pierre hadot m`a fait voir la philo autrement

©"http://www.cles.com/enquetes/article/pierre6hadot6m6fait6voir6la6philo6autrement"
Page"1"sur"3"
PIERRE%HADOT%M'A%FAIT%VOIR%LA%PHILO%AUTREMENT%
par%Roger8Pol%Droit%
!
!
! "#! $%&&'(%#)! *+'! ,$'-.! ')! /01%2#.! &$%)2*+%2'#)! (%! &32(0.0&32'! -011'! +#!
'#)$%4#'1'#)! *+0)252'#6! -')! 211'#.'! 7$+52)! %! 8%2)! .0$)2$! ('.! 9$%#5'.! 257'.! 5'.!
:2:(20)3;*+'.!&0+$!('.!$'1'))$'!%+!-'#)$'!5'!(%!<2'=!>'!&32(0.0&3'!/09'$?@0(?A$02)!(+2!'#!
'.)!2#82#21'#)!$'-0##%2..%#)=!
! >%!&$'12;$'!802.!*+'!BC%2!$'#-0#)$7!@2'$$'!D%50)6!2(!%!82#2!&%$!1C%<0+'$!*+'!BC%<%2.!
8%2((2!('!)+'$=!"#!B+2#!EFGH6!I!(C0--%.20#!5C+#'!#0+<'(('!752)20#!5CJ!"K'$-2-'.!.&2$2)+'(.!')!
&32(0.0&32'!%#)2*+'!L6!BC%<%2.!-0#.%-$7!I!.0#!)$%<%2(6!'#-0$'!&$'.*+'!2#-0##+!5+!&+:(2-6!
+#'!-3$0#2*+'!5+!B0+$#%(!>'!M0#5'!2#)2)+(7'!J!M%#2;$'.!5'!<2<$'6!1%#2;$'.!5'!52.-0+$2$=!
@2'$$'!D%50)!:0+('<'$.'!#0)$'!21%9'!5'!(%!&32(0.0&32'!%#)2*+'!L=!NCO!'K&(2*+%2.!-011'#)!
-'!-3'$-3'+$!52.-$')6!5C%&&%$'#-'!105'.)'6!0&7$%2)!&%$!.0#!)$%<%2(6!(02#!5'.!&$0B'-)'+$.!
')!5'.!12-$0.6!+#'!.0$)'!5'!$7<0(+)20#=!P<'-!+#!.%<02$!7&0+.)0+8(%#)!5'!&$7-2.20#!')!+#'!
-(%$)7! 5'! .)O('! %--'..2:('! I! )0+.6! .29#'! 5'! (C7(79%#-'! 5'.! 9$%#5.6! 2(! '#9%9'%2)! +#!
-3%#9'1'#)!.2!&$080#5!*+C0#!&'+)!&%$('$!5C+#!J!%<%#)!L!')!5C+#!J!%&$;.!L=!!!
Modifier%l’existence!!
! P<%#)! (+26! '#! '88')6! 0#! -0#.257$%2)! &$'.*+'! )0+B0+$.! (%! &32(0.0&32'! -011'! +#'!
0--+&%)20#! &+$'1'#)! 2#)'(('-)+'(('=! ")$'! &32(0.0&3'6! -C7)%2)! )370$2.'$6! 'K%12#'$! 5'.!
-0#-'&).6!57-0$)2*+'$!5'.!)370$2'.6!1'))$'!I!(C7&$'+<'!(%!-037$'#-'!5'!.O.);1'.!&(+.!0+!
102#.!.0&32.)2*+7.=!Q'))'!%-)2<2)7!.'!&0+$.+2<%2)!I!)$%<'$.!5'.!%#%(O.'.6!%$9+1'#)%)20#.6!
5710#.)$%)20#.6! $78+)%)20#.6! $73%:2(2)%)20#.R! Q'! #C7)%2)! )0+B0+$.! *+'! J!1%#2;$'.! 5'!
52.-0+$2$!L!S! -0+$.! ')! -0#87$'#-'.6! %$)2-('.! ')! (2<$'.=! >'.! *+'.)20#.! &32(0.0&32*+'.!
