Les apprentis sorciers_V.Schmuck

FL##!!Schmuck"
Patrick( Artus( et( Marie!Paule& Virard,& Les$apprentis$sorciers.!40# ans#
d’échecs(de(la(politique(économique(française,"Edition'Fayard,"2013"
!"#$%&'(#)%"*
!"#$%&'%(%)*""*+,$%&'%-'.$%/%!0"'%')-"+*1%$'"+,%"'$%23*44.'$%+44*2*'"$%5%)*""*+,$%&'%-'.$%6*6',7%',%&'$$+#$%&#%
$'#*"%&'%-8#6.'791%&9$*,&#$7.*8"*$87*+,%$:8229";.'%
<9=.8&87*+,%&#'%/%#,%.'4#$%&'%$:8&8-7'.%8#>%)#787*+,$%!%problèmes*structurels%+,7%979%*=,+.9$?%
@,%ABC(%'7%ABCB%D%-+"%&'%.'"8,2'%-8.%"8%2+,$+))87*+,%)8*$%8,,9'$%5E%D%"#77'%2+,7.'%":*,4"87*+,?%
<92',,*'% ABBE%D% -.9+22#-87*+,% $#.% "8% 2.987*+,% &'% "8% )+,,8*'% #,*F#'% +#% "8% G878*""'% &'$% 2.*7;.'$% &'%
H88$7.*237%I3+.*J+,%&'$%(K%&'%&94*2*7%G#&=978*.'L%
M,,9'$%NEEE%D%&92"*,%&'%":*,&#$7.*'%86'2%2+O7$%&'%-.+&#27*+,%'>+.G*78,7$%'7%&*4*2*7%&'%2.987*6*79%
".'4#$%&'%)'77.'%',%-"82'%.94+.)'$%,92'$$8*.'$%
M)9"*+.87*+,$%D%P*,%NEAN,* rapport* Gallois%&9G+#23'%$#.%)*$'%',%-"82'%&:#,%-"8,%&'%$8#6'=8.&'%-+#.%"'$%
',7.'-.*$'$% -8.% Q'8,RH8.2% MS.8#"7?% I-827'% &'% 2+)-97*7*6*79% 86'2% ',7.'-.*$'$% '7% ',7.'-.','#.$L% )8*$%
*,$#44*$8,7?%
+,-.*/* 01* -$232$4"(4* -%'$* 51* $451"(4* -1$* 51* (%"6%771#)%"8* '"4*
9*7151&)4*3$1":1)64*;*
9*!5*<*1*&'*6%54)5*6'$*51*=$1"(4*;*>%-#)7)674*&46*1""246*?@A*
T+,7'>7'%&'$%années*70%'7%&'%"8%P.8,2'%&'%!+)-*&+#%
U#V7'%&#%G*',RV7.'%)879.*'"1%-8$$8='%/%#,'%2*6*"*$87*+,%&'$%"+*$*.$?%La*croissance*de*l’économie*française*
dépasse* 6,5%?%!.+W'7%&'%!+)-*&+#%&'%48*.'%&'%"8%P.8,2'%#,'%&'$%-.')*;.'$%-#*$$8,2'$%*,&#$7.*'""'$%&#%
)+,&'?% P.8,2'% &'$% ',7.'-.','#.$1% &'$% =.8,&'$% 4*"*;.'$% *,&#$7.*'""'$1% &'$% =.8,&'$% *,4.8$7.#27#.'$% &'%
7.8,$-+.7X% @Y% ABC(1% CEK% &'$% 4+S'.$% $+,7% )+7+.*$9$?%Plan* social%D% $8"8*.'% )*,*)#)1% )',$#8"*$87*+,1%
-.+=.'$$*+,%*..9$*$7*G"'%&#%-+#6+*.%&:82387?%Z'%230)8='%7+#23'%)+*,$%&'%NK%&'%"8%-+-%827*6'?%Z:*,4"87*+,%8%
#,%.S73)'%8,,#'"%&'%5K?%
!'.$-'27*6'$%&:86',*.%.8&*'#>%)8*$%2'.78*,'$%prévisions*moins*positives%86'2%":86'.7*$$')',7%-"8,978*.'%
$#.%"'$%"*)*7'$% &'%"8%2.+*$$8,2'%&:['.)8,%\83,% '7%":+#6.8='%-.9)+,*7+*.'%Quand* la* Chine* s’éveillera…*
(1973)*d’Alain*Peyrefitte.*
B"*C$1"&*9*(<C"4*"%)$*&2-5%)4*646*1)546*6'$*5D2(%"%7)4*7%"&)154*
M"+.$%F#'%":8#7+)+G*"'%$')G"'%V7.'%"'%$S)G+"'%&'%"8%-.+$-9.*79%'7%&'$%)+&'$%&'%6*'%',%P.8,2'1%"8%=#'..'%&#%
\*--+#.%-#*$%"'$%'44'7$%&'%"8%.96+"#7*+,%*.8,*',,'1%&'%"8%=#'..'%].8^R].8,%'7%&#%.'&9)8..8='%&'%"8%&')8,&'%
)+,&*8"'%',7.8*,'%#,'%69.*78G"'%explosion*du*prix*du*pétrole1%&:+_%*)-827%$#.%)+&'$%'7%,*6'8#>%&'%6*'?%
`92'$$*+,% &'% ABCa% 8#$$*% &#'% /% #,'% 92+,+)*'% )+,&*8"'% "*6.9'% /% l’inflation%'7% "8% $#.238#44'?%
P82'% /% "8% 2.*$'% &'% ":8#7+),'% ABC(1% "8% .9-+,$'% &'% !+)-*&+#% '7% &'% $+,% =+#6'.,')',7% 8% 979% &:8)+.7*.% "'%
23+2%D%refus*d’un*abaissement*du*niveau*de*vie1%&:+_%&'$%conséquences*graves*sur*la*croissance?%
+%"#$4*546*9*#4(,"%($1#46*)7E2()546*;8*54*#1"&47*F)6(1$&G+,)$1(*(,%)6)#*51*$451"(4*
