Un problème « réchauffé » ? Les changements

!
"!
!
!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !
!
!
!
"#!$%&'()*+!,!%-./0122-!3!4!
!
!"#$%&'()"*"(+#$%,-*'+-./"#$0'(#$,"#$*10-'#$)1(12',-#+"#$
344563477$
$
!
!
50$$&%6!7+!%+./+%./+!
!
8("$"(./9+"$*'(0'+1"$:'2$,"$GIS$«$Climat,$environnement$et$société$»$"+$21',-#1"$0"$
(;<"*=2"$3477$>$?/-,,"+$3473$0'(#$,"$%'02"$des$‘Etudes$de$l’IFP’$
!
!
8+0#9:0$6;<6+!=&*'>!!
#$%&'()!*)!+,-./()-+)0!)-!0,+1,2,31)!*)0!4/*1%05!!
?!!
@;#.+#6!5&*0#+6!!
#6-3/-1)7(!*89'7*)05!
!
!
AB+.! C&-*;+! =/0%%;)%+D! E-0! =%+<6&6D! F;*&#+! E0.G+%'01+%D! A*-(;0!
H0(&.D! I&#&%;#+! 5+1<<0%7D! =/0%(+<! F0%%016+!#9'7*1%-'0! )-! $%0')(5!+6!
I-()#+!J1K+77+G&!#6-3/-1)7()!*8/'7*)05!
!
H&1%! .;6+%! .+! %0$$&%6!L! :,4;<! =)%->?%@'10')! )'! A,4%-)'! B1-+)-'C! 8($ :2;=,@*"$
21%&'/AA1$B$!"#$%&'()"*"(+#$%,-*'+-./"#$0'(#$,"#$*10-'#$)1(12',-#+"#$344563477C!A%@@,('!
*)! ()+D)(+D)C! 6-0'1'7'! E(%-F%10! *)! G()00)! *)! 28H-1I)(01'/! G%(10! J! K! L6M! N!:214%'C!
)-I1(,--)4)-'!)'!0,+1/'/!OC!G%(10C!JP"J!
!
G,7(!@270!*)!()-0)13-)4)-'C!4)(+1!*)!+,-'%+')(!=)%->?%@'10')!:,4;<!Q!C='D34E)*'-,F%;*!

!
J!
Remerciements*!
!
:)!'(%I%12! %! ;/-/.1+1/! *7! 0,7'1)-! *87-! +)('%1-! -,4;()! *)! @)(0,--)0! %7RS7)22)0!
-,70!0,7D%1',-0!%*()00)(!*)0!()4)(+1)4)-'0!01-+T()0U!!
!
V,7'! *8%;,(*C! 2)0! 01R! /'7*1%-'0! *)! $%0')(! *)! 28-A:!S71C! %I)+! 28%1*)! *8W/2T-)!
L7X)**)Y,C!,-'!@(,*71'C!0)@'!4,10!*7(%-'C!2)0!*,--/)0!Z!@%('1(!*)0S7)22)0!-,70!%I,-0!
@7! /'%;21(! 2)0! (/072'%'0! )R@,0/0! 1+1U! [,70! )0@/(,-0! S78120! '1()(,-'! @(,.1'! *)! +)'')!
)R@/(1)-+)!)'!2)7(!)R@(14,-0!',70!-,0!I\7R!*)!(/7001')U!!
!
[,0!()4)(+1)4)-'0!)'!-,'()!()+,--%100%-+)!I,-'!)-071')!%7R!()0@,-0%;2)0!*7!L6M!
)'! )-! @%('1+721)(! Z! M<2I1)! =,700%74)! )'! :D%-'%2! G%+')%7U! M%-0! 2)7(! +,-.1%-+)! )'! 2)7(!
+,4@(/D)-01,-C! +)! @(,])'! S71! %! @(10! 2)! @%('1! *)! .%1()! %I%-+)(! )-0)4;2)! @/*%3,31)! )'!
()+D)(+D)!0+1)-'1.1S7)!-8%7(%1'!@%0!@7!I,1(!2)!],7(U!62!.%7'!/3%2)4)-'C!)'!7-)!.,10!*)!@270C!
()4)(+1)(!2)!L6M!*8)-+,7(%3)(!2)0!)-S7^')0!)-!0+1)-+)0!0,+1%2)0!07(!2)0!)-])7R!21/0!%7R!
