• uh*+&.5,&5%(Q6S&($5#(NE%"E%(c*8$%686%9('(Q<*E8#(i&(T*.@$_&(=E%*,$%64(Q%$-686S$%6*5Pv(W;6%<(
y$+6&.(Z&-.E5($5#(=5#.B(Q$"6.Y:(65(]<&(3E.*'(]<&(T6.@%(Z&4$#&:(%&#(-9(R$.4*(AE%6:(Q&.+$$@(
Z&.**@&:( c6%*.( h$@"$.( $5#( H*z*( )*>E&6.$( R$.%65@:( G$,-.6#>&( !56+&.@6%9( 7.&@@:( /010J( 7.&C
"E-864$%6*5( +&.@6*5( $+$68$-8&( $@( Bruegel" Working" Paper( )*( 1g/00m:( R$.4<( /00m( W$8@*(
.&8&$@&#($@(Zh(3GTd)(i*._65>(7$"&.($5#(dRT(i*._65>(7$"&.YJ((
• (uA$5_65>(G.6@6@(R$5$>&,&5%(65(%<&(3!'(=5(3$.89(=@@&@@,&5%v(W;6%<(=5#.B(Q$"6.Y:(34*5*,64(
7*8649()*(2/:(=".68(/010J(7.&C"E-864$%6*5( +&.@6*5( $+$68$-8&( $@( Bruegel" Working" Paper()*(
/00bC0U:(Z&4&,-&.J(((
• u3E.*(=.&$('(a&$#9(M*.(%<&(Q%*.,Pv(W;6%<(=5#.B(Q$"6.Y:(65"]<&(&E.*($%(10'(]<&()&L%(h8*-$8(
GE..&549P( W%&#( -9( H&$5( 76@$56CT&..9( $5#( =#$,( 7*@&5Y:( A.E&>&8g7&%&.@*5( d5@%6%E%&( M*.(
d5%&.5$%6*5$8( 34*5*,64@:( HE5&( /00b( W$8@*( .&8&$@&#( $@( A.E&>&8( 7*8649( G*5%.6-E%6*5( )*(
/00bg0f:( R$.4<( /00bYJ( Q"$56@<( +&.@6*5( 65( 38( &E.*( $8( .&@4$%&( #&( 3E.*"$:( 4**.#65$%*( "*.(
T&#&.64*(Q%&65-&.>:(a&$8(d5@%6%E%*(384$5*gR$.46$8(7*5@:(/010J((
• u]<&(=446#&5%$8(78$9&.'(]<&(3E.*"&$5(!56*5($5#(%<&(h8*-$8(34*5*,9v:(65(]<&(3E.*"&$5(
!56*5($5#(d5%&.5$%6*5$8(N.>$56S$%6*5@v:(%&#(-9(t5E#(3.6_(H{.>&5@&5:(a*E%8&#>&:(/00bJ((
• u36><%(7*%&5%6$8(a*$#-8*4_@(%*(Q,**%<(3!CG<65$(34*5*,64(a&8$%6*5@v(W;6%<(=5#.B(Q$"6.Y:(65(
=5#&.@(=@8E5#($5#(R$.&_(Z$-.*;@_6(W&#@Y:(G<$88&5>&@(*M(h8*-$86S$%6*5'(d,-$8$54&@($5#(
h.*;%<:(7&%&.@*5(d5@%6%E%&(M*.(d5%&.5$%6*5$8(34*5*,64@:(HE89(/00mJ((
• r(7*86%6IE&(B4*5*,6IE&('($+*5@C5*E@($"".6@(P(s:(a&+E&(B4*5*,6IE&:(,$6(/00mJ((
• u]<&( h*+&.5$54&( *M( %<&( 3E.*"&$5( !56*5e@( d5%&.5$%6*5$8( 34*5*,64( a&8$%6*5@'( j*;( R$59(
c*64&@Pv(W;6%<(A&5*F%(G*&E.BY:(65(=5#.B(Q$"6.:(&#J:(T.$>,&5%&#(7*;&.'(3E.*"&($5#(%<&(h8*-$8(
34*5*,9:(A.E&>&8:(Q&"%&,-&.(/00U(
• uT65$546$8(65%&>.$%6*5($5#(3E.*"&$5(".6*.6%6&@v:(65(G<$88&5>&@(%*(%<&(M65$546$8(@9@%&,(|($>&65>(
$5#(8*;(>.*;%<:(".*4&A>@(*M(%<&(%<6.#(4*5M&.&54&(*M(%<&(Q%6M%E5>(h&8#(E5#(i}<.E5>:(R$9(
/00UJ((
• (u34*5*,64(d5@%6%E%6*5@($5#(7*8646&@(65(%<&(!Q($5#(%<&(3!'(G*5+&.>&54&(*.(Z6+&.>&54&Pv(W;6%<(
386&( G*<&5Y:( 65( 364<&5>.&&5:( X$5#&@,$55( $5#( Q%6&M&8:( &#@J:( ]<&( 3E.*"&$5( 34*5*,9( 65( $5(
=,&.64$5(R6..*.(:(a*E%8&#>&:(/00UJ(
• (uN589(N5&(A&#(M*.(];*(Z.&$,@'(=(G.6%64$8(a&%.*@"&4%6+&(*5(%<&(Z&-$%&(*+&.(%<&(34*5*,64(
h*+&.5$54&(*M(%<&(3E.*(=.&$v:(H*E.5$8(*M(G*,,*5(R$._&%(Q%E#6&@(+*8J(\\(5l\:(/002J((
• uT6@4$8( 7*8649( 65( 3R!'( ]*;$.#@( $( QE@%$65$-686%9( $5#( h.*;%<( 7$4%Pv( W;6%<( A&5*F%( G*&E.BY:(
NLM*.#(a&+6&;(*M(34*5*,64(7*8649(c*8J(/1(5l\:(/002J((
• u]<&( QE.".6@65>( T.&54<( 3,"8*9,&5%( 7&.M*.,$54&v:( 65( R$.%65( i&.#65>( W&#JY:( Q%.E4%E.$8(
!5&,"8*9,&5%(65(i&@%&.5(3E.*"&'(a&$@*5@($5#(a&,&@:(Rd](7.&@@:(/002J(
• r(i<$%e@(i.*5>(;6%<(X6@-*5P(s:(G3Q6M*(T*.E,(5l/g/00KJ((
• (u=(QE@%$65$-686%9(7$4%(M*.(%<&(3E.*S*5&v(W;6%<J(AJ(G*&E.BY:(65(h*+&.5$54&($5#(X&>6%6,$49(65(
3R!:(%&#(-9(X*E_$@(]@*E_$86@:(3E.*"&$5(!56+&.@6%9(d5@%6%E%&:(/00KJ((
• r(aBM*.,&.(8&(7$4%&(#&(@%$-686%B('("*E.IE*6:(4*,,&5%(P(s:(65(G*5@&68(#e$5$89@&(B4*5*,6IE&:(
aBM*.,&.(8&(7$4%&(#&(@%$-686%B(&%(#&(4.*6@@$54&,".$""*.%(5lK/:(/00\:((
• u]<&( 3E.*S*5&e@( R$4.*&4*5*,64( T.$,&;*._'( Z*&@( 6%( ,$%%&.P( i<$%( @<*E8#( -&( #*5&P:( 65(
34*5*,64(a&M*.,(65(3E.*"&'( 7.6*.6%6&@(M*.(%<&()&L%(T6+&( ^&$.@:(%&#(-9(a*>&.(X6##8&($5#(
R$.6$(H*z*(a*#.6>E&@:(7*8649()&%;*._:()*+&,-&.(/00\J(((