HV)'%$:*"$%8$$#.',7%F#:*"$%868*',7%2+,$2*',2'%&'$%'44'7$%&#%-.')*'.%23+2%-97.+"*'.1%b*$28.&%'7%T3*.82%,:',%
7*.',7%-8$%"'$%2+,$9F#',2'$?%!+#.%préparer*les*élections*prochaines,%*"$%23'.23',7%$#.7+#7%/%préserver*
à* court* terme* le* pouvoir* d’achat* et* l’emploi.* ])-+.78,2'% &'$% *&9'$% ^'S,9$*',,'$% /% 2'% )+)',7% "/1%
$'#"')',7%2.*7*F#9'$%-8.%"'%)+,978.*$)'?%c'#"')',7%/%"8%4*,%&'$%8,,9'$%CE%F#:+,%'>-"+.'%"8%F#'$7*+,%&'$%
d%23+2$%&:+44.'%e%IF&%827*6*79%'7%.9$#"787$%&'$%',7.'-.*$'$%$+,7%2+)-.+)*$%-8.%#,%23+2%'>79.*'#.L?%
Plan*de*relance*en*19751%)9"8,='%&'%.94"'>'%^'S,9$*',%'7%&'%28"2#"%-+"*7*F#'?%!%Y*6'8#%'7%)+&'%&'%6*'%
.'$7'% *,7827$% )8*$% déclin* de* l’appareil* industriel%I&92"*,% ',&9)*F#'% &'$% -.+4*7$% &:+_% *,$#44*$8,2'%
2.+*$$8,7'%&:*,6'$7*$$')',71%&:')-"+*1%&:*,,+687*+,%-#*$%&9"+28"*$87*+,L?%<'%ABCf%/%ABCB%"'%230)8='%-8$$'%
&'%aEE%EEE%/%A%fEE%EEE?%Apogée*du*keynésianisme*au*moment*où*choc*d’offre*énorme%!%-'.$+,,'%
,:+$'% 844.+,7'.% ":*)-+-#"8.*79% &:#,'% -+"*7*F#'% *,7'""*='))',7% 2',7.9'% $#.% "'$% ',7.'-.*$'$% '7% "8%
2+)-97*7*6*79%&'%":8--8.'*"%-.+&#27*4?%

H'1"&*I)4$$4*J1'$%<*"4*K%'51)#*-16*(%""1L#$4*54*7M74*6%$#*N'4*O1$%5&*P)56%"*
M..*69'%&'%"8%=8#23'%8#%-+#6+*.%',%1981%'7%"8,2')',7%&:#,'%forte*politique*de*relance?%Z'%)*,*$7.'%&'$%
4*,8,2'$1%Q?%<'"+.$1%,'%.9#$$*7%-8$%/%2+,68*,2.'%&#%G*',%4+,&9%&'%"8%.*=#'#.1%$'$%8&6'.$8*.'$%7'"$%F#'%Z8#.',7%
P8G*#$?%!%)V)'%'..'#.%&:8,8"S$'%F#:',%ABCa?%!.87*F#'.%#,'%-+"*7*F#'%&'%.'"8,2'%-8.%"8%2+,$+%8"+.$%F#'%
":8--8.'*"%-.+&#27*4%8%$#G*%#,%&+#G"'%23+2%&:+44.'%'7%,'%-'#7%-.+&#*.'%&868,78='%',7.8*,'%l’explosion* du*
déficit*extérieur*et*des*prix.*
T:'$7%":M""')8=,'%F#*%-.+4*7'%&'%"8%.'"8,2'%4.8,g8*$'?%AB5N%$+"&'%&#%2+))'.2'%'>79.*'#.%D%&94*2*7%&'%Af1Na%
)*""*8.&$%&:'#.+$%'7%78#>%&'%2+#6'.7#.'%&'%5CK?%!%.'2+#.$%/%#,%«*protectionnisme*déguisé*».%
Mai* 1982*:* préparation* du* plan* de* rigueur.%!*'..'% H8#.+S1% -.')*'.% )*,*$7.'%D% d% h,% ,'% 7*',&.8% -8$%
":*,4"87*+,%8#%)+)',7%+_%7+#7%"'%)+,&'%48*7%&'%"8%&94"87*+,%e?%!%],6'$7*$$')',7%&8,$%":9F#*-')',7%&#%-8S$%
'7%&8,$%"8%)+&'.,*$87*+,%&'$%',7.'-.*$'$%-"#707%F#'%&8,$%"8%.'"8,2'%&'%"8%2+,$+))87*+,?%La*lutte*contre*
l’inflation%&'6*',7%8#$$*%*)-+.78,7'%F#'%"8% G878*""'%2+,7.'%"'%230)8='?%@""'%*)-+$'% "8%&9$*,&'>87*+,%&'$%
$8"8*.'$%$#.%"'$%-.*>?%
c'#"')',7%',%AB5(%'7%86'2%"8%)',82'%&:#,'%2.*$'%)8W'#.'%F#:+,%8$$*$7'%/%#,%d%7+#.,8,7%e?%
Q,1#(,4$GR41C1"*%'*51*$4K1"(,4*&4*5D*9*2(%"%7)4*&4*5D%33$4*;*
* RoyaumeYUni*D%8,,9'$% ABCE%923'2% &'%"8% -+"%"*G9.8"'%&:@&i8.&% ['873% &+,2%-+"%^'S,9$*',,'%F#*%
',=',&.'%#,'%*,4"87*+,%*)-+.78,7'?%Z'%-.')*'.%)*,*$7.'%&+*7%&+,2%)'77.'%',%-"82'%#,'%-+"%&'%2+,7.0"'%&'$%
$8"8*.'$%'7% &'$%-.*>?%Dégradation* de* la* situation* économique* et* explosion* de* l’inflation%.8);,'%"'$%
2+,$'.687'#.$% 8#% -+#6+*.% ',% ABCB% 86'2% M.* Thatcher?% @""'% )'7% ',% -"82'% une* politique* monétariste%