7<0*+%2'#)! 5'.! &$0:(;1'.! 5'! :$259'6! 5C7-3'-.! 0+! 5'! 97017)$2'! 5%#.! (C'.&%-'!S! %$5+.! I!
$7.0+5$'!')!*+2!#'!-3%#9'#)!(%!<2'!5'!&'$.0##'!T!
! P&$;.! (CU+<$'! 5'! @2'$$'! D%50)6! -'))'! &32(0.0&32'! .%#.! 21&%-)! %+-+#! .+$!
(C'K2.)'#-'!.'1:('!7)$%#9'6!<02$'!-%5+*+'=!Q'!*+C2(!%!&'$12.!5'!-01&$'#5$'6!&$'.*+'!5'!
)0+-3'$! 5+! 5029)6! -C'.)! *+'! (%! &32(0.0&32'! &0..;5'! +#'! 521'#.20#! '..'#)2'(('1'#)!
&$%)2*+'=!QC'.)!+#!'K'$-2-'6!+#!'#)$%4#'1'#)6!+#'!.7$2'!5C%-)'.!*+2!105282'#)!(C'K2.)'#-'=!
P+!(2'+!5'!B0+'$!%<'-!5'.!257'.!-011'!0#!&0+..'!5'.!&20#.6!('!&32(0.0&3'!.C'#9%9'6!&0+$!
5'! :0#6! 5%#.! 5'.! J!1%#2;$'.! 5'! <2<$'!L6! 5'.! &7$2&('.! *+0)252'#.! *+2! 17)%10$&30.'#)!
$%52-%('1'#)! .%! )$%B'-)02$'=! P+B0+$5C3+26! -'.! %882$1%)20#.! .0#)! 5'<'#+'.! &$'.*+'!
:%#%('.=!QC'.)!%+K!)$%<%+K!5'!@2'$$'!D%50)6!')!I!('+$!2#8(+'#-'6!*+C0#!502)!-'!:%.-+('1'#)=!
! N'!#'!.%<%2.!&%.6!I!-'!101'#)?(I6!*+'!-'))'!$'-0##%2..%#-'!&+:(2*+'!5'!.0#!)$%<%2(!
%<%2)!'+!&0+$!'88')6!5;.!('!('#5'1%2#6!5'!8%2$'!.%+)'$!(%!&01&'!:20(092*+'!50#)!-'!9$%#5!
-%$52%*+'! 7)%2)! 7*+2&7=! V(! #'! 1C%! 'K&(2*+7! (C%<'#)+$'! *+C+#! %#! &(+.! )%$5=! @%$'2(('.!
-2$-0#.)%#-'.!-$7'#)!5'.!(2'#.=!Q'!.%<%#)!*+'!BC%512$%2.!1C%!30#0$7!5'!.0#!%12)27=!W0+.!
#0+.!.011'.6!%+!-0+$.!5'.!<2#9)!%##7'.!.+2<%#)'.6!.0+<'#)!$')$0+<7.=!
! Q'.!$'#-0#)$'.!1C0#)!&'$12.!5'!12'+K! &$'#5$'! (%! 1'.+$'! 5+! -3%#9'1'#)! 5C%K'!
*+C2(! 0&7$%2)=! W%9+;$'6! 0#! %:0$5%2)! @(%)0#! ')! P$2.)0)'! X!1%2.! 79%('1'#)! "&2-+$'6! ('.!
.)0Y-2'#.6!('.!-O#2*+'.6!('.! .-'&)2*+'.R!X!%<%#)!)0+)! -011'! 5'.! J!%+)'+$.!L!%O%#)!&0+$!
:+)!+()21'!5'!$7529'$!5'.!(2<$'.6!5C'K&0.'$!('+$!-0#-'&)20#!5+!10#5'6!5'!8%2$'!-0##%4)$'!

©"http://www.cles.com/enquetes/article/pierre6hadot6m6fait6voir6la6philo6autrement"
Page"2"sur"3"
('+$!50-)$2#'=!N'!-01&$2.!*+'!&0+$!@2'$$'!D%50)6!)0+)'!-'))'!%&&$0-3'!7)%2)!8%+..'=!Z'(0#!
