Chose en soi - Psychaanalyse

!"##$%&&'()*+,+$-.+/)0(1&*+,+&2"03-4-5430+6
Page 1 sur 76
Chose&en&soi!
7/6chose!en!soi68Ding%an%sich96-3#6:56;05;-$#6,/5#+-563+15+'+/5#6</6(=/<+#=6#-<<-6>:?-<<-6
$0:((/+#6@#(-6$-53=-6+5.=$-5./AA-5#6.-6#0:#-6-B$=(+-5;-6$033+C<-)6D+-56>:-6$(0;"-6.:6
50:AE5-F6-<<-65?-3#6$/36G6;05'05.(-6/H-;6;-<:+I;+)6
J56-''-#F6<-650:AE5-F6-56#/5#6>:?0CK-#6"L$0#"=#+>:-6.?:5-6+5#:+#+05650563-53+C<-F6>:/5.6
+<6-3#6$(+36/:63-536.-6;"03-6-5630+F65-6<?-3#6>:?-56#/5#6>:?+<6-3#6/:33+6-5H+3/1=6/:#(-A-5#6
>:-6;0AA-6$"=50AE5-)67-650:AE5-6-3#6<?/:#(-6.:6$"=50AE5-6-#6;?-3#F6$0:(6M/5#F6:56
N;05;-$#65=1/#+'N6>:+6$-(A-#6.-6.055-(6:5-6K:3#+'+;/#+056G6</6<+A+#/#+056.-6</6
;055/+33/5;-63-53+C<-)6M/5#6$(=;+3-6>:-F6<-6$"=50AE5-65?=#/5#6(+-56$/(6<:+IA@A-65+6-56
.-"0(36.-650#(-6A0.-6.-6(-$(=3-5#/#+05F6+<6+A$<+>:-6+5=H+#/C<-A-5#6:5-6(-</#+056G6:56
0CK-#F6+5.=$-5./5#6.-6</63-53+C+<+#=F6.?0O6
)))<-6;05;-$#6.?:5650:AE5-F6;05;-$#6>:+65?-3#6.05;6$/36.:6#0:#6N$03+#+'N6-#65-6
3+15+'+-6$/36:5-6;055/+33/5;-6.=#-(A+5=-6.?:5-6;"03-6>:-<;05>:-F6A/+36
3-:<-A-5#6</6$-53=-6.-6>:-<>:-6;"03-6-561=5=(/<60O6<-63:K-#6#(/53;-5./5#/<6'/+#6
/C3#(/;#+056.-6#0:#-6'0(A-6.-6<?+5#:+#+0563-53+C<-)6P0:(6>:?:5650:AE5-63+15+'+-6
:56H=(+#/C<-60CK-#F6.+3#+5;#6.-6#0:36<-36/:#(-36$"=50AE5-3F6;-65?-3#6$/36/33-Q6>:-6
<-63:K-#6.-6</6;055/+33/5;-6/''(/5;"+33-63/6$-53=-6.-6#0:#-36<-36'0(A-36.-6
<?+5#:+#+0563-53+C<-F6+<6<:+6'/:#6-5;0(-6/H0+(6:5-6(/+3056.?/.A-##(-6:56/:#(-6A0.-6
.?+5#:+#+056>:-6<-6A0.-63-53+C<-F6./536<->:-<6$:+33-6@#(-6.055=6:560CK-#6.-6;-6
1-5(-F6;/(6/:#(-A-5#63/6$-53=-63-(/+#6H+.-F6>:0+>:-6-B-A$#-6.-6;05#(/.+;#+05)6
82(+#+>:-6.-6</6R/+3056$:(-F6;"/$+#(-6Du%principe%de%la%distinction%de%tous%les%objets%
en%général%en%phénomènes%et%noumènes96
7/6;"03-6-5630+F6$/(6-<<-IA@A-F6;05#+-5#6.05;6<-650:AE5-6/:63-536$03+#+'F6;S-3#IGI.+(-6-56
#/5#6>:?0CK-#6.?:5-6+5#:+#+056$033+C<-6T6+5#:+#+05650563-53+C<-6A/+36+5#-<<-;#:-<<-6-#6
+5#:+#+056.05#6<?-5#-5.-A-5#6":A/+56-3#6+5;/$/C<-6T6-3#6</6;05.+#+056.-6#0:#-6
(-$(=3-5#/#+056-56#/5#6>:-6$"=50AE5-)67/6;"03-6-5630+6-3#6</6;"03-6#-<<-6>:?-<<-63-6
$(=3-5#-6"0(36.-36.=#-(A+5/#+0536.?-3$/;-6-#6.-6#-A$36-#6.-36;/#=10(+-36.-6
<?-5#-5.-A-5#)6U6</6.+''=(-5;-6.:650:AE5-F6-<<-6-5#(-#+-5#6$0:(#/5#6:5-6(-</#+056/H-;6<-6
$"=50AE5-6-56#/5#6>:?-<<-6-56-3#6<-6'05.-A-5#68-#65056</6;/:3-F6;/(6<-6;05;-$#6.-6
;/:3/<+#=65-6H/:#6>:-6$0:(6<-36$"=50AE5-39)6
La!chose!en!soi!chez!Kant!
V-<056JAA/5:-<6M/5#F6</6W6;"03-6-5630+6X6-3#6:56W6;05;-$#6$(0C<=A/#+>:-6XF6;?-3#IGI.+(-6
>:-6</6;"03-6-5630+6-3#6:56;05;-$#6$-53/C<-6Y6;-6;05;-$#6-3#6A@A-6+5.+3$-53/C<-6$0:(6
/33+15-(6:5-6H/<-:(6G650#(-6;055/+33/5;-6-#6$0:(6.=#-(A+5-(6<?0CK-#6.-6</6;055/+33/5;-6
3-53+C<-F6A/+36$/(6<?:3/1-6.-6;-6;05;-$#F6(+-56.-63056-33-5;-65?-3#6H(/+A-5#6;055:)67/6
;"03-6-5630+6-3#6:5-6<+A+#/#+056.-6</6;055/+33/5;-6-#6;?-3#6/+53+6>:?-<<-6/1+#63:(65036
(-$(=3-5#/#+053F6.-6A/5+E(-65=1/#+H-)67/6;"03-6-5630+6-3#6;-6>:-6<?+5#:+#+0563-53+C<-65-6
$-:#6/##-+5.(-)6Z0:#60CK-#65-6$-:#6@#(-6.=#-(A+5=6$0:(6:56@#(-6'+5+6>:-6$/(6<?0$=(/#+056
;05K0+5#-6.-6<?-5#-5.-A-5#6-#6.-6<?+5#:+#+0563-53+C<-Y6</6;"03-6-5630+63-6$(=3-5#-6.05;6
;0AA-6;-6>:+6-3#6+5;055/+33/C<-F6<?/:I.-<G6.-6#0:#-6;055/+33/5;-63-53+C<-6%6

!"##$%&&'()*+,+$-.+/)0(1&*+,+&2"03-4-5430+6
Page 2 sur 76
W6[:/5.6A@A-650:36$0:((+0536$0(#-(650#(-6+5#:+#+056G63056$<:36"/:#6.-1(=6.-6;</(#=F6
50:365?-56'-(+0536$0+5#6:56$/36.-6$<:36H-(36</6;055/+33/5;-6.-6</65/#:([email protected]
0CK-#3)62/(6-56#0:36;/3650:365-6;055/\#(+0536$/('/+#-A-5#6>:-650#(-6A0.-6.?+5#:+#+05F6
;?-3#IGI.+(-650#(-63-53+C+<+#=F6#0:K0:(3630:A+3-6/:B6;05.+#+0536.?-3$/;-6-#6.-6#-A$36
0(+1+5/+(-A-5#6+5"=(-5#-36/:63:K-#6Y6>:/5#6G63/H0+(6;-6>:-6305#6<-360CK-#36-5630+F6;?-3#6;-6
>:+650:36-3#6+A$033+C<-6A@A-6/H-;6</6;055/+33/5;-6</6$<:36;</+(-6.-6<-:(36$"=50AE5-3F6
3-:<-6;"03-6>:+650:3630+#6.055=-)6X6
T6JAA/5:-<6M/5#F6Critique%de%la%raison%pure,%«%Esthétique%
transcendantale%»6
20AA-6#0:#60CK-#6.-6;055/+33/5;-63-63+#:-6-56.-]G6.-36<+A+#-36.-6<?+5#:+#+0563-53+C<-F6;-6
>:-6<?-5#-5.-A-5#6</+33-6-5#(-H0+(6.-6</6;"03-6-5630+6;?-3#6</6(-</#+056>:?-<<-6-5#(-#+-5#6
-#6>:?+<650:36'/:#6=#/C<+(6/:6A0L-56.-6</6(/+305F6/H-;6<-6A05.-63-53+C<-)67-63-:<6A0L-56
$0:(650:36.?/##-+5.(-6G6:5-6$<:361(/5.-6.=#-(A+5/#+056.-6;-##-6(-</#+05F6$:+3>:-6/<0(36
50:36/H/5]0536;0AA-6.-36/H-:1<-36./536:56#-((+#0+(-6>:-650:365-6;055/+330536$/3F6-3#6
.?:#+<+3-(6<-6(/+3055-A-5#6$/(6/5/<01+-F6-56/L/5#6#0:K0:(36G6<?-3$(+#6>:-6<?/5/<01+-65-6
$(0:H-6(+-56>:/5#6G6;-6>:?-3#6$03+#+H-A-5#6</6;"03-6-5630+F6A/+36-<<-63-(#63-:<-A-5#6.-6
A0.E<-)6J56-''-#F6<-36(-</#+0536.=#-(A+5=-36.-6;/:3/<+#=6>:-650:36=#/C<+330536./536<-6
A05.-6.-36$"=50AE5-365-6305#6$/36/$$<+;/C<-36G6</6;"03-6-5630+)62?-3#6$/(6</6(/+3056
$(/#+>:-6>:-6M/5#6#(0:H-6<-6;"-A+56<-6$<:36;/$/C<-6.?/A-5-(6G6:5-6;055/+33/5;-6
$03+#+H-6.-6</6;"03-6-5630+)6J56-''-#F6</6<+C-(#=6/:63-536#(/53;-5./5#/<F6;?-3#IGI.+(-F6/:6
3-5365=1/#+'F6;?-3#IGI.+(-6-5;0(-6;0AA-630:3#(/;#+056'/+#-6.-6#0:#-36<-36;05.+#+0536.-6</6
;055/+33/5;-6$"=50A=5/<-F6$-(A-#63-:<-6.?-5#(-H0+(6</6A/5+'-3#/#+056.-6</6;"03-6-5630+F6
</6<+C-(#=6$03+#+H-)6
P0:(6M/5#6</6;"03-6-5630+6/6:563#/#:#6./H/5#/1-6=$+3#=A0<01+>:-6>:?05#0<01+>:-6%6;?-3#6
./H/5#/1-6:5-6<+A+#-6G650#(-6;055/+33/5;-6>:?:5-6-33-5;-60:6:56^C30<:)6
La!chose!en!soi!chez!Schopenhauer!
^(#":(6V;"0$-5"/:-(F6>:+63-6(=;</A-6.-6M/5#68/:6A0+536$0:(6;-6>:+6-3#6.-6<?W6J3#"=#+>:-6
#(/53;-5./5#/<-6XF63-:<-6$/(#+-6.-6</6Critique%de%la%raison%pure6>:?+<6/$$(0:H-6
;0A$<E#-A-5#9F6/33+A+<-6</6;"03-6-5630+6G6</6_0<05#=F650#(-6H0<05#=6=#/5#6W6<-6$<:36
+AA=.+/#6.-63-36$"=50AE5-3F6>:+63-6.+''=(-5;+-6(/.+;/<-A-5#6.-6#0:36<-36/:#(-36
$(=;+3=A-5#6$/(6;-6;/(/;#E(-6+AA=.+/#6X)62"/>:-6;"03-6-56;-6A05.-6-3#6:5-6-B$(-33+056
.-6</6_0<05#=63-<056<-6$(+5;+$-6.-6(/+305)67/6_0<05#=F6-33-5;-6.-36;"03-3F6-3#6
W60(+1+5-<<-A-5#6-#6-5630+6+5;053;+-5#-6XF6A/+36-<<-6$/(H+-5#6G63-6W6;055/\#(-6X6$/(6</6
(-$(=3-5#/#+056./536<-6A05.-6$"=50A=5/<)6
P0:(6V;"0$-5"/:-(F6W6<-6$<:361(/5.6A=(+#-6.-6M/5#6-3#6.?/H0+(6.+3#+51:=6<-6$"=50AE5-6
.-6</6;"03-6-5630+6XF6-56/<</5#6C+-56$<:36<0+56>:-6`0"5670;,-F6>:+6.+3#+51:/+#6<-36qualités%
secondaires6.-36$"=50AE5-368;0:<-:(F60.-:(F6-#;96>:+6305#6.-36/''-;#+0536.-363-53F6-#6<-36
qualités%primaires68'0(A-F6=#-5.:-F630<+.+#=)))9)6V;"0$-5"/:-(6'/+#6(-A05#-(63/6;05;-$#+056
.-6</6;"03-6-5630+6G6a=A0;(+#-bF6>:+6/''+(A/+#6%6W650:365-6(-;055/+330536$/36<-36;"03-36
.?/$(E36;-6>:?-<<-36$-:H-5#6@#(-6-5630+F6A/+363-:<-A-5#6#-<<-36>:?-<<-36/$$/(/+33-5#6X6
8;+#=6$/(6V-B#:36JA$+(+;:39)6

!"##$%&&'()*+,+$-.+/)0(1&*+,+&2"03-4-5430+6
Page 3 sur 76
7/6;"03-6-5630+65-6$-:#6K/A/+36@#(-6;0A$<E#-A-5#6-B#(/+#-6.-650#(-6+5#:+#+056-A$+(+>:-F6
>:+6-<<-F6.-A-:(-6#0:K0:(36:5-6(-$(=3-5#/#+056/''-;#=-6.-6</6.:/<+#=63:K-#I0CK-#6%67/6
_0<05#=6;0AA-6;"03-6-5630+6.+''E(-6.05;6A/<1(=6#0:#6;0A$<E#-A-5#6.-63056$"=50AE5-6
0:6.-6</6(-$(=3-5#/#+056</6$<:36+AA=.+/#-6>:?-3#6$0:(6;"/;:563/6H0<05#=)6P0:(6/:#/5#F6
50:365-630AA-36$/36>:-6(-$(=3-5#/#+05F6;0AA-6@#(-6-B+3#/5#F650:36'/+30536=1/<-A-5#6
W6$/(#+-6X6.-6</6;"03-6-5630+)6^+53+650#(-6;0($36-3#6W6.?:5-6$/(#6;0AA-6(-$(=3-5#/#+056
./536</6;055/+33/5;-6$"=50A=5/<-F6;0AA-60CK-#6$/(A+6.?/:#(-360CK-#36-#6;0AA-6
30:A+36G6<-:(6<0+6Y6-#6.?/:#(-6$/(#F6-56A@A-6#-A$3F6;0AA-6;-6$(+5;+$-6+AA=.+/#-A-5#6
;055:6.-6;"/;:5F6>:-6.=3+15-6<-6A0#6_0<05#=6X68Le%Monde%comme%volonté%et%comme%
représentationF6<+H(-6cc9)67/6;"03-6-5630+6-3#6;055:-6$/(6W6<-6#=A0+15/1-6.-6</6;053;+-5;-6
>:+650:36'/+#6H0+(6./536</6H0<05#=6<?@#(-6-5630+6.-650#(-6$"=50AE5-6$/(#+;:<+-(6X68Critique%
de%la%philosophie%kantienne9)6
7/6;"03-6-5630+65-6.0+#6$/36@#(-6/33+A+<=-6G6:56^C30<:)6V;"0$-5"/:-(6(=$05.6/+53+6G63056
.+3;+$<-6`:<+:36d(/:-53#e.#68>:+630:#-5/+#6>:-6</6;"03-6-5630+6=#/+#6l'être%originel,%incréé%et%
impérissable96%6
f/6$"+<030$"+-6-53-+15-6;-6>:?-3#6<-6$"=50AE5-6-#6;-6>:?-3#6</6;"03-6-5630+)6f/+36
;-##-6;"03-6-5630+65?-3#6#-<<-6>:-6relativementF6;?-3#IGI.+(-6./5363056(/$$0(#6/:6
$"=50AE5-6Y6-#6<-6$"=50AE5-65?-3#6#-<6>:-6./5363056(/$$0(#6G6</6;"03-6-5630+)6P/(6
/+<<-:(36-<<-6;053+.E(-6<-6A05.-6;0AA-6:56$"=50AE5-6;=(=C(/<)6f/+36;-6>:?-3#6</6
;"03-6-5630+6en%dehors6.-6;-##-6(-</#+05F6K-65-6<?/+6K/A/+36.+#F6$/(;-6>:-6K-65-6<-63/+36
$/36Y6dans6;-##-6(-</#+056-56(-H/5;"-F6-<<-6-3#6H0<05#=6.-6H+H(-)6`?/+6A05#(=6
-A$+(+>:-A-5#6>:-6;-##-6H0<05#=6$0:H/+#63-63:$$(+A-(6-<<-IA@A-6-#6K?-56/+6
3-:<-A-5#6;05;<:6>:-F6/H-;6</6;"03-6-5630+F6<-6$"=50AE5-6.-H/+#6=1/<-A-5#6
.+3$/(/\#(-)68lettre%à%Frauenstädt%du%21%août%185296
La!critique!de!Jacobi!
d(+-.(+;"6g-+5(+;"6`/;0C+F6./5363056Appendice%sur%l'idéalisme%transcendantalF6;(+#+>:-6</6
;"03-6-5630+6;0AA-6:5-650#+056;05#(/.+;#0+(-6./536</6$"+<030$"+-6.-6M/5#F6-#6+<6
(-50:H-<<-63/6;(+#+>:-6./5363056David%Hume68bhbi96%6
W6j7/6.0;#(+5-6,/5#+-55-k6/6+5;05#-3#/C<-A-5#63056$0+5#6.-6.=$/(#6./536</6;(0L/5;-6
5/#:(-<<-6-56:56A05.-6A/#=(+-<6-B+3#/5#6+5.=$-5./AA-5#6.-65036(-$(=3-5#/#+053F6-#6;-6
5?-3#6>:?/$(E36;0:$6>:?-<<-6<?=<+A+5-6$/(6</6#"=0(+-6.-6<?+.=/<+#=6/C30<:-6.-6#0:#6;-6>:+6-3#6
3$/#+/<60:6#-A$0(-<F6.-630(#-6>:-F63-<056</6'0(A:<-6>:-6K?/+6-A$<0L=-F63+6<?0565-6$/(#6$/36
.-6</6;(0L/5;-65/#:(-<<-6;0AA-6$(+5;+$-6'+B-6-#6'-(A-F60565-6$-:#6-5#(-(6./536<-6
3L3#EA-F6A/+363+6<?0563?L6#+-5#F6+<6-3#6+A$033+C<-6.?L6.-A-:(-(6-#6.-63?L6=#/C<+()6X6
T6d(+-.(+;"6g-+5(+;"6`/;0C+F6David%Hume.6
J56-''-#F63-<056`/;0C+F6M/5#63:$$03-6>:-6</6;"03-6-5630+6-3#6;/:3-6.-65036(-$(=3-5#/#+0536
8>:+6305#6+5-B$<+;/C<-363/536-<<-9F6;-$-5./5#6<-36;/#=10(+-36,/5#+-55-36-#6<-6;05;-$#6.-6
;/:3/<+#=65-6$-:H-5#63?/$$<+>:-(6G6</6;"03-6-5630+F6>:+6-3#6+5;055/+33/C<-)67-6,/5#+3A-6
.-H(/+#6<01+>:-A-5#6/C0:#+(6G6:56(=/<+3A-6.01A/#+>:-68+.-5#+#=6.-6<?0CK-#6-#6.-6</6;"03-6
-5630+960:F6$/(6(=.:;#+056.-6</6;"03-6-5630+6G6</6(-$(=3-5#/#+05F6G6:56+.=/<+3A-6/C30<:68;-6
>:+63-(/6</6$03+#+056.-6;-(#/+536,/5#+-536;0AA-6V/<0A056f/+A056./5363056Essai%de%
philosophie%transcendantale6-56blmn9)6a-6</6A@A-6'/]05F6o0##<0C6V;":<Q-F6./5363056

!"##$%&&'()*+,+$-.+/)0(1&*+,+&2"03-4-5430+6
Page 4 sur 76
AenesidemusF6(-A/(>:-6>:-6<?"L$0#"E3-6.-6</6;"03-6-5630+65-6$-:#63-6K:3#+'+-(6$/(6</6<0+6
.-6;/:3/<+#=F6;0AA-6<-6'/+#6M/5#6.-6A/5+E(-6$<:360:6A0+536.=#0:(5=-)6
M/5#63?-3#6#0:K0:(36.='-5.:6.-6<?/;;:3/#+056.?+.=/<+3A-6/C30<:6850#/AA-5#6./5363/6
Réfutation%de%l'idéalisme9F6#0:#6-56(-;055/+33/5#6>:-6<-6<+-56-5#(-6</6;"03-6-5630+6-#6<-6
$"=50AE5-F6-5#(-6<?-B$=(+-5;-6-B#-(5-6-#6<?-B$=(+-5;-6+5#-(5-F6=#/+#6+5-B$<+;/C<-)6
7-36;(+#+>:-36.-6`/;0C+6-#6.-6V;":<Q-6=#/+-5#6;055:-36.-6V;"0$-5"/:-(68>:+6-:#6V;":<Q-6
;0AA-6$(0'-33-:(6.-6$"+<030$"+-9)6V;"0$-5"/:-(6;05#0:(5-6;-##-60CK-;#+056-56
-B$<+>:/5#6>:-6</6;"03-6-5630+6-56#/5#6>:-6_0<05#=6s’exprime6./536<-36$"=50AE5-363/536
<-36;/:3-(F6#0:#6;0AA-6;"-Q6V$+50Q/6<-36/##(+C:#36W6-B$(+A-5#6X6</63:C3#/5;-p)6
La!critique!de!Jaspers!
M/(<6`/3$-(3F6./5363056=#:.-6/$$(0'05.+-6.-6</6$-53=-6,/5#+-55-qF6-B$<0(-6<-36
W6;05#(/.+;#+0536A/5+'-3#-36X6.-6</6$-53=-6,/5#+-55-)6U6</6;(+#+>:-6.-6`/;0C+F6+<6/K0:#-6:56
/:#(-6#L$-6.-6;05#(/.+;#+056%6M/5#6$-53-6<-6(/$$0(#6.-6<?-5I30+6G6<?/$$/(-5;-6G6<?/+.-6.-36
;/#=10(+-3F6+<6-33/+-6.-63/+3+(6;05;-$#:-<<-A-5#6;-6>:?+<6-3#6+A$033+C<-6.-63/+3+(6
;05;-$#:-<<-A-5#)67-6#-(A-6.-6W6;"03-6-5630+6X6-3#6.=KG6;05#(/.+;#0+(-6%6
W620AA-6W6;"03-6X60565-6$-:#6$-53-(6>:?:5-6/$$/(-5;-6Y6W6-5630+6X6+5.+>:-6>:?+<65-63?/1+#6
$/36.?:5-6/$$/(-5;-)68)))9j2-##-6$-53=-k63:11E(-6.-:B6A05.-3F6<?:56/:6$(-A+-(6$</5F6
<?/:#(-6;/;"=6.-((+E(-6I6:56.=.0:C<-A-5#6.:6A05.-)6c<6$-:#63-AC<-(6/<0(36>:?+<36-B+3#-5#6
#0:36.-:BF6<?:563-6(/$$0(#/5#6G6<?/:#(-)6aE36<0(36<-6.-:B+EA-6A05.-F6;-<:+6>:+6-3#6
.-((+E(-F6.-H+-5#6:56(0L/:A-6.-6'/5#/3A-36.05#6#0:36<-36;05#-5:36$(0H+-55-5#6.-6;-6
A05.-I;+F6>:+6-3#6<-65r#(-)6f/+36+<65?L6/6$0:(6M/5#6>:?:563-:<6A05.-)62-6>:-F61(s;-6/:6
A0:H-A-5#6#(/53;-5./5#F6</6$-53=-6(=:33+#6G6#0:;"-(F65?-3#6$/36:56/:#(-6A05.-F65?-3#6
$/36A05.-6.:6#0:#)6J#F6$0:(6/:#/5#6>:-6;-</6-B+3#-F6;-</6/:(/6-56;-6A05.-6:5-6$(=3-5;-6
.-6505IA05.-)6t5-6#"=0(+-6.?:56.0:C<-6A05.-65?-3#6$/36,/5#+-55-6Y6;?-3#63-:<-A-5#6:5-6
A/5+E(-6.-6.+(-F6+5=H+#/C<-A-5#6;05#(/.+;#0+(-)6X6
T6M/(<6`/3$-(3F6Les%Grands%Philosophes,%ceux%qui%fondent%la%philosophie%et%
ne%cessent%de%l'engendrer%:%Kant.6
V-<056`/3$-(3F6;-</65-6(-#+(-6(+-56G6<?+5#=(@#6$"+<030$"+>:-6.-6</6.=A/(;"-6
#(/53;-5./5#/<-6.-6M/5#6%6
W67/6;05#(/.+;#+05F6<-6;-(;<-F6</6#/:#0<01+-6305#6G65036L-:B6.-36'0(A-36+5=H+#/C<-36-#6
-33-5#+-<<-36.-6#0:#-6(='<-B+056#(/53;-5./5#-)68)))96./536</6>:@#-6$"+<030$"+>:-F6;-(;<-3F6
#/:#0<01+-3F6;05#(/.+;#+053F65-6$-:H-5#6@#(-6=H+#=3)6c<36305#6<-63+15-6.+3#+5;#+'6.-6</6
;055/+33/5;-6$"+<030$"+>:-F6;0A$/(=-6G6</6;055/+33/5;-63;+-5#+'+>:-)68)))96</6$(+3056.-6
<?0CK-;#+H+#=6-#6.-6</6$"=50A=5/<+#=65-6$-:#6@#(-6;0A$(+3-6>:+63+6<?056-3#6$/(I.-<G6Y6A/+36
./536;"/;:5-6.-65036$-53=-3650:3650:36(-#(0:H0536G6<?+5#=(+-:()68)))96;-##-6H=(+#=6
+A$033+C<-6G63/+3+(F6;?-3#6</6'0(;-6A@A-6>:+F6/L/5#6-51-5.(=6;-(;<-3F6#/:#0<01+-36-#6
;05#(/.+;#+053F650:36;05#(/+5#6G6<-36(-K-#-()6X6
T6M/(<6`/3$-(3F6Les%Grands%Philosophes,%ceux%qui%fondent%la%philosophie%et%
ne%cessent%de%l'engendrer%:%Kant.6

!"##$%&&'()*+,+$-.+/)0(1&*+,+&2"03-4-5430+6
Page 5 sur 76
L’approche!logique!de!Bertrand!Russell!
D-(#(/5.6R:33-<<F6./536Problèmes%de%philosophie68bmbp9F6(-50:H-<<-6<-36;(+#+>:-36
$(=;=.-5#-36/H-;6:56$/(#+I$(+36(=/<+3#-6%6</6;"03-6-5630+6-3#6+.-5#+>:-68$/(63/6.='+5+#+0596G6
<?0CK-#6$"L3+>:-F6-56#/5#6>:-6;/:3-6.-363-53/#+0536Y6M/5#65?-3#6.05;6$/36'05.=6G6</6
.=;</(-(6+5;055/+33/C<-)6
P/(6</63:+#-F6./5363/6;05'=(-5;-6W6u0#(-6;055/+33/5;-6.:6A05.-6-B#=(+-:(6X68Our%
knowledge%of%the%External%WorldF670*-<<67-;#:(-3F6D03#05F6bmbv9vF6+<6/C0(.-6</6>:-3#+056
.-6</6;"03-6-5630+6./536<-6;/.(-6.:6$(0C<EA-6$<:361=5=(/<6.-6</6(=/<+#=6.:6A05.-6
3-53+C<-6-#6.-6</6;055/+33/5;-60CK-;#+H-F6;-6>:+6<?/AE5-6G65:/5;-(63/6$03+#+05)6
c<6(-A/(>:-6>:-6</6>:-3#+0565-6.0+#6$/36@#(-6$03=-630:36</6'0(A-6W6P0:H053I50:36
;055/\#(-6<S-B+3#-5;-6.S:5-6(=/<+#=6>:-<;05>:-6+5.=$-5./5#-6.-650:3IA@A-36w6XF6;/(6</6
50#+056.S+5.=$-5./5;-6>:+6-5#(-6-56K-:6+;+65S-3#6$/36;</+(-F6-#6;-6>:S056/$$-<<-6W6A0+6X6
$03-6/:33+6.+H-(36$(0C<EA-368<-6W6A0+6X6;0AA-63:K-#6$:(65S-3#6>:S:5-6+5'=(-5;-F6-#65056
:5-6.055=-6.-363-536Y6<-6W6A0+6X6.='+5+6;0AA-6;-6>:+6;-33-(/+#6.S-B+3#-(63+650:36;-33+0536