I8G8,&+,% &'% "8% -+"% &'$% .'6',#$L1% #,'% pol* de* modernisation* industrielle,* législation* antisyndicale,*
privatisations%I#,%F#8.7%&#%$'27'#.%-#G"*2%&'6*',7%-.*69L?%M#%&9-8.7%'44+,&.')',7%&'%"8%-.+&%*,&#$7.*'""'%
'7%',6+"9'%&#%230)8='%-#*$%=.8,&'$%8)9"*+.87*+,$?%
* EtatsYUnis*D% W#$F#:8#>% jE:$% -.*,2*-'% &'% ":8.G*7.8='% *,4"87*+,k230)8='% I2+#.G'% &'% !3*""*-$L% '7%
-.949.',2'% -+#.% 48*G"'% 230)8='% )8*$% 2'.78*,$% 92+,+)*$7'$1% 2+))'% H?% P.*'&)8,% $+#"*=,'% 28-82*79% /%
8,7*2*-'.%-+#$$9'$%*,4"87*+,,*$7'$%F#*%8,,#"'.8*7%'44'7%-+$*7*4%!%Staglation?%M%"8%4*,%&'$%8,,9'$%CE%*,4"87*+,%
W#$F#:/%AN1aK%'7%230)8='%&'%-"#$%&'%CK?%],$78""87*+,%&'%R.*Reagan%86'2%,+#6'""'%$7.879=*'%4+,&9'%$#.%"'$%
G8*$$'$%&:*)-07$%-+#.%486+.*$'.%"8%2.+*$$8,2'1%«*économie*de*l’offre*»%I',%.9827*+,%86'2%":92+,+)*'%&'%"8%
&')8,&'%&'%\'S,'$L?%]"%$:*,$-*.'%&'$%7.868#>%&:M?%Z844'.% '7%.94"923*7%$#.%"8%-.'$$*+,%4*$28"'%'7%$+,%*)-827%
$#.%"8%2.+*$$8,2'?%@,%AB5A%6+7'%&'%"8%loi*fiscale1%9"9)',7%)8W'#.%&'%"8%d%$#--"S%$*&'%'2+,+)*2$%e?%Politique*
de* réduction* importante* des* dépenses* publiques%'7% $+#7*',% $8,$% 48*""'% /% "8% ,+#6'""'% politique*
monétaire*pour*lutter*contre*l’inflation%&'%!?%l+"2^'.1%-87.+,%&'%"8%P@<%IG8,F#'%2',7.8"'%8)9.*28*,'L?%
M#%&9G#7%78#>%&'%230)8='%9"'69%IAEKL%-#*$%.'7.8*7%&'%"8%68=#'%&'%230)8='%'7%&'%ABCB%/%AB5(%-8$$8='%&#%
78#>%&:*,4"87*+,%&'%AAK%/%(K%!%nouvel*élan*à*l’épargne*et*l’investissement?%
m*"8,%2+,7.8$79%&'%"8%`'8=8,+)*2$%D%8%.',4+.29%":92+,+)*'%8)9.*28*,'%+#%.'$-+,$8G"'%&#%2.'#$')',7%&'$%
&94*2*7$%I86*$%&'% `+G'.7%c+"+iL%n%H8.7*,%P'"&$7'*,%-.+-+$'%#,%G*"8,%-"#$%,#8,29%D% "8%2.+*$$8,2'%.9'""'%&#%
!]m% ',7.'% AB5A% '7% AB5a% 8% 979% &'% AE1BK1% #,% -'#% -"#$% &'% "8% )+*7*9% $'#"')',7% F#'% "'% -.+W'7% *,*7*8"?%
Z:',7V7')',7%&'%":92+,+)*'%&'%":+44.'%8%8"+#.&*%"'%&94*2*7%G#&=978*.'%8)9.*28*,?%M*,$*%d%$#.%"'%"+,=%7'.)'1%
":96+"#7*+,%&#%.'6',#%.9'"%&:#,'%,87*+,%&9-+,&%&'%":822#)#"87*+,%&#%28-*78"%-3S$*F#'%'7%*,7'""'27#'"%'7%&'$%
'44+.7$%&'%-.+&#27*6*79%&'%"8%4+.2'%&'%7.868*"%e?%
"@o% '7% `o% +,7% '#% ,+#6'""'% 8--.+23'% &'% ":92+,+)*'% &'% ":+44.'% '7% &#% .0"'% &'% ":@787% 8"+.$% F#'% -.949.',2'%
4.8,g8*$'%-+#.%"8%.'"8,2'%-8.%"8%&')8,&'%8%-.+6+F#9%&'$%&9=p7$?%
9*=)6(15*&%7)"1"(4*;8*'"4*54:%"*&46*1""246*.ST@*#%'U%'$6*&D1(#'15)#2*
%!+#.%"#77'.%2+,7.'%"'$%&'#>%23+2$%-97.+"*'.$1%)*$'%',%-"82'%&:#,'%pol*de*soutien*de*la*demande%
86'2% hausse* du* salaire* minimum* et* des* déficits* publics?% Z:*,&'>87*+,% &'$% $8"8*.'$% 81% &:8-.;$%
":92+,+)*$7'%Q'44.'S%c823$1%979%#,%38,&*28-?%!%`9-+,$'%*,8&8-79'?%<9G87%$#.%#,'%.'"8,2'%&'%"8%2.+*$$8,2'%
',% P.8,2'% ',% NEAN%D% .'"8,2'% ^'S,9$*',,'% $'.8*7% *,'44*282'% 28.% -G% &'% "8% 48*G"'$$'% &'% "8% 2.+*$$8,2'%
'>-+,',7*'""'%'7%&'%"8%F#8"*79%&'%":+44.'?%
%Z8>*$)'%G#&=978*.'%&'$% 8,,9'$%CE% 8% &9G+#239%$.% &'$% 78#>%&:*,79.V7$% .9'"$%,9=87*4$%',%ABCfRCa?%
!39,+);,'% &#% «*fiscal* dominance*»%+_% -+"% )+,978*.'% '$7% $+#$% "8% 7#7'""'% &'% "8% -+"% G#&=978*.'?% P+.7'%
