Pouvoirs religieux et politique sous les califes

!"#$%&'()*+#,(--./0#1%#234&5+#!05.60+#7%)**0+#89:;<8:9=#
!"#$"%&'(&)*%+%)#,()-(."*%-%/#)('"#'(*)(01*%21-(3(
456)7-%2'(3(
! 8-#9%)&(:(;.%'"9)'(9)(*1($%)(9)(<"=1>>)9(."#&(7)&?)&(*)(&@*)(9#(.&".=A-)(
! 0">.&)?9&)(*)'(."#$"%&'(9"??;'(1#,(01*%2)'(B(.1&-%&(9)(*1('#77)''%"?(9#(.&".=A-)(
! C?1*D')&(*1(&;917-%"?(9#(0"&1?(7">>)('"#&7)(9#(9&"%-!
!
8,)&7%7)(E3(20*#>(%6()?*#1%#>?(>@.'0#
"#!$%&'!&()!*)(&@*)(9"??;(B(<"=1>>)9!*+,!'-+./&!0+1,2&'!3!
(
FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFG(
4#!56..&!'&(!,+2(6.(!7%!9;.1&-(9)(<"=1>>)9(."#&(<;9%?)G!
!
FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF#
8#!H;7&%'(*)(&)-"#&(9)(<"=1>>)9(B(I1(<)7/#)!&)!),.*%/#)(7)(/#J%*(21%-(1.&A'('1($%7-"%&)!
(
FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFG(
#
FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFG(
9#!0">.*A-)(*)'(719&)'()?(9"??1?-(*)(?">(9)'(;$A?)>)?-'(:6,,&(*6.7+.)!;!'+!<2&!7&!=6>+??&7!
#### #### #
KL(M%*1?(%?-)&>;9%1%&)(@!8,.*%/#)(*)(&@*)(9)(<"=1>>)9!;!),+<&,(!:&(!),62(!A*2(67&(!7&!(+!<2&B#
!
FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFG(
(
FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF(
H"7#>)?-(E(@!A#3>)*(10*#10#-&#B)(/?&>@)0#10#C(@&4401#*0-(5#DB5EF)G@&4!
I1(&;$;*1-%"?(C!D-+./&!0+1,2&'!7&(:&.72)!7%!:2&'!&)!),6%<+!=6>+??&7!(%,!'&!?6.)!E2,+!F%5#4(5'&/50#*)'%30#H#>?(I)4)'3#10#-&#
C0GJ%0GB!H'!(&!?6.),+!;!'%2!&)!'%2!72)!C!I+'%)!;!)62J!K!=6>+??&7J!+*K),&!7-L''+>B!M!=6>+??&7!(&!'&<+J!*&.(+.)!N%-2'!A)+2)!
7&<&.%!O6%B!H'!(&!72,2/&+!<&,(!'&!(6??&)!7&!'+!?6.)+/.&B!=+2(!0+1,2&'!'&!*,2)!&.),&!(&(!+2'&(!&)!'%2!72)!@!C!=6>+??&7J!)%!&(!'+!
*,6*>P)&!7-L''+>!&)!Q&!(%2(!0+1,2&'J!'-+./&!7-L''+>!N%2!)-+**6,)&!(6.!?&((+/&!*6%,!N%&!)%!'2(&(!MB!=6>+??&7!'%2!,A*6.72)!@!
C!R6??&.)!'2,+2(SQ&J!?62!N%2!.&!(+2(!*+(!'2,&!3!M!0+1,2&'!'%2!72)!C!D2(!+%!.6?!7&!)6.!(&2/.&%,!N%2!+!)6%)!:,AAB!M(
(
<)?17;(9)(>"&-N(<"=1>>)9('J%?'-1**)(B(<;9%?)()-(D(2"?9)(*1(.&)>%A&)(7">>#?1#-;(>#'#*>1?)@!!
C!D-&.<6TA! 7&! 52&%! *,U:>+2)! '-2('+?! &)! +**&'+2)! '+! *6*%'+)26.! ;! (&! :6.<&,)2,B! R&))&! :6.7%2)&! :,A+2)! 7&(! N%&,&''&(! &.),&! '&(!
