1!
2%!E-T%1!>3%!)#01.+.3%!&%!)#*E31!$-*<+%0:!
!
C@+&#1#E@%!A!&'#%3,*%!-O#02-0.%=!+0-)@%,(%=!)#0.*-2+).#+*%=!2#0.!&'-))F1!%1.!%$EZ)@(!E-*!
2'+00#$O*-O&%1!)#$$%0.-+*%1!-O1)#01=!;-*<!*%11%$O&%!O+%0!A!&-!1.-.3%!2%![&-3)31=!)%!/+%3!
(,#>3(!E-*!C&-.#0=!>3+!-,-+.!1(Q#3*0(!1+!&#0T.%$E1!-3!J#02!2%!&-!$%*!>3'%&&%!%0!(.-+.!2%,%03%!
$()#00-+11-O&%:!/%0+1!"#&&+0!0#31!E*#E#1%!30!.#+&%..-T%!>3+!%1.!%0!J-+.!30%!\*%]2()#3,%*.%:!
!
M#00%!0#3,%&&%!4!;-*<!%1.!)#$E*(@%01+O&%!^!_0!)%0.!E-T%1!&%1!E*+0)+E-&%1!-*.+)3&-.+#01!2%!&-!
E%01(%!23!E@+&#1#E@%!1#0.!%<E#1(%1:!Y&!0%!1'-T+.!E-1!2'30!5!*(13$(!6!A!&'31-T%!2%1!)-02+2-.1!-3!
O-))-&-3*(-.:!N%!.%<.%!2%!/%0+1!"#&&+0!J#0).+#00%!)#$$%!30%!E*#E(2%3.+>3%!A!2%1.+0-.+#0!2%!
)%3<!>3+!,#32*-+%0.!1%!E&#0T%*!2-01!&-!&%).3*%!23!E@+&#1#E@%:!;-*<!-!>3%&>3%!)@#1%!A!2+*%!4!
)#$$%!+&!%1.!1(*+%3<!%.!)#01)+%0)+%3<=!+&!2(,%&#EE%!30%!S3,*%!&#0T3%=!)#$E&%<%!%.!-*23%!`!
)#$$%!)%!2#0.!+&!E-*&%!%1.!)%!*(%&!>3%!)@-)30!E%3.!-EE*(@%02%*!2-01!1#0!%<+1.%0)%=!+&!2#+.!Z.*%!
E#11+O&%!2%!*-$%0%*!)%..%!)#$E&%<+.(!A!30!%01%$O&%!2%!E*#E#1+.+#01!%.!2'-0-&?1%1!-))%11+O&%1!A!

.#3.!&%).%3*!2%!O#00%!,#&#0.(:!Y&!2#+.!Z.*%!E#11+O&%!2'(.-O&+*!30%!)-*.#T*-E@+%!>3+!0#31!2()#3,*%!
30!E-?1-T%!+0.%&&%).3%&!-,%)!1%1!&+T0%1!2%!J#*)%1!%.!1%1!)#0)%E.1!)&(1:!
!
N'%0.*%E*+1%!%1.!*(311+%!A!0'%0!E-1!2#3.%*:!"#$$%0.!1%!.*-01J#*$%!&'-*T%0.!%0!)-E+.-&!B!a3%!J-3.I
+&!%0.%02*%!E-*!&3..%!2%1!)&-11%1!B!a3'%0!%1.I+&!2%!&'%<E&#+.-.+#0=!2%!&'-&+(0-.+#0!B!C#3*>3#+!&%!$#2%!
2%!E*#23).+#0!)-E+.-&+1.%!%1.I+&!)#02-$0(!B!b#3.%1!)%1!>3%1.+#01!1#0.!-O#*2(%1!2-01!30%!&-0T3%!
1+$E&%!%.!E*()+1%:!N%!.%<.%!%1.!-))#$E-T0(!2%!T*-,3*%1!%0!0#+*!%.!O&-0)!2'c,%1!d#3,+F*%=!*%02-0.!
&-!)#013&.-.+#0!2%!&'#3,*-T%!.*F1!E&-+1-0.%:!
!
e0!0%!.%0.%*-!E-1!30!*(13$(!2'30!E%.+.!&+,*%!>3+!*(13$%!2(QA!.#3.%!30%!S3,*%=!)%!1%*-+.!*+2+)3&%:!
e0!E%3.!1#3&+T0%*!0(-0$#+01!A!.#3.!&%).%3*!%<)(2(!E-*!&-!&-0T3%!2%!O#+1!$-*<+1.%!%.!)#$$30+1.%!
>3'+&!2%,*-+.!.*#3,%*!*-J*-f)@+11-0.!&%!;-*<!2%!"#&&+0:!N'@#$$%!0%!2(.%1.%!E-1!2(O#3&#00%*!&%1!
+2#&%1:!g3!)@-E+.*%!5!g))3$3&-.+#0!E*+$+.+,%!6!E-*!%<%$E&%=!+&!0'@(1+.%!E-1!A!)#$E-*%*!
&'%<E*#E*+-.+#0!2%1!E-?1-01!-0T&-+1!-3!hYhF$%!1+F)&%!%.!&-!)#&&%).+,+1-.+#0!J#*)(%!+$E#1(%!E-*!
D.-&+0%!-3!$#02%!E-?1-0!*311%!2-01!&%1!-00(%1!Pi:!"%!>3+!)#$E.%=!)'%1.!O+%0!&'-))3$3&-.+#0!