création* monétaire* et* tx* d’intérêts* réels* négatifs%-+#.%4*,8,2'.%"'$%&94*2*7$%!%4"8)G9'%*,4"87*+,,*$7'?%
T+,$9F#',2'$%D% 2+..'27*+,% &'$% &9.*6'$% *,4"87*+,,*$7'$% -8.% -+"*2S% )*>% I-+"% )+,978*.'% '7% G#&=978*.'L%
.'$7.*27*4%',7.8*,'%#,%-'.7'%&#.8G"'%&'%2.+*$$8,2'?%
Inflation*a*dégradé*la*compétitivité*française*et*son*commerce*extérieur1%',7.8*,9%&'$%&968"#87*+,$%
&#%4.8,2?%!%T+,$9F#',2'$%7'..*G"'$?%
<'-#*$%2008*:* pol* monétaires* très*expansionnistes%-+#.%4*,8,2'.%&94*2*7$%-#G"*2$%'7%&'77'$1%/%,+#6'8#%
d4*$28"%&+)*,8,2'%e?%`*$F#'%&'%G#""'$%$#.%"'$%-.*>%&:827*4$%'7%2+,$9F#',2'$%$#.%2.+*$$8,2'%'7%')-"+*$?%

"Z8%6+"+,79%-+"*7*F#'%&+*7%V7.'%&'%revoir* les* priorités*collectives%'7%&'%&9=8='.%"'$%)+S',$%4*,8,2*'.$%
,92'$$8*.'$% 8#% 4*,8,2')',7% &'% "8% )+&'.,*$87*+,?% k% hGW'27*4%&'% "#77'% 2+,7.'% ":*,4"87*+,% 8% 8,98,7*% 7+#7'%
.94"'>*+,%$#.%"8%,92'$$*79%&'%soigner*la*croissance*potentielle*et*l’emploi?%
+,-*V*/*J116#$)(,#*%'*546*)"3%$#'"46*&4*51*9*K4$#'*;*
%
q.8*79% &'% H88$7.*2371% .87*4*9% "'% C% 496.*'.% ABBN% -.96+*'% "8% )*$'% ',% -"82'% &:#,'% monnaie* européenne*
unique%&8,$%"'%28&.'%&#%-.+2'$$#$%&:#,*+,%)+,978*.'?%!.9$',79'%2+))'%2'%F#*%-'.)'77.8%/%":@#.+-'%&'%
&'6',*.%A;.'%-#*$$8,2'%8#%)+,&'%)8*$%8%'#%#,%*)-827%,9=87*4%$#.%"8%2+)-97*7*6*79%&'%":92+,+)*'%4.8,g8*$'1%
":')-"+*% '7% "'% ,*6'8#% &'% 6*'% &:8-.;$% 2'% F#:+,7% ',$#*7'% '$7*)9% "'$% P.8,g8*$?% <8,$% "'$% 8,,9'$% BE1% "8% -+"%
92+,+)*F#'%4.8,g8*$'%4#7%7+78"')',7%=#*&9'%-8.%"8%6+"+,79%&'%48*.'%"8%)+,,8*'%#,*F#'%'7%&'%.'$-'27'.%"'$%
2.*7;.'$%&'%H88$7.*237?%
WX*54*9*-4#)#*(,)33$4*1"%&)"*;*64*$2KY54$1*&)1E%5)N'4*
o,*+,% )+,978*.'% &+*7% $'% 48*.'% &8,$%#,% cadre* de* convergence* des* économies1% &:+_% &'$% d%2.*7;.'$% &'%
2+,6'.=',2'%e1% &+,7% 2'"#*% &:#,% déficit* budgétaire* limité* à* 3%* de* PIB?% Z'% 23*44.'% &'% (K% '$7% #,% d%-'7*7%
23*44.'%8,+&*,%e1%&92*&9%28.%*"%48""8*7%#,'%.;="'%482*"'%$8,$%'448.+#23'.%":+-*,*+,%86'2%"'%)+,78,7%&'%"8%&'77'?%
<87'% G#7+*.'&#% A'.%W8,6*'.% ABBB% -+#.% "8% 2.987*+,% &'% "8% )+,,8*'% #,*F#'?% Z8% -"#-8.7% &'$% )+,,8*'$% '#.+%
978*',7%"*9'$%&8,$%"'%Système*monétaire*européen%IcH@L1%F#*%"'$%2+,7.8*=,8*7%/%.'$-'27'.%&'$%)8.='$%&'%
4"#27#87*+,%Ir% +#%s% N1aKL%-+#.%"'#.$% 78#>%&'%238,='?%h.%crise%D% 92+,+)*'$%$+#)*$'$%/% &'$%23+2$%2+))'%
":'44+,&.')',7% &'% ":o`cc% '7% "8% .9#,*4*287*+,% 8""')8,&'?% <968"#87*+,$% &'% ,+)G.'#$'$% )+,,8*'$%
'#.+-9',,'$% )8*$% ',% P.8,2'% &92*$*+,% -+"*7*F#'% &'% ,'% -8$% &968"#'.?% <'68,7% ":8G$',2'% &'% -+"*7*F#'%
92+,+)*F#'%'#.+-9',,'1%"'% cH@%&92*&'%l’élargissement* des* marges* de* fluctuation%I-8$$8='%/% r%+#%s%
AaKL?%!%)+,7.'%4.8=*"*79%+,7+"+=*F#'%&'%"8%J+,'%'#.+%I8G8,&+,%&'%"8%$+#6'.8*,'79%)+,978*.'%$')G"'%V7.'%
#,%38,&*28-%7.+-%4+.7%-+#.%"'$%92+,+)*'$%4.8=*"'$L?%
!$$26)6#)E546* K)4'Z* &27%"6*/* -5'#[#* 54* #%'$* &4* K)6* 3)6(15* N'4* 51* E1)664* &46* &2-4"646*
-'E5)N'46*
Pas*de* dévaluation*+*politique*de* réduction*du*déficit*public*par*la*hausse*de* la*pression*fiscale%