+D%-3)4)-'0!+214%'1S7)0U!
!
V,7')!28/S71@)!S71!%!4)-/!+)'')!/'7*)!0,7D%1')!()4)(+1)(!2)0!()0@,-0%;2)0!)'!2)0!
*,+74)-'%210')0!*)! 286[_!@,7(! 2)7(!0,7'1)-C! 2)7(! /+,7')! )'! 2)7(0! +,-0)120!S71! -,70!,-'!
(/3721T()4)-'! .%+121'/! 2%! '`+D)U! [,70! )0@/(,-0! %I,1(! @(,+D%1-)4)-'! *)! -,7I)22)0!
,++%01,-0!*)!+,,@/()(!%I)+!)7R!@,7(!Z!-,7I)%7!;/-/.1+1)(!*)0!)R+)22)-')0!+,-*1'1,-0!*)!
'(%I%12!S78120!-,70!,..()-'U!!
!
9-.1-C! -,70! ()4)(+1,-0! [%'D%21)! M,--%+! #*1()+'(1+)! *)! 281.@5! %1-01! S7)! B%2/(1)!
a)I122%(*!#*1()+'(1+)!*)0!/'7*)05!S71!,-'!)-+,7(%3/!)'!.%I,(10/!2%!(/%210%'1,-!*)!+)!'(%I%12!
)-!*/@1'!*)0!+,-'(%1-')0!7-1I)(01'%1()0!*)0!7-0!)'!*)0!!%7'()0U!
!
!
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
!"#$:2;:;#$"G:2-*1#$0'(#$%"$2'::;2+$(H"()')"(+$./"$,"/2#$'/+"/2#F$

!
b!
Résumé!
c)! @,1-'! *81-')((,3%'1,-! *7! '1'()! *)! +)! (%@@,('! -8)0'! @%0! 1--,+)-'U!
G,7(! ;)%7+,7@C! 2)0! +D%-3)4)-'0! +214%'1S7)0! +,-0'1'7)-'! 7-! @(,;2T4)!
(/+D%7../C! @%00/! *)! 4,*)C! S71! -81-'/()00)! @270! 3(%-*! 4,-*)U! G,7('%-'C! Z!
();,7(0!*)!+)'')!1-')(@(/'%'1,-!*7!0)-0!+,447-C!28)R%4)-!0+1)-'1.1S7)!*)!2%!
4/*1%'10%'1,-!*)!2%!S7)0'1,-!*7!+214%'!4,-'()!S7)!+8)0'!@(/+10/4)-'!@%(+)!
S78)22)!)0'!@%(I)-7)!Z!1-'/()00)(!2)0!*/+1*)7(0!01'7/0!%7!0,44)'! *)!289'%'!
S7)!+)'')!S7)0'1,-!%C!)-!'%-'!S7)!')22)C!I7!0%!I101;121'/!4/*1%'1S7)!*/+21-)(!
*)@710!JPPdU!!
9-'()!2%!.1-!*)0!%--/)0!"eeP!)'!JPPdC!2)0!)-'()@()-)7(0"!*7!@(,;2T4)!
+214%'1S7)! #0+1)-'1.1S7)0C! )R@)('0C! #D%7'05! .,-+'1,--%1()0C! ],7(-%210')0!
0@/+1%210/0! ,7! )-+,()! N!4121'%-'05! 08)4@2,1)-'! Z!2)! I%2,(10)(!
4/*1%'1S7)4)-'C! -,'%44)-'!)-! 4)''%-'!)-!%I%-'! 0)0! %0@)+'0! ./*/(%')7(0!
@,7(!4,-'()(!S7812!1-'/()00)!)'!+,-+)(-)!',7'!2)!4,-*)U!_!@%('1(!*)!JPPdC!
*)0!.%1'0!@,21'1S7)0! #*,-'! 2)! L()-)22)! 9-I1(,--)4)-'5!I1)--)-'! +,7(,--)(!
+)'')! )-'()@(10)! 0<4;,21S7)!)'! 2%! S7)0'1,-! *7! +214%'!%+S71T()!
@(,3()001I)4)-'!7-!0'%'7'!@7;21+!-,7I)%7C!+)271!*)!@(,;2T4)!4%])7(!@,7(!