(+26!(%!.'+('!*+'.)20#!*+2!21&0$)%2)!I!-'.!-3'$-3'+$.!5'!.%9'..'!7)%2)!'#!8%2)!S!J!Q011'#)!
<2<$'![!Q011'#)!$'#5$'!(C'K2.)'#-'!&(+.!3+1%2#'6!(%!<0(0#)7!&(+.!-0#80$1'!I!(%!#%)+$'6!
(%!&'#.7'!12'+K!%B+.)7'!%+!:2'#![!L!
! \%2$'! 5'.! (2<$'.! #C7)%2)! 50#-! &%.! ('+$! :+)=! Q'! #C7)%2)! *+C+#! 10O'#6! +#! 'K'$-2-'!
&$%)2*+'! &%$12! 5C%+)$'.=! >'+$! .'+(! 0:B'-)28! 7)%2)! (%! .%9'..'! X!.0+.! ('.! #01.! 52<'$.! 5'!
J!<'$)+!L6! J!B+.)2-'!L6! J!:0#3'+$!L6! J!.7$7#2)7!L6! ')-=! @2'$$'! D%50)! 1C%! &(+.2'+$.! 802.!
'K&(2*+76! )'K)'.! '#! 1%2#6! -011'#)! -'! :+)! +#2*+'! 5'! )$%#.80$1%)20#! 5'! .02! 0$2'#)%2)!
)0+)'!(C%-)2<2)7!&32(0.0&32*+'!5'.!,$'-.!')!5'.!/01%2#.=!V(!1C%$$2<%2)!5C0:B'-)'$!*+'!-'.!
&'#.'+$.!#'!)$%2)%2'#)!&%.!'K-(+.2<'1'#)!5'!(%!.%9'..'6!*+C2(.!.'!&$70--+&%2'#)!%+..26!&%$!
'K'1&('6! 5'! &3O.2*+'6! 5'! 1%)371%)2*+'.! 0+! 5'! &0(2)2*+'=! Z%! $7&0#.'! 7)%2)! )0+B0+$.! (%!
1]1'!S!-C'.)!&0+$!%--75'$!I! (%!.%9'..'!*+C2(! 8%+)! -01&$'#5$'!(C0$9%#2.%)20#!5+!10#5'6!
9$^-'! I! (%! &3O.2*+'6! 0+! :2'#! (%! .)$+-)+$'! 5'.! 80$1'.6! 9$^-'! %+K! 1%)371%)2*+'.6! 0+!
'#-0$'!(%!-0#.)$+-)20#!5'!(%!Q2)7!B+.)'6!9$^-'!I!(%!$78('K20#!&0(2)2*+'=!
! /78+927!%+!.+5!5'!@%$2.6!5%#.!.%!1%2.0#!.0+.!('.!%$:$'.6!@2'$$'!D%50)!'K&(2*+%2)!
*+'!(%!)^-3'!&$2#-2&%('!5'.!%#-2'#.!#C7)%2)! &%.!5C2#<'#)'$!5'.!50-)$2#'.6!1%2.!&(+)_)!5'!
('.!2#-0$&0$'$!&'+!I!&'+!5%#.!('+$.!9'.)'.!*+0)252'#.=!P+!&$2K!5'!-'))'!%.-;.'!`('!)'$1'!
%Y.a;.2.6!'#!9$'-6!.29#282'!J!'#)$%4#'1'#)6!'K'$-2-'!Lb6!('.!257'.!)$%#.80$1'#)!$7'(('1'#)!
(%! <2'=! J!>%! &32(0.0&32'6! 52.%2)! Z7#;*+'6! #0+.! 2#-2)'! I! 8%2$'6! #0#! I! 52$'=!L! Q'! )$%2#2#9!
&'$1%#'#)6! @2'$$'! D%50)! (C%! 12.! '#! (+12;$'! '#! 7)+52%#)! ('.! J!'K'$-2-'.! .&2$2)+'(.!L!
'88'-)+7.! &%$! ('.! &32(0.0&3'.=! @%$! 'K'1&('!S! 'K%12#'$! .'.! %-)'.! ')! .'.! &'#.7'.! 5'! (%!