-"#707% F#'% -8.% "8% .9&#27*+,% &'$% &9-',$'$% -#G"*F#'$?% !%-8$% &'% 23+2% 486+.8G"'% &'% 2+)-97*7*6*79% &+,2%
faiblesse* de* l’investissement* productif* et%des* gains* de* productivité?% M*,$*% 86'2% &94"87*+,1% *"% S% 8%
968-+.87*+,%&'$%.'2'77'$%'7%',%-8.8"";"'%"'$%7.8,$4'.7$%'7%$#G6',7*+,$%&'%":@787%23'.23',7%/%2+)-',$'.%"'$%
-G%"*9$%8#%230)8='?%
Cette* pol* économique* restrictive* empêche* la* reprise.%]"% 8#.8*7% 979% '$$',7*'"% &:8$$8*,*.% "'$% 4*,8,2'$%
-#G"*F#'$%7+#7%',%8#=)',78,7%"8%2.+*$$8,2'%-+7',7*'""'?%M*,$*%"'%$#22;$%&'%H88$7.*237%&9-',&8*7%&'%"8%)*$'%
',%-"82'%&'$%8W#$7')',7$%$7.#27#.'"$%,92'$$8*.'$%-+#.%-'.)'77.'%#,'%2+,$+"*&87*+,%G#&=978*.'%',%4*$28"'1%
7+#7%',%-.9-8.8,7%":86',*.?%%
<9=.8&87*+,% &'$% 4*,8,2'$% -#G"*F#'$% -8.% l’augmentation* du* poids* des* dépenses* publiques1% &'%
":',&'77')',7%-#G"*2%INEK%',%ABCa1%5B1CK%&#%!]m%',%NEANL%'7%de*la*pression*fiscale%!%cercle*vicieux.%
Z8%38#$$'%&'$%238.='$%$+2*8"'$%'$7%/%)'77.'%',%-8.8"";"'%86'2%48*G"'$$'%23.+,*F#'%&#%78#>%&:')-"+*%Ij(1BK%
',%NEAAL%'7%"'%&92"*,%&'%":822#)#"87*+,%&#%28-*78"?%
NEAA%D% "'$% $'#"$% *,79.V7$% $#.% "8% &'77'% 6'.$9$% -8.% ":@787% +,7% 877'*,7% a(% )*""*8.&% &:'#.+$% It% G#&='7% &'%
":',$'*=,')',7%$2+"8*.'L?%<:8-.;$%Carmen*M.*Reinhart*et*Kenneth*S.*Rogoff,*au*delà*d’un*certain*seuil*
de*PIB*(pour*eux*90%),*l’endettement*public*compromet*gravement*la*croissance.%
Z8%c#;&'1%"8%P*,"8,&'1%"'%<8,')8.^%'7%"'%T8,8&8%$'%$+,7%8778F#9$%8#>%&94*2*7$%'7%/%"8%&'77'%&;$%"'$%BE:$%'7%+,7%
$#%)'77.'%',%u#6.'%#,'%-+"*2S%)*>%)82.+92+,+)*F#'%'44*282'%'7%#,'%.9+.=8,*$87*+,%&'%":@787%I.9&#27*+,%
&#%2+O7%&'%4+,27*+,,')',7L?%
04*9*"%'K41'*;*7%&Y54*6'2&%)6*%'*51*3%$(4*&'*(%"64"6'6*
H+&;"'% $#9&+*$% '$7% 6#% 2+))'% #,'% d%7.+*$*;)'% 6+*'%e1% 2/&% #,% 28-*78"*$)'% '44*282'% '7% .9=#"9?% !+#.% Q',,S%
M,&'.$+,1%*"%.'-.9$',7'%#,'%d%$+.7'%&:#7+-*'%&8,$%":3*$7+*.'%-+"*7*F#'%'#.+-9',,'%e?%
Z'% d%-.')*'.%e% )+&;"'% $#9&+*$%D% @787% -.+6*&',2'% $#-'.G'% '7% =9,9.'#>% )8*$% 8#>% 8,,9'$% BE1% =.86'$%
&*44*2#"79$%&#%$'27'#.%G8,28*.'%'7%.92'$$*+,%92+,+)*F#'%IABB(%D%&94*2*7%-#G"*2%ANK%'7%&'77'%-#G"*F#'%5EK%
&#%!]mL?%
Crise*:*critique*de*l’Etat*providence*

Z'%=+#6'.,')',7%m*"&7%)'7%',%-"82'%#,'%pol*monétaire*expansionniste*et*dévaluation*de*la*couronne%
+*réorganisation*en*profondeur?%%!+#.$#*7'%&'%"8%d%)+&'.,*$87*+,%-8.%"8%$+2*8"R&9)+2.87*'%',%ABBf%IA'.%
)*,*$7.'%b+.8,%!'.$$+,L%86'2%effort*de*maitrise*du*déficit*public%'7%='$7*+,%-"#$%9F#*"*G.9%&#%G#&='7?%
!+"% &'% 2+,$+"*&87*+,% G#&=978*.'%D% réduction* des* dépenses* publiques* tout* en* améliorant* sa*
productivité* et* sa* gouvernance?% `94+.)'% &'$% *,$7*7#7*+,$% I$*)-"*4*287*+,% &'% ":+.=8,*$87*+,% &'% ":@787% '7%
&92',7.8"*$87*+,L% '7% &'% "8% -.+29&#.'% G#&=978*.'%I-"84+,&% &'% &9-',$'% '7% G#&='7% ="+G8"% .9-8.7*L?% H*$'% ',%
-"82'%&:#,%4+,27*+,,')',7%-8.%8=',2'$%86'2%$9-8.87*+,%',7.'%"8%2+,2'-7*+,%'7%"8%)*$'%',%u#6.'%&'$%-+"%