=&:N%62(B!H'(!<2.,&.)!<62,!L1%!V+'21!F-K(5G-0#10#C(@&4401G!&)!'%2!72,&.)B!C!L1%!V+'21J!.6%(!)-+<6.(!7AQ;!7&?+.7A!7&!,&)&.2,!
)6.! .&<&%! &)! )%! .&! '-+(! *+(! O+2)B! W6%(! .&! *6%<6.(! *'%(! (%**6,)&,! '&(! 2.(%')&(! :6.),&! .6(! 72<2.2)A(! &)! '&! ?A*,2(! 7&! .6(!
+.:U),&(!M!
C!D&!*,6*>P)&!(-A)+1'2)!;!=A72.&!'&!"X!Q%2''&)!YY4!!"#$%&'()*+(,'(-.%/-)01"
!L!:&))&!7+)&!=6>+??&7!+<+2)!:2.N%+.)&!),62(!+.(!M!
!
I)(&)-"#&($)&'(I1(<)7/#)(
3C!D&!*,6*>P)&!76..+!;!(&(!/A.A,+%Z!'-6,7,&!7-&.),&,!;!'+!=&:N%&!&)!7&!.&!:6?1+)),&!N%&!:&%Z!N%2!
'&%,! ,A(2()&,+2&.)B! D&(! 72OOA,&.)&(! :6'6..&(! ?%(%'?+.&(! 2.<&()2,&.)! '+! <2''&! 7&! )6%)&(! *+,)(! F[G! D6,(N%&! '&! :+'?&! ,&<2.)J! '&!
\,6*>P)&!+''+!+%!(+.:)%+2,&!7&!'+!]++1+B!L!76(!7&!:>+?&+%J!2'!O2)!(&*)!O62(!'&!)6%,!7%!V&?*'&B!H'!T!+<+2)!)6%)!+%)6%,!7%!)&?*'&!
7&(!()+)%&(!7-276'&(!(:&''A&(!+<&:!7%!*'6?1B!H'!O2)!'&!)6%,!7&(!()+)%&(B!^)!'&(!276'&(!)6?1+2&.)J!;!'-+,,2P,&!6%!;!'-+<+.)J!(&'6.!'&!
/&()&!7%!*,6*>P)&B!H'!.-&.!,&()+!*'%(!%.&!(&%'&!7&16%)BM((((((((((((((((((((((HJ1.&A'(O5?PQ%7=1>N(L)0#1%#>?(>@.'0J!H_P!(2P:'&B
(
!
!
!

!"#$%&'()*+#,(--./0#1%#234&5+#!05.60+#7%)**0+#89:;<8:9=#
8,)&7%7)(R(3(#20*#>(%6()?*#10*#G&-)M0*#
H"7#>)?-(R#2&#*%GG0**)(5#1%#>?(>@.'0#
#
#
#S(01*%2)'(#
*%GG0**0%?*# 0'#
G(4>&/5(5*##
10#C(@&4401###############################T#??%-)'(((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((0=%%-)'#
#
(
(
(
(
(M1-1%**)(9)((
#N&?B&-&#=O9#
#
#
!
!
Y#!\6%,N%62!'&(!S(.&)>%)&'(71*%2)'((6.)S2'(!:6.(27A,A(!*+,!'-2('+?!:6??&!C!2%'*(34%,#/(M!3!
(
FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFG(
`#!\6%,N%62!7)&-1%?'(>#'#*>1?'!<6.)!:6.(27A,&,!N%-C*%(-%)?-(#?(&@*)(.1&-%7#*%)&(91?'(*1('#77)''%"?(3!!
!
FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFG(
a#(8,.*%/#)(*)'(&1%'"?'(9)(*1(9%$%'%"?(9)(*J%'*1>!&.),&!T#??%-)'!&)!'&(!0=%%-)'(@!
!
FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFG(
b#!U#)*()'-(*J"56)7-%2(9)'(1&>;)'(9%&%+;)'(.1&(*)'(71*%2)'(3!
!
FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFG(
H"7#>)?-(SB!D+!G&?'0#10*#G(5J%P'0*+#0I>&5*)(5#10#-K)*-&4#1%#LDD.40#&%#LDDD.40#*).G-0!
!