B0+$#7'=! QC'.)! -'! *+'! 8%2)! M%$-! P+$;('6! (C'1&'$'+$?&32(0.0&3'!S! -3%*+'! .02$6! .0+.! .%!
)'#)'6!'#!9+'$$'!-0#)$'!('.!:%$:%$'.!.+$!('.!:0$5.!5+!A%#+:'6!2(!$7529'!*+'(*+'.!(29#'.!
&0+$! -3'$-3'$! .C2(! %! 7)7! -0#80$1'6! %+! 82(! 5'.! 3'+$'.6! %+K! &$7-'&)'.! 5'! .'.! 1%4)$'.!
.)0Y-2'#.=!Z'.!J!&'#.7'.!L!#'!.0#)!&%.!$75297'.!&0+$!8%2$'!+#!(2<$'6!1%2.!&0+$!.C'#)$%4#'$!
B0+$!%&$;.!B0+$!I!&$09$'..'$!<'$.!(%!.%9'..'=!
Se%concentrer%sur%l’instant%présent!
!c#!B0+$!*+'!BC2#.2.)%2.6!<0+(%#)!.%<02$!*+'(!'K'$-2-'!('!.%<%#)!(+2?1]1'!&$%)2*+%2)!
&'+)?])$'6!@2'$$'!D%50)! $'-0##+)! *+'!(C'#)$%4#'1'#)! I! (%!-0#-'#)$%)20#! .+$! ('!101'#)!
&$7.'#)! %<%2)! 7)76! &0+$! (+26! )0+)! %+! (0#9! 5'! .%! <2'6! 5C+#! 9$%#5! .'-0+$.=! >%! 1%K21'! 5'!
,0')3'6! J!('! &$7.'#)! .'+(! '.)! #0)$'! :0#3'+$!L6! (C%--01&%9#%2)! -0#.)%11'#)=! "#! 8%2)6!
&(+.2'+$.!5'.!'K'$-2-'.!.&2$2)+'(.!%#)2*+'.!)$%<'$.'#)!('.!.2;-('.=!P2#.26!J!-0#)'1&('$!('.!
%-)2<2)7.! 3+1%2#'.! 5'&+2.! ('! 3%+)! 5C+#'! 10#)%9#'! 21%92#%2$'!L! .'! $')$0+<'! %+..2! :2'#!
-3'd!('.!1O.)2*+'.!-3$7)2'#.!*+'!5%#.!('!J!M2-$0179%.!L!5'!e0()%2$'=!J!Z'!-0#-'#)$'$!.+$!
(C2#.)%#)!&$7.'#)!L!'#! &'$-'<%#)!.0#!-%$%-);$'!+#2*+'!X!2$$7&7)%:('! ')! 2$$'&$05+-)2:('!X!
-0##%4)!(+2!%+..2!5C2##01:$%:('.!$'&$2.'.6!5'&+2.!"&2-+$'!B+.*+CI!,0')3'!')R!D%50)=!!
! Q%$! B'! .+2.! -0#<%2#-+! *+C2(! O! %<%2)! $7'(('1'#)! +#! .%9'! 5%#.! -')! 7$+52)! 50#)! (%!
)$%B'-)02$'! &'$.0##'(('! #C'+)! $2'#! 5C+#! (0#9! 8('+<'! )$%#*+2(('=! W7! 5%#.! +#'! 8%12(('!
'K)$]1'1'#)!-%)30(2*+'6!@2'$$'!D%50)6!*+%#5!2(!&%$(%2)!5'!.0#!J!'#8%#-'!I!(C'%+!:7#2)'!L6!
#C'.*+2..%2)! *+C+#! 5'12?.0+$2$'=! Q%$! .%! 1;$'! #C%<%2)! &%.! 21%92#7! *+C2(! &f)! .+2<$'! +#'!
%+)$'! <02'! *+'! ('! .'$<2-'! 5'! A2'+=! P! Eg!%#.6! ('! <02-2! %+! &')2)! .712#%2$'!h! I! ig6! ('! <02(I!