2)0!*1(13)%-'0!*)!289'%'U!f(!Z!@%('1(!*7!4,4)-'!,g!2)0!@(,4,')7(0!*)!2%!+%70)!
+214%'1S7)!,-'!%'')1-'!+)'!,;])+'1.C!2)7(!4,;1210%'1,-!@()-*!7-)!',7(-7()!)'!
7-!0)-0!*1../()-'0U!c%!+,-.137(%'1,-!S78120!.,(4)-'!@)7'!0)!4,*1.1)(!)'!%I)+!
)22)!2%!4%-1T()!*,-'!2)!@(,;2T4)!)0'!%@@(/D)-*/!*%-0!2)0!4/*1%0U!!
V(,10!*<-%41S7)0!0,+1%2)0!I,-'!%1-01!08%+'1I)(!*%-0!2)!@(,2,-3)4)-'!
*)!+)'')!+/2/;(%'1,-!4/*1%'1S7)!)'!@,21'1S7)!*7!@(,;2T4)U!:)22)0>+1!-)!0,-'!
@%0!(%*1+%2)0!)'!)22)0!-)!;,72)I)(0)-'!@%0!28/@1+)-'()!0,+1%2!)'!0<4;,21S7)!
*7! @(,;2T4)U! 922)0! @)(4)'')-'! 014@2)4)-'! *)! +,4@()-*()! @,7(S7,1! 2)0!
4/*1%0!I,-'!@)7!Z!@)7!()2/37)(!2%!S7)0'1,-!*7!+214%'!Z!28%((1T()>@2%-!*)!2)7(!
%3)-*%!',7'!)-!)-!.%10%-'!7-!21)7!+,447-!*7!*/;%'!@7;21+U!!
c%!@()41T()!*<-%41S7)!%!+,44)!)..)'!*)!*/+)-'()(!2%!+,-.137(%'1,-!
0,+1%2)! *7! @(,;2T4)! +214%'1S7)!*)0! 0)720! 4/*1%0! @,7(! 28,(1)-')(! I)(0! *)0!
%(T-)0!@270! *10+(T')0C! *,-'!+)22)0! ,g! 0)! @()--)-'! 2)0! */+101,-0! @,21'1S7)0U!
c)0! @(,.)001,--)20! *)!281-.,(4%'1,-!,++7@)-'! *,(/-%I%-'!*)0! @,01'1,-0!
4,1-0! +)-'(%2)0!*%-0! 2)0! ()2%'1,-0! )-'()!2)0! %+')7(0! *)! 2%! S7)0'1,-!
+214%'1S7)U!62!08)-071'!7-)!/(,01,-!*)!2%! I101;121'/!4/*1%'1S7)!*7!@(,;2T4)!
*%-0! 2%! 4)07()! ,g! 0%! I%2,(10%'1,-! %7@(T0! *)0! ],7(-%210')0C! ]73/)! 4,1-0!
@(1,(1'%1()!S78%7!*/;7'!*)0!%--/)0!JPPPC!-8)0'!@270!%7'%-'!)-'()')-7)U!!
9-! @%(%22T2)! 0)! *)001-)! 7-)! 0)+,-*)! ')-*%-+)! S71!)0'! 28)-I)(0! *)! 2%!
@()41T()U!A)I)(0!*)!2%!4/*%122)!4/*1%'1S7)C!2)0!)-'()@()-)7(0!*7!@(,;2T4)!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
"!c)!+,-+)@'!*8)-'()@()-)7(!*87-)!+%70)!,7!*87-!@(,;2T4)!()-I,1)!%7!'(%I%12!@1,--1)(!*hW,X%(*!?)+Y)(!
#"eib5!)'!*/013-)!*)0!%3)-'0!,7!*)0!3(,7@)0!S71!"(+2":2"(("(+!*)!*/-,-+)(!@7;21S7)4)-'!7-)!01'7%'1,-!
S78120!)0'14)-'!@(,;2/4%'1S7)U!

!
j!
+214%'1S7)! @)(*)-'! 2)! 4,-,@,2)! *)! 2%! @%(,2)! @7;21S7)! 07(! +)0! )-])7RU!
a8%7'()0! %+')7(0! #*)0! ],7(-%210')0! -,-! 0@/+1%210/0C! *)0! +/2/;(1'/0C! *)0!
1-')22)+'7)20C! *)0! 0+1)-'1.1S7)0! *)! *10+1@21-)0! I,101-)0C! )'+U5! 0,7D%1')-'!
*/0,(4%10!21I()(! 2)7(0! @,1-'0! *)! I7)! 07(! 2)! +214%'U! :)'')! *1I)(01.1+%'1,-!
0,+1%2)! *)0! @)(0,--)0! 08)R@(14%-'! @7;21S7)4)-'! 07(! 2)! @(,;2T4)! %!%7!
4,1-0! *)7R! +,-0/S7)-+)0U! V,7'! *8%;,(*! *81-0+(1()! 2%! S7)0'1,-! *7! +214%'!
*%-0!2%!',12)!*)! .,-*! *87-! -,4;()! +(,100%-'! *8)-])7R! *)! */;%'! @7;21+U!c)0!
+D%-3)4)-'0!+214%'1S7)0!*)I1)--)-'!%1-01!7-!21)7!+,447-!*)!2%!*10+7001,-!
@7;21S7)!+)!S71!()2%'1I10)!28/(,01,-!*)!2)7(!I101;121'/!4/*1%'1S7)U!9-071')!*)!
@)(4)''()!Z!*)0!N!@,1-'0!*)!I7)!*100,-%-'0!O!*8%++/*)(!@270!.%+12)4)-'!%7R!
4/*1%0! @,7(!()4)''()!)-! +%70)! 2)! +,-0)-070! 0+1)-'1.1S7)! Z! @(,@,0! *)!
28,(131-)!%-'D(,@1S7)!*)0!+D%-3)4)-'0!+214%'1S7)0!)'!@%(!2Z!')-')(!*)!0%@)(!
2)0!.,-*)4)-'0!*7!+%(%+'T()!@(,;2/4%'1S7)!*)!2%!S7)0'1,-!*7!+214%'U!!
:)!*)(-1)(!@,1-'!%++)-'7)!7-)!'(,101T4)!*<-%41S7)!S71!+,(()0@,-*!Z!
7-)!+)('%1-)!+(10@%'1,-C! %7! 0)1-!*)0!(/*%+'1,-0! *)! @()00)C! .%+)!%7R! )-])7R!
+214%'1S7)0U!G,7(!+)('%1-0! (/*%+')7(0! )-! +D).C!2)! (/+1'! +214%'1S7)! 0)!0)(%1'!
')(41-/!%I)+! 2)! 0,44)'! *)! :,@)-D%37)! )-! JPPe!)'! 2)0! @,2/41S7)0!
%214)-'/)0! @%(! 2)0! N!+214%',>0+)@'1S7)0!O! -)! 2)0! )-+,7(%3)-'! @%0! Z! 2)!
()2%-+)(U!
62! -8)-! ()0')! @%0! 4,1-0! S7)! 2)! +%*(%3)! 4/*1%'1S7)! *7! @(,;2T4)!
+214%'1S7)!-8%!@%0!/'/!*/0'(7+'7(/!@%(!+)0!4,*1.1+%'1,-0!0,+1%2)0!*,-'!12!.%7'!
0,7213-)(! 2)! +%(%+'T()! ()2%'1.U! :)(')0! 2)0! ],7(-%210')0! @%(2)-'! 4,1-0!
(/3721T()4)-'! *)! 2%! S7)0'1,-! *7! +214%'C! 4%10! S7%-*! 120!2)! .,-'C! 2%! '(%4)!
-%((%'1I)!S78120!@(,@,0)-'!)0'C!Z!S7)2S7)0!I%(1%-')0!@(T0C!2%!4^4)U!:%(!+)!
S71! 0)! 4,*1.1)! +8)0'! @(1-+1@%2)4)-'! 281-')-01'/! *)0! /+D%-3)0! )-'()! *)0!
%+')7(0!32,;%2)4)-'!1-+D%-3/0F!c%!*1I)(01.1+%'1,-!0,+1%2)!)R@,0/)!+1>*)0070!
-8)-3)-*()! @%0! 2%! 07;0'1'7'1,-! *)0! 7-0! @%(! 2)0! %7'()0U!:)7R! S71!
)-'()@()--)-'!*)!*/.1-1(!2)!@(,;2T4)!+214%'1S7)C!;1)-!S7)!4,1-0!%+'1.0!*%-0!
2)0!4/*1%0C!()0')-'!@(/0)-'0!)'!;/-/.1+1)-'!',7],7(0!*87-!+(/*1'!/2)I/!%7@(T0!
*)0!],7(-%210')0U! 620! @)7I)-'! %1-01C! S7%-*! 120! )-! ()00)-')-'!2)! ;)0,1-C!.%1()!
)..1+%+)4)-'!;%((%3)!%7R!*10+,7(0!N!+214%',>0+)@'1S7)0!O!S71!0)!()'(,7I)-'!
+%-',--/0!%7R!4%(3)0!*)0!4/*1%0!3/-/(%210')0U!!
$%(31-%2)C!+1(+,-0+(1')!Z!*)0!)0@%+)0!4/*1%'1S7)0!+,-0,44/0!@%(!*)0!
@7;21+0! ;1)-! *,'/0! )-! ()00,7(+)0! +72'7()22)0C! 2%! I101;121'/! 4/*1%'1S7)! *)0!
N!@,1-'0!*)!I7)!*100,-%-'0!O!07(!2)!+214%'!)0'!',7').,10!1-D%;1'7)22)U!=,7%-'!
)'! @(,.1'%-'! *7! ;(,7122%3)! *)0! .(,-'1T()0! )-'()! 2)! 0%I%-'! )'! 2)! @,21'1S7)C! 2%!
N!*100,-%-+)!+214%'1S7)!O!1-')(@)22)!2)0!0+1)-'1.1S7)0!*7!+214%'!%7!07])'!*)!
2)7(0!%''1'7*)0!Z!281-')(.%+)!*)!2%!0+1)-+)!)'!*)!2%!0,+1/'/U!922)!1-I1')!Z!4)-)(!
7-!'(%I%12!+,22)+'1.!*)I%-'!@)(4)''()!*)!(/%..1(4)(!2)0!+,-',7(0!*)0!/-,-+/0!
0+1)-'1.1S7)0! %.1-! S78120! @7100)-'! ^'()! +2%1()4)-'! *10'1-37/0! *)0! %7'()0!
.,(4)0!*)!0%I,1(0!#',7'!%7001!2/31'14)05!)'!*)!2%!*10+7001,-!@,21'1S7)U!:8)0'!
)-!)..)'!2%!@2%+)!)'!2)!(k2)!*)!2%!0+1)-+)!%7!0)1-!*)0!0,+1/'/0!S71!)0'!1+1!)-!])7U!

!
l!
Sommaire!
!
!
!
!
Introduction$...........................................................................................................................................$6$
$
Première$partie.$L’érosion$de$la$visibilité$médiatique$de$la$question$climatique$......$17$
$
:D%@1'()!"U!H-)!/(,01,-!)'!-,-!7-!)..,-*()4)-'!UUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU!"m!
!
:D%@1'()!JU!c%!'(%-0.,(4%'1,-!',7')!()2%'1I)!*)!2%!+,-.137(%'1,-!0,+1%2)!*)0!
N!*/.1-100)7(0!O!*7!@(,;2T4)!UUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU!Je!
!
:D%@1'()!bU!H-!+%*(%3)!*7!@(,;2T4)!S71!0)!4,*1.1)!.1-%2)4)-'!@)7!UUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU!jP!
$
!
Seconde$partie.$Les$scientifiques$du$climat$font$toujours$autorité$dans$les$médias$
généralistes$.........................................................................................................................................$49$
$
:D%@1'()!jU!fg!0,-'!2)0!N!+214%',>0+)@'1S7)0!O!n!UUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU!l"!
!
:D%@1'()!lU!c%!4/*1%'10%'1,-!*)0!0+1)-+)0!*7!+214%'!Q!7-)!+(/*1;121'/!;1)-!%-+(/)!UUUUUUUUUUUUU!ij!
!
:D%@1'()!+,-+2701.U!o7)22)0!%''1'7*)0!*)0!0+1)-'1.1S7)0!*7!+214%'!*%-0!2)0!4/*1%0!n!UUUUUUUUUU!db!
$
!
!
Annexe$méthodologique$..................................................................................................................$84$
$
Bibliographie$.......................................................................................................................................$94$
$
Table$des$graphiques,$tableaux,$illustrations$et$encadrés$.................................................$97$
$
Table$des$matières$............................................................................................................................$98$
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!