!!!!!!R6.N%U)&(!7&!=6>+??&7!!! R6.N%U)&(!7&(!*,&?2&,(!:+'2O&(!!!!!!!!! R6.N%U)&(!7&(!c?&TT+7&(!
!!
H"7#>)?-(:(@!2&#G&>)'%-&')(5#10#Q3?%*&-04#R(
C!d62:2!'+!/+,+.)2&!N%&!'&!(&,<2)&%,!7&!52&%J!4>1&!F-0#G&-)M0#0'#=AA#H#=SSGJ!:6??+.7+.)!7&(!:,6T+.)(J!+::6,7&!+%Z!>+12)+.)(!7&!
V;&#'1*)>
B!L!)6%(J!N%-2'(!(62&.)!12&.!6%!?+'!72(*6(A(J!2'!/+,+.)2)!'+!(A:%,2)A!*6%,!&%ZS?U?&(J!'&%,(!*6((&((26.(J!'&%,(!A/'2(&(J!
'&%,(!:,62ZJ!&)!)6%)!:&!N%2!:6.:&,.&!'&%,!:%')&B!D&%,(!A/'2(&(!.&!(&,6.)!*+(!),+.(O6,?A&(!&.!>+12)+)26.(!.2!.&!(&,6.)!7A),%2)&(J!
&)!'-6.!.-&.'P<&,+!,2&.J!.2!+%Z!A/'2(&(J!.2!+%Z!*6((&((26.(!7&(!>+12)+.)(B!H'(!.&!(&,6.)!*62.)!:6.),+2.)(!&.!?+)2P,&!7&!,&'2/26.B!
^)!*&,(6..&!7-&.),&!&%Z!.-+%,+!'+!?62.7,&!<&Z+)26.!;!:,+2.7,&!F[G!\6%,!'&%,!/+,+.)2,!)6%)!:&!N%&!,&.O&,?&!:&!),+2)AJ!2'!*,&.7!
52&%! *6%,! )A?62.J! &)! '&%,! *,6?&)! '+! *,6)&:)26.! 7%! \,6*>P)&! &)! :&''&! 7&! :&(! (%::&((&%,(B! H'! .&! '&%,! (&,+! O+2)! +%:%.! ?+'J! ;!
:6.72)26.!N%-2'(!*+2&.)!'+!:+*2)+)26.B!M!!HJ1.&A'(C*PM1*19=#&%J!F)*'()?0#10*#G(5J%P'0*#4%*%-4&50*J!H_P?&!(2P:'&B
!
"e#!O?9%/#)('#&(*1(71&-)(3(
>))*@##'&+,.2./+**(B6,/#72(
*'+T3<f*+2?Ta+<:e"!!
!
!
-0#5(4#10*#40?*#0'#10*#
(G3&5*# J%)# 13-)4)'05'# -0#
4(510#)*-&4)J%0#
!
-0# 5(4# 10*# '?()*# 6)--0*#
*&)5'0*# 10# -K)*-&4"# T05# 60?'#
1&5*#-0*#1(G*#:#0'#AU#
!
20#5(4#10*#'?()*#6)--0*#
05#?(%/0#1&5*#-0#1(G#8"#
!
=6>+??&7!
g+)2?+J!O2''&!7%!*,6*>P)&!
C*%!FG(%*)5#0'#/051?0#
1%#>?(>@.'0G!YXYSYY"!
4-=>W?(
Y99SYXY!
4>1&(
Y89SY99!
C5"#(M1X&(
Y84SY89!
!
I)(71*%2)(<#J1Y%D1!O6.7&!'+!9D?1'-%)(4>)DD19)'((
B(H1>1'(ZZEP[K\(
2&#*%GG0**)(5#10*#G&-)M0*#106)05'#@3?31)'&)?0#
g2'(!7-L'2!"&,!H?+?!&)!g+)2?+!!
!C*(Q1''1?!4P?&!H?+?!
!Q#'')%?!8P?&!H?+?!
C(?'#1KF%**0)5#'%3#>&?#-K&?430#
V40WW&10#
##
]"#$)**)(HD?1'-%)(C551''%9)'((
B(M1+919(([K\PERK^(
20*#G&-)M0*#(40WW&10#10#56&,64'#?0M%*05'#G0>051&5'#
10#?0G(55&X'?0#-K&%'(?)'3#1%#G&-)M0#10#$&/1&1#
b!+%),&(!O>1>'
!F
*1(21>%**)(
9)(<"=1>>)9
G!(&!(%::P7&.)!