0$50##7!&$])$'=!j+'(*+'.!%##7'.!&(+.!)%$56!2(!'#)$'!%+!QW/Z!h!I!kg!%#.6!2(!*+2))'!(C"9(2.'=!
P!lg6!2(!%$$2<'!%+!Q0((;9'!5'!\$%#-'6!%257!&%$!M2-3'(!\0+-%+()6!+#!5'!.'.!&$'12'$.!('-)'+$.!
%512$%)28.=! "#)$'?)'1&.6! ('! -3'$-3'+$! %! '1&$+#)7! +#! .2#9+(2'$! &%$-0+$.! .0+)'$$%2#6!

©"http://www.cles.com/enquetes/article/pierre6hadot6m6fait6voir6la6philo6autrement"
Page"3"sur"3"
&%..%#)! &%$! 5'.! %##7'.! 5'! )$%<%2(! 0:(297! .+$! +#! $37)'+$! $01%2#! &'+! %))2$%#)6! M%$2+.!
e2-)0$2#+.6!')!82#%('1'#)!+#'!-3%2$'!I!(C"-0('!&$%)2*+'!5'.!3%+)'.!7)+5'.=!
!NC'+.!+#! B0+$!(%! .+$&$2.'!5'! (C'#)'#5$'!52$'! *+C2(!%<%2)! )$%5+2)!('! J!m$%-)%)+.!L! 5'!
>+5n29!o2))9'#.)'2#!50#)!2(!%<%2)!7)76!I!(%!82#!5'.!%##7'.!EFpg6!+#!5'.!&$'12'$.!('-)'+$.!
'#!\$%#-'=!A'!&$0-3'!'#!&$0-3'6!B'!57-0+<$2.!*+'!@2'$$'!D%50)!#C7)%2)!&%.!.'+('1'#)!+#!
8%:+('+K! -0##%2..'+$! 5'! (%! &32(0.0&32'! %#)2*+'6! )$%5+-)'+$! ')! -011'#)%)'+$! 5'! M%$-!
P+$;('6! @(0)2#! 0+! @0$&3O$'=! V(! 7)%2)! 79%('1'#)! 8%12(2'$! 5'.! 105'$#'.6! 50##%2)!
(C21&$'..20#!5C%<02$!8$7*+'#)7!('!1%)2#!1]1'!M0#)%29#'6!,0')3'!0+!q'$9.0#=!>C32.)02$'!
5'.!.-2'#-'.! ')!5'.! -0#-'&)20#.!5'! (%!#%)+$'! (+2! 7)%2)! %+..2! 8%12(2;$'6! -011'! (C%!$7<7(7!
.+$! ('! )%$5! (C+#! 5'! .'.! 5'$#2'$.! (2<$'.6! J!>'! e02('! 5CV.2.=! "..%2! .+$! (C32.)02$'! 5'! (C257'! 5'!
W%)+$'!L=! r#! O! 57-0+<$'! *+C2(! 1%4)$2.'6! %<'-! +#'! %2.%#-'! 57-0#-'$)%#)'6! %+..2! :2'#! ('.!
1%K21'.! 5CD7$%-(2)'! *+'! ('.! U+<$'.! 5'! q%-0#6! ,%(2(7'6! Z-3'((2#96! D'25'99'$6! -'#)!
%+)$'.R!
! >'!&(+.!%512$%:('!.%#.!50+)'!'.)!*+'!@2'$$'!D%50)!$'8+.%2)!0:.)2#71'#)!5C])$'!+#!
90+$0+!')!.'!9%$5%2)!:2'#!5'!52$'!-011'#)!2(!-0#<2'#)!5'!<2<$'=!V(!.'!-0#)'#)%2)!5'!8%2$'!
'#)'#5$'6! %+..2! 'K%-)'1'#)! *+'! &0..2:('6! (%! <02K! 5'.! 9$%#5.=! N'! #C%2! &%.! 82#26! &0+$! 1%!
&%$)6! 5'! (+2! '#! ])$'! $'-0##%2..%#)=! V(! .'! &0+$$%2)! *+'! -3%-+#! 5C'#)$'! #0+.6! +#! B0+$! 0+!
(C%+)$'6!&+2..'!'#!52$'!%+)%#)=!!