Trauma et pensée : le recours à la philosophie

!"##$%&&'''()*+$(,-&./0$"123&1*+45($"$61+789:
Page 1 sur 3:
Trauma&et&pensée&:&
le&recours&à&la&philosophie&
&
;3..4*#:$4*<3*<=*3><:6:;?4<#:>*4:@>4<#13*:$3>-:2/:$"123<3$"14:3>:24<:<)14*)4<:
)30*1#1A4<(:B/:$<C)"/*/2C<4:<?1*#4--304:%:@>?4<#=)4:@>1:*3><:$3><<4:D:$4*<4-:6:
:
La&formation&de&la&pensée&
;?4<#:+/*<:24<:Formulations,sur,les,deux,principes,du,devenir,psychique:EFGFFH:@>4:I-4>+:
45$3<4:+?/J3-+:</:#"K3-14:+4:2/:$4*<K4(:B4:+KA423$$4.4*#:+4:2?/)#1A1#K:+4:$4*<K4:4<#:4*:
-/$$3-#:/A4):24:./*@>4L:24:+K<1-:%:)?4<#:2/:#4*<13*:1*#4-*4:@>1L:4*:0K*K-/*#:>*4:
1.$-4<<13*:+4:+K$2/1<1-L:4<#:D:2?3-101*4:+4:2/:$4*<K4(:
M/*<:24:-K01.4:+1#:+4<:N:$-3)4<<><:$<C)"1@>4<:$-1./1-4<:OL:24<:@>/21#K<:+4<:3JP4#<:4#:+4<:
<1#>/#13*<:<4:-K+>1<4*#:D:2?/0-K/J24:4#:/>:+K</0-K/J24(:B4:$<C)"1<.4:1./01*4L:"/22>)1*4L:
-QA4L:)4:@>1:4<#:)4*<K:/$$3-#4-:>*:K#/#:+4:J14*=Q#-4L:4*:-K+>1</*#:2/:#4*<13*:1*#4-*4(:
R/1<:)4##4:/)#1A1#K:*4:-4.$21#:<3*:3,,1)4:@>4:+4:,/S3*:21.1#K4(:;/-:24:+K,/>#:$4-<1<#/*#:+4:
2/:</#1<,/)#13*:/##4*+>4:/.T*4:2/:+K)4$#13*L:)4:@>1:.4#:,1*:D:2/:#4*#/#1A4:+4:</#1<,/)#13*:
"/22>)1*/#31-4L:4#:$3><<4:D:)"4-)"4-:+/*<:24:.3*+4:45#K-14>-:>*4:.3+1,1)/#13*:-K4224:%:
)?4<#:)4:@>4:I-4>+:/$$4224:N:2/:.3+1,1)/#13*:+>:$-1*)1$4:+4:$2/1<1-:4*:$-1*)1$4:+4:
-K/21#K:O(:U2:C:/:>*:/$$-4*#1<</04:+4<:)3*+>1#4<:D:/+3$#4-:$3>-:/##41*+-4:<4<:J>#<L:4#:
+?/J3-+:)42>1:+4:2?/P3>-*4.4*#(:M1,,K-4-:2/:-K/21</#13*:+4<:J>#<:A/:+4:$/1-:/A4):24:
+KA423$$4.4*#:+4:2/:$4*<K4:+1#4:N:<4)3*+/1-4:O:%:<4:-4$-K<4*#4-:24:J>#L:24<:.3C4*<L:24<:
$4-<3**4<:@>1:A3*#:/$$3-#4-:24>-:/1+4L:KA/2>4-:24<:3J<#/)24<:D:<>-.3*#4-(:V4:
+KA423$$4*#:/1*<1:2?/##4*#13*L:2/:.K.3-1</#13*L:24:P>04.4*#L:#3>#4<:/)#1A1#K<:@>1:
1*#K-4<<4*#:K.1*4..4*#:2/:$"123<3$"14(:
I-4>+:1*#-3+>1#:2/:*3#13*:+4:$>2<13*:4*:FGFW:EMétapsychologie,:,pulsions,et,destins,de,
pulsionsH(:B/:$4*<K4:4<#:/1*<1:>*:.3C4*:+4:214-:24<:.3>A4.4*#<:$>2<13**42<(:;/-:24<:
.3#13*<:$>2<13**4224<L:4*:<4:21/*#L:1*A4<#1<<4*#:24<:$"/<4<:1*#4-.K+1/1-4<:@>1:+4A14**4*#:
D:24>-:#3>-:+4<:J>#<:%:2/:-4)"4-)"4L:2/:)>-13<1#K:1*#4224)#>4224L:2?/)#13*:/$$3-#4*#:4*:4224<=
.Q.4<:+4<:</#1<,/)#13*<(:
Trauma&et&pensée&
XA4):24<:FormulationsL:3*:4<#:+/*<:24:)/+-4:+4:2/:$-4.1T-4:#3$1@>4L:@>1:*4:)3**/Y#:@>4:24:
$-1*)1$4:+4:$2/1<1-:E4#:</:.3+1,1)/#13*:4*:$-1*)1$4:+4:-K/21#KH(:R/1<:/$-T<:FG89L:I-4>+:
/A/*)4:>*4:+4>51T.4:#3$1@>4L:@>1:+3**4:>*4:$2/)4:1.$3-#/*#4:D:2/:$>2<13*:+4:.3-#L:D:2/:
,31<:+K21/1<3*:4#:+4<#->)#1A1#K(:
B/:#"K3-14:+4:2/:$4*<K4:+31#:Q#-4:-KA1<K4:D:$/-#1-:+4:)4##4:<4)3*+4:#3$1@>4(:Z>4:<4:$/<<4=
#=12:@>/*+:<>-A14*#:>*:#-/>./:$<C)"1@>4:@>1:.4#:"3-<:P4>:24:$-1*)1$4:+4:$2/1<1-:6:
B4:#-/>./:$<C)"1@>4:<4:)/-/)#K-1<4:$/-:>*:4,,-31:45#-Q.4:23-<:+?>*:+/*04-:1..1*4*#:@>1:

!"##$%&&'''()*+$(,-&./0$"123&1*+45($"$61+789:
Page 2 sur 3:
$4>#:Q#-4:+?3-101*4:45#4-*4:E+/*04-:+4:.3-#:1..1*4*#4H:3>:+?3-101*4:1*#4-*4:E+/*04-:
$>2<13**42H:4#:@>1:$-3A3@>4:>*4:+K<3-0/*1</#13*:$<C)"1@>4:E),(:Au;delà,du,principe,de,
plaisirL:FG8[L:3\:I-4>+:KA3@>4:24<:*KA-3<4<:+4:0>4--4:4#:24>-<:4,,4#<:$<C)"1@>4<H(:U2:
<?/))3.$/0*4:+?>*:K#/#:+4:<1+K-/#13*:%:$/-/2C<14:.3#-1)4L:./1<:/><<1:<1+K-/#13*:+4:
2?/)#1A1#K:+4:$4*<K4(:
B?>*:+4<:<C.$#].4<:$3<#=#-/>./#1@>4<:4<#:24:+KA423$$4.4*#:+?angoisseL:@>1:$4>#:
+3**4-:214>:D:+4<:)-1<4<:+4:$/*1@>4:3>:D:>*4:/*031<<4:+1,,><4:4#:)"-3*1@>4(:B/:$4-<3**4:
#-/>./#1<K4:<4:)3.$3-#4:)3..4:<1:>*4:)/#/<#-3$"4:+4A/1#:<>-A4*1-:D:#3>#:1*<#/*#(:
;3*#-4:)4:+/*04-L:24:$<C)"1<.4:.4#:4*:^>A-4:+4<:+K,4*<4<:$/#"32301@>4<:@>1:21.1#4*#:
2?/*031<<4:P><@>?D:>*:)4-#/1*:$31*#(:;4:@>4:2?3*:/$$4224:/>P3>-+?">1:24<:_`;:E#-3>J24<:
3J<4<<13**42<:)3.$>2<1,<H:a:@>4:24:MVR:Ub:)3*<1+T-4:D:#3-#:)3..4:>*4:4*#1#K:
*3<30-/$"1@>4:a:/$$/-/1<<4*#:#-T<:,-K@>4..4*#:23-<@>4:24:+KA423$$4.4*#:+4:
2?/*031<<4:*4:$4>#:$2><:Q#-4:P>0>2K(:
B/:-4<#/>-/#13*:+4:2?/)#1A1#K:+4:$4*<K4:*3*:$2><:*?4<#:$/<:)3.$2T#4:%:$/-:454.$24L:12:C:/:
+4<:1./04<:@>1:-4A14**4*#:+4:,/S3*:-K)>--4*#4L:)3..4:+4<:,2/<"4<L:+/*<:+4<:)/>)"4./-<:
3>:D:2?K#/#:)3*<)14*#L:./1<:)4<:1./04<:-4<#4*#:1<32K4<:+4:)4:@>1:$3>--/1#:Q#-4:>*:#-/A/12:+4:
2/:$4*<K4(:
B?KAK*4.4*#:-4<#4:actuel:%:)4:*?4<#:$/<:@>42@>4:)"3<4:@>1:4<#:/--1AKL:./1<:@>42@>4:)"3<4:
@>4:24:<>P4#:A1#:/>:.3.4*#:.Q.4:3\:12:4*:$/-24L:4#:@>?12:*4:)4<<4:+4:-4A1A-4(:RQ.4:<1:2/:
$4-<3**4:/:-K)>$K-K:<4<:)/$/)1#K<:D:A1A-4:4#:/01-:)3..4:$/-:24:$/<<KL:12:<>,,1#:@>?4224:
$-3*3*)4:>*:.3#:KA3@>/*#:2/:)/#/<#-3$"4:$3>-:<4:-4#-3>A4-:+/*<:24:.Q.4:K#/#:
+?/*031<<4:1../Y#-1</J24(:B?1<<>4:/>:#-/>./:<>$$3<4:>*:#-/A/12:+4:2/:$4*<K4:4#:>*4:
-4.1<4:+4:2?KAK*4.4*#:+/*<:2/:#4.$3-/21#KL:4*:$-K<4*)4:4#:/A4):>*4:#14-)4:$4-<3**4L:
+31#=3*:/P3>#4-(:B/:)/$/)1#K:+4:)4:#14-<:D:#3>#:4*#4*+-4:4#:/+.4##-4:4*:2>1:</*<:Q#-4:
+K#->1#:4<#:)4:@>1:$4-.4#:/>:<>P4#:#-/>./#1<K:+?4,,4)#>4-:)4:#-/A/12:+4:-4.1<4:4*:21/1<3*(:
Situations&extrêmes&et&clivage&du&moi&
U2:$4>#:/--1A4-:@>?>*4:45$K-14*)4:AK)>4:+1<$/-/1<<4:+4:2/:)3*<)14*)4:4#:-4<#4:
1*/))4<<1J24(:M/*<:2?>*:+4:<4<:+4-*14-<:3>A-/04<:EConstructions,dans,l’analyseL:FG[cHL:
I-4>+:*3..4:)4:$"K*3.T*4:N:24:)21A/04:+>:.31:OL:/>:#-/A4-<:+>@>42:24:.31:<?/J<4*#4:
+?>*4:<1#>/#13*:+4:<3>,,-/*)4:45#-Q.4(:R/1<L:/J<4*#4:+4:2/:)3*<)14*)4L:2?45$K-14*)4:AK)>4:
*4:+1<$/-/Y#:$/<:4#:<4:-KAT24:$/-:+4<:<C.$#].4<:E"/22>)1*/#13*<L:+K21-4<H(:M/*<:<3*:
+4-*14-:K)-1#L:L’homme,Moïse,et,la,religion,monothéisteL:I-4>+:.4#:)4:)21A/04:4*:-/$$3-#:
/A4):24:*/-)1<<1<.4(:
M?/>#-4<:$<C)"/*/2C<#4<:45$23-4*#:)4##4:A314:$2><:/A/*#(:I4-4*)d1:+K)-1#:24:)21A/04:
*/-)1<<1@>4:+>:.31:)3..4:>*4:/>#3#3.14:EPsychanalyse,4L:e/C3#L:FGf8L:*3#4<:4#:
,-/0.4*#<:$3<#">.4<:+4:FG[F=FG[[:<>-:24:#-/>./#1<.4H(:B/:<1#>/#13*:45#-Q.4:<4:
)/-/)#K-1<4:$/-:24:,/1#:@>?4224:.4#:24:.31:4*:+/*04-:+4:.3-#:$<C)"1@>4L:$/-:24<:
">.121/#13*<:@>?12:<>J1#:3>:$/-:24:,/1#:+?Q#-4:$2/)K:+/*<:>*4:<1#>/#13*:+4:N:double,bind:O:
E1*P3*)#13*:)3*#-/+1)#31-4:+/*<:2/@>4224:3*:.4#:4*:+4.4>-4:24:<>P4#:+4:,/1-4:@>42@>4:
)"3<4:#3>#:4*:2>1:<10*1,1/*#:@>?12:4*:4<#:1*)/$/J24H(:
B4:<>P4#:$4-+:/23-<:#3>#4:4<#1.4:+4:<31:4#:)"4-)"4:D:<4:+K#->1-4:2>1=.Q.4(:;4:@>1:4<#:/>:
$-4.14-:$2/*L:)?4<#:2/:+3>24>-(:
g12,-4+:h>$-4)"#:i13*:ERéflexion,faiteL:ejIL:e/-1<L:899FH:.3*#-4:2?1.$3-#/*)4:+>:)21A/04:
4#:+4:2/:+1<<3)1/#13*:)3..4:/##/@>4:)3*#-4:24<:214*<L:4*:$/-#1)>214-:24<:214*<:K#/J21<:$/-:
2?/)#1A1#K:+4:$4*<K4(:;?4<#:@>4:#3>#4:/)#1A1#K:+4:$4*<K4:,-/0121<4:24:)21A/04:4#:-/.T*4:
2?45$K-14*)4:+4:+3>24>-(:;4-#/1*<:<3*#:#-3$:,-/0124<:$3>-:24:<>$$3-#4-(:

!"##$%&&'''()*+$(,-&./0$"123&1*+45($"$61+789:
Page 3 sur 3:
Le&recours&à&la&philosophie&
B?>*4:+4<:1<<>4<:$3<<1J24<:D:>*:AK)>:45#-Q.4:4<#:2/:$"123<3$"14L:+1#:I4-4*)d1(:M/*<:24<:
N:hK,24513*<:<>-:24:#-/>./#1<.4:O:EPsychanalyse,4HL:12:K)-1#:%:N:Z>/*+:3*:-K><<1#:
$"123<3$"1@>4.4*#:D:1*<K-4-:2/:<1#>/#13*:+4:+K$2/1<1-:451<#/*#:+/*<:2/:-K/21#K:+/*<:>*4:
>*1#K:$2><:0-/*+4:3>:$4-S>4:)3..4:@>42@>4:)"3<4:+?1*KA1#/J24L:A31-4:+4:*K)4<</1-4:D:2/:
$4*<K4L:./1<:<>-#3>#:@>/*+:3*:-K><<1#:D:#-/*<,K-4-:2/:21J1+3:<>-:)4##4:$2><:0-/*+4:>*1#K:
klmL:24:<4*#1.4*#:+4:+K$2/1<1-:$4>#:<?KA/*3>1-L:J14*:@>4:<4<:)/><4<:<>J<1<#4*#(:O:
n1*4##4:h/1.J/>2#:EL’Enfant,et,la,MortL:e-1A/#L:FGGoH:/:)3*<#/#K:/><<1:2/:</04<<4:+3*#:
#K.310*4*#:24<:4*,/*#<:/##41*#<:+4:./2/+14<:2K#/24<(:
N:B?>-04*)4:+4:$4*<4-:O:ER1)"T24:i4-#-/*+L:La,Pensée,et,le,TraumaL:B?p/-./##/*L:FGG9H:
4<#:>*4:,3-.4:+4:<>-A14:$<C)"1@>4(:B/:<3>,,-/*)4:*4:+1<$/-/Y#:$/<L:./1<:4224:4<#:-4$2/)K4:
+/*<:>*:4*<4.J24(:R1<:4*:-42/#13*:/A4):+?/>#-4<:45$K-14*)4<L:+3*#:)4-#/1*4<:$4>A4*#:
Q#-4:$2/1</*#4<L:2?1.$/)#:+>:#-/>./:<?/.4*>1<4(:B4:$2/1<1-:+4:$4*<4-L:+4:)3.$-4*+-4L:
/$$3-#4:>*4:</#1<,/)#13*:*/-)1<<1@>4:@>1:,/1#:)3*#-4$31+<:D:2/:+3>24>-:4#:2/:-4*+:
<>$$3-#/J24(:;?4<#:)4:@>?3*:/$$4224:2/:)3=45)1#/#13*:21J1+1*/24L:@>1:$4-.4#:2/:)3*<#1#>#13*:
+?>*:./<3)"1<.4:3\:24<:$>2<13*<:+4:A14:,3*#:)3*#-4$31+<:D:2/:+4<#->)#1A1#K(:
B/:$"123<3$"14:$4>#:Q#-4:/1*<1:)3.$-1<4:)3..4:>*:/$-T<=)3>$:4#:>*4:K2/J3-/#13*:
+?45$K-14*)4<:$2><:3>:.31*<:+3>23>-4><4<(:q*:.Q.4:#4.$<L:)4##4:/)#1A1#K:+4:
<>J21./#13*:<?/AT-4:$3-#4><4:+?>*4:*3>A4224:+C*/.1@>4:$>2<13**4224:4#:+4:*3>A4224<:
</#1<,/)#13*<(:
:
X1*<1L:24:#-/A/12:+4:2/:$4*<K4:4<#:*K)4<</1-4:/>:$-3)4<<><:#"K-/$4>#1@>4L:.Q.4:<?12:*4:
<>,,1#:$/<(:U2:/))3.$/0*4:2/:-4.1<4:4*:#4.$3-/21#K:+4:N:2?/)#>42:O:@>1:<4:#-/+>1#:4*:
<C.$#].4<(:U2:/$$3-#4:2/:</#1<,/)#13*:*/-)1<<1@>4:@>1:$4-.4#:+?1*A4<#1-:)4:$-3)4<<><:4*:
+K$1#:+4<:.3.4*#<:+K$2/1</*#<:3>:+3>23>-4>5L:4#:-4#-3>A4:24:)"4.1*:+4:2?r-3<L:@>1:4<#:
)42>1:+4:2/:A14(:
R1)"T24:i4-#-/*+:
R1)"T24:i4-#-/*+:4<#:$-3,4<<4>-:K.K-1#4:+4<:>*1A4-<1#K<L:)"4-)"4>-:/>:BXVU:a:>*1A4-<1#K:
e/-1<=`>4<#L:.4.J-4:#1#>2/1-4:+4:2/:V3)1K#K:$<C)"/*/2C#1@>4:+4:e/-1<(:
©,SCÉRÉN,;,CNDP(:;-KK:4*:./1:89F9:=:_3><:+-31#<:-K<4-AK<(:B1.1#/#13*:D:2s></04:*3*:
)3..4-)1/2L:$-1AK:3>:<)32/1-4(:
: