Article Alexis Manescau

!"#$%&'()*+"(L’Ostéopathie-Précisément(
(
(
«"L’effet"placebo"»"en"ostéopathie":"Élément"nuisible"ou"essentiel?"
"
,-.$/-()0"(!&'1$2(304'2%0+(56768(90+"-0#(.+()"$1(9*+$20(:+"428(;<==(
,->$2-()0"(?@"$2#$04(:-"+A-(56768(B04."0(7C?*44*"(5676('#(30"$'D9$4'(5'2&0+"$'"2(5676(
(
(
(
Préambule*
"
E*+"(4*#"'(F-F*$"'(.'(G$4(.C-#+.'28(4*+2(0>*42(#'4#-(.'(F'2+"'"(2$(%'"#0$42(G0%#'+"2(2+AH'%#$G2(022*%$-2(
I(&0(F04$J"'(.'(G0$"'(.'(&C*2#-*)0#@'(0>0$'4#(+4'($4G&+'4%'(2+"(&C0F-&$*"0#$*4(.'(&C-#0#(.+()0#$'4#6(?'&0(
4*+2(0()&*4/-(0+(%K+"(.C+4(.-A0#(#'4+()0"(&'2(%@'"%@'+"2(.'(@0+#(4$>'0+('4(*2#-*)0#@$'(L(&C$4G&+'4%'(.'(
&C'GG'#()&0%'A*('2#(2*+"%'(.'(%*4G+2$*4(*+(.'()"*A&JF'('4("'%@'"%@'(F-.$%0&'8(F0$2('4('2#D$&(.'(FMF'(
'4("'%@'"%@'(*2#-*)0#@$N+'O(P#('4(#"0$#'F'4#8(N+'&('2#(&C$F)0%#(.'(%'#('GG'#('#(N+'&&'(>0&'+"(&+$(0##"$A+'D
#D*4(.'>04#(&C'GG$%0%$#-(.'(4*2($4#'">'4#$*42O(P4(>-"$#-8(N+'&("0))*"#(&C*2#-*)0#@$'(.'>"0$#D'&&'('4#"'#'4$"(
G0%'(I(&C'GG'#()&0%'A*O(P2#D%'(N+'(&'(G0$#(.'(2*+#'4$"(&C'GG'#()&0%'A*(.$2%"-.$#'"0$#(4*#"'()"*G'22$*4O((
(
?'#( 0"#$%&'( A$'4( N+C$42)$"-( .'2( )"*)*2( 2*+#'4+2( .042( 4*#"'( F-F*$"'( Q304'2%0+( ;<==R( 4C'2#( )02( +4(
2*FF0$"'(.'(4*#"'("'%@'"%@'6(S&("')"'4.(&'2(0"/+F'4#2(#'4+()0"(&'2(%@'"%@'+"2('4(*2#-*)0#@$'(0G$4(.'(
"-)*4."'(I(&0(N+'2#$*4(2+$>04#'(L(T(?*FF'4#(.'>"0$#D*4(G0$"'(.'(&0("'%@'"%@'('4(*2#-*)0#@$'OU((
"
Introduction*:*Aspect*équivoque*de*la*persuasion*et*de*l’effet*placebo*
"
5042(4*#"'(N+*#$.$'48(4*+2(0/$22*42(#*+H*+"2('4(G*4%#$*4(.'(4*2(>0&'+"28(.'(4*2(%"*V04%'2('#(.042(+4(
%*4#'1#'(2*%$*%+&#+"'&(.-G$4$6(W(#"0>'"2(4*#"'(%*FF+4$%0#$*4(>'"A0&'8()0"0(>'"A0&'('#(4*4(>'"A0&'(0$42$(
N+CI(#"0>'"2(&'(&04/0/'(.+(%*")28(.'2(2+//'2#$*42(.$"'%#'2('#($4.$"'%#'2(0%%*F)0/4'4#(%@0%+4'(.'(4*2(
)'42-'2( '#( 0%#$*426( 5'( %'( G0$#8( )*+"( M#"'( A$'4( %*F)"$2( '#( )*+"( *A#'4$"( %'( N+C*4( .-2$"'8( 4*+2( 0>*42(
"'%*+"2( %*42#0FF'4#( I( &C+20/'( .'( &0( )'"2+02$*4( '#( %'( .'( F04$J"'( $4#'4#$*44'&&'( *+( $4>*&*4#0$"'6( 90(
"@-#*"$N+'('2#(&C0"#(.'(&0()'"2+02$*4('#(.'(&0(%*F)*2$#$*4X('&&'()'+#(0+22$(M#"'(.-G$4$'()0"(&C-&*N+'4%'6(90(
)'"2+02$*4("@-#*"$N+'(2C*A#$'4#(.0>04#0/'('4(G0$204#(0))'&(I(&0(&*/$N+'(0$42$(N+C0+1()022$*42('#('&&'(4'(
.*$#()02(M#"'(%*4G*4.+'(0>'%(&0()'"2+02$*4(%*'"%$#$>'6(90(%*'"%$#$*4('2#()&+#Y#(*A#'4+'()0"(&0(%*4#"0$4#'(
)@V2$N+'('#(F*"0&'6((
(
!G$4( .C'4/0/'"( +4( %&$F0#( .'( %*4G$04%'( I( &C$4#-"$'+"( .'( &0( "'&0#$*4( #@-"0)'+#$N+'8( &'( #@-"0)'+#'( '#( &'(
)0#$'4#( G*4#( #*+2( .'+1( 0))'&( I( .$>'"2'2( 2#"0#-/$'2( "@-#*"$N+'2( #'&&'2( N+'( &C'F)0#@$'8( &'2( )"$4%$)'2( .'(
&C-%*+#'( 0%#$>'8( &C+20/'( .'2( F-#0)@*"'28( .'2( /'2#+'&&'2( '#( .'2( F$F$N+'28Z( %'2( *+#$&2( .'>$'44'4#( &'(
>-@$%+&'(N+$()'"F'#( 0+( )0#$'4#( .'( %*FF+4$N+'"( 20( )&0$4#'( '#( 0+( #@-"0)'+#'( )*+"( )*2'"( &'(.$0/4*2#$%(
0$42$( N+'( )*+"( )"*.$/+'"( &'( 2*$46( B'&*4( %'"#0$42( 0+#'+"28( %'2( -&-F'4#2( )2V%@*2*%$0+1( .'( &0( "'&0#$*4(
2*$/404#[2*$/4-(G*4#()0"#$'(.'2(-&-F'4#2(.C+4("$#+'&('#(&*"2N+'(A$'4(*"%@'2#"-8(%'&+$D%$(0(&'()*#'4#$'&(.'(
2+2%$#'"( +4'( "-)*42'( .'( /+-"$2*4( %@'\( &'( )0#$'4#( Q]0)#%@+^8( ;<<_8( ;<==X( 3*'"F04( '#( `*4028( ;<<_X(
a0"&'V8(=bbbR6(
(
?'2( .'"4$'"2( 0+#'+"2( 'F)&*$'4#( &'( #'"F'( T("$#+'&( .'( /+-"$2*4(U( )*+"( .-2$/4'"( +4( >02#'( 0F0&/0F'(
.C-&-F'4#2()2V%@*2*%$0+1(#'&2(N+'(&0()'"2+02$*48(&0(2+//'2#$*48(&C0##$#+.'()*2$#$>'8(&'()"*4*2#$%(*)#$F$2#'8(

&'(#*+%@'"8(&'2(%"*V04%'2('#(0+#"'2(02)'%#2(%*4#'4+2(.042(&C$4#'"0%#$*4('4#"'(&'()0#$'4#('#(&'(#@-"0)'+#'6(
c+'( %'( 2*$#( .'( G0d*4( $4#'4#$*44'&&'( *+( $4>*&*4#0$"'8( .042( &0( F-.'%$4'( *GG$%$'&&'( *+( 0&#'"40#$>'( '#(
)0"#$%+&$J"'F'4#('4(*2#-*)0#@$'()&+2$'+"2(.'(%'2(-&-F'4#2(2*4#('F)&*V-2(I(&C$4#-"$'+"(.C+4'(2-04%'6(?'2(
-&-F'4#2()2V%@*2*%$0+1()'+>'4#( /-4-"'"( )*#'4#$'&&'F'4#( .'2( 'GG'#2(%+"0#$G2()0"( &'( )@-4*FJ4'( N+C*4(
4*FF'( %*FF+4-F'4#( T(&C'GG'#( )&0%'A*(U6( 9C'GG'#( )&0%'A*( '2#( 2*+>'4#( .-%"$#( %*FF'( -#04#( 4*4(
2)-%$G$N+'8(F0$2( )*+"( ]0)#%@+^( Q;<==R( &C'GG'#( )&0%'A*( '2#( &C'GG'#( 2)-%$G$N+'( .'2( "$#+'&2(.'(/+-"$2*46( P4(
.C0+#"'2( F*#28( A$'4( N+'( %'2( -&-F'4#2( 2+AH'%#$G2( 0$'4#( +4'( >-"$#0A&'( >0&'+"( %+"0#$>'8($&2( 2*4#( 0+22$(
%*42$.-"-2(%*FF'(4+$2$A&'2(I(&0(F'2+"'(*AH'%#$>'(.'2('GG'#2(.$"'%#2(.C+4(#"0$#'F'4#6((
(
Problématique*:*Les*ECR*sont>ils*les*meilleurs*moyens*pour*développer*
l’ostéopathie?*
"
90(F-.'%$4'(*GG$%$'&&'('2#(I(&CJ"'(.+(%*4%')#(.'(&CP:3(T(evidence5based-medicine(U(*+(F-.'%$4'(G*4.-'(
2+"( .'2( .*44-'2( )"*A04#'26( P4( )0"#$'( .->'&*))-'( )*+"( )"*#-/'"( &0( )*)+&0#$*4( .'2( %@0"&0#0428( &CP:3(
%*42$.J"'(&'2(P?,(Q'220$2(%&$4$N+'2("04.*F$2-2R(%*FF'(&0("J/&'(.C*"(Q/*&.(2#04.0".R6(?C'2#(I(.$"'8(0V04#(&'(
)&+2(@0+#(4$>'0+(.'()"'+>'()0"F$(&'2(-#+.'2(%&$4$N+'2(Q:0""V8(;<<eX(9$%%$0".*4'('#(,+22*(;<<eX(a0V4'2(
;<<;R6(5'>04#(&'2(02)$"0#$*42(.'(&0(%*FF+40+#-(*2#-*)0#@$N+'(I(.->'&*))'"(20(2%$'4%'('#(I(M#"'()'"d+'(
.'(G0d*4(%"-.$A&'8(&C+20/'(.'2(P?,(0>'%(/"*+)'(%*4#"Y&'(#-F*$4('#()&0%'A*(2'FA&'(M#"'(&'(F*V'4(&'()&+2(
%*4>0$4%04#6(
((
9'(/"*+)'(%*4#"Y&'(#-F*$4('2#('F)&*V-(+2+'&&'F'4#(.042(&'2(P?,()*+"(F'2+"'"(&C->*&+#$*4(4*"F0&'(.'(&0(
F0&0.$'(0&*"2(N+'(&'(/"*+)'(%*4#"Y&'()&0%'A*('2#('F)&*V-()*+"('1%&+"'(&0()*22$A$&$#-(N+'(&C'GG$%0%$#-(.C+4(
#"0$#'F'4#(2*$#(0##"$A+0A&'(I(.'2(G0%#'+"2()2V%@*&*/$N+'26(9'()&0%'A*('4(F-.'%$4'('2#(/-4-"0&'F'4#(+4(
-&-F'4#($4'"#'(.C0))0"'4%'($.'4#$N+'(0+1(F-.$%0F'4#2(-#+.$-2('#(%'&+$D%$(0(&'()*#'4#$'&(.'(/-4-"'"(.'2(
'GG'#2( #@-"0)'+#$N+'2( )0"( .'2( F-%04$2F'2( N+$( 4'( 2*4#( )02( 2)-%$G$N+'2( I( %'+1( F$2( .'( &C0>04#( .042( &'(
#"0$#'F'4#( )*+"( '1)&$N+'"( &C'GG$%0%$#-6( 5'( %'( G0$#8( )+$2N+'( %'2( 'GG'#2( 4'( 2*4#( )02( .'2( %*42-N+'4%'2(
.$"'%#'2(.C+4(#"0$#'F'4#(F0$2()&+#Y#(.'2(%*42-N+'4%'2($4.$"'%#'2(.'(&C$4#'"0%#$*4('4#"'(&'()0#$'4#('#(&'(
#@-"0)'+#'( &*"2( .+( #"0$#'F'4#8( $&2( 4'( .*$>'4#( )02( M#"'( %*42$.-"-2( )*+"( )"*+>'"( &C'GG$%0%$#-( .C+4(
#"0$#'F'4#8(.C+4'(0))"*%@'(*+(.C+4'(F-#@*.'(Q9$%%$0".*4'('#(,+22*8(;<<eX(a0"#F048(;<<bX(a0&.'F04('#(
f4.'"g**.(;<=<R6(
(
7"8(&'2(P?,(*4#(-#-(.->'&*))-'2(I()"$*"$()*+"(*AH'%#$>'"(&C'GG$%0%$#-(.'2(F-.$%0F'4#2X(&'(F*.J&'(.'2(P?,(
0>'%(/"*+)'()&0%'A*(2C0))&$N+'(F$'+1(&*"2N+C*4(>'+#(F'2+"'"(&C'GG'#(2)-%$G$N+'(.C+4(F-.$%0F'4#(N+'(
&*"2N+C*4( >'+#( F'2+"'"( &C'GG'#( 2)-%$G$N+'( .C+4( #"0$#'F'4#( *2#-*)0#@$N+'8( &'2( %*4%&+2$*42( 2*4#( .'( &*$4(
)&+2(*AH'%#$>'2(Q9$%%$0".*4'('#(,+22*8(;<<eX(E0##'"2*48(;<<hX(B@'"F048(;<<iR6(f4'(.'2(%"$#$N+'2(&'2()&+2(
%*+"04#'2(0>'%(%'(#V)'(.'(F*.J&'(.'("'%@'"%@'('2#(N+C$&(0%%*".'(#"J2()'+(.'(>0&'+"(G0%#+'&&'(I(&C-#$*&*/$'(
.'(&0(&-2$*4(0$42$(N+C0+(%*4#'1#'(2*%$*%+&#+"'&8()2V%@*2*%$0&('#(0GG'%#$G(.042(&'N+'&(&'()0#$'4#(2'()"-2'4#'X(
&'2(%*4%&+2$*42(2*4#(#$"-'2(I()0"#$"(.'2(/-4-"0&$#-2(.C+4'()*)+&0#$*4(I(&C-#+.'('#(4'(#$'44'4#()02(%*F)#'(
.'2()0"#$%+&0"$#-2(.'(&C$4.$>$.+(QB0>0".8(;<<_X(E0##'"2*48(;<<hX(]*""8(=bb=X(B@'"F048(;<<iR6(B'&*4( ]*""(
Q=bie8(;bR8(0+#'+"(.+(%*4%')#(.'(&0(&-2$*4(*2#-*)0#@$N+'('#(.'(2*4(2'/F'4#(G0%$&$#-8(%C'2#()"-%$2-F'4#(%'(
N+$( .$2#$4/+'( &C0))"*%@'( *2#-*)0#@$N+'( .'( %'&&'( .'( &0( F-.'%$4'( *GG$%$'&&'(L( T(j'( #"0$#'"( N+'( &0( 2*+"%'(
0GG-"'4#'8(F-%04$N+'8(%C'2#(#"0$#'"(I(F*$#$-8(4-/&$/'"(+4'()0"#$'(#"J2($F)*"#04#'(.'(&C-#$*&*/$'(.'(&0(&-2$*4(
'#( 2*"#$"( &0( &-2$*4( .'( 2*4( %*4#'1#'6( ?'&0( 4'( >'+#( )02( .$"'( N+'( %@0N+'( *2#-*)0#@'( .'>"0$#( .'>'4$"(
)2V%@$0#"'8( F0$2( N+C$&( .*$#( )"'4."'( '4( %*42$.-"0#$*4( &C'4>$"*44'F'4#8( &'2( G0%#'+"2( 0GG'%#$G28( '#%68( .+(
)0#$'4#6(U(
(
(

Synthèse* du* débat*:* L’effet* placebo* est>il* un* élément* nuisible* ou*
essentiel?*
(
!$42$8(&0()"*A&-F0#$N+'('1)*2-'(.042(%'#(0"#$%&'(2C0"#$%+&'(0+#*+"(.'(%'2("-G&'1$*42(L(?*FF'4#(.*$>'4#(
M#"'(%*42$.-"-2(&'2('GG'#2()&0%'A*('4(*2#-*)0#@$'O(B*4#D$&2(.'2(4+$204%'2(0+1("-2+&#0#28(*+(2*4#D$&2( .'2(
)0"0FJ#"'2( '22'4#$'&2( )*+"( &C*A#'4#$*4( .'( %'+1D%$O( B+"( %'2( N+'2#$*428( +4( .-A0#( '4#"'( .'2( 0"/+F'4#2(
2%$'4#$G$N+'2('#()@$&*2*)@$N+'2('2#('4(%*+"26(
"
!>'%( )*+"( *AH'%#$G( .'( .->'&*))'"( &0( %"-.$A$&$#-( 2%$'4#$G$N+'( .'( &C*2#-*)0#@$'( '#( 20( &-/$#$F$#-( '4( #04#(
N+C0))"*%@'(F-.$%$40&'('GG$%0%'8(&'2(%@'"%@'+"2(*2#-*)0#@'2(9$%%$0".*4'('#(,+22*(Q;<<eR8(a0&.'F04('#(
f4.'"g**.(Q;<=<R(0$42$(N+'(&'( )"*G'22'+"('#(040#*F$2#'(a0"#F04( E@5( Q;<<b8(;<<eR(2#$)+&'4#( N+'( &'2(
*2#-*)0#@'2(4'(.'>"0$'4#()02()"*F*+>*$"(&C'GG$%0%$#-(.'(&C*2#-*)0#@$'()*+"(#"0$#'"(+4'(%*4.$#$*4(N+'(&'2(
P?,(*4#()"*+>-($4'GG$%0%'8(4$()"*F*+>*$"(.'2(0))"*%@'2(N+$(4C*4#()02(-#-()"*+>-'2()&+2('GG$%0%'2(N+'(
&C'GG'#( )&0%'A*6( 9$%%$0".*4'( '#( ,+22*( Q;<<eR( "'%*FF04.'4#( .'( &$F$#'"( 4*2( $4#'"0%#$*42( 0>'%( &'( )0#$'4#(
0G$4(.C$2*&'"(&C'GG'#(2)-%$G$N+'(Q&C$4/"-.$'4#(0%#$GR(.+(#"0$#'F'4#(*2#-*)0#@$N+'('#(0$42$(F$4$F$2'"(&'2(A$0$2(
.042(&'2(P?,6(
(
B'&*4('+18($&('2#($40%%')#0A&'8(I(&CJ"'(.'(&CP:38(.'(2C0%%*".'"(&'2(A$'4G0$#2(*A2'">-2(&*"2N+'(&0("'%@'"%@'(0(
)"*+>-( N+C'4( G0$#( &'2( A$'4G0$#2( *A2'">-2( .-%*+&'4#( .'2( 'GG'#2( $4.$"'%#2( %*4#'4+2( .042( #*+#'( "'&0#$*4(
2*$/404#[2*$/4-( *+( )$"'8( .'( &C->*&+#$*4( 4*"F0&'( .'( &0( F0&0.$'6( a0"#F04( Q;<<bR( "0H*+#'( N+'( %'(
%*F)*"#'F'4#($4.+$#( '4( '""'+"(&'( )0#$'4#( '#( &'(#@-"0)'+#'6( 5042(+4(%0F)8( &'2( )0#$'4#2( /+-"$22'4#( )0"(
'GG'#()&0%'A*8(*+('4%*"'8($&2(2'(%"*$'4#(/+-"$2(0&*"2(N+C'4(>-"$#-8(&'+"2(2$#+0#$*42(2'(.-#-"$*"'4#('#(.042(
&C0+#"'8( &C*2#-*)0#@'( '2#( %*4>0$4%+( N+'( &0( /+-"$2*4( .'( 2*4( )0#$'4#( '2#( &0( %*42-N+'4%'( .$"'%#'( .'( 2*4(
#"0$#'F'4#6( E*+"( a0"#F04( Q;<<bR( %'#( '4/"'40/'( '2#( )&+#Y#( F0&@'+"'+18( %0"( $&( 0( )*+"( 'GG'#( .C0>'+/&'"(
.0>04#0/'( &'( )0#$'4#( '#( &C*2#-*)0#@'( .'( &0( "-0&$#-X( .'>04#( &'2( 02)$"0#$*42( .'( &0( %*FF+40+#-(
*2#-*)0#@$N+'(I(.->'&*))'"(20(2%$'4%'('#(I(M#"'()'"d+'(.'(G0d*4(%"-.$A&'8(%'##'(%*4.+$#'(FJ4'"0$#(."*$#(
>'"2(+4(%+&D.'D20%6(
(
k*+#'G*$2( '#( 0>'%( &C$4#'4#$*4( +&#$F'( .'( G*"F+&'"( .'2( F*.J&'2( .'( "'%@'"%@'( &'2( )&+2( 0))"*)"$-2( )*+"(
&C'22*"( .'( &C*2#-*)0#@$'8( &'( 4'+"*)@V2$*&*/$2#'( E0##'"2*4( Q;<<hR8( /"04.'F'4#( $F)&$N+-( .042( &'(
.->'&*))'F'4#(.'(&0("'%@'"%@'('4(*2#-*)0#@$'8(2+//J"'(I(&0(%*FF+40+#-(*2#-*)0#@$N+'(.'("')'42'"(
0+1(N+'2#$*42(N+C'&&'()*2'(.042(&'(%0."'(.'(&CP:36(P4(2*FF'8(%'&&'2D%$(.*$>'4#(%0."'"(I(&0(G*$2(0>'%(&'2(
)"$4%$)'2()@$&*2*)@$N+'2('#(&0()"0#$N+'(.'(&C*2#-*)0#@$'6(5'(G0d*4(#"J2(0%#+'&&'8(]*""(Q=bb=R(F'4#$*44'(
N+C$&( '2#( '22'4#$'&( N+'( &C->0&+0#$*4( .'( &C'GG$%0%$#-( .+( #"0$#'F'4#( *2#-*)0#@$N+'( 2*$#( &C->0&+0#$*4( .'( &0(
)"0#$N+'('4(%&$4$N+'6(?l'2#DID.$"'(N+'(&0(#*#0&$#-(.'(&C$4#'"0%#$*4('4#"'(&'()0#$'4#('#(&'(#@-"0)'+#'(.*$#(M#"'(
)"$2'('4(%*42$.-"0#$*4()*+"(F'2+"'"(&C'GG$%0%$#-(.'(&C*2#-*)0#@$'6(74(4'()'+#(G"0/F'4#'"(&'(#"0$#'F'4#(
)*+"('4($2*&'"8(0""04/'"(*+( 2#04.0".$2'"(+4'()"*%-.+"'6(9C'GG'#()&0%'A*('4( *2#-*)0#@$'(G0$#()0"#$'(.'2(
'GG'#2( '2%*F)#-2( Q]*""8( =bb=X( E0##'"2*48( ;<<hR6( 5'( &0( 2*"#'8( )*+"( ->0&+'"( )&'$4'F'4#( &'( #"0$#'F'4#(
*2#-*)0#@$N+'8(N+'(%'(2*$#()*+"(2'2('GG'#2(*+()*+"(2'2(F-%04$2F'28($&(4'(G0+."0$#()02(#'4#'"(.'("'#$"'"(
&C$4/"-.$'4#( 0%#$G8( %*4#"0$"'F'4#( I( %'( N+'( 4*+2( "'%*FF04.'4#( 9$%%$0.*4'( '#( ,+22*( Q;<<eR6( E0##'"2*4(
Q;<<hR( 2$/40&'(N+'( 4*+2( .'>"$*42("'%*440m#"'( N+C$&(V( 0( )&+2$'+"2( $4/"-.$'4#2(0%#$G2( %*F)"$2( .042( &C'GG'#(
#*#0&6(5'()&+28(%'2($4/"-.$'4#2()'+>'4#(M#"'(4*4(2'+&'F'4#($4#'"0%#$G2('#(%+F+&0#$G2(F0$2(0>*$"(.'2('GG'#2(
'1)*4'4#$'&26(!$42$8(%*4%&+#(]*""(Q=bb=R8(%'(N+$8(.+()*$4#(.'(>+'(.'2(P?,8()0"0m#(%*FF'(+4'(4+$204%'(*+(
+4'( 2*+"%'( .C'""'+"( '2#8( .C+4( )*$4#( .'( >+'( *2#-*)0#@$N+'8( '22'4#$'&( )*+"( &C*A#'4#$*4( .'2( "-2+&#0#2(
%&$4$N+'26(

Discussion*:* L’efficacité* de* l’ostéopathie* doit>elle* être* déterminée* en*
fonction*de*la*rigueur*scientifique*ou*de*la*réalité*clinique?(
"
5C+4(%Y#-(*4(#"*+>'(&'2(.-G'42'+"2(.'(&0("$/+'+"(2%$'4#$G$N+'(N+$()"Y4'4#(.C0H+2#'"(4*2(F-#@*.'2()*+"(
'4#"'"8(.'(&0( F04$J"'(&0()&+2( %*4G*"F'()*22$A&'8(.042(&'(%0."'()"*%-.+"0&( .'2(P?,6(90( )"$*"$#-(2'FA&'(
.*4%(M#"'(&0("$/+'+"(.'(&0()"*%-.+"'(.'("'%@'"%@'6(5'(&C0+#"'(%Y#-8(*4(#"*+>'(&'2(.-G'42'+"2(.'2(A02'2(
)@$&*2*)@$N+'2(N+$(0GG$"F'4#(N+'(&0("$/+'+"(.'(&0()"*%-.+"'(4'(.*$#()02(0F*$4."$"(&'2('GG'#2(N+'(4*+2(
)0">'4*42(I(*A#'4$"6(90()"$*"$#-($%$(2'FA&'()&+#Y#(I()"*+>'"(0>04#(#*+#(&C'GG$%0%$#-(.'(&C*2#-*)0#@$'6(74(4'(
)'+#(4$'"('4("'%@'"%@'(&C$F)*"#04%'(.'(%'2(.'+1()*2$#$*428(%')'4.04#($&(2'FA&'(/-4-"0&'F'4#(.$GG$%$&'('4(
*2#-*)0#@$'(.C-#0A&$"(+4'(F-#@*.'(.'("'%@'"%@'(N+$()+$22'()&'$4'F'4#(%*""'2)*4."'(I(%'2(.'+1()*$4#2(
.'(>+'6(
(
?'(N+C$&(G0+#(-#0A&$"(0>04#(#*+#(%C'2#(N+'(&0(F-.'%$4'(*GG$%$'&&'(->*&+'(.042(+4(%0."'(#*#0&'F'4#(.$GG-"'4#(
.'2( F-.'%$4'2( 0&#'"40#$>'2( )*+"( .-#'"F$4'"( &'( 2*$4( 0))"*)"$-6( E&+2$'+"2()"*A&JF'2( %*4%')#+'&2(
2+A2$2#'4#(.042(&C0))&$%0#$*4(.+(F*.J&'(P?,()*+"(&0("'%@'"%@'('4(*2#-*)0#@$'6(j*#0FF'4#(I(%0+2'(.'(&0(
.$GG$%+&#-(I(F'##"'('4()&0%'(+4(/"*+)'(%*4#"Y&'()&0%'A*(%"-.$A&'8(&'2("-2+&#0#2(2'"*4#(#*+H*+"2(0$2-F'4#(
%*4#'2#0A&'26( 5'2(N+'2#$*42(%*F)&'1'2(%*4%'"404#( &'( %0"0%#J"'( -#@$N+'( .'( %'( N+'( "')"-2'4#'( +4( 2*$4(
&-/$#$F'( 2*4#( 2*+&'>-'26( ?*FF'4#( .*$#D*4( .-#'"F$4'"( &'( 2*$4( 0))"*)"$-O( 5-#'"F$4'"( &C'GG$%0%$#-(
#@-"0)'+#$N+'(.'2(F-.'%$4'2(0&#'"40#$>'2()0"(&C'F)&*$(.'2(P?,(4'(.*44'()02(+4()*"#"0$#(*AH'%#$G(.'(&0(
"-0&$#-( %&$4$N+'6( W( N+$( .'( .-%$.'"O( B'&*4( +4'( 0F-&$*"0#$*4( "'&0#$>'( .-#'"F$4-'( '4( G*4%#$*4( .C+4'(
%*F)0"0$2*4(I(+4(/"*+)'()&0%'A*8(*+(2'&*4(&0(2$/4$G$%0#$*4(%&$4$N+'(.'""$J"'(&0("-%+)-"0#$*4(.'(&0(204#-(
.C+4()0#$'4#(.-#'"F$4-'('4(G*4%#$*4(.'(20()"*)"'(&$/4'(.'("-G-"'4%'O((
(
?*FF'4#(.'>"0$#D*4(G0$"'(.'(&0("'%@'"%@'('4(*2#-*)0#@$'O(9*"2N+'(&C*2#-*)0#@$'('220$'(.'(%0."'"(.042(
&'(F*.J&'(.'2(P?,()*+"(H+2#$G$'"(&C'GG$%0%$#-(.'(2*4(0))"*%@'8('&&'()'".(2*4($.'4#$#-8(20(2)-%$G$%$#-6(?'##'(
.-F0"%@'()*+"()"*F*+>*$"(4*#"'(%"-.$A$&$#-('#(.->'&*))'"(4*#"'(2%$'4%'(FJ4'(>'"2(+4(%+&D.'D20%6(74(4'(
)'+#()"-#'4."'($2*&'"(&'2('GG'#2(.$"'%#2(.+(#"0$#'F'4#(.'2('GG'#2($4.$"'%#2(.'(&0("'&0#$*4(2*$/404#[2*$/4-(
0+22$( G0%$&'F'4#( N+'( .'( 2-)0"'"( &C$4/"-.$'4#( 0%#$G( .C+4'( )$&+&'6( c+$( )&+2( '2#8( '4( 0%%*".( 0>'%( &'2( A02'2(
)@$&*2*)@$N+'2( .'( &C*2#-*)0#@$'( #'&&'2( N+'( &0( &*$( .'( %0+2'( I( 'GG'#8( &0( 2#"+%#+"'( /*+>'"4'( &0( G*4%#$*48(
&C+4$#-( .+( %*")2( 0>'%( &C'2)"$#( '#( &C0+#*( /+-"$2*48( 4*+2( %"*V*42( N+'( &'2( G0%#'+"2( )2V%@*&*/$N+'2( N+$(
0%%*F)0/4'4#( &'( #"0$#'F'4#( 2*4#( .'2( )0"0FJ#"'2( #*+#( 0+22$( $F)*"#04#( I( %*42$.-"'"( #04#( )*+"( &'(
.->'&*))'F'4#(.'(4*#"'(2%$'4%'(N+'()*+"(F'2+"'"(4*#"'('GG$%0%$#-6((
(
E0"(%*4#"'8()+$2N+'(&'2("-2+&#0#2()*+"(.-F*4#"'"(&C'GG$%0%$#-(.+(#"0$#'F'4#(*2#-*)0#@$N+'(2*4#(0$2-F'4#(
%*4#'2#0A&'28( *4( .*$#( "'2#'"( )"+.'4#( .042( 4*#"'( G0d*4( .C'1)&$N+'"( &'2( F-%04$2F'2( N+$( 2*4#( I( &CK+>"'(
.'""$J"'(&C'GG$%0%$#-(.'(4*2($4#'">'4#$*426(S&('2#($F)*"#04#(.'(%*440m#"'(&C$F)*"#04%'(.'(&0(/"04.'+"(.'2(
'GG'#2()&0%'A*(&*"2(.'(4*2($4#'">'4#$*428(%0"($&(2'()'+#(N+'8(#"*)(2*+>'4#8(*4(0##"$A+'(&0(/+-"$2*4(.'(4*2(
)0#$'4#2(I(+4'(0))"*%@'(*2#-*)0#@$N+'(2)-%$G$N+'(0&*"2(N+C'4("-0&$#-8(&'2(A$'4G0$#2(.'(4*#"'($4#'">'4#$*4(
)'+>'4#( M#"'( )0"G*$2( &'2( %*42-N+'4%'2( $4.$"'%#'2( .'2( 'GG'#2( 4*4( 2)-%$G$N+'2( .'( &0( "'&0#$*4(
2*$/404#[2*$/4-6(?'#(02)'%#(F0&(-&+%$.-(.'(4*#"'()"0#$N+'(4+$#()*#'4#$'&&'F'4#(I(4*#"'(%"-.$A$&$#-('#(0+(
.->'&*))'F'4#( .'( 4*#"'( 2%$'4%'6( 3-%*440m#"'( &C$F)*"#04%'( .'( %'2( 'GG'#2( %*4#'4+2( .042( 4*2(
$4#'">'4#$*42()'+#(4*+2($4.+$"'('4('""'+"(0>'%(.'2(%*42-N+'4%'2()*#'4#$'&&'F'4#(4-G02#'2()*+"(&0(204#-(
.'(4*2()0#$'4#26(P4("'>04%@'8(%*440m#"'(&C$F)*"#04%'(.'(%'2('GG'#2('#("'%*440m#"'(&'(F*F'4#(*))*"#+4(
)*+"('4( G0$"'(+20/'8(4*+2( )'"F'#(.'( "-)*4."'( )&+2(H+2#'F'4#( 0+1(A'2*$42(.'( 4*2( )0#$'4#28(%'(N+$('4(
"'#*+"(0GG$4'(4*#"'(H+/'F'4#(%&$4$N+'(.*4%(4*#"'()0&)0#$*4('#(+&#$F'F'4#(4*#"'('GG$%0%$#-(#@-"0)'+#$N+'6(
5042( %'( 4*+>'0+( %*4#'1#'( &C0))"*%@'( "'2#'( &0( FMF'8( F0$2( .042( %'"#0$42( %028( %'( N+$( '1)&$N+'( 4*#"'(
'GG$%0%$#-('#(&'2(F-%04$2F'2('4(%0+2'()*+""0$'4#(M#"'(.$GG-"'4#6(

Conclusion*:*Même*approche,*différentes*justifications*
(
!$42$8()0"G*$2(&'2(A$'4G0$#2(*A2'">-2()'+>'4#()"*>'4$"(.'2('GG'#2(.$"'%#2(.'(&0(#'%@4$N+'(0&*"2(N+'(.C0+#"'2(
G*$2( $&2( )'+>'4#( )"*>'4$"( .'2( 'GG'#2( $4.$"'%#2( .'( &0( "'&0#$*46( k*+#( %*FF'( .042( %'"#0$42( %02( $&2( )'+>'4#(
)"*>'4$"(.'(&0(%*FA$40$2*4(.'2('GG'#2(.$"'%#2('#($4.$"'%#2(0&*"2(N+'(.042(.C0+#"'2(%02($&(2'()'+#(0+22$(N+'(
&'2( A$'4G0$#2( *A2'">-2( 4C0$'4#( "$'4( 0( >*$"( 0>'%( 4*2( $4#'">'4#$*426( !%#+'&&'F'4#8()*+>*42D4*+2( 0GG$"F'"(
N+'( 4*+2( 2*FF'2( )&'$4'F'4#( %*42%$'4#2( .'( %'( N+$( '2#( "'2)*420A&'( .'( &C0F-&$*"0#$*4( .'( &C-#0#( .+(
)0#$'4#O(
(
j*+2(-F'##*42(&C@V)*#@J2'(N+'(&C'GG$%0%$#-(.+(#"0$#'F'4#('2#()"*)*"#$*44'&&'F'4#("'&0#$>'(I(&0(N+0&$#-(
.'(&C$4#'"0%#$*46(5042(%'#(*"."'(.C$.-'8($&(4CV(0( )02(.C'GG'#()&0%'A*8($&(4CV( 0(N+C+4(.'/"-(.C'GG$%0%$#-('4(
G*4%#$*4( .C+4( .'/"-( .C$4#'"0%#$>$#-6( 9C0))"*%@'( *2#-*)0#@$N+'( )0"( 20( .-F0"%@'( @+F0$4'( '#( 20( /"04.'(
)"*1$F$#-(0>'%(&'()0#$'4#('2#( )'+#DM#"'()0"#$%+&$J"'F'4#(@0A$&$#-'(I(/-4-"'"(.'2( 'GG'#2()&0%'A*6(3$'+1(
%*F)"'4."'(4*#"'()*#'4#$'&(0>'%(%'()@-4*FJ4'('#(%*FF'4#(%'(F-%04$2F'(.'(/+-"$2*4(0/$#(I(#"0>'"2(
4*2(F-#@*.'2(2'"0$#(0&*"2(2*+@0$#0A&'6((
(
j*+2(%"*V*42(N+C$&('2#($F)-"0#$G(.'(2'42$A$&$2'"(&'2(-#+.$04#2(I(%'##'()"*A&-F0#$N+'6(E&+2$'+"2(A-4-G$%'2(
)'+>'4#( .-%*+&'"( .C+4( 0))"*G*4.$22'F'4#( .'2( %*440$2204%'2( '4#*+"04#( &'( )@-4*FJ4'( .'( &C'GG'#(
)&0%'A*( '#( 2+"( &0( >0&'+"( .'( 2'2( 'GG'#2( '4( *2#-*)0#@$'6( ?'( /'4"'( .'( .-%*+>'"#'( 2'"0$#( G*4.0F'4#0&( '4(
*2#-*)0#@$'8( %0"( $&( .-F*4#"'"0$#( I( N+'&( )*$4#( &0( %*F)*204#'( "'&0#$*44'&&'( '2#( $F)*"#04#'( )*+"( &'(
#"0$#'F'4#(.'(%'"#0$4'2(2*+GG"04%'26(W(4*#"'(0>$28(A$'4(N+'(%'##'(.-F0"%@'()*+"(&0(%"-.$A$&$#-(.'(4*#"'(
)"*G'22$*4('#()*+"(&'(.->'&*))'F'4#(.'(4*#"'(2%$'4%'(2*$#(A-4-G$N+'8(&'2()&+2(/"04.2(A-4-G$%'2(2'"*4#(
0>04#(#*+#()*+"(&0(204#-(.'(4*2()0#$'4#26(
(
(
Bibliographie*
(
!+A-8(E6(Q;<=<R6(9'2(0##$#+.'2(.+(#@-"0)'+#'(N+$()*#'4#$0&$2'4#(&'("'&n%@'F'4#('4(*2#-*)0#@$'(Q#@J2'R6(
?*&&J/'(.Co#+.'2(72#-*)0#@$N+'26(3*4#"-0&8(?040.06(
(
:0""V8( ?6( Q;<<eR6( k@'( "*&'( *G( '>$.'4%'( $4( 0&#'"40#$>'( F'.$%$4'L( ?*4#"02#$4/( A$*F'.$%0&( 04.(
04#@"*)*&*/$%0&(0))"*0%@'26(School-of-Social-Sciences-and-Law.-e;8()0/'2(;epeDqh6(
(
:-"+A-8( ?6( Q;<<iR6( 9C$4G&+'4%'( .'( &C$4#'4#$*4( .+( #@-"0)'+#'( 2+"( &'2( #$22+2( .+( )0#$'4#( Q#@J2'R6( ?*&&J/'(
.Co#+.'2(72#-*)0#@$N+'26(3*4#"-0&8(?040.06(
(
:$4/'&8(f68(9*"'4\8(`68(B%@*'&&8(P68(r'$&&'"8(?6('#(:s%@'&8(?6(Q;<<eR6(3'%@04$2F2(*G()&0%'A*(040&/'2$0(L("0??(
"'%"+$#'F'4#(*G(0(2+A%*"#$%0&(04#$4*%$%')#$>'6(Pain.-=;<Q=D;R8()0/'2(iD=q6(
(
?*+#*8(`6(Q=bbiR6(P>$.'4%'DA02'.(F'.$%$4'L(0(]+@4$04()'"2)'%#$>'(*G(0(#"042>'2#$#'(4*4D#@'*"V6(Journal-of-
Evaluation-in-Clinical-Practice.(pQpR8()0/'2(;ehDhq6(
(
5'2&0+"$'"28(36( Q;<<bR6(9'2('GG'#2(.+( #"0$#'F'4#( *2#-*)0#@$N+'( /&*A0&( 2+"( &0(F$/"0$4'('#( &C$4G&+'4%'( .'(
&C'GG'#( )&0%'A*( 2+"( &'2( "-2+&#0#2( .'( "'%@'"%@'-Q#@J2'R6-?*&&J/'( .Co#+.'2( 72#-*)0#@$N+'26( 3*4#"-0&8(
?040.06(
((