&)!72<2(&.)!'+!1,+.:>&!R>22)&!
!
!
!

!"#$%&'()*+#,(--./0#1%#234&5+#!05.60+#7%)**0+#89:;<8:9=#
8,)&7%7)(:(3!20#,(?&5#*(%?G0#1%#1?()'#
""#!$%2!(6.)!'&(!2%9A*)'()-(*)'(%?2%9A*)'!3!R&))&!7=1&-)(9"??)P-P)**)(*J;+1*%-;(3!Q%*')M)0#'&#?3>(5*0!
#
FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFG(
!
FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFG(
"4#!$%2!&()!:>+,/A!9J1&5%-&)&()-(9)(6#+)&(*)'(7"?2*%-'(3!
!
FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFG(
#
FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFG(
#
H"7(Z(3#2&#Y%*')G0#?051%0#>&?#-0#5),%+########H"7(["#Z5#,(?&5#1%#[DD.40+#[DDD.40#*).G-0"#20#,(?&5#0*'#1)6)*3#05#
\5-%4)5%?0#10#:8A]+#$^_+#`&?)*#############::S#*(%?&'0*+#G(4>(*30*#10#>-%*)0%?*#60?*0'*"#20#-)6?0#&#3'3#3G?)'#*%?#
# # # # #################13G)*)(5#1%#G&-)M0#V'@4a5#>(%?#?&**04B-0?#-0*#40**&/0*#10#C(@&4401#
### #####
"8#!R6??&.)!;$"*#)(*1(6#'-%7)(1.&A'(*1(>"&-(9#(.&".=A-)(3!$%&'(!'"?-(')'(2"?9)>)?-'(_!
!
FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFG(
!
FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFG(
!
M%*1?(@!U#%(),)&7)(*)(."#$"%&!7+.(!'-H('+?!;!*+,)2,!7&!*JQ;+%&)(3!F-K&5#:#10#-K)*-&4#-)3#&%#13>&?'#>(%?#C31)50G!
!
FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFG(
!
FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFG(
(
FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFG(
!
H"7#>)?-(K(3(
=A72.&!&()!%.&!&.:'+<&!(+:,A&!F[G!I2!&.),&!'&(!/&.(!7&!:&))&!&.:'+<&!(%,<2&.)!%.!?AO+2)!6%!%.!:6.O'2)!N%2!,2(N%&!7&!
7A)A,26,&,!'+!(2)%+)26.J!6.!(6%?&)),+!'-+OO+2,&!;!52&%!V,P(!E+%)!&)!;!=6>+??&7!'&!*,6*>P)&B!F[G!h.!O27P'&!.&!)%&!*+(!
%.!+%),&!O27P'&!*6%,!<&./&,!%.!2.O27P'&!&)!2'!.-+((2()&!*+(!%.!2.O27P'&!:6.),&!%.!O27P'&B!D&!*+:)&!7&!(A:%,2)A!7-L''+>!&()!
%.2N%&!F[G!!D&(!O27P'&(!(6.)!+''2A(!'&(!%.(!+%Z!+%),&(!F[GB!R&%Z!7&(!Q%2O(!N%2!.6%(!(%2<&.)!6.)!7,62)!;!'-+((2()+.:&!@!6.!
.&!'&(!'P(&!*+(!&)!6.!.&!(-+''2&!*+(!:6.),&!&%ZB!5+.(!:>+N%&!&Z*A72)26.J!6.!(&!,&'+2&!;!)6%,!7&!,K'&B!F[G!D&(!O27P'&(!N%2!
(&!*,A(&,<&.)!7&!)6%)&!+:)26.!7A(>6.6,+.)&!&.!,&(*&:)+.)!:&(!,P/'&(!(6.)!7+.(!'+!<62&!'+!?&2''&%,&!&)!'+!*'%(!7,62)&B!
^Z),+2)!7&!'+!,@&?'0#05'?0#C(@&4401#0'#-0*#@&B)'&5'*#10#C31)50+!7-+*,P(!O5?(Q%'7=1>J!H_P?&!!
!