If it is alleged that you inflicted the injuries with intent, or on purpose, you
will be charged with GBH or wounding with intent, under s 33 of the
Crimes Act NSW. This is more serious than simply inflicting grievous injury
recklessly, but it is also more difficult to prove, as, along with the above
elements, the prosecution must successfully prove beyond a reasonable
doubt that you intended to cause a grievous injury or wound at the time of
the offence. The maximum penalty for this offence is 25 years in prison.
Defences
There are a number of defences available to those who are charged with an
assault offence. Depending on your circumstances, one of these defences
may be available in your case.
Self Defence
If you can prove on the balance of probabilities that you were acting in self-
defence, you will be found not-guilty of the charges against you. The
requirements to prove self-defence are found in s418 of the Crimes Act. In
order to successfully raise the defence of ‘self-defence’, you must be able
to prove two things on the balance of probabilities:
1. That you believed your conduct was necessary to defend yourself,
another person, or property; and
2. That your conduct was a reasonable response to the circumstances
as you perceived them.
You will not succeed in this defence if, for instance, you are able to prove
that you believed your conduct was necessary to defend yourself, but are
unable to prove that your response was reasonable or proportionate. For
instance, it may be very difficult to prove that your conduct was reasonable
if someone threatens to push you and in response you stab them. The more
serious the assault charge against you is, the harder it will be for you to
prove on the balance of probabilities that you were acting in self-defence.
Other defences
Other defences that you may be able to consider, depending on the
circumstances of your case, include arguing that you were acting under
duress – that someone was forcing you to carry out illegal acts by
threatening you with death or serious harm.
Another defence that may be available is to argue that you were acting out
of necessity, where you honestly believed that your illegal actions were
necessary to prevent death or serious harm. An example of this would be if
there was a fire and you push someone out of the way while trying to
escape. The defences available to you will depend on the circumstances of
your case. It is therefore very important to have a specialist defence lawyer
who will be able to examine all the aspects of your case and advise on the