E*+$+.+,%=!>3'%&&%!1#+.!5!)-E+.-&+1.%!6!#3!5!1#)+-&+1.%!6!^!5!Cette)comparaison)en)dit)long)sur)la)
nature)exacte)de)ce)que)fut)l’Union)soviétique.!6!7j9!g3.*%!%<%$E&%!%.!-3.*%!$?.@%!>3+!1'%JJ#02*%!4!
&%!E*#&(.-*+-.!)#$$%!)&-11%!30+,%*1%&&%!-T%0.!2%!&'@+1.#+*%!%.!,%).%3*!2%!&-!E-*#31+%:!D+!&%!)%0.*%!
2%!&'-0-&?1%!2#+.!1'(.-O&+*!-3.#3*!23!"-E+.-&!)#$$%!E*#)%1131!%.!0#0!13*!&'%0.+.(!1#)+-&%!k!
5!O#3*T%#+1!6=!5!)-E+.-&+1.%!6!k!)%01(!&%!2(.%0+*=!1'#EF*%!30!*%0,%*1%$%0.!)#E%*0+)+%0!4!5!ce)ne)
sont)pas)les)classes)qui)rentrent)en)lutte,)mais)la)lutte)qui)fait)les)classes.)Et)les)individus)se)
disposent)autour)de)cet)opérateur)"lutte)des)classes".!7l9!6!/F1!&#*1=!1'%<E&+>3%!>3'-,%)!&-!
1#)+-&+1-.+#0!23!"-E+.-&!\%JJ%).+,%!2-01!&%1!J#021!2%!E%01+#0!E-*!%<%$E&%]=!#0!0'-11+1.%!E-1!A!
&'()@%)!23!E*#)%1131=!$-+1!A!1#0!.*+#$E@%=!2-01!1-!J#*$%!&-!E&31!E3*%!^!
!
"&-+*%$%0.=!;-*<!%0J+0!2(O-**-11(!2%1!5!$-*<+1$%1!6!%.!2%1!5!$-*<+1.%1!6!0#31!-+2%!A!?!
)#$E*%02*%!>3%&>3%!)@#1%!23!hhYF$%!1+F)&%!)#$$%0V-0.:!e0!E#3**-!1%!2%$-02%*!
0-.3*%&&%$%0.!1+!&%!;-*<!*%1.+.3(!E-*!"#&&+0!%1.!O+%0!&%!;-*<!-3.@%0.+>3%:!m%!&%!.#*2I.I+&!E-1!A!1#0!
.#3*!E#3*!&3+!J-+*%!1%*,+*!1#0!E*#E*%!E*#Q%.!E#&+.+>3%=!30%!1#*.%!2%!*(E3O&+)-0+1$%!)#$$30+1.%!
>3+!2#+.!-3.-0.!A!n-0.!%.!A!W%T%&!>3'A!;-*<!B!D-01!2#3.%!30!E%3:!;-+1!2'30%!E-*.!;-*<!0'%1.!E-1!
30!E@+&#1#E@%!>3+!E*(1%0.%!30!1?1.F$%!-)@%,(!%.!30+,#>3%:!"%!>3+!*%1.%!2%!;-*<!%1.!30%!S3,*%!
%0!)@-0.+%*!%.!2-,-0.-T%!30%!$(.@#2%!>3'30!*(13&.-.:!"%!0'%1.!2#0)!E-1!&%!.*-@+*!>3%!2%!*%$%..*%!
13*!&%!$(.+%*!1#0!#3,*-T%:!/'-3.*%!E-*.=!%0!$%..-0.!-3!)S3*!23!E*#Q%.!23!E@+&#1#E@%!
&'($-0)+E-.+#0!2%1!@#$$%1!%.!&%!T#o.!2%!&-!&+O%*.(=!%0!*%1.+.3-0.!30!;-*<!@(*+.+%*!2%1!N3$+F*%1=!
/%0+1!"#&&+0!-11#)+%!A!&'+0.%*E*(.-.+#0!&-!E&31!&+O*%!&-!J+2(&+.(!&-!E&31!1)*3E3&%31%:!
)
!
Comprendre)Marx)et)le)Capital,)guide)graphique=E-*!/%0+1!"#&&&+0!%.!c,%1!d#3,+F*%=!;-<!
;+&#!_2+.+#01=!0#,%$O*%!Hi88:!YDMm!KpLIHIP8jiiIPi8IP!
!
!
789!Le)cauchemar)de)Karl)Marx=!E:!88!
7H9!Questions)de)méthode=!;-*<+1$%!%.!%<+1.%0.+-&+1$%=![-&&+$-*2=!Y2(%1=!E:!8H!
7P9!b@F1%!2(J%023%!E-*!q*-0)+1!q3r3?-$-!2-01!30!&+,*%=!La)fin)de)l’histoire)et)le)dernier)homme=!
-3<!-0-&?1%1!%.!-3!)#0.%03!E&31!*+)@%1!>3%!)%!>3%!1%1!2(.*-).%3*1!E*%11(1!#0.!&-+11(!%0.%02*%:!
7X9!Marx,)I.)Une)philosophie)de)la)réalité);)II)Une)philosophie)de)l’économie=![-&&+$-*2=!8Kpl:!
7j9!Comprendre)Marx)et)le)Capital=!E:!Pl!
7l9!Comprendre)Marx)et)le)Capital=!E:!jX!
!