.-6H+H(-65S-3#6$/36/+3=6G6$(=;+3-(65056$<:39)6
c<6.='+5+#6</6W6#"=0(+-6.-6</6;"03-6-5630+6X6;0AA-6W6</6#"=0(+-6>:+6$(=#-5.6>:-6;-6>:+6
-B+3#-F6G6;-(#/+536A0A-5#3F6<0(3>:-650:365-6$-(;-H0536$/36:560CK-#63-53+C<-6.055=F6-3#6
>:-<>:-6;"03-6.-6#0#/<-A-5#6.+''=(-5#6.-6;-#60CK-#F6>:-<>:-6;"03-6>:+F6(=:5+6G650:36-#6G6
50360(1/5-36.-363-53F6;/:3-650363-53/#+053F6A/+365S-3#6K/A/+36.055=630+IA@A-6./536</6
3-53/#+056X)6
c<6(-;055/\#6>:-6;-##-6#"=0(+-6(=30:#65/#:(-<<-A-5#6<-36.+''+;:<#=36>:-6$03-5#6<-36
/$$/(-5;-36;"/51-/5#-36.-36;"03-3F6<S+53#/C+<+#=6.-363-53/#+0536+53#/5#/5=-3)6c<6#-5#-6
;-$-5./5#6:5-6(-;053#(:;#+056<01+>:-68>:S+<6>:/<+'+-6.S"L$0#"=#+>:-96>:+6(-5.-63/6
H/<+.+#=6-A$+(+>:-6G6;-6>:-6<-63-536;0AA:56/$$-<<-6W6;"03-6XF63/536-A$<0L-(6<-6;05;-$#6
.-6;"03-6-5630+F6-56:#+<+3/5#6<S-53-AC<-6.-36$0+5#36.-6H:-6$/(#+;:<+-(363:(6:560CK-#F6;-6
>:S+<6/$$-<<-6<S-3$/;-6.-6$-(3$-;#+H-)62-</63:$$03-6>:-6<-6#=A0+15/1-6.S/:#(:+630+#6H/<+.-6
-#6>:S056/.A-##-6<S-B+3#-5;-6.S/:#(-36-3$(+#3F6;(0L/5;-6>:+6W650:36-3#65/#:(-<<-6X6C+-56
>:S-<<-630+#6W6$3L;"0<01+>:-A-5#6.=(+H=-6X)6
Postérité!du!concept!de!chose!en!soi!
P03#:<=-6+5;055/+33/C<-F6</6;"03-6-5630+6$03-(/6.-650AC(-:B6$(0C<EA-36G6</6$"+<030$"+-6
$03#=(+-:(-6>:+6;"-(;"-(/6G63-6$/33-(6.-6;-6;05;-$#)67/6;05;-$#+056$"=50A=50<01+>:-6
.-6<?0CK-#6;"-Q6g:33-(<6'0:(5+#6:56-B-A$<-6.-6;05;-$#+056.-6<?0CK-#65?:#+<+3/5#6$/36</6
50#+056.-6;"03-6-5630+6$0:(6;0A$(-5.(-6<?0CK-#)67?0CK-#65?-3#6$<:36+5;055/+33/C<-F6
.-((+E(-6<-6$"=50AE5-F6<?0CK-#6est6<?0CK-#6$"=50A=5/<)6
a-6</6A@A-6'/]05F6$0:(6u+-#Q3;"-F6</6;"03-6-5630+6=#/5#6+5.=#-(A+5/C<-F6<?0$$03+#+056
-5#(-6$"=50AE5-6-#6;"03-6-5630+65?/6/:;:56+5#=(@#6$0:(650:3F6$/36$<:36>:-6;-<<-6-5#(-6
A/#+E(-6-#6-3$(+#6%6
2-65?-3#6$/36<-6A05.-6-5630+F6;?-3#6<-6A05.-6-56#/5#6>:-6(-$(=3-5#/#+05F6.05;6-56
#/5#6>:?-((-:(F6>:+6/6.-6<?+5#=(@#6$0:(650:3)62055/\#(-6</6;"03-6-5630+650:36