-#G"*F#'$%v% ='$7*+,% &92',7.8"*$9'% &'$% .'$$+#.2'$% 3#)8*,'$% 86'2% .9&#27*+,% &#% ,G% &:')-"+*$% -#G"*2$% '7%
.9)#,9.87*+,%*,&*6*&#8"*$9'?%
M,,9'$% BE% +,7% 979% #,'% -9.*+&'% &'% 7#.G#"',2'$% '7% &:*,F#*97#&'% -+#.% "8% c#;&'% )8*$% "'$% 7.8,$4+.)87*+,$1%
-'.)*$'$%-8.% &'$%"*',$% 97.+*7$%',7.'%-8.7*$% -+"*7*F#'$% '7%$S,&*2871%#,%78#>% &'%$S,&*28"*$87*+,%9"'69% '7%&'%
48*G"'$%&*449.',2'$%',7.'%$8"8.*9$1%+,7%',7.8*,9%#,'%adaptation*à*la*mondialisation.%Z'%78#>%&'%230)8='%8%
979%&*6*$9%-8.%&'#>%'7%.'&.'$$')',7%&'$%4*,8,2'$%-#G"*F#'$?%
"%Z'%d%,+#6'8#%)+&;"'%$#9&+*$%e%)+,7.'%F#:*"%'$7%possible*d’améliorer*la*productivité*de*l’Etat*sans*
abîmer*la*qualité*du*service*public.*
01*$23%$74*(1"1&)4""4*%'*54*#$)%7-,4*&4*51*K%5%"#2*-%5)#)N'4*
<'% ABCE% /% ABB(%D% NN% G#&='7$% &94*2*78*.'$% 2+,$92#7*4$1% ',% ABB(%D% &94*2*7% &'% BK% &#% !]m% '7% &'77'% -#G"*F#'%
-8.)*%"'$%-"#$%9"'69'$%&'%":hT<@?%
Gouvernement* de* Jean* Chrétien%8#% -+#6+*.% $#.% #,% prg* d’assainissement* des* finances* publiques.%
`9&#27*+,% &#% ,G% &'$% )*,*$7;.'$1% $8"8*.'$% &'$% 4+,27*+,,8*.'$% ='"9$?% m#7%D% .8)','.% ',% &'#>% 8,$% "'% &94*2*7%
49&9.8"%&'%j%/%(K%&#%!]m%-8.%.9&#27*+,%&'$%&9-',$'$%&'%NEK%'7%$8,$%8#=)',787*+,%&:*)-07$?%
Processus*de*décentralisation,*privatisation,*réforme*de*l’assurance*chômage.%<'#>%-.=%&:8$$*$78,2'%
7')-+.8*.'%&'%(8,$%-+#.%8)+.7*.%"'%23+*>?%H8*$%8#$$*%"*)*7'$%&#%&.+*7%&'%=.;6'%&8,$%"8%4+,27*+,%-#G"*F#'1%
486+.*$'%4"'>*G*"*79%$#.%)8.239%&#%7.868*"?%!.+W'7%&'%G#&='7%&'%ABBa%D%.9&#27*+,%&'$%&9-',$'$%-#G"*F#'$%8#%
7+78"1%3+.$%238.='$%&'%"8%&'77'1%&'%NEK1%-.*687*$87*+,%-8.7*'""'1%8#=)',787*+,%&:*)-07$%$#.%"'$%',7.'-.*$'$1%
822*$'% $#.% ":'$$',2'% '7% "'% 78G82?% @,%-8.8"";"'*démarche* de* communication*collective* et* programme*
d’éducation*publique%-+#.%$',$*G*"*$'.%8#%-G%&'%"8%&'77'%-#G"*F#'?%
"%m*"8,%D%&94*2*7$%+,7%&*$-8.#%86'2%"'$%8,,9'$%ABBCRB51%2.+*$$8,2'%'$7%.'-8.7*'%I&'%(1jK%',%)+S',,'%&'%
ABBf%/%NEE(L%'7%"8%F#8"*79%&#%$'.6*2'%-#G"*F#'%,:8%-8$%$+#44'.7?%%
0D,%$)\%"*)"&2-1661E54*&'*&23)()#*E'&C2#1)$4*
c#;&'1% T8,8&81% P*,"8,&'1% <8,')8.^% '7% ]78"*'% +,7% )+,7.9% F#:*"% 978*7% -+$$*G"'% 2+,$+"*&'.% "'$% 4*,8,2'$%
-#G"*F#'$%&8,$%"8%&#.9'%$8,$%&9=.8&'.%"8%F#8"*79%&#%$'.6*2'%-#G"*2?% Croissance* grâce* à* des* politiques*
structurelles*et* un*soutien*dans*l’effort*d’innovation%I&'-#*$%Aa%8,$%&9-',$'$%&8,$%`w<%&'%"8%c#;&'%
x(1aK%k%P.8,2'%NKL%et*dans*l’éducation*supérieure?%T'%$+,7%"'$%-8S$%F#*%+,7%"'%)*'#>%.9$*$79%/%"8%2.*$'%
&'%NEE5%28.%*"$%868*',7%.9#$$*%/%8$$8*,*.%"'$%4*,8,2'$?%
T&7$%$#$2'-7*G"'$%&'%486+.*$'.%":'44*282*79%&'$%-+"%&'%2+,$+"*&87*+,%G#&=978*.'%'7%.94+.)'%&'%":@787%D%
R +-7*+,$% )82.+92+,+)*F#'$%D% prg* de* consolidation* fiscale* par* la* baisse* des* dépenses*
publiques1%$*%-+$$*G"'%&8,$%#,%',6*.+,,')',7%&'%-+"%)+,978*.'%'>-8,$*+,,*$7'%)8*$%8W#$7')',7%
)+,978*.'%*)-+$$*G"'%',%J+,'%'#.+%
R réorganisation*énergique*de*l’Etat%86'2%822.+*$$')',7%&'%"8%-.+&#27*6*79%
R effort* d’explication* et* de* concertation%',%&*.'27*+,%&'%":+-*,*+,%-#G"*F#'%'7%&'$%827'#.$%&'%"8%
.94+.)'%v%"8%-.*$'%&'%.*$F#'%-+"*7*F#'%$#--+$'%#,%69.*78G"'%'44+.7%&'%2+))#,*287*+,?%
En* France,%8#% 2+,7.8*.'%D% refus* d’un* réajustement* monétaire1% pas* de* modernisation* des* relations*
sociales,*augmentation* de*la*pression* fiscale?%Z'%-+*&$%&'$%&9-',$'$%-#G"*F#'$%&8,$%"'%!]m%',%P.8,2'%
IajK% ',% NEAAL% '$7% "'% -"#$% 9"'69% &:@#.+-'?% Z'$% 2+,$+"*&87*+,$% .98"*$9'$% -8.% "'$% 38#$$'$% &:*)-07$% $+,7%
-9,8"*$8,7'$1% 28.% 2+O7$% G2-% -"#$% 9"'69% ',% 7'.)'% &'% 2.+*$$8,2'% '7% &:')-"+*% F#'% "+.$F#'% &*)*,#7*+,% &'$%
&9-',$'$% -#G"*F#'$?% m*"8,% &'% l’épisode* de* consolidation* budgétaire* français*D% $'#"')',7% G8*$$'% &'%
f1CK%&#%&94*2*7%-#G"*21%F#8$*%$78=,87*+,%&#% 230)8='?%Z+.$F#'%2+,$+"*&87*+,%-8.%.9&#27*+,%&'$% &9-',$'$%
-#G"*F#'$1% +,% +G$'.6'% #,% $+#7*',% &'% "8% 2+,$+))87*+,% -8.% "'$% )9,8='$% '7% #,'% .')+,79'% &'%
":*,6'$7*$$')',7%&'$% ',7.'-.*$'$?%Z'%G*"8,%&'$%8,,9'$%BE%'$7%*,F#*978,7%28.%-8$%&'%-+"%$7.#27#.'""'$%-+#.%
restaurer*la*compétitivité*de*l’appareil*économique*français1%,*%-+#.%pol*de*croissance*potentielle?%%
!%-'.7'%&'%-8.7$%&'%)8.239%'7%&9$*,&#$7.*8"*$87*+,1%&:+_%$*7#87*+,%7.;$%4.8=*"'?%
%

+,-]*/*(%774"#*51*=$1"(4*1*61($)3)2*61*(%7-2#)#)K)#2*
01*=$1"(4*61"6*'6)"46*C1C"4*(,1N'4*U%'$*&'*#4$$1)"*
@,7.'% NEEC% '7% NEAA1% production* automobile* française* a* chuté* de* 24%1% -.+&#27*+,% &'% 6+*7#.'$%
-8.7*2#"*;.'$% 8% 979% &*6*$9'% -8.% &'#>?% `8*$+,$%D% marché* européen* en* berne* et* outils* de* production*
surdimensionné.%T.'#$')',7%&'$%928.7$%&'%2+)-97*7*6*79%&#%48*7%&:#,%manque*de*flexibilité*et*du*coût*
de* travail* en* Franc'% '7% 8#$$*% 23+*>% $7.879=*F#'% 38$8.&'#>% I2+,2',7.87*+,% $#.% "'% )*"*'#% &'% =8))'L?% Z8%
`',78G*"*79% &'$% 2+,$7.#27'#.$% 4.8,g8*$% '$7% -8$$9'% /% AK% ',% NEAN% &:8-.;$% @#"'.% ['.)'$% IC1aK% -+#.%
":M""')8=,'L?%
!8$% $'#"')',7% 8#7+)+G*"'1% 7+#7'% ":*,&#$7.*'% '$7% 7+#239'?% NEAN%D% &:8-.;$% l’Observatoire* Trendeo*:* 266*
fermetures,* 42%* de* plus* qu’en* 2011?% Z'$% 28-82*79$% &'% -.+&#27*+,% ',% P.8,2'% +,7% -.+=.'$$9% &'% AEK%
$'#"')',7%&'-#*$%ABBa%I(aK%',%M""')8=,'L?%Z8%68"'#.%8W+#79'%,87*+,8"'%'$7%&'%AN1aK%',%NEAA%IAa;%-"82'%
-8.)*%"'$%AC%-8S$%&'%"8%J+,'%'#.+L?%L’emploi*industriel*a*perdu*environ*2millions*de*postes*en*30*ans?%
!.+"*49.87*+,%&'%4.*23'$%*,&#$7.*'""'$1%&94*2*7%&'%":*,&#$7.*'%)8,#4827#.*;.'?%@,%NEAN%D%&94*2*7%&'%jC%)*""*8.&$%
&:'#.+$% -+#.% "8% G8"8,2'% 2+))'.2*8"'% 4.8,g8*$'?% M"+.$% F#'% ":'>29&',7% 8""')8,&% '$7% -8$$'% &'% AEE% /% (EE%
)*""*8.&$%',7.'%ABBa%'7%NEAA?%
"%<*)*,#7*+,% &'% "8% -8.7% &'% )8.239% &'% "8% P.8,2'% &8,$%"'% 2+))'.2'% )+,&*8"?% <*$-8.*7*+,% &'% $'27'#.$%
*,&#$7.*'"$% ',7*'.$?% Z:*,&#$7.*'% 8% -'.&#% aEE% EEE% -+$7'$% ',% AE% 8,$?%
])-+.78,2'%&'%":*,&#$7.*'%28.%activité*structurante*D%,+#..*7%&96'"+--')',7%&#%$'27'#.%&'$%$'.6*2'$%8#>%
',7.'-.*$'$%r%7*.'%":*,,+687*+,%r%$+#7*',7%"'%2+))'.2'%'>79.*'#.?%
0D)$$'-#)%"*&46*-1<6*274$C4"#6*/*'"*(,%(*&4*(%7-2#)#)K)#2*61"6*-$2(2&4"#^*
b.8,&%G+#"'6'.$')',7?%ABB5%"8%T3*,'%,'%.'-.9$',7'%F#'%(1aK%&#%2+))'.2'%)+,&*8"1%',%NEA(%D%AaK?%M6'2%
],&'1%T+.9'1%q38y"8,&'%'7%m.9$*"%D%«*réémergence*»*des*pays*du*Sud*et*de*l’Est%!%G+#"'6'.$')',7%&'%"8%
«*hiérarchie*des*places*»%'7%&:8-.;$%":92+,+)*$7'%M,=#$%H8&&*$+,1%2'"8%8,,+,2'%#,%d%=.8,&%2.+*$')',7%e%
6'.$% NENa?% Z'$% 92+,+)*'$% &*7'$% d%9)'.=',7'$%e% .'-.9$',78*',7% &9W/% ":'$$',7*'"% &#% !]m% )+,&*8"% W#$F#:8#%
&'G#7%&#%z]z;?%l9.*78G"'%23+2%&'%2+)-97*7*6*79?%
d%b.8,&'%*""#$*+,%e%&'$%-8S$%+22*&',78#>1%F#*%978*',7%2',$9$%$'%$-92*8"*$'.%8#>%&'#>%'>7.9)*79$%&#%$-'27.'%
&'% "8% 68"'#.% 8W+#79'1% -&7% F#'% &96'"+--')',7% &'$% -.+&#*7$% *,&#$7.*'"$% &8,$% "'$% -8S$% 9)'.=',7$?%
T+,$9F#',2'$%D%malgré*mouvement*de*réindustrialisation,*baisse*du*niveau*de*qualification*et*de*la*
qualité*des*emplois,*chômage*et*baisse*du*pouvoir*d’achat?%Z8%&9$*,&#$7.*8"*$87*+,%*)-"*F#'%#,%&94*2*7%
'>79.*'#.%2+))'.2*8"%23.+,*F#'1%&:+_%8#=)',787*+,%',&9)*F#'%&'%":',&'77')',7%'>79.*'#.%Rx%.*$F#'$%&'%
2.*$'$?%
c'#"'%réponse*-+$$*G"'%D%montée*en*gamme*et*différenciation*des*produits?%H8*$%',%P.8,2'%D%8G8,&+,%
&'%7'..8*,$%$#.%&'$%$'27'#.$%&'%-+*,7'%2+))'%":9"'27.+,*F#'?%
046*-$%&')#6*3$1":1)6*6%"#*E)4"*#$%-*(,4$6_*
T+,$787%D%amaigrissement*des*marges*bénéficiaires1%,+78))',7%&8,$%":*,&#$7.*'?%M*,$*%-.*>%&'%"8%68"'#.%
8W+#79%&8,$% "'% $'27'#.%)8,#4827#.*'.% 8%&92.+239%',% NEEN% '7% G8*$$'%&'% 5K% ',%AE% 8,$?% I8#=)',787*+,%&'%
A(K%',%M""')8=,'L?%
Facteurs*:*
R 2+O7$% &'% -.+&#27*+,%D% .8--+.7% &'% Z+#*$% b8""+*$% .')*$% 8#% =+#6'.,')',7% MS.8#"7% )+,7.'% F#'% "'$%
2+O7$% $+,7% "*9'$% 8#>% niveaux* des* coûts* salariaux?% c8"8*.'% 3+.8*.'% 86'2% 238.='$% $+2*8"'$% '7% &'%
(a1(E%',%NEAA%I"'%-"#$%9"'69%&'$%=.8,&$%-8S$%'#.+-9',$L%r%-.*$'%',%2+)-7'%&#%,*6'8#%&'%=8))'%
-+#.%)'$#.'.%2'7%38,&*28-%
R rigidité* des* coûts* salariaux*D% $8"8*.'% )*,*)#)% 9"'69% r% -8$% &:8W#$7')',7% &'$% $8"8*.'$% .9'"$% ',%
4+,27*+,%&'%"8%$*7#87*+,%92+,+)*F#'1%,*%&'%2'""'%&#%)8.239%&#%7.868*"?%M"+.$%F#'%G8*$$'%&'$%$8"8*.'$%
&8,$% "'$% 8#7.'$% -8S$1% "'% $8"8*.'% .9'"% -8.% 7V7'% 2+,7*,#'% /% 8#=)',7'.% ',% P.8,2'?%
8G$',2'% &:8W#$7')',7% !%-;$'% $#.% "'$% -.+4*7$% &'$% ',7.'-.*$'$1% &+,2% $#.% "8% 2+)-97*7*6*79% &#% -8S$%
86'2%7#,,'"%&'%$+#$%*,6'$7*$$')',7$%'7%&'%230)8='?%
c8"8*.'%3+.8*.'%3+.$%238.='$%$+2*8"'$%*&',7*F#'%',7.'%P.8,2'%'7%M""')8=,'%)8*$%86'2%238.='$1%&'%AaK%-"#$%
9"'69%',%P.8,2'?%T3+*>%&'%-8$%&:8W#$7')',7%,#*7%/%"8%2+)-97*7*6*79%92+%&#%-8S$%'7%&+,2%8#>%,*6'8#>%&'%6*'%
&'$%2*7+S',$?%
]&9'%&:#,%23+2%&'%2+)-97*7*6*791%2/&%&:#,%7.8,$4'.7%&'%"8%238.='%&#%4*,8,2')',7%&'%"8%-.+7'27*+,%$+2*8"'%&'$%
',7.'-.*$'$%6'.$%&:8#7.'$%*)-07$?%m#7%D%$7*)#"'.%"8%2.+*$$8,2'%',%8)9"*+.8,7%"8%2+)-97*7*6*79%&'$%$'27'#.$%
'>-+$9$%/%"8%2+,2#..',2'%97.8,=;.'?%